I Realize It’s the Daily Mail

But for the life of me the first eleven words of the headline of this story look as though they had been generated by a computer.

It’s a propos of some remarks made in comments but all I have to add is that it reminds me of Hunter S. Thompson’s wisecrack “When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro.”

4 comments

When Last We Checked In On “One Man’s Legislature”

The Illinois House did not pass public employee pension reform last night:

SPRINGFIELD— — State lawmakers spent the final day of the spring session failing to act on the crucial issue of pension reform, instead approving a major gambling expansion that wasn’t at the top of the agenda.

The turn of events dealt a significant blow to Gov. Pat Quinn, who had pleaded with the General Assembly to focus on issues that were necessary and to skip distracting sideshows.

The Democratic governor had pushed hard to rein in government worker retirement costs that threaten the state’s finances, but his efforts to come up with Democratic support for pension reform fell flat when he asked that the bill not be called for a vote.

The Illinois legislators want to

  1. Go home and campaign for re-election.
  2. Stock up on contributions from the public employees’ unions.
  3. Wait until the whole thing goes away.
  4. Make a responsible analysis of the pending legislation before casting their votes.
  5. All of the above.
  6. None of the above.
  7. a-c but definitely not d.

In related new the Chicago Teachers Union is preparing for a strike vote:

The Chicago Teachers Union says it is planning to conduct a strike vote in coming days.

With contract talks grinding along, the union recently took the first step toward a strike by requesting that a three-member panel review proposals for both sides.

Last week, 5,000 teachers rallied in and around the Auditorium Theatre, shouting “fight” and “strike” and booing every mention of Mayor Rahm Emanuel before taking to the streets in a march led by CTU President Karen Lewis and the Rev. Jesse Jackson.

A new state law requires 75 percent of the union’s membership to vote to for a strike.

I’m not sure what they’d be striking against. To the best of my knowledge the negotations are still in mediation—there’s no proposal on the table at this point. Whatever it is, they’re against it! IMO that’s almost the definition of bargaining in bad faith.

For those of you who aren’t Illlnoisans, let me give you some idea of how screwy things are here. The Chicago Public Schools don’t participate in the Illinois Teachers Retirement System—CPS has its own system. Chicago taxpayers do, however, contribute to the TRS in the form of the state’s “contribution” to the fund which comes from general revenues which in turn come from sales taxes, personal income taxes, and corporate income taxes.

All property taxes go directly to the various governing bodies in the areas in which the properties being taxed are located. In Illinois school districts, park districts, sanitation districts, and a variety of other government service providers have the ability to raise property taxes without a by-your-leave from the state legislature, county board, city council or other representative body. The state legislature, however, is empowered to limit the frequency and size of rate increases. Illinois has a vast number of independently taxing entities—6,075 as of 2000.

Generally speaking, property is reassessed in Illinois every four years except in Cook County where it is reassessed every three years. The default assessment value is a third of the fair cash value of the property but many areas of the state have their own formulas for determining the assessment. Just as a general guideline when making any statement about government or taxes in Illinois the sentence should be started with the words “in counties other than Cook”.

There is also something whacky called “the multiplier” or equalization factor that is allegedly used to provide greater uniformity among tax assessments of properties. Equalization is done within counties and between counties. County assessment officers have pay incentives to apply equalization. Equalization does not take place within Cook County but does take place between Cook County and other Illinois counties.

Cook County applies wrinkles of its own to all of this. Commercial is assessed at a significantly higher value relative to its fair cash value than residential property (there are actually 14 different property classifications, each assessed at different rates).

The reason that I’m going into so much detail on the subject of property taxes is that folks who live outside of Cook County and the collar counties often deeply resent Cook County, believing that their tax dollars go to subsidize the layabouts, welfare recipients, and overpaid public employees in Cook County and Chicago. Taxpayers in Chicago (like me) believe almost exactly the opposite—that Chicago pays its fair share and then some and that once you’ve taken the collar counties into account northeastern Illinois is, in effect, support the remainder of the state.

There’s actually some truth in both viewpoints and the subject is so complicated, probably deliberately so, I don’t know that anyone really knows the truth of the matter.

