Dave Schuler
December 17, 2018
After cataloguing China’s hard and soft power initiatives in his article at The American Interest Larry Diamond remarks:
What we call “the era of engagementâ€â€”when we believed that deepening ties would bring a more open, pluralistic, and law-based society in China—is over. What we need now is engagement without illusions: engagement that demands greater transparency, fairness and reciprocity in the relationship; and engagement with a resolve to defend the integrity of our democratic institutions. We call this approach “constructive vigilance.â€
This is now a historic juncture not only in the U.S.-China relationship but also in the domestic politics of how to think about the relationship. While there remain many advocates of the old unconditional approach, an emerging bipartisan consensus now sees this stance as dangerously naïve.
I reached that conclusion more than thirty years ago, before most of the harm had already been done. Better late than never, I guess.
I’d like to present a challenge to Nicholas Kristoff, Tom Friedman, and thousands of other journalists and pundits. What is it that you hate about the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia that isn’t ten times worse in China?
Dave Schuler
December 17, 2018
I agree with the editors of the Washington Post that increased and improved aid to Central Americans is an important component of reducing immigration of Guatemalans, Nigaraguans, and so on into the United States:
If Mr. Trump signs on to Mr. López Obrador’s vision for reviving Central America with an ambitious aid plan — one that would also serve U.S. interest as a means to “disincentivize†migration — that could be just the sweetener Mr. López Obrador needs to go along with Mr. Trump’s asylum plan.
This could be the start of a beautiful friendship, or at least a constructive alliance, between a pair of populist presidents who happen to be ideological opposites but whose goals on Central American migration should be aligned. Like Mr. Trump, Mr. López Obrador has his own reasons to discourage migrants who, in the case of the thousands who have reached Tijuana with the caravans, have become an increasingly unpopular local irritant.
and with their skepticism about the effectiveness of a wall:
Hundreds of miles of existing barriers at the border haven’t stopped the flow of migrants, and neither will Mr. Trump’s wall, if it is ever built.
President Trump’s citing of Israel in his argument for the effectiveness of a wall is misplaced. The Israelis are committed in a way and for reasons that we are not. Any wall we build will never be as impenetrable as the Israelis’ wall.
The editors neglect to mention that Mexico’s laws against illegal immigration are harsher than ours if anything and their enforcement of them can be quite ruthless. Both carrots and sticks are necessary to enforce our laws and one element of the “sticks” would be biometric ID and requiring employers to verify the eligibility of workers with stiff penalties for infractions and significantly greater likelihood of detection.
Dave Schuler
December 17, 2018
While I agree with Nicholas Kristof’s detestation of the Saudi regime and admire his courage in actually going to Saudi Arabia and attempting to gauge public opinion there, as reflected in his latest New York Times column, that an individual as intelligent and well-informed as he should be could possibly write the following:
The truth is that as Saudi Arabia’s significance as an oil producer diminishes, we need Saudi Arabia less. In 25 years, if we’re freed from the tyranny of imported oil, we may not need it at all.
staggers credulity. Saudi Arabia’s influence over the price of oil would not end if we imported no oil at all. We actually import relatively little oil from KSA but we have notional allies who are largely dependent on Saudi oil and will remain so for the foreseeable future. But the Kingdom’s significance is not limited to imports. They along with the other Gulf states are the low cost producers of high quality oil.
And to understand the full scope of that impact look up how polyester is produced, in particular purified terephthalic acid (PTA) and mono-ethylene glycol (MEG), both byproducts of oil refining. Look up where and how it is used.
Unless you envision an authoritarian United States with a command economy, being “freed” from Saudi and Gulf state tyranny will not be accomplished in our lifetimes. It would take character and determination, both in short supply in American politics. Do not hold out objectives we cannot achieve or, as an ancestor of mine put it, do not set the fence too far. We must choose not to support the truly dreadful Saudi regime and cope with the consequences rather than hoping the consequences will go away enough to make refusing to support them less painful.
Dave Schuler
December 16, 2018
I just heard Dick Durbin, the senior senator from ADM Illinois, fully support the position that I have held down for lo! these many months. Congress should just let Robert Mueller conduct his investigation and keep their noses out of it.
My advice: more light, less heat.
Dave Schuler
December 16, 2018
goes to John Crudele of the New York Post, who arrives at the surprising conclusion:
Here are the piping-hot details. Those pizzas you take home are 16 inches in diameter. The ones that are sold by the slice are 20 inches. Let’s say a full pizza costs $15, which we think is the typical price these days. And a slice of pizza goes for $2.50, also standard around Manhattan and in the ’burbs.
There are typically eight pieces to a pie. So a pie that is sold by the slice is worth $20 — or eight pieces times $2.50 if you want to see the math.
The 16-inch pie is just under 201 square inches in size. The 20-inch pie is 314 square inches. So one slice of the eight-piece, 16-inch pie is 25.12 square inches. And a piece of the 20-inch pie is 39.25 square inches.
With those numbers, you are paying 7 cents per square inch for the smaller pie and only 6 cents per square inch for the larger one. (Those are rounded just like the pies.)
So, to my surprise and maybe yours, it’s typically a better bargain to go into the pizzeria and order eight single slices of pizza rather than a full pie. To be precise (or as precise as you can get with these “typical†numbers), you’d be getting 56 percent more pizza for only 33 percent more cost.
