Debate Question

Here’s an interesting debate question.

Resolved: the greatest likelihood of nuclear war is in Asia.

Consider that in the context of this observation:

Military competition between China and the United States will not be the only struggle in Asia. China and India observe each other warily across the Himalayas and in the Indian Ocean. China and Japan are not only planning for conflict but maneuvering their forces against one another in the Western Pacific. Additionally, Japan and South Korea are developing capabilities to project power in response to other contingencies, which can possibly be seen as mutually threatening. The nations bordering the South China Sea are enhancing their ability to defend their maritime claims against China, but some have long histories of mutual mistrust.

Update

See also this article by John Mearsheimer:

The picture I have painted of what is likely to happen if China continues to rise is not a pretty one. Indeed, it is downright depressing. I wish I could tell a more hopeful story about the prospects for peace in Asia. But the fact is that international politics is a dangerous business, and no amount of goodwill can ameliorate the intense security competition that sets in when an aspiring hegemon comes on the scene in either Europe or Asia. And there is good reason to think China will eventually pursue regional hegemony.

I think that the situation is actually somewhat bleaker than the one he portrays. I think the greatest likelihood of a nuclear exchange is between Russia and China, India and Pakistan, or India and China, with the first two being far more likely.

5 comments

The Choice

In his Chicago Tribune column Steve Chapman does a pretty fair job of sketching Illinois’s problems:

Illinois has the worst public pension debt in the country. Its bonds have been downgraded so far that it faces the highest borrowing cost of any state. The nonpartisan Civic Federation says the state’s huge backlog of unpaid bills will grow this fiscal year, lamenting “a return to unsustainable fiscal practices.”

In a recent survey, Illinois got an “F” for “small business friendliness.” Moody’s Analytics predicted that this year it will have the lowest rate of job growth of the 50 states.

Quinn has taken commendable steps to improve the fiscal outlook, like trimming the state payroll, closing prisons and making the state’s required contributions to pension plans. But by raising the state personal income tax rate to 5 percent from 3 percent and the total corporate rate to 9.5 percent from 7.3 percent, he chilled an economic climate that was already locked in a polar vortex.

In its latest report, the Tax Foundation says Illinois’ state and local tax burden is the 13th heaviest in the nation, and Quinn would keep it that way. Having sold most of the income tax increase as temporary — on Jan. 1 it is scheduled to fall to 3.75 percent, one-fourth higher than the previous rate — he now proposes to make it permanent.

Actually, that only scratches the surface of Illinois’s problems. Illinois has the worst or second worst state contribution to education of any state in the union. It has the worst net rate of new business formation. It has the worst net level of outmigration. It has the third highest percentage of homes with negative equity, “underwater”. The only two states with high percentages, Nevada and Florida, had large runups in housing prices prior to 2007, something Illinois did not experience.

He summarizes the choice that faces Illinois voters:

A Rauner governorship, which could lead to a war with the legislature and public employee unions, would be a gamble on an unknown quantity. With Quinn, by contrast, Illinois voters know what they would be getting — and not getting.

Maybe they will be content to extend a dismal status quo that he seems unable to transform. Or maybe they will embrace the approach of Mae West. “Between two evils,” she said, “I always pick the one I never tried before.”

Something equally distressing is that the only complaint about Rauner that the Quinn campaign is airing in its negative ads against Rauner is that he utilized legal means to become rich. That’s not only feeble and one-sided but dangerous.

2 comments

The Emphasis

This little sound bite illustrates one of the biggest problems I have with the idea of Hillary Clinton as president:

At a Democratic rally in Massachusetts, Hillary Clinton’s attempt to attack “trickle-down economics,” resulted in a spectacularly odd statement.

Clinton defended raising the minimum wage saying “Don’t let anybody tell you that raising the minimum wage will kill jobs, they always say that.”

She went on to state that businesses and corporations are not the job creators of America. “Don’t let anybody tell you that it’s corporations and businesses that create jobs,” the former Secretary of State said.

