Read It and Weep

While we’re talking about public education you might want to take a gander at this report from the NEA. It has all sorts of interesting facts and figures. For example, I wasn’t aware that new school enrollments had, basically, fallen through the floor in 2006, i.e. very little change in enrollment. School spending has not, unfortunately, similarly remained the same. You’ve got to wonder about the relationship between that statistic and the healthcare spending statistics.

Now, guess which state is dead last in the state’s contribution to K-12 education? You guessed it: Illinois. Illinois has per capita state taxes right around the median (within one standard deviation—that doesn’t take into account the whopping increase in the state income tax enacted in 2011 and which expires soon) and is dead last in the state’s percentage contribution to K-12 education. Much, much lower than Mississippi or Louisiana or any of the usual suspects. Riddle me that.

0 comments

Overheard on Public Radio

On WBEZ’s afternoon talk program from one of the announcers: “Rahm Emanuel doesn’t know how to handle people.” Which is a conclusion I came to long ago. Too bad more people didn’t realize it before he got elected mayor.

7 comments

Whose Ox Gets Gored?

Dovetailing neatly with my post earlier today, this Wall Street Journal editorial adds an additional wrinkle to the discussion of the Chicago Public Schools:

Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel may have thought he bought labor peace when he agreed to a fat increase in teacher pay to settle a strike last year. Instead the Chicago Teachers Union is throwing massive resistance against his plan to close 54 under-used public schools.

The closings are part of the city’s attempt to address a budget gap projected to be $1 billion next year thanks to years of fiscal mismanagement. Annual pension payments for Chicago teachers will rise to $593.3 million from $218.6 million by 2016, and the city has to finance that 16% teacher pay raise over four years. Chicago Schools CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett says closing the 54 schools that are operating at less than 69% capacity will save some $43 million in operating costs next year and $560 million in capital costs over 10 years.

[…]

The real racial offense is leaving another generation of black children to languish in some of the nation’s worst schools, with a high school graduation rate near 60%. Chicago’s black population dropped by 181,000 between 2000 and 2010, and much of that decline is on the South and West sides. The Chicago Public School system now has only about 400,000 students despite a capacity for 500,000.

Ms. Lewis’s real fear is that closing those schools will expedite student migration to non-union charter schools. There are currently 119 charters operating in the city and serving some 40,000 Chicago students. Last year the charter waiting list was more than 19,000, one of the longest in the country.

In Chicago, two-thirds of charter schools perform better on state assessment tests and at charter high schools three-quarters of graduates go to college. A recent poll by the Joyce Foundation and Chicago Tribune found that about two-thirds of Chicagoans support new charters opening in neighborhoods where kids are on the waiting list and 67.9% say it should be easier for charters to expand.

Charters also save the city money. State law says charters may get between 75% and 125% of per pupil spending in the district. But in practice most get an average of 78% what Chicago spends per pupil on traditional public schools, according to the Illinois Network of Charter Schools.

The CTU’s position paper on school closings, their disproportionate effect on black students, and charter schools is here.

I continue to wonder where the CTU proposes that Chicago will get the money it needs to follow the CTU’s prescriptions for Chicago schools.

6 comments

Everything You Know Is Wrong

I think I can sum up most of what PIMCO’s Bill Gross says in his latest “Investment Outlook” in just one sentence: don’t confuse genius with a bull market.

To explain his remarks in slightly greater depth, imagine that we’re coming to the end of an era of easy economic growth and easy investment that has propelled the economy and built enormous fortunes over the last nearly 70 years. If that’s the case, then all of the experience and judgment and acumen of the Masters of the Universe, the Warren Buffetts, Bill Grosses, and George Soroses of the world, may have become meaningless, irrelevant.

What if the credit-fueled economy, whether the credit is personal, corporate, or governmental, is at an end and we’re entering “a new epoch”?

