A few days ago I tried to get a little brainstorming going on the subject of technology as the primary explanation for the too slow rate of job creation. Obviously, either I failed to pique anybody’s interest or none of my few readers can find any supporting evidence for the idea that I didn’t.
As a follow-up, I’ll present some of the reasons why I think it’s unlikely that automation is the most significant reason for slow job growth following the Great Recession:
- Very few significant new technologies have been deployed since 2007. The only technological developments I can think of since then are the growth of social media and smartphones gaining critical mass. Most of the decline in employment and/or decline in job growth as a result of automation had already taken place by 2007.
- It’s not happening everywhere. Germany’s unemployment has actually declined sharply since 2007.
- The actual decline is relatively small. Two or three percentage points. I can’t believe that automation and harnessing breakthrough technolgoies can only wring out that small a fraction of employment.
- The number of jobs is still growing. It’s just not growing fast enough to keep up with the increase in population or bring the people who lost their jobs from 2007 to 2009 back o work.
- There are plenty of explanations other than automation for slow job growth.
Now let’s try brainstorming the reasons that automation is not the main factor behind the too slow job growth of the last few years (or the last dozen years, for that matter).







