I Wish He Hadn’t Said That

With friends like Dean Obeidallah, Islam does not need enemies. In a post at The Daily Beast he writes

Look, there’s no such thing as “radical Islam.” There is only one Islam. But there are radical Muslims. And there are Muslims who engage in terrorist acts

There are plenty of other bloopers in the post but that’s the one that nettled me. Consider this from Pew Research on opinion in the Muslim world:

In most countries where the survey asked Muslims questions about religious extremism more than 75% say suicide bombing or other violence against civilians is rarely or never justified.

But substantial minorities in several countries think violence against civilians is at least sometimes justified

In Egypt, a country with a population of 82 million, that minority numbers about 24 million people. In Bangladesh, a country of 156 million, the number is 41 million. Using rough numbers of about a quarter of the total number of Muslims in the world that would mean that about 400 million Muslims believe in using violence against civilians. If even 1% of those who say that are willing to put their beliefs into practice that means there are 4 million “radical Muslims”. And that’s assuming that those who say they oppose the use of violence are telling the truth. The phenomenon of people telling pollsters what they think the pollster wants to hear is well-documented.

If anything that supports the view that those in the West who are alarmed about violent Muslims are being prudent.

His example from the United States is the Klu Klux Klan. Is he seriously contending that a quarter of Americans today sympathize with the KKK? That requires more than a blithe assertion. I think it’s a baldfaced lie.

Additionally, I think that there’s a debate going on in the West. If there is only “one Islam” but a substantial proportion of Muslims profess a belief in political violence to achieve their ends, how is that to be reconciled with the claims of the others that they don’t? If those who don’t refuse to characterize those who do as unIslamic, what should we believe?

29 comments

Who Bears the Risk?

In Megan McArdle’s most recent post, on the gap between the jobs that millennials want and those that are available, she nibbles around the edges of an important insight without apparently realizing it:

Millennials don’t want to work in sales, reports the Wall Street Journal. They think it’s exploitative. They also hate the idea of variable compensation; they want a nice, steady job where the company takes the risk, not the worker.

The insight is not that millennials don’t want to work in sales. It’s that they are risk averse. That explains a long list of issues including the very low rate of new business formation.

Who bears the risk? That’s a question that underpins a lot of the pressing questions before us from healthcare to education to foreign policy to the nature of work. Companies aren’t training their employees because they want to offload that risk onto their employees; people aren’t moving for jobs they way they used to because they don’t want to bear the risk. The UAE has stopped participating in the bombing runs against DAESH because they think the risks to their pilots are too great. That’s also the issue behind President Obama’s plan for funding higher education: he wants to offload the risk from the millennials to somebody else.

Before you ask me to bear your risks, the very first question you should ask is what’s in it for me? I already know what’s in it for you.

13 comments

Other People’s Problems

What continues to baffle me about our foreign policy is that what’s garnering the most attention are other people’s problems while we continue to ignore the problems that we have with other countries that are distinctly our own.

0 comments

Changing the Subject

The reaction of the editors at Bloomberg’s reaction to the recent Republican healthcare reform plan reminds me of one of Samuel Johnson’s famous wisecracks: “Sir, a woman’s preaching is like a dog’s walking on his hind legs. It is not done well; but you are surprised to find it done at all.”

I don’t have any particular fondness for the Republicans’ plan. I do wonder when the Democratic talking point will change from “they don’t have a plan” to “their plan doesn’t add up”. Maybe that won’t be the line of attack since it might highlight the reality that the PPACA doesn’t add up, either. How about “look at how many people will be hurt!”

It will change the subject, though.

My objection to the Republican plan is the same as the reason for my disappointment with the PPACA: neither one addresses the most pressing problem with healthcare, i.e. the increase in the cost of healthcare continues to outstrip the increases in revenues and the increases in income which practically by definition means it’s not affordable. As Uwe Reinhardt put it, it’s the prices, stupid.

2 comments

Opportunities Wanted

I think there are problems with Mike Cassidy’s interpretation of the seeming conflict between the large number of unemployed and the large number of job openings:

In other words, based on historical patterns, we’d expect the level of job openings we see today to produce a lower unemployment rate than the one we have. The job market should be better than it is. –

This disconnect — persistent unemployment and underemployment despite lots of vacancies — has fueled debates among economists. Some see it as proof that the workforce lacks the skills employers value, while others take it as evidence that demand for the products and services American companies make has not recovered as fully as we’d like to think. Which side of this debate you fall on will dictate your policy preferences; for example, those in the former camp generally oppose fiscal and monetary stimulus, while those in the latter support it.

