Portrait of a Failing Business Model

2012 revenues for U. S. newspapers were 2% lower than 2011 revenues:

Overall, total revenue for U.S. newspapers declined by 2% in 2012 from a year earlier, according to new data compiled by the Newspaper Association of America.

In total, the U.S. newspaper media industry took in $38.6 billion in 2012 compared with $39.5 billion in revenue in 2011, according to NAA’s projections.

The numbers reveal that while advertising revenue continues to decline—down 6% in 2012—several other categories of newspaper media revenue are now growing. Circulation revenue grew 5% in 2012, while a host of new revenue sources not tied to conventional advertising and that barely existed a few years ago grew by 8%. These new revenue sources, which include such items as digital consulting for local business and e-commerce transactions, now account for close to one-in-ten dollars coming into newspaper media companies. They are significant enough in scale that NAA has begun to collect detailed data about these revenue categories and track their trajectory year-to-year for the first time.

The new data offer a more granular and comprehensive picture of how newspaper media are operating today than was previously compiled by any source. This more complete accounting identifies approximately $6 billion in additional revenue, $3 billion that was not counted before and another $3 billion that did not exist a few years ago, comprising about 16% of all newspaper media revenue in 2012.

The numbers portray an industry that, faced with significant disruption in the last decade, has begun to measurably change its essential revenue model. That has begun by turning more to circulation, to digital, and to developing new revenue sources.

I think they’re whistling past a graveyard. Newspapers’ problems are not the Internet or, more accurately, they’re not merely the Internet. Newspaper revenues started declining sharply in 1987. That’s long time before the rise of the World Wide Web. The Internet as most people know it didn’t exist when newspapers began their slide. By 1992 newspaper revenues had fallen by 1/6th in real terms.

They recovered slightly right along with everything else during the boom of the 1990s. Since 2000 they’ve plummeted and are now roughly a third of what they used to be.

People turning to getting their news online, whether it’s from their computer screens or from their phones, is just part of newspapers’ problem. Add to that CNN and debt-financed consolidation in the newspaper industry along with the decline in local reporting accompanied by a decline in local advertising. And it’s not just the consolidation of the newspaper industry, either. It’s the consolidation of retail.

1 comment

The Explanation

I think that this sort of analysis:

Well, tenure-track positions in my field have about 150 applicants each. Multiply that 0.6 percent chance of getting any given job by the 10 or so appropriate positions in the entire world, and you have about that same 6 percent chance of “success.”

explains why they decided to get doctorates in literature in the first place.

5 comments

An Objective Without a Strategy

Writing in the Christian Science Monitor Kurt Cobb outlines several competing “ultimate goals” for U. S. energy policy:

Seek the cheapest price for energy with the implication that environmental consequences should not be tallied as part of the cost.
Complete a transition to renewable energy as quickly as possible while drastically reducing the burning of fossil fuels.
Replace all fossil fuel energy with nuclear power.
Develop all sources of energy to make sure we have enough at reasonable prices. This is often called the “all-of-the-above strategy.”

Goal 1 is really the argument put forth by the fossil fuel industry and therefore a defense of the status quo. Goal 2 is the dream of every climate change activist and clean-tech executive. Goal 3 seemed to be gaining some momentum before the accident at Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant dashed hopes for a widespread nuclear renaissance.

Goal 4 is the non-choice choice preferred by many mugwump Congressmen, including Kurt Cobb’s.

The problem I have with Goal 2 is that I see no practical strategy for accomplishing it. Any strategy that takes place in something other than geological time includes removing heavy manufacturing from the United States.

Heavy manufacturing wouldn’t just disappear. It would move to China where the environmental problems produced by heavy manufacturing would become intractable. What would that accomplish? It certainly wouldn’t do anything about climate change.

George Santayana once wisecracked that fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim. Goal #2 is a fine example of just that sort of fanaticism.

1 comment

The Elder

Yurok tribal elder Archie Thompson has died:

Archie Thompson, the oldest living member of California’s Yurok tribe and the last known active speaker raised in the tribal language, has died. He was 93.

