Pensions

There’s an article at The Guardian on the pension cliff the U. S. is facing that you might find worth reading. It’s not just public pensions that are problematic. It’s that Americans just haven’t been saving enough and the condition has persisted for a very long time.

Social Security retirement benefits were never intended to provide a prosperous retirement, merely to prevent absolute penury in old age. Although many in my parent’s generation could depend on company or union pensions in their old age, that day has long passed. When he died at a relatively young age and far from old, my dad had nothing set aside for his retirement and with multiple kids to put through college few prospects for doing so. I presume that he intended to work forever but when he died that left my mom in something of a fix.

I’ve already argued my opinion here: Social Security is here to stay for a multitude of reasons that are not merely political. Not only do I think that it’s impractical for most people to save enough to avoid penury in old age (do the math: assume less than 1% return on your savings) I think it would be disastrous for an economy that is largely dependent on consumer spending. Sure, there would be more saving. What guarantees that would be invested in the U. S. of A.?”

However, let’s turn to another question and just in time for President’s Day! It is time to revisit presidential pensions? I think it is.

The move towards granting former presidents substantial pensions began when U. S. Grant died destitute largely through having made bad investments. His widow was left with very little other than the royalties for his memoirs, paid generously by Sam Clemens, the former president’s friend and publisher.

It’s a lot different today than it was 150 years ago and former presidents earn millions through book sales and the modern day equivalent of the 19th century lecture circuit. They don’t really need us any more. Add to that few of today’s presidents are exactly paupers when they enter the presidency. Seeking the presidency has never been more of a rich man’s game than it is right now. Why pay them a pension?

0 comments

Finding the Right Policy

I recommend you read Robert VerBruggen’s disquisition on Peter Wallison’s latest book which takes the position that government actions caused the financial crisis, a subject we’ve discussed around here from time to time. Here’s the meat of Mr. Wallison’s argument:

The story begins in 1992, when the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) decided to impose affordable-housing goals on “government-sponsored enterprises” (GSEs) Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, institutions that buy mortgages and securitize them to provide liquidity to the market. Historically, Fannie and Freddie had been rather conservative about the loans they acquired, insisting on sizable down payments, good credit histories, and reasonable debt-to-income ratios.

At first the change wasn’t a big deal. In fact, the initial goal–that 30 percent of the GSEs’ loans be to borrowers below the median income of the area they lived in–was below what the GSEs were already doing. There’s nothing inherently wrong with loaning to these “LMI” (low- or moderate-income) borrowers, so long as they demonstrate an ability to pay and a history of meeting their credit obligations.

But the goals, which covered several other categories besides LMI, quickly ramped up. By 2001–at which point the bubble had been expanding for about four years, judging by the Case-Shiller index of home prices–the LMI goal reached 50 percent, and in 2008 it was 56 percent. The goals certainly seemed to work: The GSEs’ loans to the targeted categories closely tracked the percentages they were required to meet.

Wallison does a terrific job of documenting how much of a struggle it was to find enough qualified borrowers. A 2003 Fannie presentation noted that, in the scramble to meet the previous year’s goal, the GSEs “did deals at risks and prices we would not have otherwise done.” Two years later, in another presentation, Fannie complained about “having to compromise credit standards,” deals that were “producing negative cash flow,” and exotic products that “encourage[] continuation of risky lending.”

However, there’s a counterargument, too, something I’ve mentioned occasionally:

Min has noted, for example, that while the federal government owned or guaranteed 67 percent of all mortgages, it was responsible for just 32 percent of serious delinquencies–while private-label securities generated 13 percent of loans and 42 percent of serious delinquencies. Similarly, at a recent event for Wallison’s book, Moody’s analyst Mark Zandi pointed out that, relative to debt outstanding, realized losses on residential mortgages at Fannie and Freddie were just 3 to 4.5 percent, compared with 6 percent for banks and 23 percent for private-label securities. Jason Thomas of the Carlyle Group has written that, while Fannie and Freddie imploded and needed to be placed into conservatorship, had they “simply been required to hold equity capital in roughly the same proportion that banks are, shareholders would have absorbed all of the losses.”