There’s another possibility that Mr. Cassidy ignores but which should be obvious to anyone who’s ever hired anyone: a lot of the jobs on offer are phantoms. There are companies, particularly large companies, who are fishing for bargains. I’d summarize it this way. When you offer to buy quarters for a nickel apiece, the only people who’ll sell you their quarters are those who are really desperate to get rid of them.

I also think that the large number of two-career households has something to do with it. Not only does it mean there are fewer people really desperate to get rid of their quarters but it also means that people are less likely to move to where the jobs are than they used to be. The opportunity would need to be pretty darned good in order outweigh the cost of abandoning one job in order to take one job.

8 comments

Rauner’s First State of the State

I missed newly-elected Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner’s first state of the state message yesterday but I’ve certainly got an earful about it since then. The editors of the Chicago Tribune found it refreshing:

With Wednesday’s State of the State address, Gov. Bruce Rauner is on record with an agenda to make Illinois competitive again.

We’ve waited a long time for an Illinois governor to voice many of these proposals as if he means them.

The question now is whether lawmakers, the majority of them Democrats, will join a Republican governor in fixing Illinois or will try to block reforms that represent a sharp new way of doing the business of government.

They conclude: “Do legislators want to help? Or not?” My guess is not.

The editors of the Sun-Times, on the other hand, seemed to view it with more foreboding:

SPRINGFIELD — Gov. Bruce Rauner told voters he would shake things up.

And Wednesday, he didn’t hold back.

The rookie Republican governor used his first State of the State speech to unveil an incredibly ambitious agenda to a Democratic Legislature — where many of his ideas could be considered traditional non-starters. Senate President John Cullerton called it “divisive.” But House Speaker Michael Madigan said he’s keeping an open mind.

That’s because the next step is a negotiation with the Legislature.

That’s something that everyone agrees on. Since the Democrats have super-majorities in both houses of the Illinois legislature, they have complete control over what will or will not happen in state government.

I read one, consistent theme in Gov. Rauner’s speech and it’s a point I’ve made here again and again. Illinois does not exist in a vacuum. To survive economically and socially it must be competitive with its surrounding states and today it’s not. There is too much government here, there is too much bureaucracy here, there is too much corruption here, and our taxes are too high. There are geographical facts that set Illinois apart. Most of its major population centers are on the state border, adjacent to another state eager to lure businesses and workers away from Illinois.

As in Mayor Emanuel’s most recent speech on Chicago’s condition, the dog in the manger which was left unmentioned by Gov. Rauner is the problem posed by public pensions. The state’s plan has already been struck down by a court as unconstitutional. What’s next, guys? We’re waiting for your answer.

My off-hand guess it that Illinois’s legislators will not be receptive to the new governor’s message and will not cooperate. Refusing to solve Illinois’s problems is, after all, their core competency. I suspect they’ll decide to stick with the ones that brung them which means they’ll cling bitterly to the public employees’ unions to the bitter end. Our bitter end, that is, not theirs.

4 comments

Strange Bedfellows in Oregon

Unseen by me because I generally don’t look in that direction, there is apparently a scandal brewing in Oregon. There have been charges of a conflict of interest on the part of Oregon Gov. John Kitzhaber in his fiancee’s receipt of fellowship money that ultimately derives from Oregon’s state government. The Oregonian, the state’s largest and oldest newspaper, has called for the governor’s resignation:

More ugliness may surface, but it should be clear by now to Kitzhaber that his credibility has evaporated to such a degree that he can no longer serve effectively as governor. If he wants to serve his constituents he should resign.

To recite every reported instance in which Hayes, ostensibly under Kitzhaber’s watchful eye, has used public resources, including public employee time and her “first lady” title, in pursuit of professional gain would require far more space than we have here and, besides, repeat what most readers already know. Suffice it to say there’s a pattern, and the person who bears the responsibility for allowing it to form and persist is Kitzhaber, who should know better. After all, as he pointed out during Friday’s press conference, he’s been serving in public office on and off since the 1970s.

Consistent with my practice of keeping my nose out of other people’s business, I’m not going to remark on the scandal or offer any opinions other than to say that I’m a bit relieved to read of a state other than Illinois with a governor in hot water. If that’s schadenfreude, so be it.

