The Big Stories (Foreign)

I don’t know how you feel about it but I’m getting pretty tired of the scandal du jour and horse race side of the presidential campaign that seem to obsess the news media these days. There actually are some important stories. Unfortunately, they’ve been fermenting so long that it’s hard to come up with a new angle on them. That doesn’t mean they’ve gone away.

In this post and my next I’m going to outline the big foreign policy and domestic policy stories that I honestly wish were more the focus of both the media and the political campaign.

The slow motion collapse of the euro

This category rolls up all of the European economic stories, from Greece’s rumored impending withdrawal from the euro to what’s beginning to look like an imminent collapse of Spanish banks to economic slowdown in Germany. From this side of the pond the story is colored by commentators projecting their own domestic political policy preferences on the Europeans. As best as I can tell the operative definition of “austerity” in a European context is raising taxes and cutting government spending. That’s the only option available to non-monetary sovereigns like Greece and Spain and I don’t see that bitching about it from this side of the Atlantic changes much.

The most straightforward solution for the eurozone’s problems would be for Germany to exit the euro. The alternative that seems to be underway is for everybody but Germany and France to leave the euro. Or maybe they’ll end up with a northern monetary union and a southern monetary union. Regardless, the slow motion collapse of one of the world’s reserve currencies and a whole continent in economic downturn, from what looks like stagnation in Germany to an outright depression in Spain is a Big Story.

Economic slowdown in China

PMI has been declining in China for the last six months. China’s real estate bubble is clearly bursting messily. China’s economy is either slowing down or in outright recession. When that occurs in the world’s second largest economy it’s a Big Story.

Continuing fallout from Arab Spring

We’re continuing to see the fallout from the Arab Spring of last year. Egypt’s presidential election is down to a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, Mohammed Mursi, and a Prime Minister under Mubarak, Ahmed Shafiq. The best thing that I think can be said about that situation is that at least the Salafists lost. Qaddafi was removed in Libya with NATO help and the country is now, apparently, run by militias. The revolution in Libya destabilized Mali.

Everything that anybody worried might happen in Libya seems to be happening right now in Syria. Unfortunately for the Syrian people the Bashar al-Assad can’t be brought down by NATO air power, so they’re on their own. Their own government will continue to fire artillery shells at them until they stop protesting.

The Iranian nuclear program

Talks with Iran over Iran’s nuclear development program appear to have broken down with lost of saber-rattling on both sides. Kaspersky, the Russian security firm, says that a mammoth malware program has been attacking Iranian computers for months. This situation could turn into a real shootin’ war before the November elections here and multiple war games of the situation over the last decade have found that we don’t have much control of its starting and won’t be able to stay out once it starts. Whatever you think the outcome of this situation should be and whoever you think is in the right, this is a Big Story.

The War in Afghanistan

We still have nearly 100,000 troops in Afghanistan. Ten years from now we still plan to have a military presence in Afghanistan. To the best of my ability to tell the president’s plan for Afghanistan appears to be a timeline divorced from actual milestones. I think the president owes us a more convincing argument that Afghanistan is of strategic importance. It’s a Big Story.

The Drone War

The New York Times has a lengthy story on the drone war against al-Qaeda. I can only infer that the president believes that the number of people who actually threaten us is relatively small and once they’ve been eliminated, mostly from the air via drone attacks, we will no longer face a terrorist threat. Is there any actual evidence that’s correct?

Meanwhile, it reminds me somewhat of Lincoln’s wisecrack. If this is law enforcement, I think we should have war. If it’s war, I think we should have law enforcement.

Any other prospective candidates for really big foreign policy stories? Particularly something that isn’t being discussed?

6 comments

Are We Going to Make It Up in Volume?

I made a comment somewhat along the lines of what I posted here to a post by Doug Mataconis at OTB and I was a bit puzzled by some of the responses to it. They reminded me of the story about the guy who lost a dollar on every sale who was convinced he would make it up in volume.

