Lose-Lose

Here’s the kernel of John Kass’s acerbic Chicago Tribune column on President Obama’s announcement of his intention to move against ISIS:

The president has lived all his political life on rhetorical tricks, political theater and magic. Remember, he was even applauded for telling us that he sometimes felt as if he was the empty vessel of our dreams.

All of this was made possible by another trait he learned years ago while serving his apprenticeship with the Democratic Party bosses from Chicago: avoiding direct confrontation.

That’s not leadership training. That’s political survival training. Facing the Islamic State, and trying to shore up a crumbling, tiny coalition to fight them, is different.

I think he goes too far. It isn’t that the president’s thinking is muddled. It’s that he can only lose by clarity. If he actually lays out clearly what he thinks should be done, some group or other is bound to be bitterly opposed to it.

However, that is the job.

3 comments

Too Late Schmardt

I think I’ve mentioned before that my grandfather made his living doing dialect humor. He and his vaudeville partner did an act portraying an Irishman and a “Dutchman”, i.e. German. Oddly, my grandfather who self-identified as Irish, played the Dutchman.

There’s an old wisecrack, done in dialect, of unknown provenance: “Too soon ve get oldt, too late schmardt.” I think that’s certainly the case in this Rolling Stone article on the challenge that China presents to any attempt at reducing the world’s output of carbon:

The blunt truth is that what China decides to do in the next decade will likely determine whether or not mankind can halt – or at least ameliorate – global warming. The view among a number of prominent climate scientists is that if China’s emissions peak around 2025, we may – just barely – have a shot at stabilizing the climate before all hell breaks loose. But the Chinese have resisted international pressure to curb their emissions. For years, they have used the argument that they are poor, the West is rich, and that the high levels of carbon in the atmosphere were caused by America’s and Europe’s 200-year-long fossil­fuel binge. Climate change is your problem, they argued – you deal with it. But that logic doesn’t hold anymore. China is set to become the largest economy in the world this year, and in 2006, it passed the U.S. as the planet’s largest carbon polluter. China now dumps 10 billion tons of CO2 into the atmosphere every year. That number is expected to grow to 15 billion tons by 2030, dwarfing the pollution of the rest of the world. If that happens, then the chances that the world will cut carbon pollution quickly enough to avert dangerous climate change is, according to Kevin Anderson, deputy director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research in the U.K., “virtually zero.”

The one question I have about this article is how in the heck can you write an article about China and carbon production without mentioning that China has been adding 100 new 6 MW coal-fired power plants for the last decade? Just for comparison, on an annual basis the U. S. doesn’t add any. Maybe it’s there and I missed it. If so, it’s buried pretty well.

Ignore whether we should worry about carbon production. Just ignore it for the sake of argument. Can you write anything resembling a balanced article without mentioning the rate at which China’s production is increasing? Or its investment in infrastructure supporting that production?

2 comments

Genetic Fallacy

It seems to me that anybody who argues against Thomas Piketty’s views of capital and income inequality will inevitably be dismissed as opposing a tax on wealth for self-serving reasons.

4 comments

Bad Habits

James Taranto offers another example of the president engaging in something that’s a bad habit of his, musing out loud:

He’s a better speechwriter than his speechwriters, a better political director than his political director, and to hear President Obama tell it–or, to be precise, to hear the New York Times retell others’ retelling of Obama’s telling it–he’s a better terrorist than the terrorists:

If he had been “an adviser to ISIS,” Mr. Obama added, he would not have killed the hostages but released them and pinned notes on their chests saying, “Stay out of here; this is none of your business.” Such a move, he speculated, might have undercut support for military intervention.

Perhaps the president wishes he had pinned such a note to the chests of the journalists with whom he purportedly shared this brainstorm last Wednesday afternoon. “Although three New York Times columnists and an editorial writer were among those invited,” the Times reports, “this account is drawn from people unaffiliated with The Times, some of whom insisted on anonymity because they were not supposed to share details of the conversations.” The Times report doesn’t name any of the attendees, but the Puffington Host’s Michael Calderone does.

As comical as it is for the president of the United States to imagine himself giving political advice to a terrorist army, Obama’s musings are also revealing. He imputes to the Islamic State the objective of forestalling U.S. military intervention. It understates matters considerably to observe that there is no obvious reason to suppose that is so.

For me, musing is fine. It’s not a good practice for the president of the United States.

