A Low Trust Environment

Sheesh. What have you guys been doing while I’ve been away? The Gallup Organization has found that Americans’ faith in the ability of the federal government to handle either foreign or domestic affairs is at an all-time low:

PRINCETON, NJ — Americans’ trust in the federal government to handle international problems has fallen to a record-low 43% as President Barack Obama prepares to address the nation on Wednesday to outline his plan to deal with ISIS. Separately, 40% of Americans say they have a “great deal” or “fair amount” of trust in the federal government to handle domestic problems, also the lowest Gallup has measured to date.

[…]

Gallup has never measured lower levels of trust in the federal government to handle pressing issues than now. That includes the Watergate era in 1974, when 51% of Americans trusted the government’s ability to handle domestic problems and 73% trusted its ability to deal with international problems, and also at the tail end of the Bush administration when his job approval ratings were consistently below 40% and frequently below 30%.

The key question going forward is whether Americans’ trust in the federal government can be restored. Although there have been short-lived increases in recent years, including in Obama’s first year in office and in his re-election year, these were not maintained. The general trend since the post-9/11 surge has been toward declining trust. Simply voting new people into office may not be sufficient to restore trust in government. Rather, given the public’s frustration with the way the government is working, it may be necessary to elect federal officials who are more willing to work together with the other party to find solutions to the nation’s top problems.

I don’t believe that the federal government is less able to handle domestic or international affairs than it was six years ago. President Obama, however, seems to have succeeded in convincing Americans that is is.

Why? Is this related to expectations? Or President Obama’s bad habit of musing out loud?

8 comments

Saving the Undefinable

I learned a number of things reading this article by David Rothkopf at Foreign Policy, subtitled “Can Obama’s foreign policy be saved?”. For example, I learned that the Obama Administration has aggravated our allies, enemies, and the State Department (into which category the latter belongs I will leave to the reader to decide). I learned that Susan Rice is for reasons of temperament unsuited to be a diplomat. And I had confirmed something I have been claiming for a long time, that the administration’s foreign policy objectives are largely defined by domestic electoral politics.

Is it possible to save something that cannot be defined? Can the Obama foreign policy be defined (other than in terms of domestic electoral politics, in which case it has already accomplished its objectives)?

I don’t believe the Obama foreign policy is in need of saving. I think it’s in need of definition.

15 comments

Restoring Cabin Pressure

I want to draw your attention to what I think is a simply brilliant post at Minyanville from Peter Atwater. In the post Mr. Atwater exploits a clever central metaphor for the banking crisis of the Great Recession:

In December 2010, I wrote that the policymakers’ approach to resolving the crisis was akin to the procedure recommended by flight attendants in case of a sudden in cabin pressure. Masks should go first on the adults and then on the children.

In response to the banking crisis policymakers took deliberate monetary and fiscal action targeted to helping the biggest banks and corporations along with the wealthiest in America, with the hope that once safe, they in turn would quickly breathe life into middle market and small businesses, as well as middle- and lower-class Americans.

We have now confused ends with means. We should be attempting to restore cabin pressure. Our efforts are mostly dedicated to keeping the so-called adults breathing.

3 comments

Concession Speech

Will President Obama’s speech tonight be a concession speech?

Mr. Obama can blame this rising tide of disorder on George W. Bush, but the polls show the American public doesn’t believe it. They know from experience that it takes time for bad policy to reveal itself in new global turmoil. They saw how the early mistakes in Iraq led to chaos until the 2007 surge saved the day and left Mr. Obama with an opportunity he squandered. And they can see now that Mr. Obama’s strategy has produced terrorist victories and more danger for America.

Mr. Obama’s intellectual and media defenders were complicit in all of this, cheering on his flight from world leadership as prudent management of U.S. decline. Even now some of his most devoted acolytes write that Mr. Obama’s “caution” has Islamic State’s jihadists right where he wants them. It is hard to admit that your worldview has been exposed as out-of-this-world.

We hope tonight’s speech shows a more realistic President determined to defeat Islamic State, but whatever he says will have to overcome the doubts about American resolve that he has spread around the world for nearly six years. One way to start undoing the damage would be to concede that Dick Cheney was right all along.

I think that’s far-fetched in the extreme. Presidents simply don’t do that and expecting this president to do so is expecting too much.

