Aligning the Incentives

Fareed Zakaria neatly explains the problem with the healthcare reform that is now the law of the land:

Most Americans have health care. What they worry about is the cost of insuring 20 million to 30 million more people. Unless the meteoric rise of health-care costs is slowed, a big expansion of coverage might well remain unpopular, no matter how it is explained.

but then continues as though there were a method of allocating the scarce resource, i.e. healthcare, other than by market or by fiat:

Republican alternatives to Obamacare, such as Rep. Paul Ryan’s plan, don’t bother with expanding coverage, which is a mistake because they leave in place a broken insurance model in which people can freeload. But most do have a strategy to control costs — get consumers to pay for more of their health care. The basic idea is intuitively appealing. Markets produce efficiencies; they presumably would do the same thing in health care.

But the situation on the ground suggests that markets work imperfectly in this realm. A new study conducted by the pharmaceutical company Novartis and McKinsey and Co. shows a stunning difference among countries with regard to health-care efficiency.

citing the examples of the United Kingdom and France. The problem with this is that healthcare costs are rising at an unaffordably rapid rate in the United Kingdom and France, too. Any fiat system however well-intentioned will inevitably result in misallocation, less healthcare, and less total happiness. The problem with a market system is that in the case of healthcare the best that can be done is not good enough. We constrain the supply because we are concerned about the quality of care. As long as that’s the case (and I don’t recommend doing otherwise) there is no market system to defend.

The choice, then, is among a variety of sub-optimal fiat systems. Claiming otherwise is a lie.

I continue to believe that the problems with the U. S. healthcare system will only get worse until the incentives are properly aligned with what we’re trying to accomplish. As long as the incentives call for care rather than health, care we will get. Even if it doesn’t make us healthier. Even if it accomplishes nothing other than to increase the costs.

6 comments

A Very Feis Fourth

Today we skipped the annual Sauaganash Fourth of July Parade (you can look in the archives for prior years—it’s always fun) and attended the 2012 North American Irish Dancing competition held downtown in Chicago. My wife’s great-niece had flown in from Los Angeles to compete and we wanted to be there to cheer her on.

I’d never attended a competition of this sort or feis (pronounced, roughly, “fesh” and presumably cognate with feast or fête) so I thought it would be fun.

If you ever attend an Irish dance competition the first thing you’ll notice: wigs. It’s customary for the female competitors to wear wigs when they dance and you’ll see more of them at a feis than at a Dolly Parton impersonators’ convention. All of the wigs have ringlets and two styles appear to be worn. One style is an up-do, essentially a mound of curls on the top of the head and the other is down, anything from shoulder length to reaching the middle of the back. I don’t honestly believe that any human being every had actual hair like this. There’s a certain aspect of fantasy in it.

The second thing you will notice: legs. The (mostly) young women who compete have legs that are toned, depilated, spray-tanned, buffed, and burnished to within an inch of their lives. Among the competitors you will find no cellulite.

The costumes in which they compete are also notable. They are quite beautiful and, I am told, expensive, mostly handmade. They consist of a single piece, a tight fitting bodice, generally highly beaded or sequinned with long sleeves and a short (short), flounced skirt. I was also told that you could date the outfits based on skirt style. Older outfits have a frillier style.

The competition made me feel a bit like Degas. I’ve attended (and participated in) a lot of athletic competitions but this is the first I’ve ever attended in which competitors donned their competing togs in the viewing area. I suspect that’s because of how expensive they are—they want to wear them only when competing to preserve them. When waiting to compete dancers wear T-shirts and shorts. When it’s time to compete the dancers put their outfits on over the T-shirts, then remove their shorts under which they’re wearing undergarments that match the outfits. It’s very matter-of-fact; there’s nothing titillating about it.

The dancing is, of course, Irish step-dancing. You know, the kind of dancing in which, ideally, the dancers are completely immobile from the waist up, only their feet and legs moving. Tapping, stepping, kicking, remarkably graceful, incredibly fast. The dancing was accompanied by a piano player and an accordionist/concertinist.

