The EU Fiasco

Finally. Somebody who sees Germany and the entire EU experiment more as I do. It’s Jakub Grygiel at The American Interest:

In blunter terms, the EU promise was that Germany would not dominate Europe; Germany would become Europeanized rather than Europe Prussianized.

The EU has succeeded, but only to a degree. Berlin is not Europe’s capital—indeed, Europe has no capital. But German power is not containable by the EU and, after Brexit, will be even less so. The 2008 financial crisis showed to the debt-ridden Southern European states that German power is decisive and opposing it in financial matters is futile. More disturbingly, Berlin has no qualms of pursuing policies that undermine the security of other EU members. Two policies in particular are worth recalling. In 2015 Chancellor Merkel opened Germany’s borders to, what turned out to be, hundreds of thousands refugees. While she won widespread international admiration from Bono and the UN, her own electorate began to have serious doubts. And other European countries, on the forefront of the migration crisis, resented the unilateral German decision which immediately affected them and over which they had no say.

The second decision was to strike a dubious deal with Russia to build a second gas pipeline (Nord Stream 2) that has no economic value but enormous geopolitical consequences: by not having to cross Ukraine and Central Europe, Russian gas can be delivered directly to German industries while Moscow can threaten to cut off supplies to states deemed by it to be part of its sphere of influence. This German decision abets Russian imperial aspirations toward Ukraine as well as toward EU member states in Central Europe. Berlin may speak highly of the EU, but wields its power as it wishes, in open disdain of other EU members.

The harsh reality is that the European Union was a project that may have had a chance in a benign geopolitical environment. In a competitive world, with antagonistic external powers and growing internal imbalances, the EU is failing.

No, Berlin is not Europe’s capitol. Whatever Brussels’s pretensions, Europe is ruled from Frankfurt so it’s a distinction without a difference.

The key points to keep in mind are that nations follow their interests and that Germany’s interests are not only not ours, they’re contrary to ours. Why do we pursue them? NATO, the ur-European Union, was described as having the triple purposes of keeping Germany down, the Soviets out, and the Americans in. At this point all of those have failed and now Germany is keeping the countries of southern and eastern Europe down. If Germany refuses to sweeten the deal with France, the whole thing could come tumbling down like a house of cards.

1 comment

Question for the Day

Here’s your question for today. At the end of 2019 will any state have its own single-payer system? I say “No”. Hawaii is the best candidate for such a system and it backed off from the system its legislature passed a decade ago.

Also, I think that politicians would rather run on a national single-payer system, e.g. “Medicare for All”, than have a couple of state single-payer systems that people are watching for signs of success (or failure!). Consequently, any state’s plans will receive only lukewarm support from the national Democratic Party.

12 comments

Apple’s Bad News

Yesterday Apple announced that its first quarter revenue for 2019 would be sharply below what had been expected:

Apple cut its revenue guidance for its fiscal first quarter, sending its stock sharply lower in after-hours trading as concerns continue to mount over the company’s future iPhone and China growth.

In a letter to investors, Apple CEO Tim Cook said the company now expects revenue of $84 billion in the quarter ending Dec. 29.

Apple had anticipated revenue of between $89 billion and $93 billion for the quarter. The number is also lower compared with the $91.5 billion in revenue analysts previously anticipated, according to earnings-tracker Refinitiv.

“Based on these estimates, our revenue will be lower than our original guidance for the quarter, with other items remaining broadly in line with our guidance,” Cook wrote.

reported USA Today while at Atlantic Alexis C. Madrigal analyzed the news:

And here we are in early 2019 and it’s clear that the Chinese economic slowdown is already bad. Today’s news makes it clear that the slowdown might be very bad, and worsening at a pace that took even Apple by complete surprise.

The other Asian economies are already seeing the damage. And that’s before the trade war tariffs snap into place come March

“So, what is the positive signal?” Jayant Menon, the lead economist at the Asian Development Bank, asked the South China Morning Post, rhetorically, this week. “There isn’t one,” he said.