Illinois’s problem is that its expenses are growing faster than its revenue and, since the underlying economic activity that its revenue are based on isn’t growing either, it can’t cause its revenue to increase as fast as its expenses by raising the marginal rates. A case in point is the affiliates tax Illinois passed last year and recently declared unconstitutional and invalid. Rather than yielding additional revenue it actually reduced revenue (since most online retailers dropped their affiliates program in Illinois rather than collecting the tax). Adding insult to injury the state was forced to defend the law in court and lost.

I’m still waiting for the people (like Medicaid recipients or Chicago teachers) who are outraged at the state or city’s inability to maintain their benefits or raise their pay, respectively, to explain what they think should be done.

9 comments

I’d Really Like to Know How They Think Things Should Work

There are two big stories here in Illinois and Chicago, respectively, that I think are interrelated and deserving of a bit of consideration. In the first the Illinois legislature passed sharp cuts in Medicaid:

SPRINGFIELD — Hundreds of thousands of poor Illinoisans would lose health coverage, prescription drug discounts for seniors would be dropped and dental care for adults would be greatly curtailed as part of $1.6 billion in budget cuts lawmakers approved Thursday.

The major Medicaid reductions ignited anger in some lawmakers who say the cutbacks will jeopardize the lives of the state’s most vulnerable residents.

“I don’t know where it’s written in the law that this has to be balanced on the backs of poor people, on the backs of seniors, on the backs of the aged, blind and disabled,” said Rep. Mary Flowers, D-Chicago.

But supporters argued failure to approve the bill could lead to cuts throughout state government and result in the collapse of the entire Medicaid system.

The House voted 94-22 to approve the measure, and the Senate later approved it 44-13. But cuts are only part of the equation to fix Medicaid. Gov. Pat Quinn is seeking support for a $1-a-pack increase in the state’s cigarette tax to help fill an overall $2.7 billion gap in Medicaid funding for the budget year that starts in July.

As I’ve mentioned before the price elasticity of demand of cigarettes (coupled with the ease of avoidance of the tax) strongly suggests that the additional excise tax won’t deliver as much new revenue as they think it will. That sound you hear is the convoy of trucks from Missouri, filled to their roofs with bootleg cigarettes.

Illinois’s Medicaid expenses have increased enormously over the last decade. Part of the reason for that is the general increase in costs in medicine. But another substantial component is the large expansion of the Medicaid roster in Illinois over the last decade or so. The requirements necessary to qualify for Medicaid in Illinois changed several times over the Blagojevich era and, as a consequence, that roster has something like 380,000 more recipients than it otherwise might have had.

On the one hand you’ve got to have some sympathy for people who without Medicaid would have no healthcare insurance and are faced with medical bills that go up faster than their wages do. But on the other hand a good portion of those who will be stricken from the Medicaid rolls as a result of the newly enacted reforms should never have been on Medicaid to begin with.

The other story is the ongoing negotiations between the City and the Chicago Teacher’s Union:

The union and CPS are negotiating with the help of an independent mediator. By law, that negotiation will extend until mid-July, barring an earlier agreement.

If there is no agreement then, the mediator will propose a compromise.

Both sides will have up to 15 days to accept or reject that compromise. If either side rejects the deal, the terms are then made public. That will give residents a full view of what’s on the table. Thirty days after the report becomes public, the union can call a strike.

That process was established last year by state law. The law was written to create a more deliberate and transparent labor negotiation, to reduce the impetus for confrontation. It also set a high bar for a strike — 75 percent of the members of the union must approve it.

So why all the talk right now about holding a strike vote?

“It is impossible to take a vote in summer when all our members are on vacation,” union vice president Jesse Sharkey said Tuesday.

The graph here should put both of these stories into some perspective. As you can see Illinois’s general fund revenues have been flat or declining for the last several years even taking the large increase in taxes that took effect last year into account.

The state of Illinois derives most of its revenues from three sources: individual income tax, corporate income tax, and sales tax. City and county governments derive most of their revenues from two sources: sales tax and property taxes. Since 2007 property values have been flat or declined, retail sales have been more or less flat, and incomes have been flat or declined. In Illinois cities and counties aren’t empowered to enact income taxes and the state.