There were two different styles of dance: hard shoe and soft shoe. Hard shoes had a slight heel with hard sole and heel. Soft shoes were a bit like ballet slippers.

There were dancers there from the U. S., Canada, Australia, Eire, and England. There might have been dancers there from Mexico although I didn’t see any in the program. That’s another thing I noticed: it was the dancing that was Irish rather than the dancers although dancers obviously of Irish ancestry were clearly in evidence.

My wife’s great-niece performed beautifully. She has a wonderful combination of athleticism and grace, not surprising when you consider how athletic my wife’s family is. We won’t know how she did until quite late tonight.

9 comments

Timing Is Everything

I see that Deutsche Bank is beginning to look nervously at its watch as the minutes tick by on the U. S. economic recovery, now officially three years old. I wonder where they got the average figure of 39 months? According to the official scorekeeper the average for all of U. S. history is 42 months. It’s interesting that they should be looking at the entire 158 year history, rather than the post-war average of 59 months.

We’re now entering the period during which the scientists at the Bureau of Economic Analysis delicately strike a balance between destroying their credibility with ridiculous reports and influencing the presidential election. It will be interesting.

10 comments

The Impossible Dream

Do you think it is possible for the U. S. to reduce its carbon emissions from energy production to the levels it produced in 1990? Why, yes it is and it may well happen this year:

For US energy-related carbon emissions, fuel switching to gas is back to the future. After the first quarter, the USA’s 2012 emissions are falling sharply again and may drop to 1990 levels, or just slightly above that important milestone, according to data in EIA’s latest Monthy Energy Review.
eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec12_3.pdf.

America’s energy related carbon emissions fell about 7.5%, during the first three months of 2012 compared to the same period of 2011. And first quarter 2012 emissions are approximately 8.5% lower than emissions in the first quarter of 2010.

Total energy carbon emissions were 5,473 million tons in 2011 and last year fell below the 1996 mark of 5,501 million tons.

The first quarter 2012 reduction of 7.5% makes it possible that this year emissions will fall back essentially to the 1990 level of 5,039 million tons. That is shockingly good news.

The 1990 level of carbon emissions is an important measuring stick, as it is often used as a critical data point for judging progress in reducing a nation’s carbon emissions.

And that’s with a population that’s 25% larger than ours was in 1990.

If reducing carbon emissions is of concern to you, you should be rejoicing at this news. The big hurdle is, as it has always been, transportation.

Hat tip: Mark Perry

6 comments

A Taxonomy of Ideas

Some of my earliest posts around here were taxonomies. I wrote an early multi-part taxonomy on positions on the Iraq War—that was back when Matt Yglesias, Kevin Drum, and Josh Marshall all supported it. I like this taxonomy of ideas (hat tip: Barry Ritholtz).

Using that taxonomy here’s how I would rate some political decisions:

PPACA:  Half-baked
Invasion of Afghanistan:  Half-baked
Invasion of Iraq:  Terrible
Balance of powers:  Smart

 

and some technologies

Microsoft Windows:  Half-baked
Apple Mac:  Neat
Xerox Star:  Clever
Toyota Prius:  Interesting
Chevy Volt:  Dumb
Autarky:  Sh*t
Comparative advantage:  Incredible
Lysenkoism:  The Worst
Selective breeding:  Smart
Direct current:  Good
Alternating current:  Genius

 

I can’t think of any political ideas by anybody I’d put in the “Genius” category. Maybe that’s just familiarity. I can think of so many I’d put in “The Worst” category it isn’t even worthwhile starting.

I welcome your own nominees in comments.

7 comments

Lost Skill

In wandering out today I stumbled across an old Wall Street Journal op-ed that has transmogrified into a new book. The thesis of both is that the claim of a skills mismatch is bogus and the key problem is with employers. Either they have unrealistically low expectations of what they’ll need to pay for specific skillsets or they’ve just forgotten how to hire and train employees. Here’s the nub:

Some of the complaints about skill shortages boil down to the fact that employers can’t get candidates to accept jobs at the wages offered. That’s an affordability problem, not a skill shortage. A real shortage means not being able to find appropriate candidates at market-clearing wages. We wouldn’t say there is a shortage of diamonds when they are incredibly expensive; we can buy all we want at the prevailing prices.