I would add a couple of observations. First, no other American company is as exposed to the behavior of Chinese consumers as Apple. China accounts for nearly 20% of Apple’s iPhone sales and, as noted by Mr. Madrigal, Apple is now an iPhone company. Nike, the other U. S. company with substantial consumer sales in China, has seen flat sales in China for a couple of years now. Will it have an announcement of its own?

The message here is that doing business with China has risks as well as rewards.

My other observation is that smartphones are a commodity product but a commodity product like few others. You’ve got to produce something new every once in a while and that’s an expensive or even impossible proposition. Apple can’t maintain its brand by producing a product that’s just as good as those of every other smartphone manufacturer in the world. It’s got to produce something new and sexy. Does Apple without Steve Jobs have that mojo? Stay tuned.

I’m sticking to a prediction I’ve made before. In 10 years I won’t be a bit surprised if none of the companies with the biggest fully capitalized value, e.g. Apple, Amazon, Facebook, Google, etc., don’t exist in their present forms.

2 comments

Questions for 2019

Hey, kids! Try your hand at David Ignatius’s multiple choice quiz for 2019 in his column at the Washington Post. Here’s one of the questions:

The Democratic candidate leading in public opinion polls on Dec. 31, 2019, will be: (a) Joe Biden, who promises to nominate former Homeland Security secretary Jeh Johnson as vice president; (b) Beto O’Rourke, whose campaign is boosted by a barnstorming country-music band headed by cable TV host Joe Scarborough; (c) Kamala D. Harris, who gains the endorsements of Michelle Obama, Elizabeth Warren and Hillary Clinton; (d) Amy Klobuchar, who runs on a platform of “Make America Smart Again.”

I think that a better question would be whether there will be a revolt against the present leadership of the Democratic Party, a prospect I find dubious, or whether the leadership will be able to get behind a candidate who doesn’t remember when Truman was president?

IMO the answers to most of his questions are either “None of the above” or “All of the above”.

6 comments

The Answer

In the slug of an op-ed at the New York Times by Mustafa Akyol, an important question is asked:

In modern-day “re-education” prisons, Beijing is forcing ethnic Uighurs to forsake their religion. Why don’t Muslim governments rise up in anger?

Here’s how he answers the question:

There are three answers. One is that coziness with China, the world’s second-largest economic power, pays. China is the top trading partner of 20 of the 57 member states of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation. Its ambitious Belt and Road Initiative, a huge path of commercial and transportation infrastructure intended to pass through much of the Middle East, holds a lucrative promise for many Muslim nations.

Moreover, China does not shy away from offering its economic assistance as hush money. In July 2018, The Global Times, the mouthpiece of the Chinese Communist Party, ran an interesting editorial suggesting that China’s government would help Turkey secure its “economic stability” — but only if Turkish officials stopped making “irresponsible remarks on the ethnic policy in Xinjiang,” which means stop criticizing China’s human rights violations. (At about the same time, Germany’s chancellor, Angela Merkel, was also promising to help the Turkish economy, but only if Turkey corrected its own human rights violations. In other words, Turkey was being pulled in opposite directions, and, sadly, the dark side has proved stronger so far.)

A second reason for Muslim silence is that the Chinese government crackdown on Uighurs is based on a premise that law and order can be restored by eradicating enemies of the government and traitors within a society. This is authoritarian language that most Muslim leaders understand well. It is their own language.

The third reason is that most Muslims who are likely to feel solidarity with their oppressed coreligionists think of the oppressors as “the West,” defined as the capitalist, hedonist, Zionist civilization led by the Great Satan. These Muslims, particularly the Islamists, believe that all of their coreligionists should unite with other anti-Western forces — a stance that evokes Samuel Huntington’s prediction of a “Confucian-Islamic” alliance against the West in his 1993 article in “Foreign Affairs” titled “The Clash of Civilizations?”

Those may be factors but I think the answer is simpler than that. The Uighurs aren’t Arabs. Sometimes things are a lot less than they seem and the “clash of civilizations” may be one of them. For many people in the world tribe remains the highest value.