The emphasis is mine. Without further qualification that remark is prime idiocy. When you rule out businesses as job creators there’s only one candidate left: government. Like most big businesses government at all levels hasn’t been a net job creator for decades.

What did she mean? What does she really think? We may never know.

Update

At Bloomberg Politics it’s been pointed out that Ms. Clinton’s statement above contradicts statements in Hard Choices. Clearly, the author of Hard Choices disagrees with Sec. Clinton’s assessment.

5 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Drawing the Wrong Conclusion

I usually have no interest in Tea Party stories but the comments section in this OTB post on the dismissal of a case brought by Tea Party-related groups against the IRS has gone so far off the rails that I think it deserves some note. The case wasn’t dismissed because the IRS was exonerated or the claims were found to be spurious. It was dismissed because the groups bringing the suit had already received their non-profit status and the IRS had said that it was sorry and wouldn’t do it again. The case was moot.

Whether it had merit or not was not addressed. It might. It might not. But, since there was no remedy for the groups’ grievances because the grievances had already been remediated, the case was declared moot.

6 comments

The Coalition of the Panic-Stricken

I think it’s high time we began a list of Americans who are panic-stricken about Ebola. Here’s a start:

Andrew Cuomo
Chris Christie (ibid.)
Connecticut Department of Health
Georgia’s DeKalb County School District
Maryland’s Montgomery County Public Schools (ibid.)
New York City Department of Health (ibid.)

Nominations for new candidates gratefully accepted.

3 comments

Another Second Derivative Effect?

The way I would define “deflation” is as a general decline in prices, an increase in the real value of money. A recent article at Business Insider warns of the dangers posed by deflation:

The risk of outright deflation in Europe with inflation at such low levels, and the danger of similar developments in the U.S., should not be minimized as inflation has fallen in almost every previous U.S. and European economic contraction. Lower inflation is, in fact, almost as much of a hallmark of recessions as is decreasing real GDP. From peak-to-trough the rate of CPI inflation fell by an average of slightly more than 300 basis points in and around the mild U.S. recessions of 1990-91 and 2000-01. Starting from a much lower point, the CPI in Europe at those same times dropped by an average of 150 basis points. Given that inflation is already so minimal in both the U.S. and Europe, even the mildest recession could put both economies in deflation.

I think there are a number of distinct issues being conflated in the article: deflation, disinflation, a change in the velocity of the money supply, and a decline in the value of capital assets.

I don’t know what things are like in Europe but I see few signs of deflation here in the United States. Oil prices that have fallen slightly do not constitute deflation and neither does a small decrease in the Dow. Healthcare prices, housing prices, food prices, and the prices of automobiles are all rising, both in dollar terms and relative to incomes. If that’s deflation, it’s of a sort very different from what I was taught in school.

2 comments

Be Careful What You Wish For

From time to time I’ve suggested that the Islamic Reformation, longed for by any number of poorly informed Western pundits, is already in progress and it’s developing much as the Protestant Reformation did in Europe. In Europe a major sign of that development was the Thirty Years’ War of the 17th century.

Similarly, some have wished for a Great Awakening, a major religious revival. That may already be under way:

Economist editors John Micklethwait and Adrian Wooldridge shocked the secular West in 2009 by announcing that God Is Back—starting with China, of all places. Here were two epitomes of British reasonableness explaining that Europe was the modern exception in viewing God as dead, an irrational shadow of the past, with its Continent declining in population and power, and the rest of the world resembling America in having religion as a part of their cultural dynamism.

[…]

China’s atheistic communist government conceded that its Christian population had doubled to 21 million over the past decade, worshiping in 55,000 official Protestant and 4,600 Catholic churches. The underground church, it’s widely known, was much larger—by foreign estimates perhaps 77 million, which means larger than the Communist Party. A Pew Global Attitudes study found only 11 percent of Chinese saying religion was not important in their lives, compared to 31 percent saying it was very or somewhat important. Indeed, everywhere the authors looked outside their European homeland, religion was booming in the early 21st century world.

