Studying Louisiana

At RealClearPolitics Sean Trende presents an interesting historical case study of Louisiana politics, harnessing this to an explanation of the challenges Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu faces in her re-election campaign there:

But the real problem Landrieu has is that her 2002 and 2008 coalitions seem nearly impossible to reassemble. The 2002 runoff coalition suffers from the fact that the “normal” Democratic coalition is still down from 2002. Consider: In 2000, the population of Orleans Parish was 484,674. In 2010 it was 343,829. So, there has been a huge drop-off of adults. If we assume that 40 percent of these adults would vote, this translates to 57,000 fewer voters.

Assume further that Democrats had a 60-point edge in this group (Obama received 80 percent in Orleans Parish in 2012). That’s about 34,000 net democratic voters lost from 2002. Landrieu won her 2002 runoff by 42,000 votes, so she would have no room for erosion in the rural areas of the state. Of course, there are also other counties outside of Orleans that lost population, but they tend to be from the more Democratic portions of the state.

Landrieu could also try for the 2008 coalition, but the problem there is generating sufficient turnout. Consider: If we take Landrieu’s vote shares from 2008 (losing whites 29-65; winning blacks 96-2) and apply these numbers to the 2010 electorate (71 percent white, 24 percent black), Landrieu would still lose, albeit narrowly.

But the biggest problem – and this applies to both the 2002 and 2008 coalitions – is that it just isn’t clear that Landrieu can re-create her earlier performances among whites against a non-problematic Republican candidate.

As the late Mayor Daley once said, the one thing that is certain is that somebody’s going to win. In the only poll that really matters, the one that takes place in the voting booths on November 4 (and, increasingly, on the absentee ballots cast beforehand), the better candidate will prevail and that will be judged through the eyes of Louisianans, something I can’t speculate on. Still, the history is interesting.

2 comments

This Time For Sure!

Does anyone really believe this:

At an otherwise docile gathering Monday, New York Fed President William Dudley and Fed Gov. Daniel Tarullo delivered a message to high-ranking Wall Street executives that bad behavior won’t be tolerated. Dudley in particular said big financial institutions operate under a cloud of suspicion and have continued bad behavior even after suffering more than $100 billion in fines and triggering a multitrillion-dollar bailout after the financial crisis.

[…]

“In conclusion, if those of you here today as stewards of these large financial institutions do not do your part in pushing forcefully for change across the industry, then bad behavior will undoubtedly persist,” Dudley said. “If that were to occur, the inevitable conclusion will be reached that your firms are too big and complex to manage effectively. In that case, financial stability concerns would dictate that your firms need to be dramatically downsized and simplified so they can be managed effectively.”

The bankers at the big banks know, with a confidence rooted in experience, that in a crisis the Fed will bail them out. It doesn’t really matter what they do. If, on the other hand, we had nationalized, say, Bank of America five years ago, I think we’d be amazed at the change of behavior at the other banks. As Voltaire said of the execution of John Byng, it is wise to hang an admiral from time to time to encourage the others.

25 comments

Where Do These !@#$%^& Wilsonians Come From, Anyway?

Over at National Interest Robert Merry devotes a substantial amount of teeth-gnashing to Americans’ bad habit of electing interventionist presidents:

The United States has suffered through thirteen years of foreign-policy incompetence in the Oval Office, with little likelihood that the pattern will change before the next president is inaugurated. The country desperately needs salvation from such consistent blundering, but there’s no particular reason to believe the next president will be any better. And thus, the gnawing question is: What accounts for so many years under two presidents when foreign policy turned out to be one fiasco after another?

It is not as hard to explain as he makes it out to be. Americans tend to elect the candidate who presents the more positive, optimistic view of America and its future. Wilsonianism, liberal interventionism, is an optimistic view. If we elect candidates with optimistic views, we’ll get Wilsonians. See how easy that was?

BTW, what in the heck is the comma doing in this sentence:

The problem with that thesis is that neither George W. Bush, nor Barack Obama lacks serious native intelligence.

Is punctuation no longer taught in the schools? I realize that publications are trimming budgets and cutting back on editors but you’d think that people would have the self-respect to proofread their own published material.

6 comments

Asked and Unanswered

What is it about today? I keep browsing over to articles that raise interesting questions and am disappointed after reading them that they don’t even try to answer the questions they raise. In this case the disappointing article was in the New York Observer and propitiously titled “What if Hillary Doesn’t Run?” In a 930 word column here are the two snippets that address the question:

Most recent polls show that more than 60% of Democrats support her over the other possible candidates and that she leads the second most popular candidate, either Vice President Joseph Biden or Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts by more than 50 points. The Ready for Hillary PAC, a kind of proto-campaign organization, has raised and spent millions of dollars, far outpacing the campaign organizations of other Democratic candidates. Many high profile Democratic leaders, as well as various liberal organizations, are poised to endorse Ms. Clinton as soon as she announces her candidacy.

and

If Clinton decides not to run, the Democratic candidates will have to scramble to raise money, secure endorsements, raise their national profile and build an organization to catch up with their Republican opponents.