Thompson died March 26 at a Crescent City, Calif., hospital after an apparent stroke, according to his daughter Sherry O’Rourke.

“It’s our language that truly gives us our identity as Yurok people,” said Thomas P. O’Rourke Sr., the tribal chairman and Thompson’s son-in-law. “He is very much responsible for preserving not just a way of life, but the identity of a people.”

Thompson was one of a handful of remaining full-blooded members of the Yurok tribe, which numbers nearly 6,000 members and is California’s largest.. He was also the last of about 20 elders who helped revitalize the language over the last few decades, after academics in the 1990s predicted it would be extinct by 2010.

He made recordings of the language that were archived by UC Berkeley linguists and the tribe, spent hours helping to teach Yurok in community and school classrooms, and welcomed apprentice speakers to probe his knowledge.

It paid off: A recent tally by the tribe’s language program indicated there are more than 300 basic Yurok speakers, 60 with intermediate skills, 37 who are advanced and 17 who are considered conversationally fluent.

Read the whole thing. An extraordinary individual.

0 comments

Riffing on Steven Taylor

In the past I’ve mentioned that there are a number of different reasons for blog posts. Likewise, blog posts, at least my blog posts, have a number of different sub-genres. The most common of these sub-genres for me is the newspaper column. In length, style, and tone, the newspaper column is a very natural one for me. Other sub-genres I have employed from time to time have been the journal article, the lament, and what this post will be: the riff. This time I’ll be riffing on a post of Steven Taylor’s over at OTB. I have no interest in Roger Simon’s post which Steven takes as his point of departure. I’ll just use Steven’s numbered points.

  1. Contrary, apparently, to Mr. Simon’s opinion of President Obama, I think that he is, unfortunately, the most successful president we’ve had in decades.
  2. I disagree that Americans are polarized. I think that they are sorted. The Congress is polarized.
  3. What is the trend in employment? Are we, as Steven contends, moving “in the right direction”? In my view and using the graph CR graph that Steven reproduces the trend I see is no trend. If anything, employment is trending downwards. Is that “the right direction”? Not to me. In a bit more nuanced analysis, I think that since about the second quarter of 2010 jobs have been increasing in a bounded fashion, between roughly 100,000 and 300,000. That is not the right direction. Characterizing that as “far more gradual than we would like” drastically understates the nature of the problem. At that rate, anybody who was over 50 when he or she lost his job and has been unemployed for more than 99 weeks will never be employed again. That’s wholly unacceptable.
  4. The United States of today is no more the United States of 50 years ago than the United States of 1963 was the United States of 1913. In some ways that’s a good thing. The most notable way in which that’s a good thing is that the United States of today is so much better if you’re black than it was 50 years ago there is really no comparison.

    However, there are some ways in which the United States of today is very much worse than it was 50 years ago and, sadly, I think those ways are very debilitating. The United States of today is much, much more bellicose than the United States of 50 years ago with practically no reason for being more bellicose. Fifty years ago there was a sort of boundless optimism here. That has, sadly, largely been replaced with a kind of facile, sophomoric cynicism.

    Fifty years ago, most people were reasonably confident that their kids’ lives would be better than their parents’ lives. Such confidence has very little basis now.

    Finally, the confidence in science and engineering that was so prevalent in the United States fifty years ago has been replaced by either know-nothingism or a sort of fetishism. I don’t think that bodes well for the future.

In conclusion, Steven comments on the primacy of structures in our political problems. I agree. Beyond here lie dragons. I would prefer a much more limited government of enumerated powers than we have today. I recognize that in such an environment there are some things that you might want very much to accomplish that simply cannot be accomplished.

The alternative is increasing tyranny and I suspect that’s the direction in which we’re heading.

22 comments

An Intellectual Turing Test

The moral of this story might be that you shouldn’t put a burr under the saddle of somebody with practically unlimited funds to get even with. While playing a golf round the president of Bowdoin and prospective donor Thomas Klingenstein had an argument about Bowdoin’s radical politics and fixation on divisive identity politics. Here’s what happened next:

After the essay appeared, President Mills stood by his version of events. A few months later, Mr. Klingenstein decided to do something surprising: He commissioned researchers to examine Bowdoin’s commitment to intellectual diversity, rigorous academics and civic identity. This week, some 18 months and hundreds of pages of documentation later, the project is complete. Its picture of Bowdoin isn’t pretty.

