Declaring Victory

Now that the U. S. has started bombing ISIS in Syria I have seen a familiar pattern emerging. Some are already declaring success while others are immediately declaring failure. That is what we saw in each of the Obama Administration’s major initiatives—the stimulus package, healthcare reform, and now operations against ISIS. Either one is tremendously premature. Success can only be measured against strategic objectives and simply because the bombs detonated or struck their intended targets does not mean that there is a clear strategic objective to accomplish, that progress has been made in accomplishing it, or that the strategic objectives can be accomplished by means we are willing to employ.

For that we will need to wait for weeks, months, or even years. Frankly, I do not believe we can achieve any real last, strategic victory unless we’re willing to occupy large portions of the Middle East for a century or more, something I do not believe we are willing to do or should be. Consequently, I tend not to be sanguine about this latest campaign.

10 comments

I Read the News Today Oh Boy

I learned something interesting the other day. Apparently, high rates of cannabis use by young men is associated with cyclical vomiting syndrome. If you’ve ever known anyone who had CVS, it’s a frightening and debilitating condition. A serious matter.

I wonder if the correlation has anything to do with the anti-nausea effect also reported in cannabis use. I can think of several ways the causality could work. High rates of cannaabis use could produce CVS in young men. Or, alternatively, young men who are predisposed to CVS may have high rates of cannabis use in an attempt at self-medicatingg.

Whatever the case note that I’m not arguing that the bans on marijuana use should be maintained because of this. I just think it’s possible that the acceptability of cannabis use may produce higher incidence of CVS than might otherwise be the case.

3 comments

Sixteen Tons

Over the period of the last seventy-two hours I have had, perhaps, an aggregate of five hours of sleep. Combination of work, stress, pain, jet lag, and this dmmnable cold/flu I picked up shortly after returning to this country. That’s aggravated by my tendency to have perverse reactions to drugs. Things that bring decongestion and pain relief to others bring me increased congestion and heightened pain. If it were predictable it would be one thing but, sadly, it’s not. Just maddening.

20 comments

Baseball, Religion, and George Will

Here’s a very interesting interview with George Will on baseball, Wrigley Field, and religion. Mostly not politics.

7 comments

Who Should Vote?

In the aftermath of the Scottish independence in which 16 and 17 year-olds voted (contrary to assumptions a majority of this group voted against independence) there’s been some discussion over who should be allowed to vote:

While it’s true that this potential voting cohort will be profoundly impacted by the decisions made by politicians elected before they are eligible to vote, there does’t seem to be the same sense of urgency. Indeed, beyond the knowledge issue dealt with above, the fact that these potential voters don’t really have anything other than an abstract stake in society at this point in their lives is another argument against extending the franchise to them. That being said, the seemingly successful experiences of nations like Austria and Denmark, along with the decision to extend the franchise in Scotland for the limited purpose of the independence referendum, argues that it is at least an idea that ought to be considered even if we don’t rush headlong into signing up High School Seniors and Juniors to vote.

So far the discussion has dodged the question of who should be allowed to vote and why. Let me present some alternatives:

  • Everybody. No criteria.
  • All people of sound mind. How is that defined?
  • All people of sound mind above some arbitrary age. What age? Are some 7 year old more prepared to vote than some 16 year olds?
  • Stakeholders.
  • Shareholders.
  • Whatever criteria can be reasonably administered.

I opposed lowering the voting age to 18 and still believe there’s a better argument for raising the voting age to 30 than lowering it even farther. IMO the basic criteria for voting should be the ability to render an independent judgement. That’s the reason we don’t allow 7 year olds to vote rather than simply their ages or imputed lack of knowledge. That their votes are heavily influenced by their parents.

5 comments

The Damage

I think that this CNN op-ed by David Gergen illustrates just how damaging the clumsy debut of the PPACA’s portal was to the Obama Administration:

(CNN) — Someone in the Obama White House clearly has a good book to write one day: “How Not to Do Rollouts.”

With one hapless episode after another, the rollout of the President’s plan to destroy ISIS is beginning to rival the less-than-splendid debut of the Obamacare website.

President Barack Obama’s critics may take some glee from the recent missteps, but they shouldn’t. Going to war is serious business, especially when the conflict promises to be long and messy.

For the nation’s sake, our dysfunctional politics needs to become functional on this one or we put too much at risk, starting with the lives of our men and women in uniform.

