One of the most important thing that those who develop policy and strategy need is an understanding of the human geography of the problem sets they are looking at in order to establish more fully informed objectives and develop the ways and means to achieve them. An understanding of the socio-cultural context that shows the interaction of people, places, and things (both natural and man made) is always illuminating when trying to explain this type of context in support of policy formation, strategic development, and planning. Using annotated maps is especially helpful. There are three maps that demonstrate why Dr. Muravchik’s thesis is not the best option.
The Iranians are informed, well educated people in spite of the wild-eyed claims of Bibi and his ignorant friends in the US Senate. The Iranians have no intention of getting into war with the US. As someone wrote here, this silliness is about the at least theoretical threat to Israel, not the unreal threat to the US from Iran. BTW, the US would not care at all about “world opinion” in this. My friend Walrus consistently underestimates the amount of damage the US can do but then, he has never seen a B-52 strike close up. Once Iranian air defenses were eliminated the US could roam the skies over Iran, “bombing tha back to the stone age.”
Just as reminders
Preventive war against Iran would be illegal. We are a signatory to treaties that commit us to eschew war in the absence of Security Council approval.
Preventive war against Iran would be immoral. It would not meet the standards of a just war
Preventive war against Iran would in all likelihood kill millions of people and anything short of a war of extermination would be ineffective in achieving its goals.
Preventive war against Iran might just provoke what it would presumably be intended to prevent, i.e. an attack on the U. S.
War should never be viewed as the “best option”. Thinking that is loathsome. It should only be the last remaining option.
Article II, Section 2, Clause 1 of the United States Constitution reads (in reference to the president):
He shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur; and he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law: but the Congress may by Law vest the Appointment of such inferior Officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the Courts of Law, or in the Heads of Departments.
The phrase “advice and consent” caught my eye and I wondered what its history was.
The formulation, apparently, derives from the constitution of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, appears frequently there, and refers to the interrelationships among the governor, the Massachusetts Executive Council, a small elective body with broad powers of approval and counsel, and the General Court. After a little digging I learned that the phrase has been hotly debated going back to the early days of the Republic.
The first draft of the U. S. Constitution submitted at the constitutional convention, the “Pinckney Draft” after its primary author, Charles Pinckney of South Carolina, gave to the Senate the sole authority of declaring war, making treaties, or appointing ambassadors and other government functionaries. That was the prevailing form until quite late in the convention when the present language giving to the president the right to negotiate treaties and the Senate the power of ratification and “advice”. That was apparently arrived at in the interests of expedition, something that George Washington learned about to his dismay when he presented a treaty with various native tribes he had negotiated for ratification by the Senate and the Senate sent it committee.
Keep in mind: there was never serious discussion of giving the sole power to negotiate treaties to the president. Debate was over whether to give any power in that area to the president at all.
The professionalization of treaty negotiation is actually a relatively recent phenomenon. William McKinley, among the shrewdest of our presidents, asked senators to participate in the negotiation of our peace treaty with Spain in 1898. The treaty was approved unanimously. In contrast not only did Woodrow Wilson not include the Senate in the negotiation of the Treaty of Versailles, he angrily rejected the Senate’s “reservations” (proposed amendments) to the treaty. The U. S. never ratified the treaty, the United States never joined the League of Nations, and that is a reason frequently given for the league’s eventual failure.
Presidents Franklin Roosevelt and Harry Truman included senators in important treaty negotiations with the effect that their treaties were frequently ratified. Since then presidents have asserted ever-greater authority in negotiating treaties until arriving at the point at which we are now in President Obama’s apparently assuming that once negotiated his treaties should automatically be ratified.
As I’ve written before I think the members of Congress who sent an open letter to the leaders of Iran erred. They should have addressed their letter to the president and bought full page spreads in the New York Times and Washington Post for it. And posted it on Facebook. The leaders of Iran are not ignorant of the United States or things happening here and in doing so members of the Senate would be acting fully within their powers to advise the president on matters of foreign policy.
I also think that characterizing the letter as “treasonous” is excessive. Treason has an actual meaning and it isn’t “stepping on the president’s toes”. or “going around the president to exercise the Congress’s legitimate authority”.
We have arrived at this pass because of the hostility between the Congress and President Barack Obama, something I appear to be nearly alone among Democrats in attributing to ideology and partisanship rather than racism and think that the president has gone out of his way to alienate the Senate, something that applies not only to Republicans but to Democrats as well, something attested by enough Senate Democrats it can hardly be denied.
In writing this post I used the following references:
I heartily recommend reading James Madison’s journal on the Constitutional Convention. It’s full of interesting information on how we got the constitution that was finally arrived at. One of the things that should be no surprise is that it was a compromise. An interesting characterization of the constitution during deliberations (reported by Madison but not his) was that it was a treaty among the states. That’s a thought worthy of reflection.
The illustration above is of a manuscript of the “Pinckney Draft”.