4 comments

Maybe Not the Chinese Century

Martin Wolf considers China’s prospects for the future in a piece at the Financial Times:

Future demand will depend on the emergence of a mass-consumer market, while growth of supply will require an upsurge in growth of “total factor productivity” — a measure of innovation. Yet, in 2017, private consumption was only 39 per cent of GDP. If it is to drive demand, the savings rate must tumble and the share of household incomes in GDP must jump. Neither will be easy to achieve. But the biggest hurdle of all, especially to the needed upsurge in productivity growth, is the shift towards a more autocratic political system.

For one and a half decades, China has benefited from the reforms introduced by Zhu Rongji, premier from 1998 to 2003. No comparable reforms have happened since his time. Today, credit is still being preferentially allocated to state businesses, while state influence over large private businesses is growing. All this is likely to distort the allocation of resources and slow the rate of innovation and economic progress, even if an outright financial crisis is avoided.

In sum, China may well fail to replicate the success of other east Asian high-growth economies, in becoming a high-income country in short order. It will surely be far harder for it to do so, because the distortions in its economy are so large and the global environment is going to be so much more hostile.

None of these are novel observations. Indeed, I and others much more prestigious than I have been pointing these things out for 15 years. Fifteen years ago I pointed out that China had some grave challenges to meet in the years ahead, among them demographics, the environment, and their corrupt, inefficient banking system. None of those changes have been addressed.

Will China continue to outperform its critics’ expectations? The answer may well depend on the preferences of the Chinese. Will the instinct to concentrate power in a few hands serve it well?

I’ve been skeptical of the “Thucydides Trap” scenario but the U. S. isn’t the only candidate for the role of “established power” while China isn’t the only candidate for “rising power”. Are demographics destiny and which direction do they point?

0 comments

Chicago Homicides, 2018

According to the invaluable site, HeyJackass.com, Chicago ended 2018 with 588 homicides. That’s fewer than 2017 or 2016 but more than any other year in the last 16.

It’s difficult to place that completely in perspective. The homicide rate in Chicago is about the same as that of Mexico, Colombia, or Guaetemala, a bit lower than El Salvador or Honduras. Most of those homicides take place in just six of Chicago’s neighborhoods. Here, courtesy of Google Maps, is a picture of the heart of the Austin neighborhood on the West Side, the neighborhood in which the greatest number of those homicides took place:

The Austin neighborhood is 83% black. In 2015 its estimated population was around 98,000 people but I suspect that the 2020 census will reveal that has dropped sharply. As is evident from the picture, it is a neighborhood with many empty lots and failed businesses. If you move the map east or west along Chicago or north or south along Long, you’ll see what I mean.

There are many reasons for the large number of homicides, mostly interrelated. Gangs, bad relationship between the people and the police, lack of economic development and opportunity, collusion between the city government and the gangs, the list goes on.

8 comments

The End of Empire

Robert D. Kaplan, the neocon’s neocon, admits that it’s time to throw in the towel on Afghanistan in an op-ed in the New York Times:

No other country in the world symbolizes the decline of the American empire as much as Afghanistan. There is virtually no possibility of a military victory over the Taliban and little chance of leaving behind a self-sustaining democracy — facts that Washington’s policy community has mostly been unable to accept.

While many American troops stay behind steel-reinforced concrete walls to protect themselves from the very population they are supposed to help, it is striking how little discussion Afghanistan has generated in government and media circles in Washington. When it comes to Afghanistan, Washington has been a city hiding behind its own walls of shame and frustration.

I won’t analyze the op-ed in detail but I would like to highlight a few passages.

The total cost of the war could reach as high as $2 trillion when long-term costs are factored in, according to Brown University’s Cost of War Project. All that to prop up an unstable government that would most likely disintegrate if aid were to end.

which is exactly what anyone who actually knew anything about Afghanistan was saying in 2002. Afghanistan cannot support the sort of military structure we are building for it and they will never be capable of defending their own borders. Since those borders were drawn by the English, why not leave it to the English to defend them? There is a barely defensible argument for retaining a small, lethal force in Afghanistan with a mission of counter-terrorism but none whatever for a mission of counter-insurgency.