Ah, now, that would be a test of greatness: the ability to adapt to a new epoch. The problem with the Buffetts, the Fusses, the Granthams, the Marks, the Dalios, the Gabellis, the Coopermans, and the Grosses of the world is that they’ll likely never find out. Epochs can and likely will outlast them. But then one never knows what time has in store for each of us, or what any of us will do in the spans of time.

What I do know, is that, like Michael Jackson sang in his brilliant, but all too short lifetime, I am and will continue to look at the man in the mirror. PIMCO, Gross, El-Erian? – yes, we’re lookin’ good – in this epoch. If there’s a different one coming though, to make our and your world a better place, we might need to look in the mirror and make a Chaaaaaaaange … Depends on what we see, I suppose. We will keep you informed.

None of those guys will be hurt if we’ve begun that new epoch. They’re too rich and too old for it to make much difference to them. What about the rest of us?

4 comments

Disproportionate Representation

I found one very interesting fact in Campbell Brown’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal on the Obama Administration’s ambiguous message on gun violence:

Almost a third of the $1 million-plus donors to the president’s Super PAC were entertainment and media heavyweights including producers Jeffrey Katzenberg and Steven Spielberg. In one Obama fundraiser alone, held at the home of George Clooney, the campaign brought in an estimated $15 million.

Most of the attention on the president’s political contributions goes to the large number of small donors. Less goes to the reality that the majority of his donations comes from large donors (more like two-thirds in 2007).

Entertainment and media are actually a very tiny part of the U. S. economy: roughly 3%. But that 3% is enormously dependent on government subsidies.

I am not alleging that the “entertainment and media heavyweights” who have contributed so heavily to the president’s campaigns and to his PAC are doing so for personal gain. Those contributions do, however, represent a wonderful confluence of interests.

2 comments

How Do We Improve Public Education?

In an op-ed at the Washington Post, Microsoft co-founder and philanthropist Bill Gates proposes student test results as just one of the factors used in evaluating teachers:

While there is justification for rewarding teachers based in part on how their students perform, compensation systems should use multiple measures, including classroom observation. In top-performing education systems in other parts of the world, such as Singapore and Shanghai, accomplished teachers earn more by taking on additional responsibilities such as coaching and mentoring other teachers and helping to capture and spread effective teaching techniques. Such systems are a way to attract, retain and reward the best teachers; make great use of their skills; and honor the collaborative nature of work in schools.

States, districts and the U.S. Education Department would do well to encourage the right balance. States such as Connecticut, Delaware and Kentucky are showing leadership in creating feedback and evaluation systems that reflect the patience and involvement of teachers and administrators. This is what’s required to build the kind of infrastructure that stands the test of time.

Does any school district in the country disagree with that? I only know of one group of organizations that opposes anything other than seniority and education as the basis for determining compensation: teachers’ unions.

As an experiment I went over to the site of the Chicago Teachers Union to see what the bargaining organization for Chicago’s teachers wanted to do. There is significantly more attention there to what they oppose than to what they support. They’re opposed to closing schools, standardized tests, and merit pay. They’re in favor of smaller class sizes which is another way of saying “hiring more teachers”.

If Chicago’s teachers wish to be treated as professionals, behaving professionally might be a good start. One of the hallmarks of professionals is that professionals have a heightened level of responsibility for determining the standards of their profession than, say, truck drivers, do. I would very much like to see what Chicago’s teachers want to do to improve the Chicago Public Schools. You won’t find much on the CTU site.

The scholarship on class size is actually pretty ambiguous. The general finding is that a class size of 15 is better than one of 40. There has been no proof that a class size of 29 is better than a class size of 30.

Chicago is not going to double the number of teachers employed by the CPS. It simply doesn’t have the money—the city can’t even pay the bills it already has. It is either naive or disingenuous to identify increasing tax rates with increasing tax revenues. It looks very much as though Chicago has reached its limit load with respect to revenues. The state of Illinois is in even worse shape.

When the teachers struck successfully for higher pay, the clear implication was that schools would be closed and the total number of teachers reduced.