There’s a round-up of more commentary on the scandal at memeorandum.

6 comments

As It Does Now

In their latest salvo against net neutrality which, judging from the most recent pronouncements of the FCC, is what the Obama Administration favors, there are a few things that the editors of the Wall Street Journal don’t seem to understand. The first is that the Internet service providers didn’t gain their positions under competitive systems. They did so through government franchises and monopoly power. They didn’t even develop or promote their own technologies. That was done for them by the government, too. They’re just reaping the profits.

The second thing is that consumers deserve to get what they pay for. The editors write:

The Wheeler cover story is that such antiquated rules are necessary to provide “net neutrality,” the concept that all Internet traffic should be treated equally and not blocked from reaching consumers—in other words, to allow the Internet to function pretty much as it does now.

but that’s not true. Nobody knows how the Internet actually functions now. Sure, you may be paying for a 10Mbps pipe but you don’t know for certain that you’re not being throttled twenty times a day. The providers are free to advertise one thing and deliver something completely different. They can throttle certain sites and leave others alone. They can throttle at certain times. And never tell you about any of it.

As I’ve written before in the 30 years I’ve lived in this house, I’ve lost telephone service twice, lost power a dozen times, and I lose my Internet connection on average about once a week. One of these things is not like the others and it darned well should be.

4 comments

The Scorecard

In his most recent column George Will tallies the economy’s performance. It goes something like this:

  • In 2014 we had one quarter of 5% growth.
  • Economic growth for the year was phlegmatic. Under 2%.
  • At the rate at which new jobs are being produced those who lost their jobs in the late recession will never find work.
  • The jobs that are being created are either a) in protected sectors or b) pay a lot less than the jobs that were lost during the recession.
  • The rate of new business formation is at the lowest rate since 1980 when the Baby Boomers hit their stride.
  • The rate at which households are being formed is lower, too.
  • The birth rate’s down, too.
  • The present expansion has continued for 73 months.
  • Of the twelve post-war recessions only four have been longer. The expansion that followed the 1945 recession was 80 months long; the expansion that followed the 1970 recession was 106 months longs; the expansion that followed the 1990-1991 recession was 92 months long; the expansion that followed the 2001 recession was 120 months long.

It appears to me that we have been in a pitched battle over what constitutes a good life, what constitutes a good country. I think we’re losing.

There’s more commentary on Mr. Will’s column at memeorandum.

13 comments

Why Supplements Don’t Contain the Stuff They Say They Do

I found this post at the New York Times interesting but unsurprising:

The New York State attorney general’s office accused four major retailers on Monday of selling fraudulent and potentially dangerous herbal supplements and demanded that they remove the products from their shelves.

The authorities said they had conducted tests on top-selling store brands of herbal supplements at four national retailers — GNC, Target, Walgreens and Walmart — and found that four out of five of the products did not contain any of the herbs on their labels. The tests showed that pills labeled medicinal herbs often contained little more than cheap fillers like powdered rice, asparagus and houseplants, and in some cases substances that could be dangerous to those with allergies.

[…]

“Mislabeling, contamination and false advertising are illegal,” said Eric T. Schneiderman, the state attorney general. “They also pose unacceptable risks to New York families — especially those with allergies to hidden ingredients.”

The attorney general’s investigation was prompted by an article in the New York Times in 2013 that raised questions about widespread labeling fraud in the supplement industry. The article referred to research at the University of Guelph in Canada that found that as many as a third of herbal supplements tested did not contain the plants listed on their labels — only cheap fillers instead.

Hat tip: Glenn Reynolds

What’s missing from the article is why? It’s not simple greed on the part of the “major retailers”. Walgreens, Target, GNC, and Walmart don’t manufacture the supplements and, presumably, although they’re the ones getting sued they’re victims of fraud as certainly as their customers are. Even the private label supplements that bear their brand names aren’t manufactured by them.

I strongly suspect that even Walgreens et al.’s suppliers aren’t the actual culprits. I’m guessing that they’re paying for and using ingredients in the things they’re compounding under the mistaken assumption that they’re the real deal.

You may not be aware of this but practically all food additives, whether for nutrition, color, or texture are made in China and I’m guessing that the same is true of many of the ingredients used in the supplements in question. As was clear from the dog food adulteration scandal of a couple of years ago and which I wrote about extensively, practically nobody up or down the supply chain does any kind of quality assurance. They just hope for the best.

12 comments