Funded by Mr. Klingenstein, researchers from the National Association of Scholars studied speeches by Bowdoin presidents and deans, formal statements of the college’s principles, official faculty reports and notes of faculty meetings, academic course lists and syllabi, books and articles by professors, the archive of the Bowdoin Orient newspaper and more. They analyzed the school’s history back to its founding in 1794, focusing on the past 45 years—during which, they argue, Bowdoin’s character changed dramatically for the worse.

Published Wednesday, the report demonstrates how Bowdoin has become an intellectual monoculture dedicated above all to identity politics.

Some facts that support the report’s findings:

One of the few requirements is that Bowdoin students take a yearlong freshman seminar. Some of the 37 seminars offered this year: “Affirmative Action and U.S. Society,” “Fictions of Freedom,” “Racism,” “Queer Gardens” (which “examines the work of gay and lesbian gardeners and traces how marginal identities find expression in specific garden spaces”), “Sexual Life of Colonialism” and “Modern Western Prostitutes.”

Regarding Bowdoin professors, the report estimates that “four or five out of approximately 182 full-time faculty members might be described as politically conservative.” In the 2012 election cycle, 100% of faculty donations went to President Obama. Not that any of this matters if you have ever asked around the faculty lounge.

I don’t know the truth of this dispute. But I do have a suggestion for resolving it. I propose a sort of intellectual Turing test. Bowdoin’s faculty should deputize one of their identifiably left-leaning faculty members and one of their few “politically conservative” members to produce written statements of the political views of the other side, stated as accurately and fairly as they can. In other words let the left-leaning faculty member write a statement of political principles using what he or she believes is the voice of people who take more “conservative” views and let the right-leaning faculty member write a statement using what he or she believes is the voice of someone with left-leaning politics. Publish the two statements and let the world decide.

I suspect it would probably be a useful educational exercise.

12 comments

Tech Support Scammers

Well, that’s a first for me. I just received a call on my home phone. The young woman on the other end of the line had a strong South Asian accent. She said “I’m a Microsoft-certified support person. We have been receiving messages from your home computer…” I cut her off. “Who do you represent?” Silence. “What company are you with?” Silence, then “I’m not with any company” to which I replied “Thank you very much. Goodbye.” Click.

An obvious scam. I wonder if people actually fall for this stuff.

Apparently, I’m not the only one who’s had this experience.

The way I had it figured they were calling me to let me allow them to plant malware on my home computer which they would then want me to pay them to remove.

6 comments

46

For those of you who are playing at home this is the 46th month of the recovery. According to the NBER, the average period from trough to peak in the post-war period is 59 months.

5 comments

Stalled

If you haven’t read it yet, the latest employment situation report points to an economy that is stalled:

Nonfarm payroll employment edged up in March (+88,000), and the unemployment rate was little changed at 7.6 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Employment grew in professional and business services and in health care but declined in retail trade.

Both the number of unemployed persons, at 11.7 million, and the unemployment rate, at 7.6 percent, were little changed in March. (See table A-1.)

Among the major worker groups, the unemployment rates for adult men (6.9 percent), adult women (7.0 percent), teenagers (24.2 percent), whites (6.7 percent), blacks (13.3 percent), and Hispanics (9.2 percent) showed little or no change in March. The jobless rate for Asians was 5.0 percent (not seasonally adjusted), little changed from a year earlier. (See tables A-1, A-2, and A-3.)

In March, the number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks or more) was little changed at 4.6 million. These individuals accounted for 39.6 percent of the unemployed. (See table A-12.)

The civilian labor force declined by 496,000 over the month, and the labor force participation rate decreased by 0.2 percentage point to 63.3 percent. The employment-population ratio, at 58.5 percent, changed little. (See table A-1.)

The number of persons employed part time for economic reasons (sometimes referred to as involuntary part-time workers) fell by 350,000 over the month to 7.6 million. These individuals were working part time because their hours had been cut back or because they were unable to find a full-time job. (See table A-8.)

