Where I Stand On Attacking Syria

At this point I oppose authorizing President Obama to attack Syria and I thought I should explain why.

First, attacking Syria as the president has said he believes we should does not rise to the level of a just war. To be just a war must have a number of characteristics: just authority, just ends, just means, and, something that should go without saying, there must be a reasonable expectation that the means will effect the ends. In my view two of those (authority and effect) are seriously deficient and another (end) is weak.

Second, consider the authorization the president has requested. I honestly don’t see how anyone could vote for that in good conscience. It is too unlimited in time, space, and means. It would authorize the president to invade Syria or to continue bombing Syria (or Iran, for that matter) for the rest of his presidency. It’s not an authorization; it’s a free hand.

My opposition is not ideological or categorical. It’s practical. I can imagine circumstances under which I’d support attacking Syria but present conditions don’t even bear a remote resemblance to those circumstances.

16 comments

Tally 15-5

Today Tally turned 15 years, 5 months of age. She is by far the oldest Samoyed we’ve ever had.

The expression you see on her face is mischievous merriment. She’s teasing us. There’s nothing she likes better than making us chase her around the backyard. Nowadays we call her the “Blanco Bronco” in recognition of these low-speed chases.

She’s still holding in there. Every day it seems she’s a little weaker, her vision or hearing or sense of smell fades a little more. But she’s still happy, loves her life, and does the things she likes to do.

12 comments

Isolationism and Engagement

When did the alternative to isolationism become military intervention? Isn’t there some other kind of engagement than military?

12 comments

Whip Count on Syria

Following President Obama’s rather surprising announcement yesterday that he would seek Congressional approval for the use of military force against Syria, attempts to identify how Congress would vote have become something of a cottage industry. Michael Tomasky, writing at Daily Beast, assumes that such a vote would, essentially, be along party lines which would mean tepid support for an attack in the Senate, rejection by the House:

In the Senate, I presume a resolution will pass. Obama might lose a very small number of Democrats, and maybe Independent Bernie Sanders. But he should get several Senate Republicans—McCain and Graham, their buddy Kelly Ayotte, probably Lisa Murkowski, Bob Corker, a few others who aren’t up for reelection this year and in hiding from the tea party. McCain and Graham will push Obama to do more than he wants, to do a strike that could lead to regime change, but one would hope they can agree on language to make both sides happy. Harry Reid said Saturday he’d try to bring the Senate back early for a vote, meaning it will say yes first, adding to the drama as we turn to the House.

There? Yesterday, I thought the chance the House would pass a war authorization for this president was about 0 percent. Today I’ve revised that up to about 5 percent. I think a certain number will be so favorably impressed/shocked by Obama’s decision to consult them that they’ll be inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt.

I still consider approval a real long shot, though. Consider first the number of possible Democratic defections. So far, we know that 18 Democrats signed a letter circulated by Republicans stating that a strike undertaken without congressional approval would violate the Constitution. That concern is taken off the table, so maybe those 18 will play ball. But you have to think that maybe a couple dozen of the most liberal members, representing districts where three-quarters of their constituents are telling them no, will vote against.

If I’m right about that, it would mean that Obama would need around 45 Republican votes. Possible? I guess. But keep an eye over the weekend on how ferociously the media wingnuts start whipping this vote. What’s Rush Limbaugh going to be saying? He is also bereft of the constitutional argument now, of course, so what’s his new excuse going to be and how hard is he going to push people to oppose a strike? Rand Paul and the other libertarians? The various tea party movements?

That’s consistent with the narrative of implacable Republican opposition to all things Obama but is it correct? My general impression is that the Republicans have actually been quite accommodating to the president in the areas of the military and foreign policy and such opposition as there’s been has largely been kibitzing, i.e. that he hasn’t acted decisively or violently enough, but no disagreement as to his course of action. Am I mistaken?

Writing at Mother Jones, Tim Murphy and Asawin Suebsaeng present a somewhat more nuanced analysis, dividing the Congress into several different groups—Republican anti-interventionists, Democratic doves, the GOP “Maybe-if-You-Ask-Nicely” caucus, a Democratic “Wait-And-See” caucus, the Marco Rubio “We-Waited-Too-Long” caucus, Republican hawks, and Democratic hawks. To those I’d add the Republican “I oppose Obama and all his works” caucus and yellow dog Democrats. Read the whole thing.

