Overreaching

The story of the morning is undoubtedly the failure of the gubernatorial recall in Wisconsin:

Scott Walker on Tuesday became the first governor in the country’s history to survive a recall election, besting his 2010 rival in a contest that broke spending records and captured the nation’s attention.

“Tonight we tell Wisconsin, we tell our country, and we tell people all across the globe that voters really do want leaders that stand up and make the tough decisions,” Walker told an overflow crowd at the Waukesha County Exposition Center.

He said he would meet with his cabinet Wednesday to focus on the economy and said he hoped to soon bring Democratic and Republican lawmakers together to meet over brats, burgers and beer. He cut off the crowd when they booed a mention of his opponent, Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett.

“Tomorrow is the day after the election, and tomorrow we are no longer opponents,” he said. “We are one as Wisconsinites.”

If Gov. Walker is as good as his word, the leaders of the Wisconsin public employees’ unions are very fortunate. I think that Gov. Walker was needlessly truculent and confrontational but they have waged a personal vendetta against Walker and they have failed. If I were in the Wisconsin governor’s shoes, I would return the favor if only our of a sense of self-preservation.

I think the story is being widely misrepresented or distorted. For example, in listening to the reporting on the election last night I heard the moves to constrain what are deemed as public employees’ collective bargaining rights as “moves by conservatives”. Since the governors of Michigan, Massachusetts, New York, and Illinois,, hardly hotbeds of conservatism, have all come out in favor of similar constraints and in some instances have enacted them into law, the urge to change the relationship between public employees’ unions and state governments can hardly be characterized that way. That’s no move be a handful of right wing radicals. It’s an idea whose time has come. The states hardly have any other alternative. Their budgets are strained to the breaking point, borrowing becomes more dear to them practically by the day, and their attempts to increase revenue by raising taxes haven’t been as effective as they’d hoped and do not look as though they will become more effective when employed repeatedly.

However, I think that any Republicans who think that this election has implications for the fall are kidding themselves. This election was about Wisconsin and the conditions that prevail there, Scott Walker, and the Wisconsin public employees’ unions. What we have learned is that a majority of Wisconsinites either believe that Scott Walker was right in his actions against the public employees’ unions or don’t believe in government by recall. It was not a referendum on Obama.

Yesterday Mickey Kaus had some good observations about the recall:

Even if you support private sector unionism, I don’t think public sector unionism makes sense–if the unions win too much, we can’t let the government go broke the way we can let GM go broke [bad example-ed you get the point–the market’s restraints aren’t there]. Democrats who believe in affirmative government should want it to be as efficient and affordable as possible–so we can afford more of it, if necessary. The combination of official bureaucracy plus labor adversarialism plus dues-fueled political contributions has not been a happy one.. …

I think this election does expose some of the inherent contradictions of the Democratic coalition. Good government Democrats, of which I guess I’m one, are not particularly compatible with people who believe that the primary purpose of government is maximizing the extraction of rents.

One more point that Mickey makes and that I think is worth repeating. There’s a significant number of people who get their news from CBS or the New York Times, where the possibility that the recall might fail has, shall we say, been underreported, who will be completely nonplussed when they awaken this morning to the news that the recall did, indeed, fail. How could this possibly have happened?

Update

There’s an entertaining post at Politico that uses a series of quotes from Vince Lombardi as a connecting thread in their commentary. The post, entitled, “Wisconsin: the Biggest Losers” has a graphic at the top showing Lombardi flanked by President Obama on his right and Scott Walker on his left. The implication would seem to be the Walker the winner, Obama the loser. As I’ve suggested above, I think that’s exaggerated. However, I do think that the president took the worst possible course of action in his belated lukewarm tweet in support of Barrett. Not only did he inject himself into an ultimately losing election in which he had played no role but neither his distancing himself from the election nor meager belated support exactly covered him in glory with his supporters. He’d’ve been better off saying nothing.