To rephrase this if it weren’t for workers leaving the workforce the unemployment rate would be increasing rather than staying the same.

For the problem with the employment situation to be explained by demographics, more older workers would need to be leaving the workforce than is the case.

For the problem with the employment situation to be explained by technology, the productivity gains due to technological change would need to be more recent than is the case.

To me it really looks like the “capital strike” of 1937. Why invest? You can do better by rent-seeking with a lot less risk. When rent-seeking is the business model, the only employment that increases is of lobbyists.

29 comments

The Head Feint

I don’t know why Yves Smith is so discombobulated over President Obama’s reported willingness to reduce entitlement spending in exchange for tax increases:

There is no more pretense possible. As we’ve warned for some time, Obama is eager to put a notch on his belt by being the President that rolled back the New Deal programs that helped create broad-based middle-class prosperity and dignity. He’s cast himself as an adult inflicting discipline on profligate Americans. But in reality, the profligacy was most concentrated among elite financiers who used leverage on leverage vehicles to stoke liquidity that led to worldwide underpricing of risk. They paid themselves record bonuses in the years immediately preceding the crisis, and then in a grotesque display of ingratitude, did so again in 2009, able to do so only thanks to massive taxpayer support, alphabet-soup special borrowing programs, and the tax on savers known as ZIRP. And the direct result of their looting exercise that produced the crisis was the explosion in government deficits, due to a collapse in tax revenues and a rise in payments under countercyclical programs such as unemployment insurance and food stamps.

But are the real perps the object of Obama’s disciplinary impulses? No. He seems spectacularly unwilling to take on anyone even remotely approaching his size (as if a President should be cowed by senior banker bullies like Jamie Dimon). The President’s failure to reprimand the financial CEOs who dissed him by refusing to attend his address on the first year anniversary of Lehman was a tacit acknowledgement that they were really in the driver’s seat.

Keep in mind what is happening here. We are not in the realm of Obama kayfabe, where he pretends that those big bad Republicans forced him to do what he wanted to do all along. This is Obama’s budget offer, not the result of pretend hard fought battles over positions that are at most 10 degrees apart.

Let’s recap. The president is willing to offer things he’s confident won’t happen and that he probably can’t deliver in exchange for things he’s confident will happen and political gain. How do we know that the entitlement cuts won’t happen? Because they include tying SSRI increments to CPI and the chestnut “cutting Medicare payments to doctors and hospitals”. Congressional Democrats in both the House and the Senate have already rejected the first one more than once (it’s one of the reasons that the president’s blue ribbon deficit-cutting panel never delivered a consensus report) and, if Democrats wanted to cut Medicare spending, that could be effected simply by never bringing the annual “doc fix” to the floor in the Senate, something at the discretion of committee chairman. In fairness, there’s equal opportunity sophistry here: the Republicans could have done the same thing when they held the Senate majority.

The president has a confidence, born of experience, that he can get tax increases enacted, especially if a few Republicans go along with the gag. What’s the worst case reasonably anticipated scenario? That no deficit reduction will be enacted while the president gets credit for being the adult in the room? Quelle horreur!

I think that Rick Moran has it right:

All the president needs is to peel off 5 Republicans in the Senate to get an up or down vote on the budget. And that’s dependent on more liberal Senators sticking with the president despite the entitlement cuts. I don’t see it happening – nor will the GOP House even bother to take it up if it gets that far.

But in the PR fight over the budget, it might be a political version of “shock and awe.” Obama is going to anger his base – they will go ballistic – and win no friends on the right. But most Democrats will probably stay with him and indpendents will wonder why the GOP won’t accept most of what they’ve been advocating for months.

As a serious effort at deficit reduction, it falls considerably short. But as a political document, it will probably give the president at least a temporary advantage and make life difficult for Republicans running in 2014.

There is nothing beyond the mid-term elections. With every passing day, I think it becomes clearer that the White House strategy is to hold the Senate and capture the House. I don’t think it’s going to happen but I do think it’s the strategy.

8 comments