Weasel of the Week

The Watcher’s Council has announced its Weasel of the Week for last week. This week it’s CNN news anchor Carol Costello:

Although CNN News Anchor Carol Costello shouldn’t have a job after her disturbing antics, last week, she does deserve to be considered for the esteemed title of Weasel of the Week in my humble opinion.

In the shocking segment, Costello could barely contain her glee over hearing new audio of Bristol Palin describing her assault at a party in Alaska a few weeks ago. In fact, Costello called it “quite possibly the best minute and a half of audio we’ve ever come across.”

Costello then proceeded to describe the “massive brawl” and before playing the audio she told her viewers “so sit back and enjoy.”

My vote went to Erdogan but I can’t argue that Ms. Costello doesn’t deserve her award.

1 comment

The American Creed

There’s a reason that Americans regard the the Constitution as “as a quasi-religious document”. As G. K. Chesterton pointed out astutely a century ago, the United States is a country founded on a creed. We do not have a lengthy common history or blood ties or other forms of national identity to bind us together. Our tie is our common belief in the foundational ideas expressed in the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and later additions like Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address or his Second Inaugural.

Can we survive as a nation without that source of national identity? Is existence as a support system for Social Security and Medicare enough? Can the ethnically-based nations of Europe survive without that basis for national identity? We’re now engaged in a massive experiment and may soon find out.

1 comment

The Few, Bare Acorns

I’ve been rooting around in the columns, op-eds, and editorials of the last few days and have found it terribly difficult to come up with much more than a few, bare acorns. For example, here the editors of the Washington Post muse about the prospects for breaking the legislative lobjam that has rendered this Congress the least effective in enacting legislation of any in the last 150 years:

The roots of this election season’s discontent seem to lie not so much in the ebb and flow of events but instead in a spreading sense that national political institutions, beset with partisanship, no longer work well. In the Post-ABC poll, 60 percent said they do not trust Washington to do what is right. Some 53 percent say the federal government’s ability to deal with problems has gotten worse. In the CNN-ORC International poll, 74 percent of respondents said they were dissatisfied with the way the nation is being governed. These results, too, must be treated skeptically; voters blame politicians for gridlock but seldom acknowledge that elected representatives usually follow the wishes of their constituency.

For all of the whinging about the feckless Republican House, for my money there are not nearly enough complaints about Harry Reid’s Senate. Under Sen. Reid the Senate has transformed from the place where heated legislation goes to cool to where it goes to die. In order to avoid leaving fingerprints on legislation that could come back to haunt future Senate races, Sen. Reid has elected to end Senate deliberation by not bringing legislation to the floor—that is the enormous power of the Senate majority leader.

If the Republicans do manage to eke out a victory in the Senate we may have the opportunity to determine the source of the do-nothingness of our present do-nothing Congress.

1 comment

Panic or an Abundance of Caution?

The editors of the Chicago Tribune have entered the lists in support of what they’re calling “an abundance of caution” on the state of Illinois’s response to the question of handling a potential spread of Ebola:

Health officials around the country continue to scratch their heads about how these changing guidelines will work in practice. The public is left to … well, let’s not call it panic. People are not panicking. They are, though, worried and confused because the U.S. response consistently seems to be one step behind events.

Here are the measures they’ve come out in support of:

  • But if we’re going to err, let’s err on the side of caution. Given the lethality of Ebola and the virus’ 21-day incubation period, a quarantine rule for medical professionals and others who have had contact with the disease in those high-risk countries seems reasonable.
  • Given the high incidence in certain countries, a temporary travel and visa ban on visitors from those nations makes sense too. It could be structured without impeding the movement of health professionals to and from those countries.

but

Halting Ebola at the source — in West Africa — remains the key to ending this epidemic.

That’s my first priority. I think the other measures are somewhat of an overreaction but, contrary to the jibes of some, I think they’re an overreaction to real failings of our healthcare system.

The situation faced in authoritarian countries is ever so much simpler. In a liberal democratic republic like ours elected officials need to respond to political concerns if they want to keep their jobs. Note the number of governors who have put measures in place that go beyond the guidelines that the CDC has found supportable by science.

And “an abundance of caution” is not merely an American disease. The Australian government has imposed a travel ban between Australia and the West African countries in which most of the Ebola cases have occurred.

Let’s not take our eyes off the ball. Either this Ebola epidemic will burn itself out after killing who knows how many people as Ebola outbreaks have in the past or it will only be checked with help from developed countries. My own sense of prudence tells me that we should be taking more energetic efforts towards helping Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone deal with the epidemic.

Which means efforts on the part of our government, i.e. the American military, rather than relying on volunteers.

18 comments

Why Has Violent Crime Declined?

Heather MacDonald muses over why violent crime has declined so notably over the period of the last decade or so:

So what happened? No consensus exists. Favored explanations among criminologists include the collapse of the crack cocaine trade, a shrinking youth population, and a better job market, but none of these theories perfectly fit the data. The spread of New York–style policing and increased incarceration are better, but by no means exclusive, explanations for the national crime drop.

Another possible explanation she doesn’t mention: Kevin Drum’s pet theory that it’s due to the decline in the use of leaded gasoline.