It seems to me that there’s a counter-counterargument. As house prices rose it might be the case that the ever-larger loans became increasingly difficult to secure and that the bubble ended when the market “froze” for lack of ability to purchase the stock that was coming onto the market. I don’t know that’s the case but it would certainly be an interesting avenue for someone to research.

I don’t want to dwell on the “who shot John?” aspect of this question but to turn to a different aspect. What was the actual policy objective of the government’s actions and did they succeed? It seems to me that if the objective was to make lower income people homeowners it was only partially successful and it was a byzantine way of accomplishing the objective. If that were the objective, why not just give them houses?

If, on the other hand, the objective was to saddle lower income people with debt, it was wildly successful and the project is still in full swing in the form of educational loans.

Finally, if the objective was to inculcate financial responsibility in lower income people, it was a complete flop. It might even have been counterproductive. I would go on to question the legitimacy of federal government projects to make better people not just from a moral standpoint but from a practical one. You can improve the human condition but humans are not perfectible and projects intended to solve human problems by perfecting human beings are doomed to failure.

5 comments

The Non-Event

Early voting has started in the Chicago mayoral election and I am being absolutely deluged with robocalls. They’re coming in at the rate of from one to four an hour. I honestly don’t know why. Everybody knows the outcome already.

Emanuel will be re-elected. There might be a run-off. In fact there’s likely to be a run-off with five candidates, each with his own constituency. Based on current polls of registered voters certain to vote in the election, Emanuel has 42%, Cook County Commissioner Chuy Garcia has 18%, Alderman Bob Fioretti has 10%, Willie Wilson has 7%, and Dock Walls has 2%. I’m not even sure that one or more of the candidates pulling out and throwing his support behind Emanuel will avoid a run-off. In some sense every other candidate is an anti-Emanuel protest candidate.

He only won by 55% when he was first elected. In Chicago terms that’s a squeaker.

0 comments

Disagreement About Public Pensions

There’s a post I found genuinely interesting at Reason.com on the gulf that separates most people’s opinions about public pensions from those held by public workers. I recommend reading the whole thing.

Here in Illinois I believe the issue is moot. Under the state’s constitution the legislature doesn’t have the power to correct a problem that’s completely out of control. As I see it there are only two, equally politically impossible solutions: amend the state’s constitution or stagger along until the state takes the unprecedented step of declaring bankruptcy.

2 comments

Corruption in the City That Works

I think that my views on political corruption are more like those of Alexander Hamilton as quoted in this post by Jay Cost than it is like Jay’s. Take my home town of Chicago (please!).

The late Mayor Daley didn’t call Chicago “the city that works” because it was free of corruption. It was because public corruption was the lubrication that enabled the city’s competing factions to coexist peacefully. Our problem in Chicago isn’t corruption. It’s greed and stupidity. Chicago just doesn’t have the ability to allow public officials or public employees to live like the contemporary equivalent of the Swifts and Armours and they’re chafing under that restriction. There’s a saying from an old folk tale that covers the situation nicely: killing the goose that lays the golden eggs.

0 comments

The Shadow of Scott Walker in Illinois

Well, that’s interesting. Illinois’s newly inaugurated Gov. Bruce Rauner has thrown down the gauntlet:

Moving beyond rhetoric, Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner on Monday issued an executive order that aims at absolving state workers who don’t want to join a union from paying fees that support collective bargaining.

The new governor’s decree effectively attempts to impose right-to-work rules on public employees, an idea Rauner and his pro-business allies also are pursuing for private-sector unions.

My first question is whether Gov. Rauner is acting within his powers in doing this? I’d welcome opinions on that.

It seems to me that there are three questions: the governor’s powers under the state constitution, his powers under statute, and the contents of the state’s contracts with its public employees’ unions.

It appears that I’m not the only one raising these questions:

Anticipating a strong pushback from organized labor, Rauner filed a pre-emptive federal lawsuit in Chicago seeking to have his decision declared legal. But the move likely will spark additional court battles as unions quickly decried the effort as an illegal abuse of power. It’s also possible Democratic lawmakers could vote to overturn Rauner’s executive order.

