Jesuit Educated

Mark Judge’s Jesuit high school in Maryland was founded just about twenty years before the Jesuit high school I attended in St. Louis was. He clearly learned somewhat different things from the Jesuits than I did. Not that I didn’t learn the thing he lists as what he learned from the Jesuits. It’s that I learned other things as well.

For example, intellectual clarity. What he summarizes as “have an extracurricular activity” I would state as it’s not enough to be be a great scholar or a fine athlete or a winning debater. You should be a great scholar, a fine athlete, and a winning debater.

And in debate you shouldn’t merely go for the win. You should go for the kill.

1 comment

Poor Judgment? Or Political Judgment?

For the sake of argument imagine that on any given issue the only consequences that you need to be concerned about are the political consequences. You don’t need to worry about economic consequences in the case of an ill-considered economic policy. You don’t need to worry about adverse reactions from other countries or foreign organization as a result of foreign policy decisions. And so on. Just the electoral political implications. I think that’s a much better if over-simplified explanation for the president’s words and actions than Peggy Noonan’s explanation:

A man who personally picks drone targets, who seems sometimes to enjoy antagonizing congressional Republicans, whose speeches not infrequently carry a certain undercurrent of political malice, cannot precisely be understood as soft.

But we focus on Mr. Obama personality and psychology—he’s weak or arrogant or ambivalent, or all three—and while this is interesting, it’s too fancy. We are overthinking the president.

His essential problem is that he has very poor judgment.

And we don’t say this because he’s so famously bright—academically credentialed, smooth, facile with words, quick with concepts. (That’s the sort of intelligence the press and popular historians most prize and celebrate, because it’s exactly the sort they possess.) But brightness is not the same as judgment, which has to do with discernment, instinct, the ability to see the big picture, wisdom that is earned or natural.

Mr. Obama can see the trees, name their genus and species, judge their age and describe their color. He absorbs data. But he consistently misses the shape, size and density of the forest. His recitations of data are really a faux sophistication that suggests command of the subject but misses the heart of the matter.

Take the president’s decision to oppose ISIS/ISIL with bombs, support for imaginary Syrian moderate rebels, and non-existent allies who will commit troops to the campaign but not “boots on the ground”. I think the complete package of the president’s views inclusive both of rhetoric and practical steps can only be recognized when viewed solely through the lens of domestic electoral politics.

The president must do something. The bloody heads of Americans and Brits beheaded by ISIS form an unassailable argument. Failing to react forcefully to those provocations won’t pick up seats in Illinois, New York, or New Jersey. Those seats are already solidly Democratic. Lack of a forceful reaction might lose seats in Louisiana, Iowa, and Alaska. The merits of the threat posed by ISIS just don’t warrant a committed response. Consequently, a response that falls short of a committed response is the best possible political judgment.

As I have said before, I don’t fault the president for not wanting to commit troops to Iraq and Syria because I don’t think the threat to the United States posed by ISIS/ISIL warrants it. My sole complaint is that the president does not appear to be willing to assuage the concerns of the American people and sell his plan to them.

14 comments

Scots Vote “No”

English politicians are breathing a sigh of relief as the Scots vote remain part of the United Kingdom by a substantial margin:

Scotland has voted to stay in the United Kingdom after voters decisively rejected independence.

With the results in from all 32 council areas, the “No” side won with 2,001,926 votes over 1,617,989 for “Yes”.

Scotland’s First Minister Alex Salmond called for unity and urged the unionist parties to deliver on more powers.

Prime Minister David Cameron said he was delighted the UK would remain together and said the commitments on extra powers would be honoured.

Mr Cameron said the three main unionist parties at Westminster would now follow through with their pledge of more powers for the Scottish Parliament.

“We will ensure that those commitments are honoured in full,” he said.

After dismissing the possibility that the Scots would vote for independence until late polls suggested a much closer decision that had been anticipated, party leaders responded with ineffectual panic.

Early analysis suggests that the old, the young, and the Highland and Island Scots voted for Scotland to remain part of the United Kingdom. Speculation on the Highland and Island Scots is that they preferred a seat of government far away in London to one closer at hand in Edinburgh.

4 comments

Culture Shock

I’m full of questions today. As you know I rarely write here about sports or sports-related matters. It’s generally just not something that interests me.

However, I do have a question about the rash of suspensions of NFL players over charges of spousal abuse and/or child abuse. Is there a racial and/or cultural element in the outrage? I think there is. For example, I think that corporal punishment of children is much more socially acceptable among African Americans and rural whites than it is among, say, middle class suburban whites living in the Northeast.

I also notice that no one has asked if the wives or girlfriends of these NFL players strike them.

Just for the record I don’t think people should strike their children, spouses, or significant others. If you beat a dog, it does not cause the dog to express the behavior you might be looking for. Rewards are much more useful in eliciting behaviors than punishment. It may make the dog mean or furtive, however. We aren’t that much different.