That’s why it is imperative and urgent that the Obama team and their allies take a deep breath, pull themselves together and get this war effort on solid footing. Instead of becoming defensive, they need to go on offense, showing the world they are firmly in charge and on a winning path.

Just to clear the fog from Mr. Gergen’s understanding, the purpose of the White House’s policy in Iraq is “showing the world they are firmly in charge” rather than “on a winning path”.

That having been said, I find that a pretty fair illustration of the damage that the Obama Administration did to itself last year when it insisted that Healthcare.gov be opened for business on schedule rather than when it was ready. I’m sure they had their reasons but I suspect they’re finding that it casts a pall over every action they take or will take.

I also predict that its legend will grow and it will increasingly be portrayed as much worse than it actually was, hard as that may be to imagine. It will become a symbol of overreaching, under-accomplishing federal government programs of every stripe for the foreseeable future.

3 comments

Why Aren’t Large Retailers Security-Conscious?

I didn’t want to let this pass without commenting on it since it touches on several point I’ve mentioned here from time to time. Tyler Cowen asks, in economistese (“What is the market failure in data storage and protection at the retail level?”, why (large) retailers aren’t more security-conscious:

There’s been another accident and data leak from Home Depot, and some people are claiming the company was negligent, so I was thinking what kind of market failure might be present. One problem is this. They store your credit card number whether you buy one thing at the store or make fifty trips over the course of two years. So, if you don’t trust a store, at the margin you only get one chance to make a decision whether to give them your credit card number by shopping there or not. You are comparing the total expected consumer surplus from having a relationship with the store at all against the data privacy risk. Such blunt, once-and-for-all trade-offs are not always conducive to good marginal incentives.

If Home Depot acted as he is suggesting, there’s more going on than a “market failure”.

Quite a number of years ago the payment card industry agreed on a set of security standards. Under those standards if Home Depot is acting as Dr. Cowen suggests, Home Depot is not “PCI compliant”. Merely storing the credit card is an unacceptable security risk. What they are supposed to do is pass the credit card immediately on to a processing organization that will “tokenize” it and pass the token back to them for storage and re-use. Home Depot should be subject to substantial fines for its recklessness.

IMO laws, regulations, and standards are for the little guys. They are mechanisms by which larger institutions fend off competition from smaller ones. They are rarely enforced against large institutions, the large institutions recognize that, and, consequently, have few incentives to comply.

9 comments

How Not to Change

I really need to check in on McSweeney’s more regularly. Here’s an amusing list of ways to make classic movies less sexist. Gone With the Wind sounds about right:

Rhett kisses and grabs at Scarlett against her will. Scarlett informs Rhett that though they are married, she still has autonomy over her body and has the right to refuse sex. The pair ascend the staircase in thoughtful conversation, and Rhett wakes up the next morning glowing with newfound feminist awareness.

Read the whole thing at least if you want a lift from Ebola, beheadings, and the exploding stock market.

59 comments

Compare and Contrast

When I read this I thought of this. It’s good for you!

If they’d adapt that wheel to power the electronics they’d really be on to something.

5 comments

Necessary

For some reason Doug Bandow’s bios do not mention where he grew up. David Goldfield’s CV says that although he was born in Memphis he grew up in Brooklyn. I on the other hand grew up within walking distance of a Civil War battle, not much farther from a slave market, numbered among my schoolmates people whose great-great-grandfathers had served on opposite sides in the American Civil War, and I had two great-great-grandfathers who fought for the Union. I think that explains my visceral reaction when Mssrs. Bandow or Goldfield write that the Civil War was unnecessary.

It was necessary as surely as it is the case that there are still people south of the Mason-Dixon Line who refer to the American Civil War as “the War of Northern Aggression”, sometimes but not always humorously.

It was baked in. The Civil War was the price that we paid in blood for the U. S. Constitution. I think they are dismissing this too quickly:

A house divided against itself cannot stand. I believe this government cannot endure, permanently, half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved — I do not expect the house to fall — but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing or all the other. Either the opponents of slavery will arrest the further spread of it, and place it where the public mind shall rest in the belief that it is in the course of ultimate extinction; or its advocates will push it forward, till it shall become lawful in all the States, old as well as new — North as well as South.

Their claim is the claim that the South would willingly have abandoned slavery or that slavery’s opponents would willingly have allowed it, assertions for which I find little evidence. Lincoln’s election was a signal that slavery would be abolished, the South took it so, and acted accordingly.

27 comments