The real problem, then, is more appropriately an inflexibility problem. Finding candidates to fit jobs is not like finding pistons to fit engines, where the requirements are precise and can’t be varied. Jobs can be organized in many different ways so that candidates who have very different credentials can do them successfully.

To my ear this has something of a ring of truth.

4 comments

This Time Is Different

Since the Supreme Court issued its decision last week, I’ve been following the commentary on the PPACA AKA “ObamaCare” in the new media and various and sundry blogs on all sides of the political spectrum pretty closely. All sorts of people from Joe Klein to the editors of Bloomberg have been offering their ideas on how to fix the law, something that would have been handy several years ago. A couple of things have struck me.

Have you noticed that nobody is really enthusiastic about the law? For some it’s an ugly but necessary first step, for many a false step, and for some, apparently, the last straw. But I have yet to find anyone who sees it as an optimal first step. I guess some would say that’s what happens with laws in the United States: necessarily, they are compromises. I don’t see the PPACA so much as a compromise as a Rube Goldberg. I considered using other, less polite characterizations but this is a family blog. Engineers in the audience will probably know what I mean.

The other thing that struck me and that I’ve mentioned from time to time is that the law is a technocrat’s fantasy of how government works in the United States: you revisit and tinker and adjust and fine tune and modify until you get something that works. We’ve never done that before but, apparently, they think we’re going to do that now. I honestly don’t understand how anyone could have applied for a drivers license, gotten a building permit, or done their own income tax and still believe that.

13 comments

Graph of the Day

The graph of the day is here at ZeroHedge. Go on over and take a look at it.

The graph illustrates the deviation of the unemployment rate from average by state over the period of the last 36 years, since 1976.

There’s a lot of information there presented in a very compact format and, frankly, it’s hard to digest. I strongly suspect that this illustrates what is likely to drive American politics today and for some time to come.

20 comments

Handy Summary

Scott Sumner neatly summarizes the American political scene:

As the core of the GOP moves south, it becomes more like a European-style conservative party—pro-big government, pro-cartels and regs that favor affluent people, and culturally conservative. Unfortunately our political system has no place for pro-free market and socially liberal people. The kind that read The Economist magazine. So they end up as independents.

Or, if they live in Chicago, they’re Democrats.

The provisos I’d put on Dr. Sumner’s assessment is that European-style conservative parties aren’t rightwing parties at least as we reckon things and they cover a much broader political spectrum than the Republican Party does. The German Christian Democratic Union, for example, is a conservative, center-right party.

However, there’s my conventional caveat: comparing politics across national boundaries is approximate at best. By some reckonings the U. S. Democratic Party is a European-style conservative party.

4 comments

Increase the Death Rate!

Well, here’s a contrarian view. The world’s population problem isn’t that the birth rate is too high; it’s that the death rate is too low:

Infants and small children consume without producing, but they are the very people who will provide the productive adults of the future who will build their communities, their nations, and the world. They represent future production that can vastly outweigh their current consumption. Yes, a minority will die before they can produce, but the majority will far out-weigh them in impact.

Adults over 65 are different. Either voluntarily or out of sheer necessity, they cease to produce, but they do not cease to consume. In fact, their consumption of many resources (that is what the fuss is all about), notably health care, can increase dramatically. Yes, a minority may successfully return to production, but the majority will far out-weigh them in impact.

I read a great deal about the “impossibility” of supporting the consumption of essential resources by a larger global population, but I do not see anyone who provides a comparison of the current and future impact of a 5-year-old child with the current and future impact of 65-year old adult. They persist in either saying or implying that the problem lies at one end of the human lifespan. They have it upside-down. They’re looking at the wrong end.

Lots of interesting graphs that may challenge some of your preconceived notions.

Update

The more I thought about this the more I recognized the profoundly pessimistic and, I think, perverse school of thought in the world today. We should rejoice when a baby is born, someone lives to an advanced age, or the cure to a deadly disease is found not the other way around.

12 comments