Off-loading

In the comments to an earlier post it was noted by a frequent commenter that the Republican healthcare plan “largely shifts costs onto the consumer”. So does the PPACA, as this article at Bloomberg from Christopher Flavelle points out:

…cost sharing on the exchanges is still typically far higher than for the employer-based coverage that about half of Americans still have. Maybe that’s a necessary price to pay for extending government-subsidized health care. But it also means that when people complain about the high cost of care, they’re not wrong.

That seems to be the consensus view from both sides of the aisle on reducing healthcare costs in the United States. I’m skeptical. I’m unaware of any study that has ever demonstrated that people economize solely on unnecessary healthcare as higher costs fall on them. Quite to the contrary I think they skimp on both unnecessary and necessary healthcare, resulting in higher costs down the road.

1 comment

The Bombing of Dresden, 70 Years Later

On the 70th anniversary of the bombing of Dresden, Spiegel Online interviews British historian Frederick Taylor. Here are a few snippets.

On the mythologization of the bombing by the Germans:

Dresden was undoubtedly a particularly fine city, a tourist center well known to Germans and foreigners alike as a place where the arts flourished amidst architecturally distinguished surroundings. This gave rise to the myth that it was of no military or industrial importance. The high civilian death toll — though current estimates of 25,000 are not as high as once thought — also plays a role. Hamburg could never be seen as being of no military importance. Dresden, plausibly — though not really accurately — could be.

On disruption of the German civil order as a main objective of the bombing:

Raids on Dresden and Chemnitz were delayed by bad weather. And ultimately, only the Dresden raid was successful — horribly so as the 25,000 or more casualties bear witness. This was, in fact, a clear-cut case where maximum destruction was the central aim of the attack. There can be no question that the presence of many refugees was factored into the Allies’ calculations. A Feb. 1, 1945 memorandum specifically noted the huge tide of refugees passing through the eastern German cities as a “plus point,” chillingly adding that attacking these cities would “result in establishing a state of chaos in some or all of these areas.”

On the strategic importance of Dresden:

Dresden was undeniably a beautiful city, a center of the arts and a symbol of all that was great about pre-Nazi German humanism. It was also quite strongly Nazi and a major industrial center. Its light industries, ranging from factories producing typewriters and cigarettes to furniture and candy, had overwhelmingly been converted to war use after 1939. Around 70,000 workers in the city are thought to have been involved in war-related work. Its regional railway directorate was heavily involved in the war effort on the eastern front and also in the transport of prisoners within the concentration camp system. The question therefore is not whether Dresden contained legitimate bombing targets, but whether the method and intensity of the February 1945 bombing was justifiable.

Let me preface my remarks with my view that a) the bombing of Dresden on February 13 through February 15 1945 was a war atrocity and b) was immoral. However, I think the blame for it can be laid squarely on the British.

The British high command made no secret of their support for as many German civilian casualties as possible. The Americans were the champions of precision bombing in the European theater; that interested the British significantly less as anyone who’s ever visited the sectors bombed by the British and the sectors bombed by the Americans during the war can attest. Both American and British bombers took part in the bombing but the declassified air logs of the American bomber makes it clear that they were going after legitimate military targets. Also, keep in mind that “precision bombing” seventy years ago meant something quite different than it does today.

Did Americans take part in deliberate targeting of civilian targets? Probably.

One more little item that I believe is too infrequently remarked on. The famous talks among Roosevelt, Stalin, and Churchill at Yalta took place from February 7 to February 11, 1945. Although the popular mythology of the war is that the three Allied leaders were discussing how to divvy up Europe to the best of my knowledge no transcripts of the talks have ever been made public. I strongly suspect that the air attacks that included the bombing of Dresden were a major topic of discussion and that Stalin made an impassioned plea to Roosevelt and Churchill to draw the Luftwaffe away from the Red Army’s forces which at that point were just 120 miles from Dresden.