2 comments

Step 1. Steal Underpants

Unless something explodes, bursts into flame, or is hijacked the big news of the day is likely to be the Bureau of Labor Statistics Employment Situation report for May. The report is not good. A net of only 69,000 jobs was added to an economy that needs almost twice that just to employ the new people who enter the labor market as a result of the natural increase. To add insult to injury April’s tepid 115,000 was revised down to 77,000. Here’s what Barry Ritholtz said in anticipation of the announcement:

Net new jobs has clearly been on a downslide since the peak 5 months ago.

A variety of other data points suggest a slowing of the economy, but not an imminent recession. However, it wont take much int he way of negative data to raise those fears again.

The overall trend in employment has been muddling along, 100-200k for most of the past year. Consensus is for 150,000 new jobs following the punk April report of 115,000.

When you combine the very slow (or no) GDP growth announced yesterday to this jobs report, it paints a picture of an economy that has passed the peak of the present business cycle and is slowing towards the trough of the next recession. This was a point at which we really needed robust growth.

It’s been clear for some time that the strategy of the president’s re-election campaign is to produce fear, uncertainty, and doubt about Mitt Romney, the presumptive Republican nominee. It is a strategy not without risks—for example, it jettisons the hope and change campaign of 2008 and at least some of the voters who supported Barack Obama for those reasons.

One thing that could derail the strategy entirely is a domestic economic situation that is itself so frightening coupled with a lack of any plan for altering its present trajectory that is so obvious that they overwhelm any fears, uncertainty, or doubt about what the other guy would do on the grounds that anything would be better than this. This month’s employment situation report is not good news for the president’s re-election campaign strategists.

57 comments

What We Need Is a Time Machine

The big news here in Illinois is the state legislature’s mad dash to enact pension reform legislation. The tirade of one legislator’s reaction to the bum’s rush has already reached viral status:

The reason for the hurry can be found in Article IV, Section 10 of the state constitution:

The General Assembly shall provide by law for a uniform effective date for laws passed prior to June 1 of a calendar year. The General Assembly may provide for a different effective date in any law passed prior to June 1. A bill passed after May 31 shall not become effective prior to June 1 of the next calendar year unless the General Assembly by the vote of three-fifths of the members elected to each house provides for an earlier effective date.

Unless the law is passed today, either it can’t become effective for a year or a three-fifths vote of the legislature will be required to enact the earlier effective date into law. That would mean that the legislation would require Republican votes to pass.

That’s the reason that House Speaker Mike Madigan struck the provision that local governments become responsible for teacher pensions rather than the state as it is now. Here’s the Sun-Times’s editorial on the subject:

Late Wednesday night, House Speaker Michael Madigan agreed to drop a provision in his public employee pension reform package that Republicans had vehemently opposed. The provision would have shifted teacher pension costs from the state to suburban and Downstate school districts.

By stripping away that piece, Madigan dramatically increased the odds that desperately-needed pension cuts are coming to Illinois.

That is progress, even if passage on Thursday, the last day of the legislative session, isn’t guaranteed.

And, it’s important to point out, Madigan was right on the cost shift.

Madigan’s provision wasn’t a side note to pension reform. It was a vital component. It would have, for the first time, forced school districts to pay for the benefits they dole out. Currently, school districts can sweeten pensions without paying for them. Cost shifting is a much-needed check on excessive pension benefit growth.

The Trib is even more strident:

If the majority Democrats push through pension reform lite at the last minute, with virtually no Republican input and with genteel treatment of current workers, they will have delivered one more in a long line of feckless legislative sessions that didn’t fix the most pressing danger to state government’s financial future.

A legislative session that began in February has produced meaningful cuts in Medicaid spending. It may produce a tight spending plan that will close several expensive and unnecessary state institutions. All good. But on the year’s most crucial issue — pension reform — lawmakers have perpetuated their decades-long habit of popping huge legislation on the eve of adjournment, creating an artificial rush to an uninformed decision. At that point, bosses rule and gotcha politics trumps good policy.

[…]

So far this year, the most impressive leadership on pensions has come from the governor. Quinn proposed a bold plan to reduce benefits, eliminate unfunded obligations over 30 years, and add a legal requirement that lawmakers fully fund the pension system every year. That’s still the better outline for a negotiated solution.

Gov. Quinn, don’t cave. If legislators don’t deliver, keep them in Springfield.

As I see it Illinois’s pension problems have three major components:

  1. The perverse incentives that districts and local governments have to beef up public employees’ retiree benefits, a burden that doesn’t fall on them but on the state.
  2. The failure of the state, particularly during the Blagojevich years, to fund the public employee pensions’ funds.
  3. The decline in revenues as a consequence of the recession and the new normal in the economy. Despite increased taxes revenues are still down.