Six in 10 Americans today tell Pew pollsters that religion plays a very important role in their lives. Over 80 percent believe in God or some higher power, with only four percent choosing agnosticism and merely two percent atheism. Only eight percent said they did not pray, as against 73 percent who said they prayed at least weekly, while 83 percent said God answered prayers. Sixty-three percent said they belonged to a church. The most recent Pew poll reflected some changes, with a plurality agreeing that gays had a right to marry, but a majority also thinking that homosexuality was sinful. Seventy-two percent agreed religion was “losing influence” in America but 56 percent of these thought that this was a bad thing.

What is often overlooked is international data. WIN-Gallup International statistics show that 59 percent of the world population says it is religious and only 13 percent is atheistic, almost all of the latter in China, Japan, the Czech Republic and France. The people of Africa, Latin America, India and Asia, and the Muslim world almost all consider themselves religious. Tempering the Micklethwait/Wooldridge thesis somewhat, even many in Europe say they believe in God (with Sweden registering the lowest polling number, apparently we ought to call it Secularism Central) and many Europeans also say they pray.

Religion is not only a very powerful force but one that’s very difficult to control. I think that’s why some Americans and many Europeans fear it.

6 comments

The One Sentence Answer

My goodness. Iliya Atanasov took 760 words to answer the question “Why public pension plans are left unfunded” that I can answer in a sentence. Public pensions are left unfunded because it’s cheaper to promise large pensions, make unrealistic assumptions, and not pay for the promised pensions than it is to either to pay for the pensions or increase the wages of public sector workers.

See how easy that was?

3 comments

Whistling Past a Graveyard

A world that is free from conscious intent and in which actions do not have consequences must come as a constant surprise. In a recent article the Economist laments that the United States isn’t more like Europe with compact cities and comprehensive mass transit:

In a paper* published in 1965, John Kain, an economist at Harvard University, proposed what came to be known as the “spatial-mismatch hypothesis”. Kain had noticed that while the unemployment rate in America as a whole was below 5%, it was 40% in many black, inner-city communities. He suggested that high and persistent urban joblessness was due to a movement of jobs away from the inner city, coupled with the inability of those living there to move closer to the places where jobs had gone, due to racial discrimination in housing. Employers might also discriminate against those that came from “bad” neighbourhoods. As a result, finding work was tough for many inner-city types, especially if public transport was poor and they did not own a car.

[…]

Some suggest that governments should encourage companies to set up shop in areas with high unemployment. That is a tall order: firms that hire unskilled workers often need to be near customers or suppliers. A better approach would be to help workers either to move to areas with lots of jobs, or at least to commute to them. That would involve scrapping zoning laws that discourage cheaper housing, and improving public transport. The typical American city dweller can reach just 30% of jobs in their city within 90 minutes on public transport. That is a recipe for unemployment.

Let me provide an alternative explanation.

Stage 1: There are many inner city jobs.

Stage 2: Blacks move into inner cities.

Stage 3: Jobs move out of inner cities.

Stage 4: The increase in new entry level workers represented by the Baby Boomers begins to come to an end.

Stage 5: The United States imports entry level workers, mostly from Mexico, to fill the gap.

I think I see a pattern emerging here. American businesses don’t want to hire blacks.

The obvious explanation is racism and I think that racism is a substantial component but it’s not the only component. Other components include mutual lack of cultural understanding and social pressure opposing cultural assimilation, just to name two. None of those problems are going to be solved by scattered site low cost housing or improved mass transit. Or by more immigration for that matter.

Just as a point of reference the last gasp of low-cost housing on the North Shore, a strip of SROs, was razed a decade ago. Anyone who thinks scatter site low cost housing is going to catch on is whistling past a graveyard.

16 comments