Under state law, employees can decline to join a union but are still on the hook for “fair share” fees related to collective bargaining and contract negotiations. The idea is that if all employees are getting the benefits from a new contract, everyone should contribute to the cost.

Illinois statute prohibits those fees from being used to support political activities, but Rauner contended it’s nearly impossible to draw a distinction because public sector unions directly negotiate with the government.

Indiana’s former Gov. Mitch Daniels led the way on this back in 2005 and it will be interesting to see how this works out. This is totally consistent with the remarks Gov. Rauner made in his State of the State address, namely that if Illinois is to compete with its neighbors conditions here must be brought more into line with those that prevail among our neighbors.

There’s more commentary on this story at memeorandum.

Update

Wisconsin resident Ann Althouse notes the temperate reaction to the governor’s move from the Illinois Democratic leadership:

Explain the calmness: 1. The Democrats have the majority, so they’ll be in control and need to plot a careful response, 2. The Democrats feel vulnerable in the next election cycle, and Rauner is shining a light on what actually is something of a “corrupt bargain… crushing taxpayers,” and an intemperate reaction would make them look guilty, 3. They know the budget needs hard work, and they rather appreciate Rauner’s taking the front line against the unions, 4. All of the above/something else?

I’d pick door #1 except that I’d stop with “The Democrats have the majority”. Democrats have a super-majority in both houses of the Illinois legislature. It’s well within their power to block anything Gov. Rauner does. Why be intemperate? They have nothing to worry about.

4 comments

The End of the Affair

David Ignatius, the augur of the prevailing Washington wisdom, advises caution on continuing diplomacy with Iran. After hearing assertions from both the Iranian foreign minister and President Obama that extending talks past late March would not seem to serve any purposes, he notes:

The seeming impasse raises an unpleasant but essential question: What should the United States and Iran do if the talks fail? My answer would be that, at least initially, both sides would be wise to do nothing. It’s like a labor negotiation where both parties conclude that it’s in their interest to keep working by the old rules even after a contract has expired.

which echoes the observations I’ve made here. He goes on to explain the distance between the two parties on just one of the issues that divide them, the issue of sanctions.

It seems to me that these talks were wildly premature. Can diplomacy succeed in an environment of such mutual mistrust as exists between the United States and Iran? Or when each perceives the others loss as a gain? Those are questions not answers. I’d genuinely like to know more.

There is one thing that puzzles me. See this statement from Mr. Ignatius:

Iranians seem convinced that, with the rise of the terrorist Islamic State, the United States needs Iran’s help in Iraq. But the counterargument could also be made: Iran has chaos on its borders; a rupture in the talks would leave it fighting multiple enemies, with no reliable allies.

Is the rise of DAESH in Iran’s interests or not? If DAESH’s rise is in Iran’s interest (hard for me to fathom), why would they oppose them? To get a few sanctions lifted? To curry U. S. favor? If DAESH’s rise is not in their interest, do they really need negotiations with the U. S. to oppose it? Using something you already plan to do as a negotiating chip to gain further advantage is a time-honored strategy, cf. the recent U. S.-China agreement on global warming.

0 comments

The Shortcomings of the President’s Remarks

Eugene Robinson, neither a Republican shill nor enemy of the president, explains the shortcomings of the president’s controversial remarks that the prayer breakfast:

By reaching so far back into history, Obama seemed to echo those who argue that today’s turmoil and terrorism are taking place because Islam has not yet had a Reformation or the Muslim world an Enlightenment. I won’t put words in the president’s mouth. But I will say that, whatever he meant, to compare the depredations of the Islamic State with those of the Crusaders is patronizing in the extreme.

Why? Because Muslims are not slow learners who can be held to only a medieval moral standard. Everyone in the world can be expected to know that it is wrong to burn a helpless human being alive, as Islamic State murderers did to a captive Jordanian pilot. The fact that Joan of Arc met a similar fate in 1431 does not make it improper to “get on our high horse” about unspeakable acts being committed in our time, which makes them our responsibility.