Now the state’s in a bind. It’s having problems increasing revenues. It needs to make up the shortfall that it created. And there’s a mad dash to the door as public employees retire, hoping to secure their pensions before the legislature changes the rules.

There are several things that I want to add to the pot before I close this post. First, I can’t imagine the public employees’ unions sitting still for the drastic change in their retirees’ pensions and benefits that the reforms being debated will impose. I don’t see any way that legislators, public employees, and voters can all be satisfied at the same time. Did I mention that this is an election year?

Second, as I’ve mentioned before the pension reforms will unquestionably end up in the courts and by “courts” I mean the U. S. Supreme Court. Interesting times.

Finally, I haven’t seen anyone else mention this but the revision in pensions and benefits completely re-write the rules on public employee compensation. For decades local governments and school districts have been able to promise hefty retirement packages as an alternative to higher pay, promises Illinois’s economy isn’t able to live up to. That will certainly be taken into account at the next contract negotiations. I expect teachers, police officers, and firefighters to demand higher pay so that they can pay for the loss they will see in retirement compensation themselves.

5 comments

Economics as Advocacy

Most of the economic news this morning is bad. Unemployment claims are up:

The Labor Department’s report Thursday on weekly unemployment claims showed first-time filings rose to 383,000 for the week ending Saturday. That was an increase of 10,000 from the previous week’s revised figure, a sizable jump after smaller increases in the previous two weeks.

The rise in jobless claims was consistent with a report from Challenger, Gray & Christmas, a private outplacement firm, that showed an acceleration of layoff announcements this month by employers. Challenger said Thursday that businesses in May announced plans to cut 61,886 workers from their payrolls, up 53% seasonally unadjusted from April and 67% higher than May 2011. The May layoffs were reported largely by the computer industry.

and GDP is down:

Adding to the dreary economic news, the government said in a separate report Thursday that U.S. gross domestic product grew at a slower pace in the first quarter than previously thought. Growth in GDP, the total value of goods and services produced in the nation, was revised down to an annualized rate of 1.9% from 2.2% initially estimated a month ago.

As I pointed out yesterday that means that in real terms GDP is actually flat or even declining. The Chicago PMI declined, too:

The pace of business activity in the U.S. Midwest slowed in May as new orders fell to their lowest since September 2009, a report showed on Thursday.

The Institute for Supply Management-Chicago business barometer declined to 52.7 from 56.2 in April, falling short of economists’ forecasts for a modest gain to 56.5.

A reading above 50 indicates expansion in the regional economy. It is one of the last regional factory activity surveys for the month ahead of the national manufacturing report due on Friday, which is expected to show growth in the sector slowed slightly in May.

The forward-looking new orders index fell to 52.9 from 57.4, while the gauge of employment slipped to 57.0 from 58.7.

I think these details mostly substantiate what many of us with ears to the ground already recognize: the economy is stalling. I think that all misses the real story. To me the real story is that all of these indicators did worse than economists expected them to.

Not long ago I stumbled across a study that found that over the last several years economists’ expectations had been wrong systematically on the upside, i.e. they had thought things would improve much more frequently than actually occurred. Being wrong is not unexpected. As Markus M. Ronner put it, prediction is difficult, especially about the future (the wisecrack has been attributed to Yogi Berra and Niels Bohr but the earliest instance of the remark found to date was by the Swiss theologian in 1918).

However, when error is systematically in the same direction there’s more going on. There’s either something wrong with the models that are being used or they’re engaging in wishful thinking. Or maybe they’re cheerleading. It worries me when economics is advocacy.

37 comments

Desperately Seeking Bottom

You might want to take a look at Barry Ritholtz’s survey post of the various prognosticators who have repeatedly and erroneously announced the bottom of the housing market. The list includes ABC, CNN, the New York Times, Reuters, Bloomberg, himself, and practically every other media outlet.

I’ve noticed something of an air of desperation lately in some of those who are announcing the bottom of the housing market.

It seems to me that we’d be better off looking for some other sector to lead us out of the economic doldrums than wishing that the housing market would resume its role in that regard.

0 comments

So What?

The headline is eyecatching: “WOW: In No State Is a 40-Hour, Minimum Wage Work Week Enough to Afford a Two-Bedroom Apartment” and the associated graphic is interesting. However, when I thought more about the statistic my overwhelming reaction was “So what?”