2 comments

The Way of the World

Despite his “pox on both your houses” conclusion, something I endorse whole-heartedly, I found a lot to dislike in Dean Baker’s latest article at the Guardian. He of all people should realize that consumption is not a fixed, static thing. In 1905 there was very little demand for automobiles in the United States. Only 8,000 of them were sold nationwide. Despite initially low demand over the period of the next several decades there was an enormous amount of capital investment that resulted in more employment, more consumption, and the largest industrial sector the world had ever seen. And that happened without federal stimulus packages or bailouts.

Yes, we need more end user consumer demand. End user consumer demand is not the only kind of consumption or demand. The road to more end user consumer demand lies through capital investment and the reasons for doing that will be what they have always been: you have a better idea, you can do it better, you think you can make a buck doing it. Take away those incentives as we have done with our current system of intellectual property, bailing out floundering dinosaur industries, and taxes or the fear of taxes and you get less of what we need.

What really irked me was this:

The world doesn’t work that way. Firms create jobs when they have more demand, not because we are nice to their rich owners.

On what basis can he tell me how the world works? He’s never been there. He’s either been an elected official, a worker at a not-for-profit, or an academic. How does that prepare you for lecturing on how the world works?

I think there was a reasonable argument three years ago on Keynesian grounds for a WPA-type program in which people who were unemployed were given a government-created job. Instead of Keynesian “government as employer of last resort” we got neo-Keynesian “government as consumer of last resort” dragged through the filter of cronyism and politics. The result was pretty much what could be reasonably expected: not nearly as much as its proponents had hoped or claimed.

I thought we needed structural reform then. The need is even more intense now.

17 comments

Opposing Views

Joseph Stiglitz on why monetary policy is useless in producing a robust recovery:

“They should know that [the Fed is] not going to make much of a difference. Anyone putting their hope in monetary policy … is just wrong.”

Stiglitz also believes the low policy push may be stifling job growth, even as it bolstered lending.

“There are some people that think that in a way low interest rates are making it more likely that we’ll have a jobless recovery.”

Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/stiglitz-anyone-putting-their-hope-in-qe-is-just-wrong-2012-6#ixzz1ww177M00

His reasoning, apparently, is that increased business investment will mostly be directed at reducing the cost of labor via automation.

Scott Sumner on why monetary policy is the only approach that will produce a robust recovery:

In 2009 there were three groups, conservatives that opposed stimulus, Keynesians that favored fiscal stimulus, and MMs who said monetary stimulus is the only solution. Now the world is waking up to the fact that monetary stimulus is the only solution. Why? Just look at what 15 years of Keynesian stimulus has bought Japan

My view: good monetary policy beats lousy fiscal policy every time. Since the Fed is more authoritarian it is theoretically easier to implement good monetary policy than it is good fiscal policy which demand that Congress act. Unfortunately, I think there are social controls on the Fed which make it difficult for it to respond appropriately, i.e. in order to maintain repute they must do the expected thing.

I don’t think that either monetary policy alone or fiscal policy alone will solve our problems. Not only have they been operating at cross-purposes but neither producing nominal increases of GDP at five percent or more (if that is, indeed, possible) or spending any amount of money will produce the growth we need without some of the structural reforms we are desperate to put off. Hiring Phil Shipley to bury $1 trillion in his backyard will “spend” the money but it won’t do much for the economy.

3 comments

Downer of the Day

If you’ve been having problems finding reading that’s discouraging enough, you might try this piece from Doug Bandow at Forbes. Here’s a taste:

The best measure of current indebtedness may come from economist Laurence Kotlikoff. Add in all the prospective liabilities and he figures America’s real public debt at about $211 trillion. That’s 14 times America’s official national debt—and GDP!

I fully endorse his suggestions: cut military spending and corporate welfare starting with the Export-Import Bank.