However, I would go farther than that. It is true that “Dick Cheney was right all along”? Or are we looking in the wrong places for ways to make us more secure?

5 comments

Put to the Question

David Ignatius asks a series of pointed questions:

● What’s the exit strategy? As Obama begins his effort to “degrade and ultimately destroy” the Islamic State, his aides told the New York Times the campaign could take three years. How will the United States and its allies know when they have “won”? Or will this be more like the Cold War, a decades-long ideological battle punctuated by periods of intense local combat? If so, are the American people ready for such a long and patient struggle?

● If Obama is serious about using U.S. military power against the Islamic State, why has he initially been so tentative? Militarily, a sudden, sharp attack makes more sense than a drizzle of airstrikes. There may be sound political reasons for the cautious U.S. approach, to force countries in the region to step up and make commitments themselves, but this goes against military logic.

● The United States may begin with the limited goal of helping allies fight the Islamic State, but what if the campaign goes badly, or it spreads more widely to Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, or the U.S. homeland is hit in retaliation? We may plan a restrained campaign, but the enemy gets a vote. Won’t the United States inevitably have to escalate if it seems to be losing?

And, finally, the hardest question: Is the United States walking into a trap that has been constructed by the Islamic State — launching attacks that will rally jihadists around the world? From everything the jihadists proclaim in their propaganda, we can sense that they have been dreaming of this showdown. This is why the United States needs to make sure that, with every step it takes, it is surrounded by Muslim friends and allies.

That’s more than I’m usually comfortable with quoting and I apologize to Mr. Ignatius for it but there’s really no other way of getting the point across.

I think I would begin at a different point than Mr. Ignatius does. What is the U. S. interest? If it’s avenging the deaths of two young Americans who put themselves in harm’s way with foreseeable consequences, it returns to the point I made a couple of weeks ago about the War of Jenkins Ear. Is that really a reason to go to war?

If it’s to remove threats to our security, our security will remain threatened as long as the factors that produce and enable the threat are in place. Those factors are both at home and abroad. As long as those factors remain going after Osama Bin Laden or Al Qaeda or Afghanistan or Saddam Hussein or IS are just disconnected actions without strategic coherence.

As I’ve said repeatedly, I don’t object to not going to war. I do object to lurching uncontrollably into war without articulating our interests or objectives. It’s up to President Obama to articulate those interests, lay out the objectives, and produce a plan to achieve them.

One thing of which we shouldn’t lose sight. Saudi Arabia and Jordan are much more in the crosshairs than we are. Does a more, er, kinetic role for the U. S. encourage or discourage their own involvement? I think the more we commit the less they will.

14 comments

My First Reaction

My first reaction when I read this opening sentence fragment:

President Obama is dispatching Secretary of State John Kerry to the Middle East…

was “We’re doomed!”

9 comments

The Wavelet

Nate Silver’s latest numbers find the Senate increasingly coming within Republicans’ grasp:

The FiveThirtyEight forecast model gives Republicans a 65.1 percent chance of winning the Senate with the new polling added, similar to the 63.5 percent chance that our previous forecast gave them on Friday.

But the path to a Republican majority is becoming a little clearer — and the problem for Democrats is that it runs through six deeply red states.

while Stuart Rothenberg sees a Republican wave forming:

While the current Rothenberg Political Report ratings don’t show it, I am now expecting a substantial Republican Senate wave in November, with a net gain of at least seven seats.

But I wouldn’t be shocked by a larger gain.

Rothenberg Political Report ratings reflect both where a race stands and, more importantly, where it is likely headed on Election Day. Since early polls rarely reflect the eventual November environment, either in terms of the candidates’ name recognition and resources or of the election’s dynamic, there is often a gap between how I categorize each race (my ratings) and what I privately assume will happen in November.

That gap closes as Election Day approaches, of course, since polling should reflect changes in name identification, candidate and party spending, and voter attitudes as November approaches.

Right now, for example, the Rothenberg Political Report/Roll Call Senate ratings suggest Republican gains in the mid-single digits. My newsletter has the most likely outcome of the midterms at Republican gains of 5 to 8 seats, with the GOP slightly more likely than not to net the six seats it needs to win Senate control.

