It’s the Prices, Stupid—Revisited

Kaiser Health News notes that a new study by the Health Care Cost Institute has produced some interesting findings:

Higher prices charged by hospitals, outpatient centers and other providers drove up health care spending at double the rate of inflation during the economic downturn– even as patients consumed less medical care overall, according to a new study.

Prices rose at least five times faster than overall inflation for emergency room visits, outpatient surgery and facility-based mental health and substance abuse care from 2009 to 2010, says the report by the Health Care Cost Institute, a nonpartisan research group funded by insurers. Prices declined in only one category: nursing home care, which saw a 3.2 percent drop in the cost per admission.

One of the areas with the fastest growing spending, meanwhile, was children’s medical care.

“The story really does seem to be prices,” said Martin Gaynor, chair of the institute’s governing board and a health care economist at Carnegie Mellon University.

Representing one of the broadest looks at actual claim payments made by insurers, the study’s findings raise questions that go to the heart of the nation’s $2.6 trillion annual bill for health care: Why are prices for medical services rising far faster than inflation? Is a rapid increase in spending on children an anomaly, or a long-term trend with major implications for future costs?

“If you don’t know what the cause is, you don’t know what the right policy lever is (for a solution),” Gaynor says

Besides the rapid rise in the cost of children’s medical care there are two things the report made me wonder about. First, since as I have reported previously spending by hospitals and other healthcare providers on capital expenses and supplies is not rising fast enough to be causing the increases that have been observed, what can the cause possibly be?

Second, the finding that spending rose even as utilization declined supports the point the I’ve been making around here for some time and casts at least a little doubt on the notion that the rise in healthcare spending is being driven by patients. The healthcare sector has become a self-licking lollipop. Changing how the bills are paid won’t change that. We need healthcare reform. Healthcare spending is the federal government’s single largest budget item and it’s driving state and local governments to default.

One last point: the situation is actually slightly worse than the article or the study would suggest. They’re comparing the increase in prices in healthcare to the increases in prices, generally. They should be comparing prices in healthcare to non-healthcare prices for a more realistic view of what’s actually happening. Total healthcare spending is now a sufficiently large proportion of total spending that increases in healthcare spending are a major component if not the major component of overall spending increases that they account for a substantial portion of “inflation”, i.e. increasing prices which is apparently what the article intends when it uses the word.

7 comments

What If She’s Right?

James Hamilton points to a paper by UCSD colleague Professor Valerie Ramey on the effects of government spending from a forecasting perspective. Here’s her conclusion:

Using a variety of identification methods and samples, I find that in most cases private spending falls significantly in response to an increase in government spending. These results imply that the average GDP multiplier lies below unity.

That finding is certainly consistent with the various empirical studies which have found little or no net economic stimulus as a result of increased government spending.

My guess is that the folk and neo-Keynesians, still clinging bitterly to increased government spending to cure what ails our economy, will merely dismiss this finding when what they should be doing is producing evidence of their own, something they’ve been reluctant to do.

9 comments

Attacking Beliefs

My only comment about this story:

The melee at a Tinley Park restaurant Saturday appears to have been the work of radical protesters who wanted to attack a gathering of alleged white supremacists, the mayor and a law enforcement source said.

Ten people were injured at the Ashford House Restaurant on 159th Street after 15 to 18 young people, wearing hooded black jackets and wielding bats and hammers, burst inside and attacked another group of 12 to 15 people who were meeting there, officials said.

is that if we have reached the point where we attack beliefs, even offensive or reprehensible beliefs, with bats and hammers, civil order has already broken down.

17 comments

Going Rogue in Skyrim

After completing the main quest in Skyrim as a brawny Nord warrior, I decided to start the game over, this time as a wiry Redguard specialzing in the activities of stealth: sneaking, lockpicking, pickpocketing, speech, one-handed (dual wielding), light armor, smithing, enchanting, alchemy. I also tweaked the difficulty up a bit.

Playing Skyrim as a rogue is much harder than playing as a fighter. There are many more skills to master. I’m up to Level 20 with skill levels of 50 or more in the first six skills above. I plan to advance as far as I can in the Thieves Guild and Dark Brotherhood (assassins) before proceeding any farther in the main quest. I’m aiming for a sort of ninja warrior. It’s incredibly difficult. I actually had to backtrack to an old save because I reached a subquest where I could neither advance nor retreat at the gameplay difficulty (Adept) I’d chosen.