2 comments

Moynihan’s Oracle

At the Wall Street Journal Jason Riley reminds us that Pat Moynihan was right about the social dysfunction that plagued our inner cities:

Next month marks the 50th anniversary of the future senator’s report on the black family, the controversial document issued while he served as an assistant secretary in President Lyndon Johnson’s Labor Department. Moynihan highlighted troubling cultural trends among inner-city blacks, with a special focus on the increasing number of fatherless homes.

“The fundamental problem is that of family structure,” wrote Moynihan, who had a doctorate in sociology. “The evidence—not final but powerfully persuasive—is that the Negro family in the urban ghettos is crumbling.”

[…]

History has proved that Moynihan was onto something. When the report was released, about 25% of black children and 5% of white children lived in a household headed by a single mother. During the next 20 years the black percentage would double and the racial gap would widen. Today more than 70% of all black births are to unmarried women, twice the white percentage.

You can argue about the reasons for this. I think it’s that over a century of racism, Jim Crow, and badly constructed social programs made black men superfluous in the family. They sought social support elsewhere and frequently that was in street gangs. That lead to violence and crime. Lather, rinse, repeat.

I think we should be concerned that inner city African Americans were a harbinger of things to come to the larger society. I don’t relish the prospect of ours becoming a country in which men are seen as burdens to the self-realization of women.

6 comments

Can McDonalds Be Saved?

Following steep declines in sales and earnings at McDonalds, a former McDonalds executive takes to the pages of the Wall Street Journal to explain what he thinks need to be done at the fast food chain to regain its luster:

Another fast turnaround of the McDonald’s brand is possible—and it is essential for the company’s future. If you don’t take care of the short term, there will be no long term. Here are a few immediate actions that would reignite McDonald’s.

Here are his proposals:

  • Make sure you retain your current customers.
  • Compete with your actual competitors rather than the companies you wish were your competitors.
  • Better food.
  • Know what business you’re in: fast food.
  • Do a few things better than anyone else rather than a lot of things poorly.
  • Restore relevance.
  • Dedicate the company to “the right actions executed in the right way to achieve the right results.”
  • Introduce a small number of winning new products rather than a lot of products that mostly fail.
  • Rebuild employee pride.
  • Rebuild trust.

Most of those are basic Peter Drucker management It’s seems to me that some of them, e.g. “restore relevance” and customer retention, are actually in direct conflict. It’s a tall order.

Mr. Light undoubtedly has more insider knowledge of McDonalds than I do but that might be a problem. I don’t think he gets to the crux of McDonalds’s difficulties which I would see as two-fold. First, McDonalds grew up during a very peculiar period in American history. A very large number of entry level workers were coming into the job market and would do so for the next quarter century. For many Baby Boomers working at McDonalds as a teen was a right of passage. For the last thirty years the situation has been different. Rather than attracting bright-faced teens today’s McDonalds is largely staffed by immigrant adults with very different needs. Rather than expecting to work a few years, gain experience, and move on to something that paid more they expect to be able to live a decent, independent life, raise families, and maybe even send some money home to mama. That’s in direct conflict with McDonalds’s business model.

Additionally, the United States is a saturated market. New franchisees (again supplied by Baby Boomers) just aren’t coming along at the rate they did a half century ago. I don’t have the figures to back this up but I’d guess that most new franchises these days are overseas. Here in the United States McDonalds is a staple for lower income people, young people, and new families. I strongly suspect it serves a different market overseas. Different business models.

IMO McDonalds has encouraged two generations of Americans to prefer mediocre food. That’s the company’s core customer base and they won’t retain them with better food, different menus, or new products. Which is what they’ll need to get new customers.