Consider this summary of workers who earn minimum wage. Here’s the author’s summary:

1. It just simply isn’t true that tens of millions of Americans support their families on minimum wage earnings.

2. There is nothing racist about the federal minimum wage. No racial group can claim that theirs is the one carrying more of the burden than any of the others.

3. High school- and college-aged people are by far the largest groups of minimum wage workers, many of whom are working their first jobs. With a higher minimum wage, one has to wonder if many of these jobs would even exist.

Minimum wage workers are relatively small in number, racially diverse, preponderantly Southern, and mostly below the age of 25. Unless your model of family life is a single-mother family with the mother below the age of 25, the frightening image of a family trying to get by on one minimum wage income is atypical in the extreme.

Should we subsidize single-mother families headed by women below the age of 25? How should we subsidize them? Is it an important societal value for single people below the age of 25 without children to be able to afford a two-bedroom apartment? Those are questions not answers.

2 comments

My Reflection for the Day

When a country is well governed, poverty and a mean condition are things to be ashamed of. When a country is ill governed, riches and honor are things to be ashamed of.

4 comments

Withdrawal from Afghanistan in Friedman Units

In reviewing my thirty or forty posts on Afghanistan both here and at Outside the Beltway over the period of the last eight years or so, I noticed something interesting. There is a sort of Friedman unit in the president’s plans for withdrawing our forces from Afghanistan. In 2008 when running for the presidency Candidate Obama spoke of complete U. S. military withdrawal from Afghanistan by 2011. More recently he’s been talking about an end to our combat role in Afghanistan by 2014 and complete withdrawal by 2020.

This post is more of a lament than a complaint. I gather that either a responsible withdrawal has proven more difficult than the president had hoped, the Afghans’ ability to field a military capable of fulfilling the role that we’ve been filling is less than he’d hoped, or withdrawing earlier was more of a hope than a plan.

23 comments

The Big Stories (Domestic)

Continuing on from where my last post left off, let’s consider the big domestic stories.

The U. S. economy is flat

At the present rate of growth of the U. S. economy There is no growth in the U. S. economy. Real growth is, essentially, zero. The Case-Shiller index fell again, ending the first quarter of 2012 at the lowest level since the housing crisis began in 2006. Why don’t we hear a coherent plan to remedy the present situation from somebody, anybody?

Please do not tell me that higher education is the key to a bright economic future. More than half of recent college grads are unemployed or underemployed. Canada has the highest percentage of people with college educations—roughly 50%. That seems to be about the limit for higher education for a population. What about the other 50%? We’ve had three consecutive administrations for which higher education for all has been the keystone of their economic policy. What that has produced is mountains of student debt.

If you believe that cutting taxes will produce a vibrant economy, please explain why the multiple tax cuts of the last decade haven’t had that outcome? And why this time will be different?

This is not just a Big Story. This is The Big Story. The entire world’s corporate economic plan seems to be for the U. S. consumer to recover.

State and local governments are broke

State and local governments are being bankrupted by increasing healthcare and pension costs. Healthcare and pension costs are rising fast enough and incomes, real estate values, and retail sales are rising slowly enough (or even falling) that just increasing taxes is no solution. We need national healthcare reform that lowers healthcare costs. This is a Big Story.

Energy self-sufficiency

As I’ve written any number of times before energy independence is a will o’ the wisp—there’s a world market and unless we close our doors and pull the rug in behind us we’ll be subject to the effects of a world market. However and somewhat ironically, energy self-sufficiency may be within our grasp. This is an absolutely enormous story. Our imports of oil are a big component of our trade deficit and our trade deficit is a component of our economic slowdown. My suggestion on energy policy: lead, follow, or get the hell out of the way. Mostly the latter.

ZIRP

If anybody has a good explanation of how most people can save for their futures as long as the Federal Reserve maintains a zero interest rate policy, I’d like to see it. It’s also killing the insurance industry but that’s a topic for another time.

Reverse migration

Mexican immigration seems to have stopped and may even be going back the other way. I honestly don’t think that enough people appreciate how big a story this is. I think the assumption is that, if the American economy picks up, Mexican immigration into this country will resume. The demographics and economic development of Latin America and the Caribbean do not support that conclusion.

If you have other candidates for really big domestic stories, please submit them in comments. I’ll add the ones I agree are Big Stories in an update to this post.

42 comments