I honestly don’t see how Skyrim is playable at all as a pure (or mainly) magic user.

2 comments

A Dream of China

Some have fantasies of China. Siva Yam and Paul Nash, after soberly and reasonably outlining the challenges that China faces have this prescription for China’s addressing them:

China needs to grow to remain stable. To maintain growth, it will have to adapt to changing conditions. Like America over the course of the past few decades, China too must experience the pains of globalization if it is to change structurally to compete and prosper. The government has to push forward the reform process with renewed urgency – to deepen transparency and foster a stable, consistent legal system. It can’t allow this process to peter out, leaving only a system of changeable laws and arbitrary enforcement. It must also encourage the separation of “guanxi” (personal relationships) from business and demand that decisions be made based on sound economic rationale.

It’s unrealistic, of course, to expect Chinese culture to change overnight. But by taking confident strides towards greater transparency and the rule of law, China will instill confidence, both in its own citizens and in foreign investors. As this happens, it will become easier for China to acquire the skills and non-strategic technologies it needs to carry it to the next stage of development, as well as for U.S. companies to reinvigorate their operations in China. In the end, both countries can only benefit.

That is a dream worth having but it’s a dream. China doesn’t have the institutions or the will to act as they suppose. Its leaders’ objectives are not for China to grow to become prosperous. Those are only means to the end. The objective is maintaining power and keeping the system pretty much the way it is.

1 comment

Imagine

The recurring theme I’m seeing today is fantasy. To start Bruce Judson has a dream of a “Night of the Long Knives” or, more accurately a “Week of the Long Knives” for Wall Street executives:

Day One: Read the HUD Inspector General’s reports and the public records of past mortgage foreclosure cases from across the nation.

Day Two: Meet with the team at the Office of the Inspector General at HUD that prepared the audits. Obtain the names of all the bank officials, lawyers, and notaries whose behavior, as cited in the audit reports or otherwise known to the investigators, represent clear and unquestionable criminal violations. Add to this list other individuals who have similarly demonstrated or testified to behavior unquestionably constituting criminal acts, as indicated by the public records of the mortgage foreclosure cases reviewed in day one.

Day Three: Indict all of the individuals on the list compiled on day two.

Day Four: Indict banks and financial institutions on criminal charges where criminal behavior by employees (as demonstrated by day three indictments) appears to be endemic. The Justice Department guidelines for prosecuting firms include: (1) the pervasiveness of such activity, (2) the compliance procedures in place, (3) attempts by the corporation to end bad behavior, and (4) cooperation with federal investigators. In 2008, the Justice Department adopted a policy of accepting “deferred prosecutions,” involving agreements to change corporate behavior without damaging innocent third parties through prosecution.

Corporations receive the benefits of “legal persons,” as demonstrated by Citizens United. But they must also bear the responsibilities of these privileges. A reading of the HUD reports, and other public records, suggests several banks should clearly be prosecuted.

Day 5: Discuss plea bargains with indicted lower-level officials in return for cooperating in investigations of higher-level officials.

Day 6: Consider plea bargains with indicted banks, which require the removal of all remaining officers and directors who were serving when egregious criminal activity occurred, as well as senior officials who were in a position to exercise appropriate supervisory responsibility but chose to look the other way.

Day 7: Indict any senior Wall Street officials implicated by new cooperative testimony resulting from activities on day five. Adopt and announce a policy that future criminal violations will be prosecuted in a similar fashion.

His basic point is sound: there’s an increasing body of evidence that actual criminal behavior took place and continues to take place on the part of bank executive, perjury at the very least.

But the political powers-that-be have been absolutely desperate over the last half dozen years to prop up the banks and bulwark public support for them. Paying attention to their crimes at this late date would undermine that effort and put too many politicians’ careers at risk. It’s a fantasy. It won’t happen. The most we can expect is a show of effort “to encourage the others”.

7 comments

Why Are They Leaving Money On the Table?

I want to commend a fascinating post by Jim Manzi to your attention. In the post Jim considers the findings of business prof Anne Marie Knott that American companies are drastically under-spending on R&D:

Knott claims that if just the top 20 American corporations had followed her recommendations, they would have collectively increased their market capitalization by more than $1 trillion. Consider this assertion for a moment The current total market capitalization of the top 20 U.S. public companies is a little over $4 trillion. Knott claims that she has outsmarted the entire system of management teams, investors, equity analysts, hedge funds, large-scale private equity firms and everyone else who is trying to change management practices to increase share price, and knows how to increase the total value of the most-closely followed companies in the world by almost 25 percent….by building a regression model using publicly-available data.