17 comments

Analyzing the Republicans’ Healthcare Plan

Remarkable as it may seem, it is possible to analyze the Republicans’ plan without simply dismissing it, mocking it, or attributing bad motives to it, and Robert Laszewski at The Health Care Blog has done just that. Here’s one small snippet of the much longer post that does a bit of deconstruction of the entire plan into a single paragraph:

By capping the tax exclusion and offering defined tax credits to those under 300% of the poverty level and, importantly, limiting future increases of both to no more than the increase in the Consumer Price Index plus 1% (CPI+1%), the Republican proposal would increase these federal benefits annually but do so in a limited way that would reduce future federal budget costs and likely health care inflation. But, this would also shift more risk for the future cost of health care to the consumer.

Here’s his conclusion:

And, therein lies the Republican challenge––convincing people that their complex health insurance reform ideas provide people with more health insurance security than the problematic and complex Obamacare plan does. Take it or leave it––ours or theirs.

Again, I think Republicans would have been far better off taking a big gulp and accepting Obamacare as the baseline in health insurance public policy and then use many of their ideas to tell the American people how they could make it work a lot better.

After all, isn’t that what most people really want?

I think that what most people want is to be able to afford the healthcare they need when they really need it and, sadly, neither the PPACA nor the Republicans’ plan accomplish that for a simple reason: they’re both patches. The PPACA was a patch on the present (now past) system as is the Republicans’ plan. I think that patches only forestall the inevitable, that time is not on the side of cost control, and that over time our healthcare system will only become less affordable.

7 comments

The Monopolists

I agree wholeheartedly with the position the editors of the Washington Post have articulated on “net neutrality”:

IN THE war over net neutrality, it’s clear where the country should end up. Americans should pay for the bandwidth they consume, and they should consume any legal content they want, without interference from the network operators that transport the packets of information into their homes. That’s not just the way to maintain the free flow of information and services on which the Internet thrives; it’s also the way to encourage service providers to improve their networks rather than just manage traffic on their existing wires.

[…]

For years, the FCC has attempted to use old law to regulate broadband. The best way out of this mess is to create new law. That would settle the jurisdictional question between the FCC and the FTC, and it would make net-neutrality rules legally unassailable. Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) and Rep. Fred Upton (R-Mich.) have proposed a net-neutrality bill, but it has little chance of becoming law because it strips the FCC of some useful regulatory authorities. That shouldn’t be the end of the legislative discussion.

The part of the discussion that I find astounding is that so many libertarians and anarcho-capitalists have raised the red banner in support of the service providers who for the most part achieved their positions through government-granted monopolies as opposed to the upstarts like Google, NetFlix, or Facebook who didn’t. They saw opportunities and exploited them which would seem to me to be the free marketers’ paragon. There is nothing whatever that stopped Verizon, AT&T, or Comcast from creating world-spanning search engines, streaming services, or social media nexuses other than a lack of the will to innovate. Why should they? They got where they are by government fiat and they know they can darn well stay there by government fiat.

1 comment

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

IR TOs WH NSS

If you’re puzzled by the title, it’s shorthand for “International Relations Ticks Off White House National Security Strategy”. “Ticks off” is, of course British slang for harshly criticizing. I thought the acronyms might be more eye-catching than if it were spelled out.

What do I think about it? I think that like everything else in the present administration the NSS is primarily about domestic politics. The post is a round-up of reaction, favorable and unfavorable. Yes, there has been some favorable reaction.

0 comments

The Energy Policy

I disagree with T. Boone Pickens’s assessment of President Obama’s energy policy. I don’t think it’s “Kill the Pipelines”:

News that acclaimed American author Harper Lee has a follow-up book to “To Kill a Mockingbird” triggered an energy-focused parallel thought in my mind as it relates to President Obama. His views on the Trans-Alaska pipeline and the Keystone pipeline are nothing more than: “To Kill the Pipelines.”

Should the president make this view a reality, America’s energy security will be dangerously undermined, and the prospects of a prolonged downturn in gasoline prices that benefit consumers to the tune of $720 per year will be in serious jeopardy.

I think it’s actually simpler than that. I think that either a) he believes that producing less energy would be good for America and the world or b) he thinks that solar, wind, etc. can replace coal, oil, and gas for energy production and that would be good for America and the world.

