The Best Evidence

Reuters repots the best evidence that Assad had a direct hand in the use of chemical weapons against civilians in Syria:

An analysis by the Congressional Research Service, a branch of the Library of Congress, reported that a declassified U.S. government paper summarizing intelligence findings concludes that Syrian government officials were “witting and directed” the gas attack. But the evidence of who ordered it was not watertight, the analysis said.

The findings were partly based on intercepted communications “involving a senior official intimately familiar with the offensive” which “confirmed that chemical weapons were used by the regime,” it said.

As more information has been collected and analyzed, early theories about the attack have largely been dismissed, U.S. and allied security sources said.

Reports that Assad’s brother, Maher, a general who commands an elite Republican Guard unit and a crack Syrian army armored division, gave the order to use chemicals have not been substantiated, U.S. sources said. Some U.S. sources now believe Maher Assad did not order the attack and was not directly involved.

It genuinely concerns me that the reason that the United States hasn’t made a more convincing case is that we don’t have one.

11 comments

11 Reasons the Obama Administration Should Present Its Case to the Security Council

This morning Secretary of State John Kerry said that the Obama Administration has not ruled out seeking Security Council authorization for the use of force against Syria:

(Reuters) – U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said on Sunday the United States did not rule out the possibility of returning to the United Nations Security Council to secure a resolution on Syria once U.N. inspectors complete their report.

Speaking at a news conference in Paris with his Qatari counterpart Khaled al-Attiya, Kerry said President Barack Obama had yet to make a decision on the issue.

Here are some of the reasons I think the Obama Administration should present its case for the use of military force against Syria to the United Nations Security Council, indeed, has an obligation to do so:

  1. “a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them”
  2. We are signatories to a treaty which requires us to seek Security Council approval before using military force against another country other than in cases of self-defense.
  3. The “Responsibility to Protect” initiative is a new and evolving norm rather than a law and it has never been ratified by the Senate.
  4. Vladimir Putin has said that he could support military action aginst Syria if the U. S. could produce a convincing case.
  5. If there is enough time for Congressional approval, there is enough time to present a case to the Security Council.
  6. A convincing case could attract support from other countries.
  7. Russia’s blocking of action following the presentation of a convincing case would isolate Russia.
  8. Attacking Syria without presenting a convincing case would isolate the United States.
  9. Outrage is not a sufficient cause for attacking another country. At the very least there should be proof beyond reasonable doubt that the Assad regime was responsible for the use of chemical weapons against civilians.
  10. There is reason to be skeptical about the Obama Administration’s claims.
  11. The downside risks of attacking Syria and then having incontrovertible evidence that the rebels were responsible for the use of chemical weapons (and, especially, that the U. S. was aware of it) would be real and substantial.
17 comments

Cheesemaking I: Making Soft, Unaged Cheeses

Yesterday I went to the first day of my cheesemaking workshop. The workshop took place the Learning Center of Angelic Organics, a working farm in Caledonia, Illinois, a reasonbly stress-free two hour jaunt up the Northwest Tollway, I90, from where I live in Chicago.

I don’t know if everyone feels this way or it’s just a product of my upbringing but I find getting out into the countryside good for the spirit. A little time in the rolling hills, the forests, and the fields really revives my soul.

The first session of the workshop covered soft, unaged cheeses. There were eleven of us in the class and we divided into teams. Each team made one or more different kinds of cheese: chevre, fromagina, queso blanco (AKA “farmer’s cheese”), paneer, ricotta, and mozzarella. I volunteered to be one of the two members of the team making mozzarella because the process included more steps than any of the other cheeses and I’d never made it before. The whole process of making mozzarella took a good two hours which I think I could have compressed a bit working in my own kitchen with a stove with which I was familiar and over which I had more control. Making mozzarella requires a half hour of gentle cooking at 108°F, something difficult to achieve quickly on an electric range.

I also had the opportunity to walk around the farm a bit, pick some herbs and vegetables from their kitchen garden (the kale I brought home was fantastic), and milk a goat.

At the end of the workshop each of us went home with a sample of each of the cheeses we’d made with some fresh fruits and vegetables as a lagniappe. Today I’ll go back for the second session, this one concentrating on making hard cheese, aged cheeses.

I’ll post some thoughts about the cheesemaking process, the second session, and recipes in later posts.

3 comments

Another Question

Should we go to war based on classified evidence?

23 comments

The National Conversation on Syria

Notice the political drama playing out in the national debate on action against Syria. The “National Greatness” hawks are making common cause with the liberal interventionists in the Congress to vote in favor of authorization while the American people, 4:1 by the most recent polls, are overwhelmingly against attacking Syria.

This national conversation reflects forces that have been contending for some time, the Wilsonians vs. the pessimistic realists (Jacksonians) and the pessimistic idealists (Jeffersonians). I strongly suspect the Hamiltonians, the optimistic realists, will heighten their complaints about paying for the attacks and their outcome, adding their voices to the conversation.

