The Widening Gap

Here’s an empirical illustration of how the two major political parties have diverged over the last forty years. The graph above, from Americans for Democratic Action, shows how their ratings for members of the House and Senate have changed over the years.

17 comments

The Vitality

The section of Orff’s Carmina Burana in the previous post got me thinking about something I haven’t thought about for a long time. The Carmina Burana is a collection of 200 some odd songs, poems, and plays from the 11th to 13th centuries that were discovered in manuscript in a German monastery in the first decade of the 19th century. They’re satirical, sometimes scatological, sometimes obscene, common themes being the corruption of the Church, wine, women, and song. They’re written in Medieval Latin, Old German, Old French, sometimes in combination (macaronics) with a smattering of other Western European languages.

Here are the first several lines of the O, Fortuna section in the original Latin:

O Fortuna
velut luna
statu variabilis,
semper crescis
aut decrescis;
vita detestabilis
nunc obdurat
et tunc curat
ludo mentis aciem,
egestatem,
potestatem
dissolvit ut glaciem.

Even if you don’t know Latin there are some things that are pretty obvious about this. First, it’s written in trochaic dimeter. That means two “feet” per line, each foot containing two syllables with the stress on the first syllable. Here’s an example you should recognize of that meter:

Bubble, bubble,
Toil and trouble.
Fire, burn!
And cauldron bubble.

It’s actually a little more complicated than that with triplets, two lines of trochaic dimeter followed by a single line of trochaic trimeter. And, importantly, it rhymes.

Compare that with the opening of the Lay of Hildebrand, one of the earliest works of German literature:

Ik gihorta ðat seggen
ðat sih urhettun ænon muotin
Hiltibrant enti Haðubrant untar heriun tuem
sunufatarungo iro saro rihtun
garutun se iro guðhamun gurtun sih iro suert ana
helidos ubar hringa do sie to dero hiltiu ritun

The Lay dates from, probably, the 7th or 8th century.

The language is peculiar. It’s written in a combination of Old Bavarian and Old Saxon, understandable since it was found in a German monastery founded by Anglo-Saxon monks. However, look at the versification. It’s constructed along very different lines from the verse of the Carmina although the latter was composed only a few hundred years later. It’s alliterative verse like Beowulf or the Norse Eddas. The earliest poem in Old English that rhymes is the Rhyming Poem in the 10th century. A rhymed version of the gospels was written by Otfried of Weissenburg in the 9th century.

Pretty clearly something happened to induce such a transition. In my opinion what happened was contact with Arab culture.

From approximately the 8th century through roughly the 10th century Arab culture was the most energetic, vital, and influential culture in the world. Like the Roman culture from, say, the 1st century through the 3rd century and the Chinese culture in the 5th through 8th centuries, Arab culture influenced art, literature, cooking, manners, and, as in this case, poetry.

In its turn something happened to Arab culture: invaders from Central Asia, initially the Turks but the final nail was hammered by the Mongols under a grandson of Temujin’s. Arab culture changed from being vital, rational, ethical, and expansive to pessimistic, repressive, and dogmatic.

However, I think it’s important to consider that the influence of Arab culture wasn’t just the hard power of military and economic might but soft power as well. It was attractive, energetic, and vital.

2 comments

Carmina Burana for non-Latin Speakers

For those of you who’ve been wondering about the words to the famous O, Fortuna section of Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana.

Here are the actual words in English translation:

O Fortune,
just like the moon
thou art variable,
always dost thou
wax and wane.
Detestable life,
first dost thou mistreat us,
and then, whimsically,
thou heedest our desires.
As the sun melts the ice,
so dost thou dissolve
both poverty and power.

Monstrous
and empty fate,
thou, turning wheel,
art mean,
voiding
good health at thy will.
Veiled
in obscurity,
thou dost attack
me also.
To thy cruel pleasure
I bare my back.

Thou dost withdraw
my health and virtue;
thou dost threaten
my emotion
and weakness
with torture.
At this hour,
therefore, let us
pluck the strings without
delay.
Let us mourn together,
for fate crushes the brave

Seems somehow appropriate. And the animation above provides the final lagniappe.

1 comment

Growth Through Attrition

Well, this is interesting. Last quarter corporate profits declined for the first time since the recession ended in 2009:

Corporate profits declined last quarter, ticking down by $6.4 billion or 0.3 percent in seasonally adjusted annual terms. A small decline, yes, but it was also the first decline since the fourth quarter of 2008, when the great recession was still raging.

My explanation for what’s been happening with the U. S. economy over the period of the last twenty or so years goes something like this. Once any organization reaches a certain size it becomes a bureaucracy. Governments. Companies. Hospitals. Churches. You name it. It is the nature of bureaucracies to grow. It is the iron law of bureaucracy.