I think that either of those are obviously ill-conceived. More and cheaper energy makes all sorts of things possible that would not otherwise be possible and in an economy in which growth is either slow or declining that’s vital. And if the president believes b) he’s been misinformed. The only present viable alternative to coal, oil, and gas is nuclear.

5 comments

Renaming As an Opportunity

There an article at Nature on something that is almost certain to prove controversial. It is being proposed that Chronic Fatigue Syndrome be renamed “Systemic Exertion Intolerance Disease” and its diagnostic criteria be revised:

The mysterious disease known as chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) has long defied classification, as the millions of people who suffer from it show a wide variety of symptoms. Now a panel commissioned by the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has produced what is sure to be an influential report on how the disease should be diagnosed. This new definition comes with a new moniker: systemic exertion intolerance disease (SEID).

The report, released by the US Institute of Medicine (IOM) on 10 February, says that the new name better reflects the key symptom of the disease — extreme exhaustion after any exertion. It argues that other symptoms, such as poor sleep and cognitive impairment, are secondary. But some experts are already challenging the name and revised diagnostic criteria.

IMO this is a good move and advocates should view the renaming as an opportunity rather than a threat. CFS is obviously a real condition but people with it are treated too frequently as malingerers. It may take them decades and a parade of physicians before they get what little treatment there is for the condition. If the new diagnostic criteria are clearer and more targeted, the renaming might be an advance.

1 comment

A Better Way on Ukraine

There are better approaches to resolving the problems in Ukraine than escalating the conflict there, the path the U. S. is on, and Raymond Smith proposes one in his article at National Interest. He begins by articulating something near and dear to my heart, the idea that policy should advance vital national interests:

I suggest that America’s vital national interests can also be succinctly defined: 1) prevent an attack on the homeland; 2) enhance the stability of the international system; 3) fulfill our security-alliance commitments. The first of these is presumably clear enough in principle; the second and third perhaps less so. We want to maintain the stability of the international system, because we are the most powerful state in it and its structure is advantageous to us. If we are perceived as unwilling or unable to maintain our security-alliance commitments, that will have a profoundly destabilizing effect on the international system.

That’s a good list. I would add an additional one: freedom of air traffic, sea traffic, and the flow of information. But that’s a good list.

Here’s the summary of Mr. Smith’s article:

  • The U. S. does not have a vital interest in Ukraine.
  • Russia does.
  • Giving arms to Ukraine escalates the conflict.
  • That’s against our vital interests.

He proposes a trilateral trade agreement among the U. S., Russia, and Ukraine that would allow Ukraine to serve a different role than it would as a NATO member:

Ukraine could be a bridge between the West and Russia, rather than a prize to be fought over. Ukraine must negotiate a relationship with Russia that both countries can live with. There is no reason that cannot include an economic relationship with the European Union that encourages desperately needed reform within Ukraine, while at the same time promoting trilateral economic ties beneficial to all three parties. The EU leadership can help with this. If we have no vital interests in Ukraine, European countries do have vital interests in not seeing a large-scale ground war break out on their continent. The clarity of our decision making on this issue would improve if we stopped demonizing Russia’s leader. He is not Hitler, and Ukraine is not Czechoslovakia. Putin is an authoritarian leader in a country that has known nothing but authoritarianism and disorder, and prefers the former to the latter. His brand of authoritarianism is, to date, less restrictive than the political practices in China, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, to name just a few. Russia considers its interests in Ukraine vital, but its objectives have been limited, as have been the means chosen to achieve them. It will escalate if necessary to protect its interests, but it would rather negotiate.

Such an agreement would need either to partition Ukraine or provide for Russian access to the Crimean peninsula and the rights of ethnic Russians within Ukraine but it’s a start.

And it has the advantage of advancing our interests rather than running counter to them as our present policy does.

10 comments