Untouched By Human Hands

There’s quite a bit of chortling going on at the New York Times’s expense over an editorial that repeatedly refers to Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker as “Mr. Scott”. What occurred to me when I saw that is that this is what happens when you’ve got a computer program enforcing the Times’s style rules and the editorial writer consistently wrote “Scott” (as I understand is commonplace in the Wisconsin papers) in reference to the governor.

0 comments

More on the Time-Warner/Comcast Merger

While I wasn’t paying attention to it, the FCC’s latest moves may have doomed the merger between Time-Warner and Comcast:

So why is the Comcast-Time Warner Cable deal doomed? Even before the FCC decided to change how it regulates broadband service providers, the commission redefined what qualifies as a high-speed Internet connection — from 4 megabits per second to at least 25 megabits per second for downloads. Here’s the significance of the new definition: If speeds don’t hit that benchmark, an Internet service provider isn’t allowed to call the connection “broadband.” (The average connection speed in the U.S. is about 10 megabits per second.)

This new standard completely redrew the U.S. market-share map because only cable operators like Comcast, as well as other companies such as Verizon FiOS, AT&T U-Verse and Google Fiber, can currently meet that standard. In this new world, the broadband end of the Internet services spectrum is dominated by just a handful of companies. In the regulatory world, market dominance translates into a lack of competition.

That’s a bitter pill for Comcast, because it’s been saying that there is so much competition for Internet services that consumers have plenty of options before them. Hence, a merger with Time Warner Cable wouldn’t be anti-competitive. The FCC just redefined that notion into oblivion.

It will be interesting to see whether that analysis pans out and what its implications might be for the shape of the Internet service business and its relation to content providers. As I’ve said any number of times, I think that government-granted monopolies (like cable companies) should be barred from the content business but I seem to be in the minority in that view. The whole “net neutrality” issue has certainly created strange bedfellows with anarcho-capitalists rising to the defense of government-granted monopolies while big government fans point out the evils that have been created by big, activist government.

5 comments

The Hangover

In an analysis at Bloomberg, Justin Fox notes “where the jobs aren’t”:

Even as the economy as a whole was beginning to add jobs in 2010, government — with the exception of a temporary federal hiring spurt for the 2010 Census — was shedding them. Local governments, which have more employees than the states and the federal government combined, had shed 448,000 jobs by June 2013.

The problem with his observation is his horizon. If you change the horizon you’re looking at to consider 2006 to date, you see a somewhat different different picture. Until the late recession state and local governments were on a spending spree. State and local governments have been trimming their payroll back from their peak in 2009 until today they’re just a bit higher than they were in 2006.

IMO the question that should be considered is how many state and local jobs should there be? The metric I’d propose is that the number of state and local employees should rise with income first, population second. That’s a practical necessity for state and local government, most of which are required by law to balance their budgets.

In other words if you want more state and local government employees, you should want incomes to rise.

4 comments

246 Varieties

Charles de Gaulle is said to have remarked “How can you govern a country that has two hundred forty-six varieties of cheese?” I think the question might be asked equally of a country that has 607,380 bridges:
Overall, 98.7 percent of roads get 43 percent of the spending, while the newly built 1.3 percent of roads get 57 percent. As Angie Shmitt pointed out on Streetsblog USA, the math just doesn’t work there.

Calling for more infrastructure spending sounds great, and makes an easy sound bite, but without a coherent plan and sense of priorities, all the money in the world won’t fix what ails America’s roads.

The position I’ve tried to stake out here is that local travellers are in a much better position to determine what roads and bridges need repair than bureaucrats in Washington (or economists in New York) and one way to measure that is by what they’re willing to pay for. The civil engineers’ report is pretty frequently cited by those pointing out how much work there is to be done but the civil engineers are interested parties and tread a fine line between what might be done and what is worth doing.

0 comments

Nature Is Complicated

Well, here’s an interesting hypothesis:

How are seafloor volcanic eruptions affected by Earth’s motion around the sun? New research suggests the planet’s volcanism is inextricably linked to sea levels, which, in turn, are directly linked to minute fluctuations in Earth’s orbit around the sun.

As a result of these variations in the frequency of their eruptions, underwater volcanoes might have a greater impact on Earth’s climate cycle than current predictive models estimate.

“People have ignored seafloor volcanoes on the idea that their influence is small, but that’s because they are assumed to be in a steady state, which they’re not,” Maya Tolstoy, a marine geophysicist with the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory of Columbia University, reportedly said.

Yet another factor which will need to be factored into climate change models. Nature is complicated.

2 comments

The Shoes Begin to Fall

I see that as I predicted Amy Pascal’s tenure as co-chairman of Sony Pictures has come to an end:

Amy Pascal is leaving her position as co-chairman of Sony Pictures Entertainment to start a new production venture within the company, the company announced Thursday. Pascal’s job has been the source of speculation since hackers released a trove of internal Sony email in which she made racially insensitive jokes about U.S. President Barack Obama.

Pascal, 56, was highly regarded in Hollywood before the Nov. 24 Sony hack shed light on her acerbic private conversations with producer Scott Rudin. In the messages the pair joke that Obama’s favorite movies include “Django Unchained,” “12 Years a Slave” and others that focus on race.

Pascal will launch her operation within Sony starting in May. She explained in a press release from Sony Pictures that she and Sony CEO Michael Lynton have long discussed moving her into a producer role. They have worked together for the past decade, with Lynton handling the business and financial decisions at the studio and Pascal keeping tabs on the creative side.

The emphasis in the IBT article is on the personal but I’d bet a shiny new dime that if the problems at Sony Pictures had been limited to a few racist emails she’d still have her job. The problems are manifest and include a culture that ignored data security, puzzling when so much of the company’s property is online.

