In an op-ed at the Washington Post, Microsoft co-founder and philanthropist Bill Gates proposes student test results as just one of the factors used in evaluating teachers:
While there is justification for rewarding teachers based in part on how their students perform, compensation systems should use multiple measures, including classroom observation. In top-performing education systems in other parts of the world, such as Singapore and Shanghai, accomplished teachers earn more by taking on additional responsibilities such as coaching and mentoring other teachers and helping to capture and spread effective teaching techniques. Such systems are a way to attract, retain and reward the best teachers; make great use of their skills; and honor the collaborative nature of work in schools.
States, districts and the U.S. Education Department would do well to encourage the right balance. States such as Connecticut, Delaware and Kentucky are showing leadership in creating feedback and evaluation systems that reflect the patience and involvement of teachers and administrators. This is what’s required to build the kind of infrastructure that stands the test of time.
Does any school district in the country disagree with that? I only know of one group of organizations that opposes anything other than seniority and education as the basis for determining compensation: teachers’ unions.
As an experiment I went over to the site of the Chicago Teachers Union to see what the bargaining organization for Chicago’s teachers wanted to do. There is significantly more attention there to what they oppose than to what they support. They’re opposed to closing schools, standardized tests, and merit pay. They’re in favor of smaller class sizes which is another way of saying “hiring more teachers”.
If Chicago’s teachers wish to be treated as professionals, behaving professionally might be a good start. One of the hallmarks of professionals is that professionals have a heightened level of responsibility for determining the standards of their profession than, say, truck drivers, do. I would very much like to see what Chicago’s teachers want to do to improve the Chicago Public Schools. You won’t find much on the CTU site.
The scholarship on class size is actually pretty ambiguous. The general finding is that a class size of 15 is better than one of 40. There has been no proof that a class size of 29 is better than a class size of 30.
Chicago is not going to double the number of teachers employed by the CPS. It simply doesn’t have the money—the city can’t even pay the bills it already has. It is either naive or disingenuous to identify increasing tax rates with increasing tax revenues. It looks very much as though Chicago has reached its limit load with respect to revenues. The state of Illinois is in even worse shape.
When the teachers struck successfully for higher pay, the clear implication was that schools would be closed and the total number of teachers reduced.