At Politico Seung Min Kim, John Bresnahan, and Jake Sherman go back to the history of Congress’s reactions to the Obama foreign policy and, generally, arrive at the conclusion that it’s complicated. Support and opposition go well beyond party lines and neither the House nor the Senate are sure things are either direction.

I honestly don’t know which way Congress will vote. The history of the last almost seventy years has been that members of Congress, more concerned about their own personal political good than the good of the country, have been reluctant to leave their fingerprints on any U. S. military action and I don’t think that has changed. Some are characterizing this as yet another master stroke by President Obama. It might just as easily be an exit strategy.

What does the president actually want to do? I don’t know the answer to that, either. If the president is determined to attack Syria, Congressional approval will give him cover to do it, even in the face of a lack of popular support. If the president is actually reluctant to attack Syria, Congressional disapproval will give him an out for not attacking Syria.

I sincerely hope that, whatever the president actually wants to do, his advisors have counted the votes in Congress for that before he announced he’d seek Congressional approval. IMO the worst possible outcome is that Congress will reject the president’s request at which point he goes ahead and bombs Syria anyway.

So, how will the Congress vote?

22 comments

About That Housing Rebound

Remember that robust housing market that was going to life the U. S. economy out of the doldrums it’s been trapped in for the last four years? Maybe not so much:

Though it may have largely been lost in the shuffle of Middle East headlines, sales of new homes fell 13.4% in July to 394,000, which was a far cry from the 487,000 forecast by the consensus and the biggest variance from expectations in more than five years. In addition, sales in June were revised down to 455,000 from 497,000.

Those numbers are proof that whatever logic the real estate Pollyannas, who said mortgage rates weren’t going to affect demand for new homes, were using is totally false.

4 comments

Will Assad Negotiate?

I’ve just finished listening to President Obama say that he had decided to use military force against Syria and that he would seek Congressional approval for the action. I think that seeking Congressional approval is prudent and only time will tell whether attacking Syria is also prudent.

In the comment thread to a skeptical post at OTB by James Joyner on the strategic value of attacking Syria frequent commenter Michael Reynolds predicts:

We’ll blow some things up. Assad will not use chemicals again. Then they will resume their regularly-scheduled civil war. We will lose zero Americans. There will be zero boots on the ground (excepting intel.)

And here’s my “out on a limb” prediction: Russia, seeing the potential for this to cause problems for them, will pressure Assad into negotiating. Those negotiations will begin to consider partitioning Syria into (roughly) Shia and Sunni areas.

That’s actually seven predictions and for me they are roughly in descending degree of confidence. I want to focus on the last two predictions.

The Assad regime and the Russians have repeatedly said that Assad’s remaining in power was a precondition for negotiations while the rebels have made Assad’s departure a precondition for negotiations. Under the circumstances I see the most likely scenarios as:

  1. They’re both kidding and will settle the Syrian civil war at the negotiating table.
  2. Assad is kidding. He’ll leave and the Syrian civil war will be settled at the negotiating table.
  3. The rebels are kidding and the Syrian civil war will be settled at the negotiating table.
  4. Neither side is kidding. Negotiations are impossible.
  5. There is no unified opposition with which to negotiate. Whatever the Assad regime may want or do negotiations in good faith are impossible.

The only scenarios that I see as remotely possible are #4 and #5.

13 comments

The Obama Administration Makes Its Case for Strikes Against Syria

I think that Secretary of State John Kerry’s presentation yesterday has advanced the Obama Administration’s case for an attack on Syria:

Our intelligence community has carefully reviewed and re-reviewed information regarding this attack, and I will tell you it has done so more than mindful of the Iraq experience. We will not repeat that moment. Accordingly, we have taken unprecedented steps to declassify and make facts available to people who can judge for themselves. But still, in order to protect sources and methods, some of what we know will only be released to members of Congress, the representatives of the American people. That means that some things we do know we can’t talk about publicly.