Bolstered by two consecutive bubbles (first the dot-com bubble then the housing bubble) that concealed the problems we were having under a blanket of credit-driven increases in retail sales, companies were feeling pretty cozy. They did what bureaucracies do: they added employees. Many of these employees had little or nothing to do with the nominal mission statements of the companies that employed them. They were what Tyler Cowen calls “zero productivity employees” and what Jerry Pournelle calls “dedicated to the organization itself”.

When the housing bubble collapsed companies hunkered down in survival mode. They cut employees. They didn’t replace employees that left. I think that many companies over-reacted to a very frightening set of circumstances unlike anything anyone working there had ever experienced before.

Profits increased. That’s what happens when you cut expenses that don’t contribute to marginal productivity.

However, there’s something else that I think is an iron law: no company ever cost-reduced itself to greatness. You can cut costs to increase profits but you can’t cut costs to grow. We may have reached that point.

Or we may just be going into recession again.

7 comments

Healthcare Myths

You might want to take a look at this post on myths about our healthcare system. It succeeds in goring just about anybody’s ox. Here are the “myths” he lists:

  • Healthcare prices have soared in the recent past

    Despite the hand-waving he engages in he’s right about this. Healthcare spending is soaring. Healthcare prices soared in the 1970s. Now they’re generally rising at the rate of inflation which is hardly an endorsement.

    This may sound contradictory but it’s not. In a fee for service system which is what we have spending isn’t determined just by prices but by the number of procedures performed as well. More procedures, more spending.

  • The pre-ObamaCare system was ‘insurance’

    He’s right about this one, too. The system we had and the system we have is a prepaid, subsidized maintenance program. No such plan is sustainable in the absence of a ceiling on spending whether it’s for a typewriter, a computer, a car, or anything else.

  • Stopping insurance companies from charging based on pre-existing conditions is the one good part of ObamaCare

    Essentially, it throws the fiction that what we have is an insurance plan overboard.

  • Healthcare costs are very high in the United States compared to socialized countries

    He does an enormous amount of hand-waving here and I think he’s wrong on this one. Healthcare here is more expensive than practically anywhere else in the world and by a significant margin. In Switzerland (the country with the next highest level of per capita spending) median PPP wages are higher than they are here and they still spend signficantly less. IMO the features of the ACA intended to control costs are mostly just wishful thinking.

Worth a glance.

13 comments

The Law of the Land

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act is now the undisputed law of the land following yesterday’s Supreme Court decision narrowly upholding the Congress’s power to impose a mandate to purchase healthcare insurance under its taxation powers while more broadly rejecting the Congress’s ability to punish states that reject the expansion of the Medicaid burden that the law would impose on them. Some progressives have sniped derisively at “Tea Party governors” who would refuse to accept the expansion of Medicaid for which the PPACA provides. I strongly suspect that they will be very surprised and dismayed at the Democratic governors who do so. The states have fiscal problems enough without accepting significantly more of an expense that rises faster than their revenues do.

Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the House of Representatives when the PPACA was enacted, famously remarked that we would need to wait until the law was enacted to learn what was in it. If only that were the case! As I pointed out yesterday enough of the law will be promulgated in the form of regulations many of which have not been written yet and some of which won’t be written until after the law goes into effect fully in 2014 that nobody can really say what’s in it. The best we can say is “we’ll see”.

When we do know what’s in it, I suspect that more people will come to the conclusion I did when the law was enacted: it’s simultaneously excessive and inadequate. It doesn’t result in everybody having healthcare insurance, it retains multiple, competing healthcare systems, it doesn’t slow the increase in costs let alone reduce them as I believe we need to do, and it expands the bureaucratization of an already too bureaucratic healthcare system.

But we’ll see.

13 comments

The Verdict

Well, I was wrong. The Supreme Court has voted 5-4 to uphold the PPACA:

June 28, 2012 (WASHINGTON) — The Supreme Court has upheld the individual insurance requirement at the heart of President Barack Obama’s health care overhaul.

The court on Thursday handed Obama a campaign-season victory in rejecting arguments that Congress went too far in requiring most Americans to have health insurance or pay a penalty.

The entire ACA is upheld, with the exception that the federal government’s power to terminate states’ Medicaid funds is narrowly read.

The White House must be very pleased. Relieved.

What I expect going forward is that, barring its repeal by a future Congress, the workings of the ACA will be allowed to play out. The law will not be expanded for the foreseeable future. A few more people but not everybody will have healthcare coverage. Due to the Medicaid portion of the decision the additional number covered will not be as many as projected. Healthcare costs will continue to rise at a rate sufficient for healthcare to remain the primary driver in the increasing cost of living.