It did not have to be like this. Had the United States not become diverted from rebuilding the country by its invasion of Iraq in 2003 (which I mistakenly supported), or had different military and development policies been tried, these forces of division might have been overcome.

or, in other words, blame it on Bush. Sorry, Mr. Kaplan. The blame belongs solidly on those who wanted the U. S. to occupy Afghanistan in the first place, e.g. you. Afghanistan would not have been less warlike or less divided. The last conqueror to successfully pacify Afghanistan was Alexander and he did so by settling a population there. Which brings up another important fact: the people who actually fight America’s wars have no interest in the sort of American Empire you have espoused.

According to the Pakistani journalist Ahmed Rashid, there was simply too much emphasis on the electoral process in Kabul and not nearly enough on bread-and-butter nation building — in particular, bringing basic infrastructure and agriculture up to the standards that Afghans enjoyed from the 1950s until the Soviet invasion of 1979.

because Pakistan is such a good example of a country in the region that has become a peaceful liberal democracy. This is a free flight of fancy. I wonder if it’s occurred to him that Pakistan was one of the reasons for our failure in Afghanistan? Advice from Pakistanis about Afghanistan is questionable at best. And dare I mention that the ongoing acts of terrorism in Afghanistan made the sorts of programs he envisions futile? For every school or road built there were 100 terrorists ready to blow them up or burn them down.

Can anyone cite an example of that strategy having been effective anywhere but in Germany, Japan, and South Korea? Those societies are much more cohesive than Afghanistan ever was. The real past in Afghanistan was one in which only Kabul and its immediate environs experienced “the standards that Afghans enjoyed” prior to the Soviet invasion.

Do we owe it to the Afghan people to stay? Not if the ideals that we claim to represent appear unachievable. Spending billions and stationing thousands of troops there with no end in sight to stem a deepening chaos is simply not sustainable policy.

But that policy hasn’t just been invented in the last few years. It was the policy from the outset and a foreseeable outcome as soon as we put “boots on the ground”.

I think that those who say that some show of force was necessary in the aftermath of the attacks in 2001 are, sadly, correct. However, the political leadership simply did not have the stomach for the level of airpower that would have been necessary to accomplish the objective of rooting the Taliban and Al Qaeda out of Afghanistan.

9 comments

Pro-Nuke

The editors of Bloomberg use their last editorial of 2018 to promote nuclear power:

Nuclear accounts for almost 60 percent of emissions-free power in the U.S., and when plants shut down, utilities mostly turn to fossil fuels to fill the void. More than one-third of the country’s plants, representing 22 percent of total nuclear capacity, are either scheduled to close or at risk of closure within the next five to 10 years, says a new UCS study. This could lead to a 4-6 percent increase in carbon emissions from the power sector by 2035.

Nuclear power is expensive, and it’s under pressure from market forces — notably, the falling price of solar and wind power. Then why not simply let it lose market share to those safe, clean fuels? Because wind and solar can’t immediately fill the gap. They still account for less than 8 percent of energy produced in the U.S. (nuclear is 20 percent). It’s crucial that their growth displaces coal and natural gas, not nuclear.

In addition wind and solar require backup power, either nuclear or fossil fuel. I’m not sure how one can reconcile taking steps to reduce climate change and opposition to nuclear energy.

7 comments

It’s Hard to Make Predictions

especially about the future.

I’ve basically given up making year-end predictions. Events are either completely obvious (the press will continue to whine about Trump) or impossible to predict accurately (will we enter a recession?). The closest thing I have to a prediction is that I don’t believe that the new Democratic House will distinguish itself.

Who will be the next mayor of Chicago? Probably Bill Daley, a discouraging thought. I don’t even have a solid idea of who my next alderman will be. I’m thinking of starting a neighborhood club to talk about it and learn how my neighbors are thinking.

Please make your predictions for the coming year here.

8 comments