0 comments

This Is Not the Recovery You Were Looking For

I have severely mixed feelings about Robert Barro’s most recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal. On the one hand I think this description, pointing out how even taking the nature of the late recession into account growth during the recovery is lower than it should have been, is spot on:

The pattern of strong recoveries following sharp downturns is clear when one examines the history of economic disasters. The worst depressions relate to wartime destruction, and the subsequent peacetime periods typically exhibit strong growth. Examples include the high post-World War II growth rates in Japan, Germany and much of Western Europe.

The pattern applies also to non-war depressions, including the Great Depression of the 1930s. U.S. GDP growth from 1933 to 1940—starting from the trough of the Depression and ending before the economy was heavily influenced by World War II—was a remarkable 7% per year, despite the 1937-38 recession.

A better argument can be made that recoveries are typically sluggish following a real-estate crash and prolonged declines in housing prices, as the U.S. has recently experienced. In a study of international housing crises published May 2 by Global Economics Weekly, Jose Ursua examines long-term house-price data for 11 countries, including the U.S. His sample included 65 housing busts, defined as falls in average house prices by at least 15%. The bottom line is that housing crises do impede subsequent recoveries.

However, the average GDP growth rate during the U.S. recovery since 2009 remains nearly 2% per year lower than would be expected, according to the Ursua study. That is, after factoring in the estimated impact of the typical housing bust, Mr. Ursua found that the U.S. growth rate since 2009 should have averaged a little over 4%, rather than the 2.4% we’ve experienced.

And, with some reservations some of which Dr. Barro mentions in passing in his op-ed, I agree with his diagnosis:

What’s interfering with a real recovery? Perhaps the Obama administration should stop casting blame elsewhere and examine the policies it has implemented to ease the pain of recession and falling housing prices. (Some of those, to be fair, were initiated under the Bush administration.)

I agree with Dr. Barro that policy errors beginning during the Bush Administration and continuing in the Obama Administration have made the recovery much weaker than it might have been. I don’t think I agree with him on which policies were in error.

I disagree with him on his prescription, that we should roll back the “safety net” policies that have been put in place since the recession, e.g. repeated extensions of unemployment benefits. Let me explain why.

I think he’s probably right at the margins. I think there are probably people who have not taken jobs they might have because the jobs that were on offer paid less than they were used to making, that they were doing things they didn’t care to do, or that were in places to which they were unwilling or unable to relocate. However, I don’t think that the numbers of such people explain the very large number of long-term unemployed or its twin, the large increase in people who’ve gone on the Social Security Disability roster.

Consider, for example, the number of online “Help Wanted” postings for Orange County, California. That has, essentially, been flat since late in 2008. See also the precipitous decline in newspaper “Help Wanted” advertisements since 2006. Both contrast starkly with the national statistics on online “Help Wanted” postings which have grown considerably over the period.

I think that the picture that emerges is of a recession that continues in full force in some areas of the country with other areas in robust recovery or never having experienced a downturn. Or even a recession in some segments of populations in some areas. Getting someone who earned an income in the fourth or even fifth quintiles of income earners to accept a job in retail sales or flipping burgers won’t produce the recovery we need, either. And those individuals are unlikely to relocate to take such a job, either, particularly when their spouses have jobs that are supporting the family now.

So, consider incentives when evaluating policy initiatives? Definitely. But focus on the incentives for those who are starting or developing businesses. I believe that’s where the potential is.

13 comments

Infrastructure

I’m a daily shopper. Every afternoon I trundle over to my beloved little local grocery store, Happy Foods, and shop. Generally, I buy what’s fresh and what’s on sale.

Today on my regular daily shopping trip what to my wondering eyes did appear on the street that runs between my house and the grocery store but the sign above. I didn’t see any evidence of workmen but the traffic backup suggested to me that a lane ahead was closed. It did bring some questions to mind.

In what universe is patching a city street three years after the recession has ended an effective fiscal stimulus? How is it creating productive infrastructure?

The best that I can see that it does is move a little from the expenses section of Chicago’s balance sheet to the liabilities section of the federal balance sheet.