I expect she won’t be the last.

0 comments

The Elephant in the Room

I see that Steve Chapman noticed the same thing I did about Gov. Rauner’s first State of the State address:

Bruce Rauner, the new Republican governor, gave a State of the State address Wednesday that mysteriously failed to address the state’s huge public employee pension debt. It’s like a biography of George Custer that omits Little Bighorn.

The chance of success is about as small as Custer’s. Illinois has a bigger unfunded obligation than any state in the country, exceeding $100 billion and, by some estimates, as high as $250 billion. It has attained that distinction by failures like skipping contributions and assuming the economic good times would never end.

He concludes:

Rauner has talked about moving state workers into defined-contribution 401(k)-style pension programs. But that option does nothing to lighten the vast obligations that have already been incurred. And there is a good chance the state courts would disallow it because it would leave these workers with something less than they were promised when they were hired.

Nearly every state has followed the same basic policy of making promises today and letting someone figure out how to pay for them years from now. Illinois may be on the road to ruin, but it’s just the lead car in a long parade, passing every exit.

As I have been saying for some time the courts are likely to reject any plan from the state legislature that requires paying present public workers less than they were promised other than in a bankruptcy proceedings, something that would be unprecedented at the state level. Illinois has a limited array of alternatives: higher taxes which will be paid by fewer individuals and companies since both are leaving the state at a rapid clip, greater economic growth which it’s hard to see happening with a legislature whose only solution is raising taxes or a nationwide boom that doesn’t appear to be materializing, or cutting everything else the state spends money on as far as is necessary, possibly to zero.

5 comments

Where Do You Draw the Line?

Let me start this post with a confession. Just about everything that Fareed Zakaria (or Tom Friedman for that matter) writes nettles me. Given that confession, I have a question about Mr. Zakaria’s most recent column:

The many recent acts of terror committed in Europe don’t have behind them a coherent strategy. But they could make European governments and people treat all Muslims in Europe as suspicious and dangerous — and then the jihadis and terrorists will have achieved an important goal.

He’s warning against overreaction.

Here’s my question: where do you draw the line between reaction and overreaction? There is an English language adage that’s at least a half millennium old with which Mr. Zakaria may not be familiar: give him an inch and he’ll take an ell. Under-reaction promotes further aggression.

I have made no secret of my opinion that we reacted wrongly in response to the attacks on 9/11. However, it was not an overreaction. An overreaction would have been, as I heard asserted in the aftermath of the attacks, that we should nuke every Arab capitol.

If anything invading Afghanistan and Iraq and taking the measures towards security at home and stopping the financing of terrorism abroad were an underreaction in that they did not accomplish the objectives they were purportedly intended to accomplish. So here’s my reaction: how you draw the line between a reaction and an overreaction?

3 comments

The Lady or the Tiger?

Peter Berkowitz makes a point that I hope is not lost in the shouting. At some point the American Left will need to choose between multiculturalism of the sort that not long ago led President Obama to draw a strained equivalence between European Christians a millennium ago and DAESH today and the defense of freedom, justice, and victim peoples:

To March’s argument that as a leftist, Walzer should forthrightly oppose the massive state violence directed at the Islamists, Walzer responds that “the left-wing anti-communism of Dissent in its early years” was subject to analogous criticism. But many of those who apologized for or defended Stalin, Walzer trenchantly observes, “went on to defend or apologize for third-world dictators who call themselves anti-imperialists and for terrorists who call themselves liberators — and now for Islamist zealots.”

While March prefers to dwell on the crimes of the West and boasts of his belief in reform arising from within the Islamic world, Walzer counters with a hard fact: “the America he [March] excoriates is right now the only force effectively opposing or, at least, containing, the power of ISIS and therefore the beheadings and the mass executions and the enslavement of Yazidi girls.”

Which will it be? The lady or the tiger?

10 comments

A Competitive Race

Larry Sabato et al. point out what should be obvious—that regardless of who the Democratic or Republican presidential nominees are it’s likely to be a competitive race:

It appears that the GOP will have one of the largest, and probably the largest, field of candidates in modern presidential history (while Democrats have one of the smallest). Intense competition can invigorate a party, but the dangers of corrosive factionalism are substantial—and the current Republican Party is faction-ridden.
All that said, some might put a pinkie on the scale for the GOP at this very early moment. Why? Primarily because American politics is cyclical, and our recurrent history makes an argument for turnover at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
Running for a third consecutive presidential party term probably does exact a penalty on the incumbent’s party. Dan McLaughlin, writing at the conservative website The Federalist, looked at the 11 elections conducted since the end of the Civil War when there was no incumbent on the ballot and an incumbent had been reelected in the previous election (which is what we’ll have in 2016). He found that the incumbent party lost an average of 6.9 percent of the two-party vote in the next election. So, subtract 6.9 percent from Obama’s 2012 share of 52 percent, and the Republican wins the presidency quite easily—though in today’s polarized America such a significant shift from one election to the next doesn’t seem very likely.

In the post-war period once having elected a president except in the case of presidents who are obviously poorly-suited for the job, e.g. Carter, Americans are predisposed to re-elect him but not predisposed to award the president’s party a third term however qualified the candidate put forward might be.

That doesn’t mean that the Democratic candidate will inevitably lose or the Republican candidate inevitably win. It means that if the Democrats put forward a strong candidate whether the Republicans have a strong or weak candidate it’s likely to be a competitive race and if the Democrats put forward a weak one it could turn into a rout.

Over the next two years I think we’re likely to hear a lot of attempts at defining weak as strong and vice versa but I hope that Democrats don’t kid themselves into believing that whatever candidate they put forward is a shoe-in. It ain’t necessarily so and history suggest it is not so.

3 comments