10 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Tally at 15

Today is Tally’s 15th birthday. We’re grateful to still have her with us. This day has crept up on us unexpectedly and all too soon. She’s slowing down. She has aches and pains (don’t we all?). Her sight and sense of smell are failing. She continues to love life and still enjoys doing the things she loves the most: chasing a ball and simply being outdoors. She would be out-of-doors 100% of the time if we allowed it.

Tally has lived longer than her parents, her grandparents, or her littermate. To the best of my knowledge she has lived longer than any of her full or half siblings or cousins. I attribute her longevity to good genes, good luck, our vigilance and attentiveness to her health, the excellent veterinary care she has received from her lifelong vet, Robbie Drell, and her own indomitable spirit.

Here’s another picture of her, this time inside.

Tally at 14½
Tally is 14
Tally at 13
Dog Picture of the Day
The Pack Plays Together
My Girls
Happy Birthday, Tally!
Dogsledding Chicago, 2007
Fall, 2006
A fall hike
Chicagoland Samoyed Club Summer Specialty Show, 2006
Our weekend away
Take your dog to Ben Pao
Chicagoland Samoyed Club 2005 summer specialty show
Snow
Take your dog to dinner
Tally
From my front porch looking in

There are many more posts in which Tally is mentioned (you can search for them in the search bar at the bottom of the page on the right) but those are the ones with pictures. Her life summed up in blog posts.

9 comments

The Goldilocks Principle

I’m not as outraged as some people apparently are at the Obama Administration’s urging of banks to relax their standards for creditworthiness a bit:

The Obama administration is engaged in a broad push to make more home loans available to people with weaker credit, an effort that officials say will help power the economic recovery but that skeptics say could open the door to the risky lending that caused the housing crash in the first place.

President Obama’s economic advisers and outside experts say the nation’s much-celebrated housing rebound is leaving too many people behind, including young people looking to buy their first homes and individuals with credit records weakened by the recession.

If you want to read some of the squeals of outrage, memeorandum has a pretty good sampling.

I think what’s being missed is that by practically every account credit requirements now are significantly higher than they were in 2006. Would even the slightest relaxing of them mean a return to the bad old days? Isn’t it just barely possible that the banks have overcompensated?

I don’t think it’s reasonable to consider bank policy without taking into account the enormous subsidies that the large banks have received over the period of the last half dozen years. I strongly suspect that banks’ high credit requirements now are a consequence of those subsidies. Risk/reward.

I think it’s possible that, if the credit requirements in 2006 were too hot, those today are too cold. Judging by the state of the economy they’re certainly not just right.

30 comments

The Modern Star Chamber?

I haven’t really followed the sad case of Aaron Swartz particularly closely. For those of you who have been following it even less closely, Mr. Swartz was a computer programmer, one of the founders of the social news site Reddit, and involved in developing RSS, the protocol by which many of you are probably reading this post. He was also an intellectual property activist and his activities in that area lead to his arrest and prosecution for various crimes including breaking and entering, wire fraud, and other crimes stemming from his systematic downloading of academic journal articles from JSTOR. Early this year he took his own life. Some, including the legal scholar Lawrence Lessig, have claimed that he was hounded by the authorities to his death. You can read some of the details here.

Mr. Swartz’s lawyers haven’t given up:

The U.S. Attorney’s Office is fighting to keep the names of those involved in the federal prosecution against Internet activist Aaron Swartz under court seal, arguing prosecutors have been victims of hacking and death threats.

Threatening emails have been sent to U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz and prosecutor Stephen Heymann, according to court documents, which said Heymann’s Facebook account was hacked and Heymann’s father, a Harvard professor, received a postcard with his photo in a guillotine.

Glenn Reynolds calls this “the 21st century substitute for tar and feathers.” I can understand the reluctance of those involved in the prosecution to have their names made public but keeping them secret sounds uncomfortably like the Star Chamber to me.

2 comments