I think it’s probably multi-factorial so looking for one silver bullet isn’t particularly useful.

Something else that goes unmentioned: it doesn’t support the idea that greater poverty and unemployment will lead to more violent crime.

1 comment

What Do You Do about the Security State?

If Sharyl Attkisson’s story can be taken at face value, it paints a picture of intolerable government intrusion. If the Congress isn’t all over this, what’s the cure?

9 comments

Mitigating Risk

I am shocked, shocked to see governors acting politically in the face of the risks, whatever they may be, posed by Ebola in this country. This morning there seems to be a pitched battle between those who think the governors of New York, New Jersey, Illinois, Maryland, and Virginia have acted injudiciously or prudently. At least they’re taking steps to mitigate risk.

That, I think, is one of the factors missing in the discussion of the conduct of Dr. Craig Spencer, the young physician who, after returning from a volunteer stint with Doctors Without Borders treating Ebola patients, tooled around New York before showing symptoms that he’d contracted the disease: did Dr. Spencer act to mitigate the risk he posed to others? This is a subject to which I’ve returned again and again here: different people have different perceptions of risks and rewards. These perceptions are not right or wrong; they are merely different and that should be taken into account. IMO doctors of medicine have a very different perception of risk than non-physicians.

BTW, I’m old enough to remember when skepticism rather than credulity was the hallmark of science. Those were the days! The word science is derived from the Latin word for knowledge. In the absence of greater knowledge as, for example, why several orders of magnitude more people are being infected by Ebola in West Africa than in any previous outbreak, I’m not quite sure how we can characterize what we think we know about the outbreak as science. There are just too many unknowns.

How do you mitigate the risks posed by Ebola? My view continues to be that the best way for us to mitigate those risks is by aiding Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone with public health problems that have grown beyond their ability to manage. We’ll need to act quickly. The virus is operating in those countries on virus time rather than U. S. federal government time. And it’s indifferent to the elections that take place here in a week.

60 comments

Writing With Blinders On

I am astonished that James Sherk can write about reduced labor demand without mentioning either automation or offshoring or increased labor supply without mentioning immigration.

How in the heck can you write about wage stagnation without mentioning most of the factors contributing to wage stagnation?

8 comments

And Then It’s On to 2016

The general election will be held one week from tomorrow and much of the suspense will be over, except in the run-off states. Although I have been predicting that Democrats will hold the Senate for the better part of the last year, I now doubt that will be the outcome. It’s not just the Republicans’ advantages—the favorable election map, a midterm, the midterm of a president of the opposite party’s second term. It’s that I just don’t see the Democrats rallying to overcome those advantages as I thought they would.

As things look today after the elections a week from Tuesday Republicans are likely to hold 49 seats outright. Two seats are toss-ups (Colorado and Kansas) and are likely to go into run-offs (Georgia and Louisiana). When the dust has settled the Republicans will take an additional two seats, Colorado and Louisiana which will give them control of the Senate.

The more interesting question is what they’ll do with control of the Congress and on that subject I have no idea. I would hope that the new Republican leadership would be gracious in victory as I hope the president would be gracious in defeat but, sadly, I think that both of those are long shots.

What do you think the outcome of the November elections will be? Which party will control the Senate? If it’s the Republicans, what will they do and how will the president respond?

14 comments

Your Regulatory Capture Story of the Day

“Regulatory capture” is the process by which regulatory agencies come to be dominated by the industries they’re supposed to be regulating. Examples of regulatory capture include the Federal Reserve, the SEC, and the FCC. One of today’s big news stories revolves around regulatory capture by the automobile industry of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, the recalls due to exploding airbags:

The Department of Transportation will conduct a review of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which has been criticized for its handling of the Takata airbag recall this past week, as well as other recalls this year, a senior administration official told ABC News.

The airbags, made by Japanese auto supplier Takata, are blamed for at least three deaths and more than 100 injuries.

“The roll out of the safety advisory by NHTSA was not optimal, but what is most important right now is that a NHTSA-led investigation uncovered a very serious defect,” a DOT spokesperson said. “Impacted vehicle owners should have their cars immediately checked by their manufacturers. This investigation is far from over and we will leave no stone unturned in the interest of public safety.”

Regulators had allowed a recall limited to areas of the country with “high humidity,” but some lawmakers are now calling for an immediate nationwide recall of millions of potentially faulty airbags.

“There needs to be a real overhaul of the National Highway Transit Safety agency,” said Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., one of the lawmakers who has criticized the limited recall.

“These exploding airbags can be killers,” he said. “They literally have killed people.”

So far there have been at least four deaths and how knows how much injury and destruction as a consequence of the airbags and NHTSA’s phlegmatic response is clearly attributable to the cozy relationship between the agency and the automobile industry. as Sen. Blumenthal, quoted above, asserted.

Regulatory capture was a factor in the Gulf Oil spill. It is so prevalent it would make a good topic for a specialized blog rather than just a post or two. It is not benign. It has resulted in the deaths of Americans and the destruction of property and the wrecking of lives. As Sen. Blumenthal noted it is not a problem that can be solved by increasing the sizes of the budgets of the agencies involved or by expanding their power. It requires a change in culture.

2 comments