However, I do think that the incident is revealing but not in the way in which Mr. Taranto suggests. Why do people think that the audience for the beheading of Americans and a Brit by ISIS is the United States or Britain? I think they were just handy Westerners. I think the audience for these actions is Muslims in the Middle East.

ISIS is portraying itself as the “strong horse” and the legitimate carrier of the banner of Islam for all Muslims, with the right to make demands on all Muslims. It’s a specific challenge to Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and any other notionally Muslim country that won’t march to its banner but particularly Arab Sunni Muslim countries. It’s not about us at all.

Update

After noting the psychological impact the beheadings have wrought on Western audiences, Pat Lang remarks:

Secondly, these are mightily potent weapons in the struggle for control of the collective Sunni mind. The gesture of defiance explicit in the deeds appeals greatly to people who seek an absolutist answer to the riddle of existence. Fighters and money seem to be joining the cause and the horror of IS actions contributes to that achievement.

In my view that’s the primary purpose of the actions. They’re a recruiting tool.

18 comments

Defending Western Movie Values

I am beginning to lose track of who is posturing about what. In his most recent Wall Street Journal op-ed, Anders Fogh Rasmussen, Secretary General of NATO present a breathtaking and head-spinning re-interpretation of the history of the last twenty-five years:

With Russia, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization has tried long and hard to build a partnership that respects Russia’s security concerns and is based on international rules and norms. Regrettably, Russia has rejected our efforts to engage. Russia has trampled on all the rules and commitments that have kept peace in Europe and beyond since the end of the Cold War. It is now clear that Russia regards the West as an adversary, not a partner.

Handsome is as handsome does. I note that SG Rasmussen does not present a single instance of NATO having extended the hand of peace to Russia. Russians can offer dozens of examples of having been snubbed, dismissed, and opposed. Both of the examples SG Rasmussen presents, Ukraine and Syria, are cases in point.

In the Russian view the democratically-elected (and pro-Russian) government of Ukraine was overthrown in a violent coup by a group of right-wing Ukrainian nationalists with the support and/or connivance of the West. In the case of Syria could ISIS have risen there in the absence of Western support for forces opposing Assad (of which ISIS was one) or the support of Western allies? The Russians have been warning of exactly the outcome we’ve seen since the rebellion began.

SG Rasmussen portrays the course of action he supports as the defense of Western values:

Our liberal international order—embracing freedom, democracy, the market economy, common rules and norms, and renouncing territorial conquest—has brought unprecedented peace, progress and prosperity to billions of people. This has been an historic achievement. So we must stand up with greater confidence for our principles and our values.

These values are now under threat. They cannot be taken for granted. As we approach the end of over a decade of fighting in Afghanistan, there is a temptation to turn inward. But the world will not become less dangerous just because we wish it to be. Threats will not go away just because we want to look away. We must keep a global perspective and counter isolationism and retreat.

I don’t think he’s defending Western values. I think he’s defending Western movie values. You can tell the hero from the villain because the hero wears a white hat and the villain a black one. The Russians? They’re those guys over there in black hats.

The hero rides into town, defeats the black hat-wearing bad guy, and rides out again at sunset. In most of the world’s towns it is not nearly so simple. Once having ridden in we can’t simply ride out again, at least not without leaving chaos in our wake.

We need to learn that riding into town implies that we’ll be willing to stay indefinitely regardless of cost in lives or money. High Noon is the reality, not the Lone Ranger. I just don’t see us as willing to bear those costs.

4 comments

The Return

Frankly, I’m disappointed. I thought you guys would get all of this stuff sorted out while I was away. 😉

7 comments

What Interest?

No one’s writing about it so I don’t have a quote with which to open this post. What interest of ours are we defending in bombing ISIS or, heavens forfend, sending troops to oppose it?

I can see the Saudis’ interest and I understand Jordan’s interest. Is an attack on the KSA or Jordan an attack on the United States? I think there are interests there but they are conditional and far removed.

If it’s the “Pottery Barn Rule”, that’s a pretty fair argument for never having withdrawn our troops from Iraq in the first place and occupying the country on an indefinite basis. Surely that isn’t what’s meant.

I honestly don’t see any threat that wouldn’t exist with or without ISIS/ISIL as long as we continue our present principles of operation.

However, equally, it’s hard for me to follow the argument that, once having identified an interest worth going to war over and, let’s face it, bombing is war, that interest should be conditional on what the Saudis or the Iraqis or the Turks are willing to do. There’s either a mortal interest or there isn’t.