3 comments

À la carte

Henry Blodget has an interesting post on something that seems so obvious to me that it’s hardly arguable: the impending collapse of the business model for television networks. After a lengthy exposition, outlining the collapse of the print newspaper business model (check out the astounding graph of real newspaper advertising revenue), he makes the following points:

  • “Networks” are completely meaningless.
  • The majority of what we pay our cable company is wasted.
  • We rarely watch TV ads, and when we do, we’re usually doing something else at the same time–like typing.
  • The vast majority of money TV advertisers spend to reach our household (~$750 a year, ~$60/month) is wasted,
  • The vast majority of money we pay our cable company for live TV (~$1,200 a year / ~$100/month) is wasted,

Virtually the only network television program I go out of my way to watch these days is NCIS and I think that’s on twilight cruise at this point. Most of what I watch is on Netflix (I would watch more on Hulu if Hulu weren’t such a mess).

The brightest new development in my television-watching habits is that I’m now a subscriber to Acorn TV. Every month I get a nice selection of British TV I can stream via my Roku directly to my TV. That’s the direction I’d really like to see television move in: à la carte

22 comments

Ten Things to Do

The conversation in comments about the state of the economy has become rather lugubrious lately. It is not as though we are without alternatives. Here are ten things that would increase GDP and employment that don’t require cutting taxes or spending more. In no particular order

  • Eliminate agricultural subsidies
  • Limit new regulations to issues of actual health and safety
  • Limit credentialing and licensing requirements to areas where there are actual health and safety concerns
  • Rationalize intellectual property law and get the WIPO to do the same
  • End subsidies to alternative energy production
  • Eliminate roadblocks to increased energy production, to the extent consistent with public health and safety
  • Enter into more bilateral free trade agreements
  • Reduce spending on defense and security to the extent consistent with actual defense and a reasonable level of security
  • Resuscitate the DOHA multilateral trade negotiations. And, last but not least
  • Cut public healthcare spending and reduce the rate of increase in healthcare costs

There are also some steps we could take that could be construed as cutting taxes or increasing spending but don’t necessarily do so:

  • Eliminate the corporate income tax
  • Re-write the tax code to make it simpler and more efficient

IMO all of these things fall more into the category of “Don’t wanna” rather than “Can’t”. I also suspect that some readers may find this list puzzling, wondering what the relation between them and increasing GDP or employment might be. They are all moves that will make the economy more efficient or will encourage the formation of new businesses or increased rates of business invesment.

Please submit your own suggestions in comments.

19 comments

Getting Out of the Cycle

Former Treasury Secretary and former Director of the White House United States National Economic Council Lawrence Summers gives his prescription for breaking out of the Sisyphean cycle the U. S. economy appears have entered:

So, what is to be done? Rather than focusing on lowering already epically low rates, governments that enjoy such low borrowing costs can improve their creditworthiness by borrowing more, not less, and investing in improving their future fiscal position even assuming no positive demand stimulus effects of a kind likely to materialize with negative real rates. They should accelerate any necessary maintenance project-issuing debt leaves the state richer not poorer, assuming that maintenance costs rise at or above the general inflation rate.

As my colleague Martin Feldstein has pointed out, this is a principle that applies to accelerating replacement cycles for military supplies. Similarly, government decisions to issue debt, and then buy space that is currently being leased, will improve the government’s financial position as long as the interest rate on debt is less than the ratio of rents to building values – a condition almost certain to be met in a world of sub-2% government borrowing rates.

I think that one aspect of his prescription, i.e. preferring spending that does more over spending that does less, is commonsensical. Commonsense has been in terribly short supply in Washington for some time. However, I’m not as sure about one of the examples he gives: accelerating replacement cycles for military supplies. This would seem to me to be an example of time-shifting and assumes that the economy at the time from which the spending is being shifted is stronger than the economy is now. What if the economy in a year or two years is weaker than it is now?

Another reason to be chary of his prescription is that levels of public debt approaching 100% of GDP have been shown to be associated with slower growth in GDP. I would think that our problem is that GDP is growing too slowly rather than too quickly.

7 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

0 comments