We need to enlist the support of the Muslim community and we won’t do that by absolving them, patronizing them, or trying to insulate them. Anything that allows the greater Muslim community, particularly in Western countries, to remain neutral in the war against DAESH is a strategic error.

8 comments

Duel of the Titans

Nobel Memorial Award in Economics? Check. Best-selling author? Check. In the New York Times Robert Shiller remarks on the role of what fellow award recipient and best-selliung economist has referred to as “the uncertainty fairy”:

Anyone can tell you that there is no certainty about the effect that new technologies will have on job security in coming decades: There is a risk, but it is hard to quantify for general categories of jobs, and nearly impossible to calculate for individuals. Yet these concerns have effects on investor decision-making through the emotional component of our actions — what John Maynard Keynes, the great British economist, called our animal spirits.

Uncertainties about individual economic fortunes can affect asset prices through an important indirect channel, government policy, which is swayed by popular concerns. Raghuram Rajan, governor of the Reserve Bank of India, in his book “Fault Lines: How Hidden Fractures Still Threaten the World Economy” (Princeton 2010) argued that governments were more tolerant of excessive credit expansion when their citizens were upset about rising inequality. Governments, he said, use expanded credit in a desperate effort to placate a dissatisfied electorate. Credit expansion can create housing bubbles and an illusion of wealth for many people, for a while, at least. The idea is: “Let them eat credit.”

But with rising anxiety about our economic lives and about the state of the markets, we need something more substantial than credit expansion to help us. We all need to think hard about the underlying mechanisms producing individual uncertainty and inequality, and we need to devise financial and insurance plans to help us to deal with whatever looms ahead.

I found a becoming modesty in Dr. Shiller’s op-ed viz.:

There is a great deal that we don’t know about market movements. Interest rates and prices generally reach extreme levels when there is an unusual confluence of many precipitating factors, like anxiety, and others as well. We are usually puzzled by this multiplicity.

And, because markets are really not very efficient, the effect of these varied factors tends to be amplified through emotional feedback.

How do you foster confidence? There are all sorts of ways. A less confrontational Congress. A less activist executive with a greater relish for doing whatever’s necessary to work with the Congress. Modesty would be a good start. Or maybe instituting rules-based regimes rather than the goggles and white scarf approach to economic planning we’ve engaged in for the last couple of decades would be a start.

0 comments

Our Policy on Ukraine

At the New York Times John Measheimer urges a different policy on our part with respect to Ukraine:

The only way to solve the Ukraine crisis is diplomatically, not militarily. Germany’s chancellor, Angela Merkel, seems to recognize that fact, as she has said Germany will not ship arms to Kiev. Her problem, however, is that she does not know how to bring the crisis to an end.

She and other European leaders still labor under the delusion that Ukraine can be pulled out of Russia’s orbit and incorporated into the West, and that Russian leaders must accept that outcome. They will not.

To save Ukraine and eventually restore a working relationship with Moscow, the West should seek to make Ukraine a neutral buffer state between Russia and NATO. It should look like Austria during the Cold War. Toward that end, the West should explicitly take European Union and NATO expansion off the table, and emphasize that its goal is a nonaligned Ukraine that does not threaten Russia. The United States and its allies should also work with Mr. Putin to rescue Ukraine’s economy, a goal that is clearly in everyone’s interest.

If any of that sounds familiar it might be because it’s very consistent with what I’ve been arguing here since the onset of the crisis. That and that I don’t understand why we’re supporting a neo-Nazi junta in Kiev in the chronically corrupt Ukraine.

I doubt that we can reverse course that way but it might be fun to outline a drastically different approach to foreign policy than we’ve used for the last several decades. First, identify a desired, stable end state. Then figure out the steps we’d need to take to get there. Finally, take the steps.

What’s the stable outcome in Ukraine? I think it’s the one the Mr. Mearsheimer has delineated but let’s not stop there. What’s the stable, desired end state in Iran? I don’t think we can have an acceptable not to mention stable end state in Iran that doesn’t involve replacing the theo-fascist regime in charge there with something that’s at least minimally more congenial. Do the talks move events in that direction or into the opposite direction?

How about DAESH? What’s the stable end state? And how can it be effected?

25 comments