Let’s take this column from Tom Friedman on how to defeat ISIS as a point of departure:
The way you defeat such an enemy is by being “crazy like a fox,†says Andy Karsner, the former assistant energy secretary in the last Bush administration and now the C.E.O. of Manifest Energy. “We have one bullet that hits both of them: bring down the price of oil. It’s not like they can suddenly shift to making iWatches.†We are generating more oil and gas than ever, added Karsner, and it’s a global market. Absurdly, he said, the U.S. government bans the export of our crude oil. “It’s as if we own the world’s biggest bank vault but misplaced the key,†added Karsner. “Let’s lift that export ban and have America shaping the market price in our own interest.â€
But that must be accompanied by tax reform that puts a predictable premium on carbon, ensuring that we unite to consistently invest in clean energies that take us beyond fossil fuels, increase efficiency and address climate change. Draining our enemies’ coffers, enhancing security, taxing environmental degradation — what’s not to like? And if we shift tax revenue to money collected from a carbon tax, we can slash income, payroll and corporate taxes, incentivize investment and hiring and unleash our economic competitiveness. That is a strategy hawks and doves, greens and big oil could all support.
which invites a little thought experiment. How high a tax on oil would you need to impose to put pressure on Russia, Iran, and other nogoodnik oil exporters? What would the implications of such a tax be?
I think the first question has several components. As I understand it the price elasticity of demand for oil, that is the degree to which the demand for oil responds to increases in price, is generally thought to be quite small but not nonexistent. IIRC the short term price elasticity of gasoline is around -.09 and the long term is around -.3. In other words in the short term if you doubled the price of gasoline demand would decrease around 9% and in the long term around 30%.
Right now the price for WTI is around $95 a barrel. For an oil-based strategy to work you’d need to lower the net price of oil worldwide to $75 a barrel or below.
I submit that a tax on oil in the United States would have no impact whatever on the worldwide consumption of oil because Europe and North America aren’t the only major markets any more. There is a global market for oil and it is incredibly efficient with changes in behavior reflected in the markets everywhere practically instantaneously. China is a major consumer. So is India. If whatever we do actually lowers consumption, they’ll just step in to fill up the loss of demand. For such a tactic to work it would require the cooperation of all of the major consumers. In other words, I think it’s a futile tactic. It’s perfectly suited to the world as it was 35 years ago.
But let’s keep thinking about it, anyway. In the U. S. (just talking about at the federal level), people in the lower half of income earners pay FICA (payroll tax) and excise taxes (mostly the gas tax). People in the next 45 or so percentages in income pay FICA, excise taxes, and income taxes while people in the top 5% or so pay excise taxes and income taxes. Most of their income isn’t subject to FICA because of FICA max. In other words FICA and excise taxes are very regressive and while the income tax is mildly progressive.
The only tax you can lower without making our system even more regressive is the payroll tax. IMO it was obviously foolish to reinstate the tax once it had been suspended. How much of FICA actually falls on the bottom 50% of income earners? Not much as it turns out. I’ll have to dredge up the numbers but since FICA is a percentage of income and the lower 50% of earners don’t have that much income you’re limited to about 8% of that.
All of this is a formula for a tax increase on the poor and a tax cut for the rich. Like banks, it’s where the money is.
It doesn’t take a lot of that before commuting to work stops making sense. Or, said another way, we won’t stop until the last job is wrung out of the economy.
Update
If we really wanted to cut the price of oil, the best strategy we have for that not on the demand side but on the supply side. If that’s what we wanted to do, we should be producing a lot more oil.