20 comments

Prioritize

While I’m giving quizzes, here’s another one. Put into priority the following goals of the House Oversight and Government Committee in its investigations into what happened in Benghazi in September 2012:

  • Arriving at a fair and factual assessment of the events that lead to the deaths of four Americans.
  • Impeaching the president
  • Battlespace preparation for 2016
  • Keeping the issue in the public eye to embarrass the president
  • Staying in the public eye personally
  • Other (specify)

I’ve always thought it was keeping the issue in the public eye, self-aggrandizement, battlespace preparation, embarrassing the president, impeaching the president, arriving at, etc.

6 comments

Arming the Rebels

Now that the House has voted in favor of arming the Syrian rebels:

The House of Representatives voted on Wednesday afternoon to greenlight President Obama’s controversial proposal to arm and train moderate Syrian rebels in effort to defeat the terrorist group known as the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS).

Lawmakers approved the amendment by a 273-156 vote after six hours of debate. The amendment, which includes no new money to pay for the operation, was then incorporated into a larger spending bill that will fund the U.S. government through Dec. 11 and avoid a partial government shutdown.

“As we continue to take targeted military action against ISIL terrorist targets, today’s vote is another step closer to having the authorization to train and equip vetted elements of the moderate Syrian opposition so they can defend themselves against, and ultimately push back on, ISIL forces in Syria, while creating the conditions for the political solution necessary to solve Syria’s crisis once and for all,” Obama said in a statement Wednesday evening. ISIL is an another acronym for the terror group.

Let’s consider a couple of questions. First, how will the Senate vote?

Will the Senate:

  1. Vote in favor
  2. Vote against
  3. Not vote on it

My prediction is that the Senate will narrowly approve the measure. Most or all Republicans will vote in favor of the funding the rebels, Democratic senators in Red states will vote in favor or funding the rebels, the Democratic Senate leadership will vote in favor of supporting the rebels, and most other Democrats will oppose it.

Next question. A year from now what will have happened?

  1. Nothing much. Things in Syria and Iraq will look much as they do now.
  2. We will have destroyed ISIS/ISIL
  3. We will have ground troops fighting ISIS/ISIL because the objective of destroying it can’t be realized otherwise.
  4. ISIS/ISIL will hold Baghdad
  5. The objective in arming the Syrian rebels and/or bombing ISIS/ISIL will have been redefined to approximate conditions on the ground more closely
  6. Something else (specify)

I think that nothing much will be different but there’s a 1:3 chance that ISIS/ISIL will have taken Baghdad.

8 comments

Destiny

I can’t wait until I’m at liberty to tell you about the next project I may be involved with. All I will say is “Be careful what you wish for.”

9 comments

In England’s Green and Pleasant Land

Before it slipped down the memory hole, I wanted to mention one aspect of my visit to Old Blighty, now sadly ended. The last time I had been in the UK was fifteen years ago. Then as had been the case in my several previous visits I was impressed by the observation that every visit to the restroom was like a visit to a plumbing museum. Not only were the fixtures old their variety was incredible. I am convinced I didn’t see any two the same. I was also convinced that being a plumber in the United Kingdom must have required at least a doctorate in mechanical engineering from the complexity of interconnecting so many different systems.

No more. On this visit every fixture was remarkably the same. My speculation is that it was a consequence of an attempt at becoming more “green”. Low flow shower heads, toilets, and so on.

I also found the many signs, billboards, etc. proclaiming the naturalness or low resource utilization of the premises a marked difference from my previous experience.

1 comment

The Threats

As I looked out over the headlines this morning, on Ebola (likely to become endemic in West Africa now), ISIS (we’re going to oppose them with a limited strategy), and Ukraine (still unclear why we’re supporting the government there), I notice that each of these had something in common: they are only threats to us as a consequence of policy. In each instance there is a strained case for our involvement.

The best case is with respect to the Ebola outbreak in West Africa. There are humanitarian reasons we should be involved there but even those are conditional. We should only be involved insofar and to the degree that we can actually help there.

I understand the policies at stake but it’s not clear to me that the risks and rewards of the policies are being distributed equally. It seems to me that increasingly we’re all bearing the risks while the policies only benefit a relative few.

36 comments

The Warning

This statement should fill us with foreboding:

Years of increasingly choking smog have sparked public anger and even led to protests. In 2013, a government survey of 74 Chinese cities found that all had pollution levels that exceeded levels the World Health Organization deems safe.

“We will resolutely declare war against pollution as we declared war against poverty,” Premier Li Keqiang said in March. The plan calls for the closure of old and dirty steel, cement, and coal plants: An estimated 1,725 small-scale dirty coal plants are expected to be shuttered. The government also declared it would spend $275 billion in the next three years to reduce pollution.

According to the World Bank more than half of China’s people live on $4 or less per day. A quarter live on $2 or less per day. 10% live on $1.25 or less per day. And that’s after 35 years of modernizing their economy.

3 comments