151 comments

Bureaucratic Choice

There are several things that made me uncomfortable with Daniel Henninger’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal this morning. For one thing I think he’s wrong in his central premise:

Electronics, foods, fashion, entertainment, apps, social media, appliances—pretty much anything that escapes the cold hands of a public agency is laid before us in a dazzling, unprecedented array of choices. Despite all the incoming, people learned to navigate the options. Virtually everyone has become adept at customizing a personal milieu that suits them. Given a reasonably growing economy, they’ll be able to sustain these choices.

In this context, the Affordable Care Act gave new meaning to the word “outlier.” Starting with the insurance mandate. Of course most people hated it. They’re living in a world turning more anti-mandate by the minute, and the Democrats are ordering them all into a national health-insurance pool.

Back in 2010, some Democrats talked like it was 1937 all over again. They intoned how for 70 years they’ve wanted to enact a big national health-care law. The Depression—those were the glory days. Or they said ObamaCare’s coverage-for-all would close the policy loop left open 45 years ago with Medicare for the elderly and Medicaid for the poor. So naturally one pillar of the Obama health-care law was to push more people into Medicaid’s already faceless, frightening maw.

There is plenty of choice, a plethora of choice, indeed, an overabundance of choice in the PPACA. It’s just not consumer choice. It’s bureaucratic discretion.

A report issued in 2010 on the regulatory impact of the PPACA lists approximately fifty places in the legislation that calls for the Secretary of HHS to promulgate, isssue, or formulate regulations on a fixed or indefinite schedule. Each of these would potentially involve multiple individual regulations. I’ve mentioned it here before but that reminds me of the “I’ll fill the rest in later, sir” scene in M*A*S*H. Contra Mr. Henninger, I wish the law were much more monolithic. At least people would know what they’re contending with.

His formulation makes me uncomfortable in another way, too. Isn’t there a difference between cellphones and healthcare? The best cellphone for your purposes is certainly a matter of your opinion. If you think it’s the best cellphone for your purposes, it is. Formulating the healthcare debate as one in which the problem is that there aren’t enough choices not only flies in the face of the basic structure of our entire healthcare system, it promotes the damaging fiction that the problem is with care and not health.

Quite to the contrary, the problem with our healthcare system as it has evolved is that it is almost entirely about care and insufficiently about health.

4 comments

Predictions Are Hard, Part II

Brad DeLong takes an odd sort of victory lap:

On all of these issues, historically-minded economists were right. Those who said that there would be no downturn, or that recovery would be rapid, or that the economy’s real problems were structural, or that supporting the economy would produce inflation (or high short-term interest rates), or that immediate fiscal austerity would be expansionary were wrong. Not just a little wrong. Completely wrong.

Of course, we historically-minded economists are not surprised that they were wrong. We are, however, surprised at how few of them have marked their beliefs to market in any sense. On the contrary, many of them, their reputations under water, have doubled down on those beliefs, apparently in the hope that events will, for once, break their way, and that people might thus be induced to forget their abysmal forecasting track record.

So the big lesson is simple: trust those who work in the tradition of Walter Bagehot, Hyman Minsky, and Charles Kindleberger. That means trusting economists like Paul Krugman, Paul Romer, Gary Gorton, Carmen Reinhart, Ken Rogoff, Raghuram Rajan, Larry Summers, Barry Eichengreen, Olivier Blanchard, and their peers. Just as they got the recent past right, so they are the ones most likely to get the distribution of possible futures right.

Which of Paul Krugman’s conflicting predictions were right? He makes a lot of predictions. How can you determine before the fact which one will be right?

My view of Dr. Krugman is that when he speaks as an economist he’s frequently, maybe generally, right but that when he speaks as a columnist and on matters of politics and policy he has a sort of reverse infallibility: he’s practically always wrong.

Dr. DeLong goes on to list some of the things that have surprised him during the downturn and its aftermath. Read the whole thing.

The single thing that has surprised me the most among economists over the period of the last five years is that they have failed to realize that bubbles don’t just inflate asset prices, they inflate wages, too. That further implies that lack of flexibility in lowering wages as the air is let out of the bubble will induce unemployment and varying inflexibility among different sectors of the economy will induce distortions.

3 comments

Predictions Are Hard

In my earlier post this week I outlined what I thought were the most likely outcomes of the Supreme Court’s verdict on the constitutionality of the PPACA AKA “ObamaCare”. Obviously, I have no idea what that verdict will be. If I had to make a WAG, I think the Court will vote 5-4 to invalidate Title 1 of the law, the portion dealing with private insurance.

I think the decision will be complex with multiple differing concurrences and dissents.

To my mind the second most likely outcome is for the law to be upheld completely 6-3.

4 comments