If the Congress votes to authorize the president to attack Syria or if the president proceeds without Congressional authorization, we may be moving into a period of real political crisis.

15 comments

The Political Question

Should House Democrats fall on their swords to pass the authorization to use force in Syria?

10 comments

Intel View

You might want to read this post at Sic Semper Tyrannis. The author has his ear to the ground with respect to our intelligence operations. It’s full of good points but here’s one that struck me:

President Obama’s problems go way beyond the Halls of Congress. He is facing three daunting problems with his Syria war scheme, according to one senior US intelligence officer. First, the case that Assad ordered the chemical weapons attack on Aug. 21 is, at best, circumstantial. A triangulation of intercepts by Israeli, German and US sigint agencies has been pitched to Congress as “proof” that Assad did it. But the case is flimsy and, ultimately, is all based on interpretations of conversations involving Syrian military commanders, Iranian diplomats and Hezbollah leaders. Clearly the American people are also unconvinced, as the opposition to any military action is polling well above 80 percent in most recent polls.

Read the whole thing.

It does bring another question to mind. In the history of warfare has anybody ever been able to control developments on the ground through air power alone? I don’t think so.

16 comments

Explanation Wanted

Can someone explain to me how you can uphold international norms by violating international norms? That’s a sincere question. I really don’t understand.

12 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a couple of foreign policy-related posts at Outside the Beltway:

The “Powell Doctrine” As Applied to Syria

Not a good fit.

The Only Way to Win Is Not to Play

Has Bashar al-Assad already won a strategic victory against the U. S.?

1 comment

I Agree With Barack Obama

I agree with Barack Obama. Not the President Obama of the last few weeks. The Barack Obama of 2002:

Now let me be clear—I suffer no illusions about Saddam Hussein. He is a brutal man. A ruthless man. A man who butchers his own people to secure his own power. He has repeatedly defied UN resolutions, thwarted UN inspection teams, developed chemical and biological weapons, and coveted nuclear capacity.

He’s a bad guy. The world, and the Iraqi people, would be better off without him.

But I also know that Saddam poses no imminent and direct threat to the United States, or to his neighbors, that the Iraqi economy is in shambles, that the Iraqi military a fraction of its former strength, and that in concert with the international community he can be contained until, in the way of all petty dictators, he falls away into the dustbin of history.

There is very little that can be said about Bashar al-Assad that was not even more true of Saddam Hussein. Not only had Saddam Hussein used chemical weapons, he had used them against his own people. He killed an order of magnitude more Iraqi Kurds, civilians including women and children, than Assad has killed Syrians (assuming that it was the Assad regime that used chemical weapons in Syria rather than the rebels).

There are many things we should have learned from our experience with Iraq but, apparently, haven’t. Dictators of Saddam Hussein’s and Assad’s sort cannot be deterred by air power alone. Removing such a dictator requires “boots on the ground”. And it’s darned hard if not impossible to control the aftermath of the removal of such a dictator even with “boots on the ground” and impossible without them.

A futile, short term bombing campaign is not the only possible way of dealing with Bashad al-Assad. The other day Tom Friedman proposed a very different approach:

That’s why I think the best response to the use of poison gas by President Bashar al-Assad is not a cruise missile attack on Assad’s forces, but an increase in the training and arming of the Free Syrian Army — including the antitank and antiaircraft weapons it’s long sought. This has three virtues: 1) Better arming responsible rebels units, and they do exist, can really hurt the Assad regime in a sustained way — that is the whole point of deterrence — without exposing America to global opprobrium for bombing Syria; 2) Better arming the rebels actually enables them to protect themselves more effectively from this regime; 3) Better arming the rebels might increase the influence on the ground of the more moderate opposition groups over the jihadist ones — and eventually may put more pressure on Assad, or his allies, to negotiate a political solution.

By contrast, just limited bombing of Syria from the air makes us look weak at best, even if we hit targets. And if we kill lots of Syrians, it enables Assad to divert attention from the 1,400 he has gassed to death to those we harmed. Also, who knows what else our bombing of Syria could set in motion. (Would Iran decide it must now rush through a nuclear bomb?)

But our response must not stop there.

We need to use every diplomatic tool we have to shame Assad, his wife, Asma, his murderous brother Maher and every member of his cabinet or military whom we can identify as being involved in this gas attack. We need to bring their names before the United Nations Security Council for condemnation. We need to haul them before the International Criminal Court. We need to make them famous. We need to metaphorically put their pictures up in every post office in the world as people wanted for crimes against humanity.

It may be that mobilizing world public opinion against Bashar al-Assad and his regime is beyond the core competencies of the Obama Administration. Is the only thing they themselves believe they’re good at is bombing that no one really believes will have much effect?

31 comments