The bottom line for the state, city, and county governments here in Illinois is that the things that they depend on for revenue have been flat and the things they spend money one, mostly healthcare and education, have been getting more expensive fast.

I understand that Medicaid recipients and teachers want more money. That’s human. Nearly all of us want more money. What I’d really like to know is where they think the money will come from?

Here in Chicago, for example, the starting salary for a teacher with bachelors only for a ten month job is half again the median income for the city. The base pay of the superintendent of Chicago Public Schools is around $250,000 with teacher and administrator salaries ranging between that and $50,000. Chicago is not empowered to enact an income tax. There are legal limits to the rate at which property taxes can be raised and property values have declined. The sales tax in the City of Chicago is already the highest of any major city, high enough to drive some retailers out of the city.

So, that’s the basis for my question. Wages for Chicago teachers are already high relative to wages in the community they serve. Revenues are just about maxxed out. The foreclosure rate in the Chicago metropolitan area is already ninth among major metro areas and higher property taxes will only exacerbate that. Where the heck is the money supposed to come from?

22 comments

Causal or Irrelevant?

The more I looked at this graph from Marc Nunes, plotting “nominal spending and output growth from 1800 to 2011” the more questions I had. Mr. Nunes notes:

Note that since the 1980s, and increasingly, nominal and real growth have become more tightly knit.

I wish there were a little more detail. I’d particularly like to know how the figures were derived.

I interpret his comment to imply that the change in nominal GDP is effecting the change in real GDP. Can you determine that from the graph alone? Why isn’t it the other way around?

I think a perfectly reasonable interpretation of the graph is that over time the Federal Reserve has become increasingly skilled at doing what it perceives its job to be. The Federal Reserve was established in 1913, coincidentally just shortly prior to the largest discrepancy between NGCP and RGDP over the period. After a few oscillations (notably, the Great Depression and World War II) there’s the “Great Inflation” followed, starting about 30 years ago, by the “Great Moderation”.

Has the old order really failed? That may be the case but I don’t see how you can support that conclusion from that graph.

7 comments

Courage Little Seen In This Day and Age

Recently, this particular scene from Blazing Saddles came to mind:

It needed to be said. What worries me is how often I’m likely to think of that scene over the next six months.

0 comments

Only Esther

New scholarship has identified a fragment of the Book of Nehemiah among the Dead Sea Scrolls. Heretofore fragments of every canonical book of the Hebrew Bible had been identified among the Scrolls except for the Book of Esther and the Book of Nehemiah:

Working together with Esther Eshel of Bar-Ilan University, Torleif Elgvin of Evangelical Lutheran University College in Oslo, Norway, has been examining previously unknown fragments from 29 scrolls (including scraps of four others). The fragments include that of Nehemiah for the first time, textual variations of Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Deuteronomy, 1 Samuel, 2 Samuel, Ruth, Proverbs, and the Twelve; a fragment from an unknown Enoch-related text and two new copies of 1 Enoch; and a new copy of a sectarian biblical commentary. Most of these fragments were found decades ago in “Cave 4” near the Dead Sea, but several were found at the Bar Kokhba caves and some small fragments were originally discovered at Wadi el-Daliyeh, a valley fourteen kilometres north of Jericho.

Now the only book unrepresented among the Scrolls is Esther. Note, also that the scrolls contain a number of non-canonical books, e.g. the Book of Jubilees and the Book of Enoch.

2 comments

Peak Obsidian

New research from the Field Museum and UIC suggests that a decline in the availability of obsidian may have been instrumental in precipitating the decline in the high civilization of the Maya:

“Our research strongly suggests that changing patterns of trade were instrumental in prompting the ‘Maya collapse,'” said Gary Feinman, curator of anthropology at The Field Museum, which collaborated with the University of Illinois at Chicago on the study.

The new research casts doubt on the idea that climate change was the sole or principal cause, Feinman said, noting that some Maya centers, which flourished after the collapse, were located in the driest parts of the Maya region. Feinman said that climate change, along with breakdowns in leadership, warfare, and other factors, contributed to the collapse, but the shifting exchange networks may have been a key factor.