I think this is what comes of trying to pretend that war is clean and sanitary and scientific and precise and can be waged freely on the basis of cost-benefit analysis.

12 comments

Returning Home

The picture above is of The Raven, a pub not far from the hotel in which I lodged for the first two weeks of my sojourn in Bath. The Raven is known for its pie. The one time I went there it was packed. I created a space for myself at the bar by grabbing a chair that was sitting against the wall, placing the chair between two other chairs at the bar, and planting myself in the chair. I ordered a pint of their ale and a pie.

“Pie” in England isn’t quite the same as it is here. Generally, English pie has a raised crust, i.e. it’s a cylinder rather than a disk, and it’s usually made with hot water pastry rather than with our pie crust which in England is called “flaky pastry”. Pies are usually savory—beef, pork, chicken—and served with mashed potatoes and gravy.

The last time I was in Bath was nearly twenty years ago. Since then the town has been tidied up quite a bit, it’s more cosmopolitan, and it’s bustling with visitors. Twenty years ago it had a somewhat dilapidated, rundown look and most of the restaurants and tourists in it were English. Now there are Thai, Italian, Turkish, even American restaurants and in addition to the English and American visitors there are European, East Asian, and South Asian visitors as well as many, many East and South Asian residents.

That’s consistent with the trend we saw in London when we visited there 20 years ago, a trend that has apparently spread to the rest of the country.

I think it was Chesterton who said that the great advantage of foreign travel is the gift of returning to your native land as though it were a foreign country. This was the first time I had been abroad in 15 years. Customs was, if anything, more onerous than it had been fifteen years ago. The lines were vastly longer, the security was not appreciably greater but it was tremendously more officious and harsher.

10 comments

The Scottish Play

I haven’t mentioned the vote on Scottish independence yet. It’s big news here—scarcely an hourly newscast passes without at least five minutes and sometimes much more being devoted to the subject.

As is my practice I don’t want to intrude in other countries’ political affairs. IMO Scottish independence is an issue to be worked out between the Scots and the English.

I would note parenthetically that I have heard no commentary whatever on the implications of not being a monetary sovereign. It’s pretty obvious that the large nominally Scottish banks are aware of the issue:

Scotland’s Yes campaign has been dealt a significant blow after Lloyds and RBS threatened to move headquarters operations to London if the country quits the Union.

The banks, which employ a total of 27,500 in Scotland, confirmed they would register themselves in England if voters opt for independence next week.

And the department store giant John Lewis warned that shoppers in Scotland could expect higher prices if it votes for independence because retailers would no longer be willing to absorb the higher cost of trading there across the UK.

It moves the referendum battleground to matters of the “head” and the country’s crucial financial services sector, which generates around £7-9bn each year and employs 100,000.

It’s difficult to ferret out the statistics to get a decent handle on the character of Scotland’s trade. I know that the U. S. is its largest single foreign trading partner, if taken as a whole the EU is its largest single foreign trading partner, and that because of present free trade between Scotland and the balance of the United Kingdom it’s a bit difficult to nail down the volume of that trade.

The prevailing wind seems to be blowing in the direction of retaining the pound if the independence vote passes. Is that the right move?

Emotions are running very high on this subject on both sides and I strongly suspect that the ultimate decisions will be made emotionally. That doesn’t negate the many practical considerations that should be taken into account.

From the U. S. point of view I think that Scottish independence would be a bad development. Not only would it weaken the United Kingdom, one of only two NATO members other than the U. S. at the highest level of military force readiness, should it elect to join NATO it would be yet another free rider that was not pulling its weight in the alliance.

10 comments

The President’s Speech

The president’s speech last night was given at 2:00am local time so I was in troubled slumber. How did it go? My work schedule won’t provide me the time to listen to it streaming or even read the transcription.

My guess is that he said he was going to do something but we’re not sure what or why but, gosh darn it, it will take care of ISIL. Does that about cover it?

Update

Col. Pat Lang, a man with substantial area expertise, writes this about the president’s plan:

In the end, if a decisive outcome is desired, there will be no alternative to substantial US ground forces. That will mean reconstruction of the US logistical and command and control base in Iraq as well as the use of several air bases. Is Obama going to demand legal extra-territoriality for our forces as a precondition? He should, but, will he?

He also offers important insights on the Turks, Kurds, Saudis, Qataris, and Iranians. His conclusion: too many moving parts.

51 comments