So what do we really know that we can talk about? Well, we know that the Assad regime has the largest chemical weapons program in the entire Middle East. We know that the regime has used those weapons multiple times this year and has used them on a smaller scale, but still it has used them against its own people, including not very far from where last Wednesday’s attack happened. We know that the regime was specifically determined to rid the Damascus suburbs of the opposition, and it was frustrated that it hadn’t succeeded in doing so.

We know that for three days before the attack the Syrian regime’s chemical weapons personnel were on the ground in the area making preparations. And we know that the Syrian regime elements were told to prepare for the attack by putting on gas masks and taking precautions associated with chemical weapons. We know that these were specific instructions. We know where the rockets were launched from and at what time. We know where they landed and when. We know rockets came only from regime-controlled areas and went only to opposition-controlled or contested neighborhoods.

and I’m glad the administration is making its case. Sec. Kerry produced no actual evidence but I guess that is only to be expected. What he produced was the administration’s analysis of the evidence. And it’s clear that the specter of Iraq and Colin Powell’s presentation to the UN hung over Sec. Kerry’s presentation. Writing at The New Yorker John Cassidy remarks:

Inevitably, there will be comparisons with Colin Powell’s infamous 2003 presentation to the United Nations about Saddam Hussein’s chemical-weapons program, which turned out to be largely bogus. Until Kerry’s claims are subjected to further inspection, it is probably wise to avoid reaching any definitive conclusions. But Kerry himself obliquely referred to the Powell fiasco, saying that the intelligence community had “reviewed and re-reviewed” the evidence about the attack, adding, “And I will tell you, it has done so more than mindful of the Iraq experience. We will not repeat that moment.”

There’s more than one way of viewing the Bush Administration’s claims about Iraq. One way is that they just lied. The other is that they presented what they believed to be the truth as they saw it in a way that bolstered their case for the course of action they believed to be the correct one, zealous advocacy. That, of course, is precisely what Sec. Kerry did yesterday.

Not everyone agrees with the Obama Administration’s interpretation of what happened in Syria. Vladimir Putin has, of course, rejected the administration’s claims as fabrications:

Russian President Vladimir Putin has challenged the US to present to the UN evidence that Syria attacked rebels with chemical weapons near Damascus.

Mr Putin said it would be “utter nonsense” for Syria’s government to provoke opponents with such attacks.

US President Barack Obama says he is considering military action against Syria after intelligence reports that 1,429 people were killed on 21 August.

UN weapons inspectors have left Syria after gathering evidence for four days.

They crossed into neighbouring Lebanon. They are due to go to the headquarters of the Organisation for the Prevention of Chemical Weapons in the Netherlands.

The US says hundreds of children were among those killed in the suspected chemical weapons attacks, which the US says was carried out by the Syrian government.

Syria said the US claim was “full of lies”, blaming rebels for the attacks.

A recent poll has found that nearly two-thirds of the French oppose military action against Syria and there are somewhat mixed messages coming from the French government on what should be done next. On the one hand:

President Hollande of France said that the vote by the UK Parliament would not affect France’s will to act.

He supported “firm” punitive action over an attack which had caused “irreparable” harm to the Syrian people. When asked if France could act against Syria without Britain he said: “Yes. Each country is sovereign to participate or not.”

but on the other:

Both Paris and Berlin put store by waiting for the UN to deliver its report on what happened even though the inspectors will not attempt to apportion blame. That report will not be ready until Sunday.

The French President says “everything must be done to reach a political solution” and has been urging the Syrian opposition to become a credible force.

What the French – and I think the Germans – favour is not just to punish Damascus for its alleged use of chemical weapons but to try to muscle it towards agreeing to attend talks in Geneva.

That is the goal for the Europeans – to get Russian President Vladimir Putin to push Syria’s Bashar al-Assad towards talks, but that will only happen if Mr Assad feels vulnerable.

