Alex Berezow summarizes the CDC’s actions to date:
The CDC is one of the great institutions of our federal government. Microbiologists, such as myself, idolize the scientists who have dedicated their careers and lives to making the planet safer. But the CDC has made some major missteps. Some understandable mistakes are clearly from inexperience in dealing with Ebola, but others are harder to explain. For instance, effective communication is a vital part of all crisis management, which should be a core function at the agency.
But that’s also harder than it looks. CDC has found itself in a Catch-22. It’s a nearly impossible balancing act to provide accurate information without unnecessarily frightening the public. Whether CDC said too much or too little, it was going to be criticized by the news media. The outbreak spread, so the CDC was condemned for being unprepared. But if the outbreak had fizzled, it would have been chastised for fear mongering.
Likely aware of this, the CDC chose the worst possible action: In an effort to keep the public calm, the CDC pretended to know more about Ebola than it actually does.
while Alexis Simendinger outlines the CDC’s course correction:
An Ebola SWAT team from the CDC in Atlanta traveled to New York to exercise a beefed up regimen of care, one that has evolved dramatically since the country’s first and fatal case of the disease showed up in Dallas last month.
The CDC “surged†treatment experts to New York to help the patient and guide the health care workers responsible for his care. The CDC has established a new policy to bring experts to Ebola patients, and then transfer the stabilized patients to a handful of pre-trained and designated health facilities around the country, if necessary.
This, too, is a calculated risk. It presumes that the number of patients being treated in the United States remains very low, less than 20 which is the capacity of the “designated health facilities around the country.” Prudent risk mitigation requires that steps be taken to ensure that assumption remains good which is piece I think is missing at this point.
We can only hope that the no further secondary cases show up in New York.