That’s it. The balance of the column is devoted to why she’ll run and why she’s not a particularly satisfying candidate. I’m left with the clear impression that the author believes she’s inevitable which means there’s no there there for this column.

Let’s face it. Among those with even a scintilla of political consciousness in the United States Hillary Clinton has 100% name recognition. And there are no undecideds, merely liars and truthtellers. We could hold the election tomorrow and the results probably wouldn’t be materially different from those in 2016. If Ms. Clinton decides to run, that is. If she decides not to, it’s “Katie, bar the door.”

3 comments

Heidi Waleson’s Review of The Death of Klinghoffer at the Wall Street Journal

The slug on Ms. Waleson’s review of the Met’s production of John Adams’s controversial opera, The Death of Klinghoffer, which depicts the murder of Leon Klinghoffer on a cruise ship in 1985 by Palestinian terrorists, is “This production makes it clear: John Adams’s opera is neither anti-Semitic nor anti-Israel. It does not condone terrorism.” Is it possible to create an artistic work depicting the murder of a man because he is Jewish that is not intrinsically anti-Jewish? If the killers are Palestinian terrorists and they are motivated by hatred of Jews and Israel is it possible for it not to be anti-Israel?

I had hoped to learn the answers to these questions but after having read Ms. Waleson’s bland review of the Met’s production, I am left unsatisfied. I may never know the answers.

2 comments

Crowd-Sourcing Education on Ebola

I’d like to draw your attention to an excellent presentation on Ebola in YouTube video form:

ably summarized in text form at the blog Raconteur Report. There’s no panic, no partisan posturing, no temporizing, no embroidering. Just a basic presentation from Michael Osterholm, Director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy. It also challenges the “nothing to see here, move along” posture we’re getting so much of these days.

This presentation was brought to my presentation by the commenter Piercello. In my view this exemplifies one of the very best aspects of the World Wide Web, generally, and social media in particular. A link to the video was left by an anonymous commenter at Raconteur Report who promoted it into a post. I am now, in turn, promoting a comment left here to a post (giving credit to all sources) in the hope that it might be helpful to someone else.

20 comments

The Red Shoes

I’ve mentioned Michael Powell’s masterpiece, The Red Shoes, before. If you haven’t seen it, I recommend it. It’s foundational cinema, filmed in that glorious, saturated, surreal, old British Technicolor. I don’t think my revealing the end will spoil it for you. At the end of the movie, the production of the ballet goes on. A pair of red pointe shoes are carried around the stage. The ballerina who was to have worn them has committed suicide.

That’s what I think of when I read about the challenges to the subsidies for states that did not implement their own healthcare exchanges that are making their way through the courts and which I think the Supreme Court should hear with all due haste. The production is the PPACA. The subsidies are the red shoes. The ballerina is Jonathan Gruber, a prime architect of the PPACA, and his explanation of the subsidies as incentives to the states to create their own exchanges. Without recognizing there once was a ballerina it all becomes surreal and imcomprehensible.

2 comments

This Is No Time to Remain Calm

According to the Mayo Clinic’s helpful website the symptoms of a panic attack are:

  • Sense of impending doom or danger
  • Fear of loss of control or death
  • Rapid heart rate
  • Sweating
  • Trembling
  • Shortness of breath
  • Hyperventilation
  • Chills
  • Hot flashes
  • Nausea
  • Abdominal cramping
  • Chest pain
  • Headache
  • Dizziness
  • Faintness
  • Tightness in your throat
  • Trouble swallowing

I don’t feel any of those symptoms other than, possibly, nausea but that’s clearly because I listen to the political discourse in the United States too closely. Indeed, when I look around the clearest signs of panic are among Democratic politicians rather than the public at large. It’s just like in the movies. The most panic-stricken guy on the boat is the one who’s rushing around frantically telling everyone else to remain calm.

In this post I’d like to suggest that we not remain calm.

In every crisis over the period of the last century or more the only things that have motivated Americans to action have been strong emotions: pity, fear, most commonly anger. Those are what motivated us to enter World War I, to act during the Great Depression of the 1930s (whether you think we acted prudently is another question entirely), to respond to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, to become the primary healthcare provider in Pakistan for a year following a massive earthquake there, or even to send a man to the moon. Calm motivates us to watch the World Series or check out the antics on The Big Bang Theory.

The reality is that the Ebola epidemic that has struck Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone is beyond those countries’ ability to manage. Not only are they among the poorest countries in the world but they have among the least competent and most corrupt governments, not unrelated things. Since healthcare workers are highly at risk from Ebola the epidemic has depleted their already weak healthcare systems.

The number of deaths from Ebola in those countries is already approaching 5,000. There are projections that within a month or so it will rise into the tens of thousands and if unchecked it could rise into the millions by early next year.