I find myself largely in agreement with local Congresswoman (and wounded Iraq War veteran) Tammy Duckworth:

U.S. congresswoman and Iraq War veteran Tammy Duckworth said Thursday that she did not favor American military intervention in Syria and urged Middle East nations to find a resolution to the crisis.
U.S. congresswoman and Iraq War veteran Tammy Duckworth said Thursday that she did not favor American military intervention in Syria and urged Middle East nations to find a resolution to the crisis.

[…]

Duckworth said Mideast countries should take the lead in stopping Syria’s humanitarian crisis. “The nations in the Middle East have a responsibility to do something as well. This is their backyard,” she said.

Leadership is an appropriate role for the United States. Designated flak-catcher is not.

When we attacked Libya we were equipped with a UN resolution, allies who were capable of lifting at least some of the weight, and, importantly, allies from the Arab League. If we attack Syria, we may do so with none of that.

The next day or so will be critical. We’ll have a better idea of whether the Obama Administration is succeeding in convincing the American people. We’ll have a better sense of where Congress stands. The UN inspectors are expected to deliver their report.

4 comments

What Then?

It appears that I am not alone. Yesterday, in a post over at OTB I wrote:

I think that before taking military action against Syria the president should wait for the UN inspectors’ report, try to secure approval from the Congress, and try to secure approval from the United Nations Security Council.

It seems that the overwhelming preponderance of Americans agree with me, a condition to which I am unaccustomed:

Nearly 80 percent of Americans believe President Barack Obama should receive congressional approval before using force in Syria, but the nation is divided over the scope of any potential strike, a new NBC News poll shows.

Fifty percent of Americans believe the United States should not intervene in the wake of suspected chemical weapons attacks by Syrian President Bashar Assad, according to the poll. But the public is more supportive of military action when it’s limited to launching cruise missiles from U.S. naval ships – 50 percent favor that kind of intervention, while 44 percent oppose it.

at least with respect to the matter of Congressional approval.

In all likelihood Americans may just be sick of war and sick of their country starting wars, especially when the national interest in those wars is ambiguous.

I hope at least some of them are asking the question that presidents should ask themselves more and, apparently, don’t ask themselves at all: what then?

Assume an attack on Syria is unsuccessful in the sense that Assad continues to use chemical weapons after the attack. What then?

Assume an attack on Syria is successful, Assad stops using chemical weapons (he might have done so anyway), but he is able to defeat the rebels without them. What then?

Assume an attack on Syria is successful, Assad stops using chemical weapons (he might have done so anyway), he is unable to defeat the rebels outright, and the civil war just continues. What then?

Assume an attack on Syria is successful and Assad, hamstringed in his attempts to preserve his regime, is ousted by the rebels. The rebels are radical Islamists. What then?

We attack Syria. Syria, Iran, or both retaliate by attacking Americans or American interests in the Middle East using asymmetric warfare techniques. What then?

We attack Syria. An American aircraft carrier is sunk by asymmetric warfare techniques (that’s actually occurred in war games of conflict in the Middle East). What then?

32 comments

One Picture

While I’m in a graphic-y sort of mood, I would be remiss if I didn’t link to Kerwin Datu’s network analysis of the Syrian situation:

Max Fisher of The Washington Post published a chart showing the tangled web of love and hate that ensnares the various “meddlers” and “meddlees” in the Middle East. The chart is the work of an Egyptian blogger, The Big Pharaoh, and was inspired by a letter to the Financial Times. The chart looks completely hopeless, or in Fisher’s words, “sort of terrifying”.

And yes it does, at least until you start teasing it apart step by step. Part of my own research involves analysing the global economy as a network of cities using the tools of social network analysis. While I don’t pretend to have any kind of expertise on the Middle East, I decided to convert The Big Pharaoh’s chart into a network graph (incorporating the quibbles Fisher noted in his update) to see what’s really happening inside it. I also don’t pretend to evaluate the truth of the original chart; I offer this simply as an interesting methodological exercise that may be replicated by anyone looking for new ways to analyse complex diplomatic problems.

I’m not sure that enhances my understanding but at least it’s a different way of looking at a hopelessly complicated situation.

Hat tip: Charles Cameron at Zenpundit

1 comment

The Chart

Contemporary American culture, graphed.

1 comment