Things must look very different in the six “battleground states” than they do in Illinois. My vision is clouded on this and I’m still seeing slight Republican gains but no wave.

7 comments

The View

Former Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker lays out his argument in favor of “defeating IS” and his strategy for doing so. I think he does a pretty fair job of making his case that the “Islamic State” should be confronted:

It is hard to overstate the threat that this organization poses. I call it al Qaeda Version 6.0. The Islamic State is far better organized, equipped and funded than the original. They are more experienced and more numerous. Several thousand carry Western passports, including American ones. All the terrorists have to do is get on a plane and head west. But perhaps the most important asset they possess is territory. For the first time since 9/11, a determined and capable enemy has the space and security to plan complex, longer-range operations. If we don’t think we are on that list, we are deluding ourselves.

but his case that it endangers us and that it should be confronted by us isn’t nearly as strong. HI strategy is:

  • Increase the pace of airstrikes.
  • Strike IS targets in Syria.
  • “…continue an intensive, high-level political effort to help the Iraqis form an inclusive government that will bring Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds into a unified front to confront a common enemy. We will have to ensure that they have the weapons to prosecute a successful campaign. “

and that we should avoid supporting the Iranians or Assad and support “moderate Sunni forces” however they may be identified.

I am left with an enormous number of questions.

  • Can ISIS be defeated by U. S. air power alone?
  • Who is more threatened by ISIS? Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Europe, or the U. S.?
  • Who should be most motivated to confront ISIS?
  • What actions or ours would encourage and promote those priorities in confrontation and what would discourage them?
  • What is the evidence Sunnis, Shi’ites, and Kurds in Iraq will ever unite to oppose ISIS? What should we do in the absence of such unity?

for a start.

9 comments

The Beinart Take

Peter Beinart responds to the same Robert Kagan op-ed op-ed I commented on a couple of days ago:

For Kagan, the 1990s were “our version” of the 1930s too. “At the end of this bloody century, we all should have learned that appeasement, even when disguised as engagement, doesn’t work,” he wrote in a 1998 critique of Clinton’s China policy. “The word that best describes Clinton administration policy,” he wrote in an editorial with William Kristol the following year, “is appeasement.”

The analogy was bizarre then. The supposedly appeasement-minded Clinton administration went to war in the Balkans twice, the second time without UN approval. It extended NATO into Eastern Europe, spent more on defense than the next nine nations combined, and in 1998, bombed Iraq for almost three days straight, once again with no mandate from the UN.

And the analogy is bizarre now. “In the wake of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan,” writes Kagan near the beginning of his essay, “it is the U.S. that seems to be yearning for an escape from the burdens of power and a reprieve from the tragic realities of human existence. Until recent events, at least, a majority of Americans (and of the American political and intellectual classes) seem to have come close to concluding not only that war is horrible but also that it is ineffective in our modern, globalized world.”

I think a couple of points need to be made. First, as I’ve noted before, I think it is clearer, just as was the case with the Bush Administration, to think in terms of a first term foreign policy and a second term foreign policy. The examples of Obama hawkishness Mr. Beinart submits as evidence were part of President Obama’s first term foreign policy. His self-described second term foreign policy is “don’t do stupid sh*t”.

Second, I do not fault the president for what he is not doing in Syria, Ukraine, or Iraq. I disagree with what he’s saying. I don’t think he should set rhetorical red lines and then walk them back or say that he would pursue miscreants to the gates of hell (or equivalent) unless that is what he intends to do. As I have said any number of times, I think the president should identify and prioritize U. S. interests, argue for that analysis and persuade people to agree with him, and take actions that would further those interests sufficient to the end.

It may be that the president’s not saying what he really thinks or that he knows that he’d get severe pushback if he were to say what he really thinks. But that’s the job.

2 comments

Long Days

Just so you don’t get the impression that my life is a bed of roses, let me give you a schedule of my typical day.

4:00am Rise. Clean up, prepare and eat breakfast.
7:30am Walk to where I’m picked up for work.
7:45am Picked up for woek
8:30am Arrive at client’s office
12:00pm Walk to Tessco (equivalent of 7/11—it beats the roach coach) for lunch
8:15pm Return to Bath with ride
9:00pm Find a place that’s still open for dinner
10:00pm Return to apartment, try to get to sleep.
11:30pm Sleep

2 comments