Each new case is accompanied by the possibility that the virus could go airborne, a prospect that would be a disaster of global proportions, or that it could become endemic in that region of Africa or even beyond. Those are things we don’t want to happen.

The time-honored approach to dealing with the disease and the approach that has been successful in Nigeria and Senegal already has been to isolate the active cases and track down and quarantine those most at risk from the disease due to their contacts with people with active cases. That still is not impossible, as Nigeria and Senegal have demonstrated, but it soon may become so and Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone are incapable of managing the problem on their own. I also think that our own greatest safety lies in treating the epidemic successfully in West Africa.

We need to intervene with all due speed and I don’t see calm as motivating us to do that. It’s the last thing we need. A few hundred soldiers erecting tent hospitals, our present commitment, isn’t enough to do the job.

11 comments

The Hail Mary

When I was an undergraduate my alma mater’s football team’s biggest yard-gaining play was the quick kick. You read that right. It’s a play of desperation, one that’s rarely seen in modern football. Another play of desperation is the “Hail Mary pass”, a long forward pass with little likelihood of successful execution.

That’s pretty much analogous to what Scott Gottlieb and Tevi Troy propose as our response to the Ebola epidemic in West Africa:

Mr. Obama has stated repeatedly that the U.S. has helped to snuff out every other outbreak of Ebola and that the country will do the same with this one. However, past outbreaks occurred almost exclusively in remote villages, and entire locales would be cordoned off while the virus burned itself out. Liberia, a country of 4.4 million people, can’t be encircled. Nor can Dallas be quarantined.

Instead, medical countermeasures are critical. Despite early swagger by public-health officials at the National Institutes of Health and CDC that this crisis will be solved with public-health tools alone, and that a vaccine or treatment won’t be available in time, smart medical experts are recognizing the need for a therapeutic drug or vaccine.

One leading plan is for a 30,000-person clinical trial to begin as early as December with two experimental vaccines. Two groups of 10,000 West Africans will each receive one of the two novel vaccines. A third group of 10,000 West Africans will serve as a control group and receive a hepatitis B vaccine. The plan is dependent on completing early-stage trials under way now and having vaccine supply on schedule.

While a vaccine is needed to help stop the epidemic in West Africa, it is equally important to develop a drug to treat the disease in those who have been infected. This is especially so for the U.S., where a drug or drugs can combat containable outbreaks.

The problem with this strategy is that it ignores downside risk. It could take two years or twenty years to develop an effective vaccine. Or it may prove impossible to develop one. We just don’t know. Meanwhile, the number of cases in West Africa will continue to grow, people will continue to die, and, in all likelihood, the probability that Ebola will become endemic in West Africa or even in sub-Saharan Africa more generally will grow.

The only way we can avoid the worst case scenarios of the Ebola epidemic is by serious attention now, not merely from the United States but from the entire developed world. There’s a lot riding on it.

13 comments

Premature Burial

The editors of the Chicago Tribune pronounce cost control under the PPACA dead:

In year one, spending increased at 14 sites and only 13 of the 32 qualified for a bonus. In year two, spending increased at six of the remaining 23 and 11 received a bonus. Spending did fall somewhat overall, driven by a few high-performance successes. After netting out the bonuses and penalties, the Pioneer ACOs saved taxpayers a grand total of $17.89 million in 2012 and $43.36 million in 2013. All in, per capita spending was a mere 0.45% lower compared to ordinary fee for service Medicare.

Yet the upfront start-up investments for the pioneers (in administration, compliance and information technology) ran to $64 million, so at best the program is a wash. More to the point, the Medicare budget for 2013 was about $583 billion and these are supposed to be the most experienced providers. If most of them can’t succeed, what about the community hospitals that need the most improvement?

HHS runs a second ACO pilot for everybody else, with rewards but no penalties, called the Shared Savings program. Among those 114 ACOs, only 29 hit HHS’s financial targets in 2012. They saved $128 million and were paid $126 million in bonuses. In 2013, only 64 of 243 participants hit the targets.

The WSJ editors continue to cling bitterly to the illusion that market forces can bring down healthcare costs in the U. S.:

A better alternative would give patients the incentive and usable information about prices and value a la Paul Ryan’s defined-contribution Medicare reform. Doctors and hospitals will quickly adapt to compete for their business. That might mean ACOs or something else.

That might be true except that providers control both the supply and demand for healthcare. Revenues can be increased either by increasing the prices of individual services or by increasing the number of services prescribed. That’s no market.

The reality is that the fee-for-services model has fallen and it can’t get up. Under the model as it exists now almost all of the economic surplus is captured by producers while far too many patients can’t afford care. The PPACA with its healthcare exchanges has not improved on this. It has merely provided an illusion of improvement. For many people deductibles are unaffordably high.

Reform can no longer just nibble around the edges. It’s got to be a lot more basic than that.

7 comments