For the Maya, who did not have metal tools, obsidian (or volcanic glass) was highly valued because of its sharp edges for use as cutting instruments. Maya lords and other elites derived power from controlling access to obsidian, which could be traded for important goods or sent as gifts to foster important relationships with other Mayan leaders.

The Field Museum researchers found that prior to the fall of the Maya inland centers, obsidian tended to flow along inland riverine networks. But over time, this material began to be transported through coastal trade networks instead, with a corresponding increase in coastal centers’ prominence as inland centers declined.

This is a topic I’ve returned to from time to time. This same set of circumstances arose in the Middle East. 10,000 years ago there was an extensive obsidian trade throughout the region. As nearby obsidian stocks were depleted trade extended over an increasing area. Eventually, good quality obsidian became hard enough to come by that substitutes were used.

Unfortunately for the Maya there wasn’t much in the way of copper deposits available to them for substitutes as there were in the Middle East.

3 comments

A Note on Taxes

The average effective individual tax rate for those in the top .1% (that’s the top one-tenth of one percent, roughly 138,000 of them) was 24.3%. The threshold for that income level was about $2 million in income. I think that group counts as rich by nearly any standard and, indeed, is my definition of “the rich”.

If you believe that the rich are paying too much in taxes, you necessarily mean that they should pay a lower proportion of their income in taxes than that. Those are equivalent statements. The precise mechanism for the tax doesn’t matter except at the margins. It could be a consumption tax, a flat tax, a graduated income tax or some combination.

Moreover, if you believe in balancing the federal budget (whether it could or should be balanced is a discussion for another time) and you don’t also believe in cutting Social Security, defense spending, and the various federal healthcare programs, then you pragmatically believe that the effective tax rate of 24.3% is too low.

Just for the record I believe that over the long term the federal budget should be approximately balanced but I don’t think that a small deficit in perpetuity would present a problem, that taxes are about right, that defense spending and entitlement spending are far too high. I also believe that rising healthcare spending is the single most important fiscal problem and that, while decreasing utilization might be a component of the reform that we need, most of the reform that we need in healthcare is structural.

26 comments

The President and the Economy

In my earlier post this morning I repeated my position that I vote for president based on foreign policy. There’s a reason for that. Constitutionally, the president has a lot of influence over foreign policy and defense. He has relatively little power over domestic policy or, particularly, the economy. That power is vested in the Congress, just about as depressing a thought as I can muster.

However, just for fun let’s imagine that the president’s views do make a difference. What does he believe? I think we’ve got enough hands-on experience that we can make some reasonable inferences. The Obama economic policy, like the Obama foreign policy, has a high degree of continuity with that of the last few years of the Bush Administration, i.e. subsidizing preferred industries (banks and the auto industry, just to name two) and fiscal stimulus through tax cuts and increased spending.

To be sure there are differences in emphasis. Under Obama I strongly suspect that the UAW took less of a haircut than it might have under Bush or under a prospective Romney Administration. Where the Bush administration emphasized reductions in the personal income tax, the Obama Administration has emphasized reducing FICA.

One area in which I think there was a substantial change from the Bush Administration is the the present administration’s support for alternative energy, support that I strongly suspect will return to haunt them. While some case can be made for research, touting the support as a jobs creation program was at the least over-stated and at the worst unhinged. I find it incredible that an industry that can’t survive without subsidies will at some point cross some threshold and suddenly become a self-sustaining jobs engine. I think that was always wishful thinking.

You might want to take a look at James Pethokoukis’s contrasting of “Obama-style” capitalism with “Romney-style” capitalism. While I think there may be some aspirational differences I don’t believe that the differences between the two are quite as stark as he does.

I might add that I think the notion that further reductions in the personal income tax are likely to spur economic growth is, well, goofy. IMO the experience of the first part of the Aughts should be enough to dissuade anybody of that but apparently not. I think that our problem is that we’re spending too much on education and healthcare and not investing enough in industries that might actually employ somebody.