Hat tip: RealClearInvestigations
Dave Schuler
December 16, 2018
If you’ve ever wondered why I have written so little about Brexit, the answer is simple. I don’t think it’s any of my business (or Americans’ business more generally), I don’t know enough about British politics to weigh in, and I don’t think that the U. S. has a great deal of stake in the matter.
My question would be why do American pundits write so much about it? You’re not English, you don’t understand the issues, and it’s no skin off your nose.
Dave Schuler
December 16, 2018
I’ve mentioned this before but I think it bears mentioning again.
The concepts of “right” and “left” derive from the seating of delegates in the French National Assembly in 1789. Supporters of the king sat on the right of the chamber. Supporters of the revolution sat on the left. Over 230 years the terms have lost relevancy.
Politics doesn’t travel well. As a general rule under the parliamentary systems that prevail in Europe the range of political views represented are enormously greater than in the United States. For 70 years it has been a joke in Britain that both the American Democratic and Republican parties fit within the spectrum of political views held by members of the Conservative Party in the United Kingdom. It’s still true. Even with the drift in views that has occurred in the U. S. over the last 30 years the Democratic Party is at the very most a centrist party while the Republican Party is at most a right wing party. IMO both are better considered center-right parties by European standards. Keep in mind that in most European countries there are far left parties who represent at least 10% of the population and there are far right parties who represent at last 10% of the population. We don’t even have far left or far right factions of the major parties with that kind of popular support.
All of that supports George Will’s wisecrack that American politics is like a football game played between the 40 yard lines.
My advice to Americans is don’t think you can make common cause with European political parties. Just because they’re called “right” or “left” and you think of your political views in those terms, don’t think that they believe what you do.
Dave Schuler
December 15, 2018
In France demonstrators came out for the gilets jaunes demonstrations for the fifth consecutive week. Per France 24 half as many demonstrators showed up this week as last in Paris:
housands of protesters are back out on the streets of Paris and other French cities, towns and villages, braving freezing cold temperatures and defying calls to hold off after a gun attack in Strasbourg earlier this week.
France’s interior ministry said the number of protesters across the country was estimated at 33,500 at midday, around half the level of a week ago. Police in Paris said fewer than 3,000 had gathered in the capital for the fifth consecutive Saturday of demonstrations, which have so far been peaceful.
but they do seem to be spreading. In addition to Paris there have been demonstrations in Nantes, Brest, and Marseilles, among other cities, as well as in Belgium, Netherlands, Sweden, and Britain.
At least in France the demonstrations seem to have a nationalist cast. For example, women are dressing as Marianne, symbol of the Republic.
Dave Schuler
December 15, 2018
I do not see much evidence of the battle over the direction of U. S. foreign policy that Emma Ashford and Trevor Thrall write about in their piece at War on the Rocks:
Curious to understand where the right and left are heading on foreign policy, we’ve held a variety of events at the Cato Institute to try and understand this question: a roundtable building on Patrick Porter’s work on the “liberal international order,†events with notable critics of the existing foreign policy consensus, such as Harvard’s Stephen Walt, meetings to explore potential areas of common ground between libertarians and progressives, and interviews with experts for Power Problems, our biweekly podcast.
The results highlight not only the internal debate inside the Republican Party, but also the growing demand inside the Democratic Party for a coherent alternative both to Trump and to the existing foreign policy consensus that he helped discredit. We also found evidence of an unexpected and potentially significant turn in U.S. foreign policy: a new bipartisan consensus on the need to confront and contain China.
What I do see is a gap between what those in charge of the federal government and both political parties want and what most Americans want. What I see is an elite consensus in favor of intervention, sometimes for security reasons, sometimes for humanitarian ones, while ordinary people are willing to go to war to defend the U. S. when we are attacked but not for other reasons.
For example, I have yet to encounter any ordinary person who’s greatly exercised about America’s abdicating its leadership role in world affairs such as it is. But there are endless editorials, articles, and opinion pieces about that in the New York Times, Washington Post, and other outlets for elite opinion.
Other than, possibly, a few Ukrainian-Americans, is anyone outside of elite circles very much concerned about the war between Russia and the Ukraine? I’m more concerned that the present Ukrainian government will push us into a war with Russia than I am about Russia wanting to avoid having a hostile periphery. Maybe it’s because I’ve observed that cornered rats will strike.
Dave Schuler
December 15, 2018
The “false dilemma” also called the “black or white” fallacy is the logical fallacy in which only two alternatives are presented while other alternatives are possible. Keep that in mind as you read this article by Antara Haldar at Atlantic:
Economists’ resistance to incorporate the wisdom of behavioral approaches may seem like a frivolous concern confined to the ivory tower, but it has serious consequences. What students are taught in their economics classes can perversely turn models and charts that are meant to approximate reality into aspirational ideals for it. Most economics majors are first introduced to Homo economicus as impressionable college freshmen and internalize its values: Studies show, for instance, that taking economics courses can make people actively more selfish. The consequences are only made more acute by the fact that business, a more preprofessional version of economics, is the single most popular major for college students in the United States—some 40 percent of undergraduates take at least one course in economics. That behavioral economics has been minimized and treated as an aberration by the mainstream has major bearings on how students make sense of markets and the world.
There are such things as first and second order approximations. When you’re dealing with the real world, sometimes those are good enough. A first order approximation is certainly better than throwing up your hands and deciding that most of what we experience in life is unexplainable because the offered explanation doesn’t deal with 100% of the cases or even deals with 100% of the cases only approximately.