Dr. Knott has found, for example, that Dow Chemical would have maximized its total market capitalization if it had spent an additional 10% on R&D and Apple would have maximized its total market capitalization by spending an eye-popping five times what it actually spent.

Jim correctly responds:

I’m confident that exactly the effect Knott describes is real. Some companies are better at managing research, and they will spend more, all else equal, and create greater returns for it.

But causality also runs in the opposite direction. For example, when management teams rationally foresee a good year coming, they tend to relax spending discipline. So we will see R&D spending go up in year X, and profits rising in year X+1. The expectation of future profits cause R&D spending to rise today This effect is unobserved in Knott’s model, because we have no data on executive anticipations. Some other variables will proxy for it, but the correlation between the actual unobserved variable and the proxy won’t be close to 1.

Further, there are many confounding variables. For example, different firms that are called competitors will actually face different landscapes of potential R&D opportunities, independent of R&D effectiveness. IBM and HP, as examples, have different mixes of end-use markets, different customer bases, different installed technologies and so on that means that each is looking at a different list of potential relevant projects when deciding what to fund. This changes over time. Who were Apple’s competitors in 1995? 2000? 2010? Who will be their competitors in 2015? This is referenced conceptually in Knott’s paper, but how do we segregate this effect from RQ and everything else when the model has no data on it.

However, I think that many, many companies don’t see R&D the way that Jim suggests. So, for example, in an early post here I examined the financial reports of a number of large pharmaceutical companies over a period of several years and found that R&D expenses increased, roughly, at the rate of inflation while marketing and lobbying spending increased with revenues. Or, said another way, R&D is viewed as overhead and restrained.

Dr. Knott’s findings do dovetail nicely with a recurring theme here, that R&D spending in the U. S. is far too low. Imagine, just for the sake of argument, that Dr. Knott’s findings are correct and that big companies were, in fact, behaving correspondingly. Tens or even hundreds of billion more would have been spent on R&D. That would have increased the incentives for students to pursue careers in science and technology rather than, say, finance. Or, to pick a worst-case scenario, art history.

11 comments

Remember!

In recognition of the NATO Summit that will be going on in Chicago on May 20th and 21st with all of the attendant street closings, motorcades, and protests, please remember: the Chicago police will not be there to create disorder. The Chicago police will be there to preserve disorder.

2 comments

Outcomes

Based on conditions as they are right now here’s how I see the potential outcomes of the November elections. In declining order of likelihood:

  • Unchanged: Obama re-elected, Republicans hold House, Democrats hold Senate.
  • Very slightly behind that: Romney elected, Republicans hold House, Democrats hold Senate.
  • Regime change: Romney elected, Republicans hold House, Republicans take Senate.
  • Obama’s still reasonably popular but Democrats aren’t: Obama re-elected, Republicans hold House, Republicans take Senate.
  • It’s 2008 all over again: Obama re-elected, Democrats take House, Democrats hold Senate.
  • Anti-incumbent fervor sweeps nation: Romney elected, Democrats take House, Republicans take Senate.

There’s one more possibility but I think it’s very unlikely so I didn’t include it above. How do you see the potential outcomes in November?

68 comments

Unchanged

The number of new unemployment claims this week came in at 370,000, below the economists’ expectations of 365,000. It’s unchanged:

New U.S. claims for unemployment benefits were unchanged last week, according to government data on Thursday that will do little to ease concerns about a recent slowdown in jobs growth.

Initial claims for state unemployment benefits held steady at a seasonally adjusted 370,000, the Labor Department said.

The prior week’s figure was revised up to 370,000 from the previously reported 367,000.

Economists polled by Reuters had forecast claims falling to 365,000 last week. The four-week moving average for new claims, considered a better measure of labor market trends, fell 4,750 to 375,000.

“We are really not showing much momentum in the labor market at this time,” said Sean Incremona, an economist at 4Cast in New York.

Unchanged sounds pretty good but, actually, it’s horrible. Anybody who tries to portray it as anything else should be ashamed of themselves.

See here for some perspective on where we are relative to where we should be.

4 comments