2 comments

Halfway

Halfway up the stairs
Isn’t up
And it isn’t down.
It isn’t in the nursery,
It isn’t in town.

For those of you who’ve just tuned in it’s likely that Mitt Romney will secure the number of delegates necessary for him to sew up the Republican nomination for the presidency next Tuesday. We will have reached the halfway point of the presidential election campaign process. The next quarter in that process will culminate with the party conventions and the final quarter will consist of both candidates running out the clock until the election in November.

As I have said any number of times before I vote for president almost entirely on the basis of foreign policy and the flip side of that coin, defense. For someone with my views on foreign policy the choice is particularly distressing. As the late Mayor Daley used to say, let’s look at the record.

Candidate Obama ran on bolstering the forces in Afghanistan, something that his opponent would undoubtedly have done as well. He was as good as his word. In 2008 the institutional momentum was pushing in the direction of counter-insurgency and under President Obama that is the policy we have followed. In my opinion it was an error but it was an error that would have occurred regardless of who was the resident of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue in Washington, DC.

I strongly suspect that President Obama will continue to be as good as his word with respect to Afghanistan. I expect that the forces there will be drawn down gradually and that we will continue to have a military presence in Afghanistan into the indefinite future. I have no idea what President McCain would be saying at this point about Afghanistan.

I don’t believe that President Obama has made a convincing strategic case for our continued presence in Afghanistan to the American people. The polls certainly suggest that we are not convinced. I also expect that shortly after we withdraw our forces from Afghanistan Congress will withdraw U. S. funding from Afghanistan.

Guantanamo is still in operation; we have made increasing use of unmanned drones in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and other areas around the world including Yemen. Osama bin Laden was killed. This was referred to as “bringing him to justice”, further blurring the line between counter-terrorism as warfare and counter-terrorism as law enforcement. I don’t believe that killing OBL had a great deal of strategic significance; the letters of his that have been released support his loss of operational control.

President Obama conformed to the terms of the Status of Forces Agreement negotiated under President Bush. The last U. S. troops left Iraq on December 16, 2011. The negotiated date was December 31, 2011. I would characterize that as “on time”, neither late nor early.

The Iranian regime continues to do its level best to convince its friends and enemies alike that it does, indeed, have a nuclear weapons development program and has just started another round of “Lucy and the football” with the international community over nuclear inspections. Obama’s approach to ending whatever nuclear program Iran is engaged in has not been successful but I don’t know that anybody else would have been more successful.

The best that can be said about the Libyan intervention that President Obama supported is that Qaddafi is no longer in charge there, no American lives were lost, and we don’t really know what the outcome will be. At this point it looks very much as though Libya is now being controlled by various militias and overthrowing Qaddafi may have had the unforeseen side effect of destabilizing Mali. As I said, we don’t really know what’s going to happen and, while not having boots on the ground does keep the cost of intervention down and avoids losing American lives it also cedes what little influence we might have had on how events unfold there. I continue to believe our intervention in Libya was an error. What would President McCain have done? President Romney? I have no idea.

Last fall President Obama gave three trade agreements that had been negotiated under the Bush Administration their final push through Congress. The president has his own Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement that he’s pushing. The Doha Round of multilateral trade negotiations continues to have something in common with Generalissimo Franco. This is the sole area in which I suspect President Romney would be better than President Obama. However, a free trade agreement can be written on the back of a napkin; the thousands of pages of trade agreements that have been signed over the last twenty years aren’t. They merely change the terms of managed trade. Generally speaking, that change has been in our favor so the agreements are Good Things but real free trade would be even better.

Mitt Romney has made increased military spending part of his platform, something I think is unhinged.

In summary, over the last four years the Obama Administration has largely continued the policies of the last several years of the Bush Administration with the possible exception of Libya. He can hardly be said to have been “soft on defense”. To his detriment in my view but I recognize that I’m in the minority and to the best of my ability to determine President Romney would be even worse in that regard.

At this point using the primary yardstick I use for presidential candidates, Obama has the advantage. I can’t say I’m enthusiastic about his foreign policy. But I think he’s the lesser evil.

10 comments