There’s an underlying point in the Washington Post editorial on the agreement the Obama Administration is negotiating with Iran. There’s a legitimate concern that the administration is kicking the legs out from beneath the bipartisan strategy that has guided U. S. policy with respect to Iran for the last 35 years:
he president himself has provided much of the fuel for the speculation. According to news accounts, Mr. Obama has dispatched four private letters to the Iranian supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. The most recent one, in October, assured the ayatollah that the United States would not attack Iranian forces or those of its Syrian ally in operations against the Islamic State, according to the Wall Street Journal. Publicly, Mr. Obama said in an interview in December that he hoped a nuclear deal “would serve as the basis for us trying to improve relations over timeâ€; if Iran agreed to the accord, he added, it could become “a very successful regional power.â€
Such statements have understandably alarmed Mideast leaders at a time when Tehran is engaged in what Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called a “march of conquest, subjugation and terror.†A relaxation of U.S. efforts to resist this bid for regional hegemony would be a strategic calamity for Israel and the Persian Gulf states. Saudi Foreign Minister Saud al-Faisal said after speaking to Mr. Kerry that it was “really the main concern of the Gulf Cooperation Council.â€
Unfortunately, the administration’s assurances are at odds with its actions. While the nuclear negotiations have continued, Mr. Obama has refused to support military action against the Assad regime in Syria, in accord with his letter’s reported promise, and his administration has tacitly blessed an ongoing, Iranian-led offensive in Iraq’s Sunni heartland. It took no action to stop the ouster by an Iranian-backed militia of a pro-U.S. Yemeni regime. Nor has it reacted to Iran’s deployment of thousands of Shiite fighters to southern Syria, near the Israeli-occupied Golan Heights.
That record raises the question of what the administration’s response will be to further Iranian adventurism following a nuclear deal.
I doubt the administration has thought that far ahead. I think they’re too busy keeping score.
As I read the various op-eds and editorials on Hillary Clinton’s email and our incipient agreement with Iran (just to name two), I see a common thread. When you need to explain that appearances to the contrary notwithstanding, you’re actually winning, you probably aren’t. Just as in checkers or handball in politics it’s pretty easy to tell who’s winning. Winners don’t generally need to explain themselves.
In the course of a day I read a lot of articles, typically 40 or 50 a day. Today’s winner both for content and its extremely eye-catching title is “Steampunk Regulation, Medical Technology, and the IT Revolution” by Robert Graboyes. It has a pretty simple premise. It’s the 21st century, the technology (and practitioners!) of healthcare are 20th century, and our regulatory system is stuck in the late 19th century.
Modern life brings with it a challenge that I don’t think enough people have appreciated. If a process evolves more rapidly than the structures intended to regulate it, it cannot be regulated. That pertains to everything from email to firearms to healthcare, just to name a few. Just as the Internet itself functions, regulatory obstructions will just be routed around.
Just to give one example of the breadth of the problem half of all practicing physicians are more than 50 years of age. Many are more than 60. Most people of that age just aren’t particularly tech-savvy. Maybe physicians are exceptional in that regard but that has not been my experience.
As in most else I’m an oddball in that respect. I’m technologically competent and probably more aware of what’s going on in technology than 99.99% of the population. If I were more forthcoming about my background and experience, you’d understand. You’ll just have to take my word for it.
I think that it was G. K. Chesterton who said that radicals say “I don’t understand why this social custom exists; we should throw it out” while conservatives (in the Burkean conservative sense) say “I don’t understand why this social custom exists; we should keep it”. In his column today, Nicholas Kristof reminds us about Pat Moynihan’s warning:
Daniel Patrick Moynihan, at the time a federal official, wrote a famous report in March 1965 on family breakdown among African-Americans. He argued presciently and powerfully that the rise of single-parent households would make poverty more intractable.
“The fundamental problem,†Moynihan wrote, is family breakdown. In a follow-up, he explained: “From the wild Irish slums of the 19th-century Eastern seaboard, to the riot-torn suburbs of Los Angeles, there is one unmistakable lesson in American history: a community that allows large numbers of young men to grow up in broken families … never acquiring any stable relationship to male authority, never acquiring any set of rational expectations about the future — that community asks for and gets chaos.â€
That message was rejected by the Democrats of the day but Mr. Kristof doesn’t do a good job of explaining why it was rejected and, indeed, instantiates the very problem he’s criticizing:
My point isn’t to cast judgment on nontraditional families, for single parents can be as loving as any. In fact, when one parent is abusive, the child may be better off raised by the other parent alone. And well-off kids often get plenty of support whether from one parent or two.
Unfortunately, there is no ready substitute for social stigma. When every social arrangement is treated as having the same legitimacy and value to the society as every other it will inevitably lead to the rejection of policies and attitudes that support the traditional social arrangements, even if those policies and attitudes are demonstrably beneficial and their abandoning demonstrably harmful.
“Nontraditional” lifestyles will always have the most serious consequences for poor blacks and the least serious for the white bourgeoisie who are the custodians of the social mores. What’s the misery of a few black kids compared with a few white folks being able to throw off the bonds of social convention?
Over the last decade there has been increasing concern about an impending shortage of primary-care physicians. The most cited study projecting a shortage of these doctors (whose specialties include internal medicine, family medicine, and pediatrics) was published by the Association of American Medical Colleges Center for Workforce Studies in 2008, and its projections were updated in 2010 to take account of the Affordable Care Act. Lost in the dire warnings is an equally alarming shortage of non-primary-care physicians: The same organization puts the numbers at 33,100 this year; 46,109 by 2020; and 64,600 by 2025.
They go on to consider several strategies for dealing with the situation.
To my mind the shortage of family care physicians highlights the problem of simultaneously trying to treat healthcare as a a market-based economy and a command economy. It is not and cannot be a market-based economy without drastic reform. The supply is capped by a politburo, for goodness sake. The reason there’s a shortage of family care physicians is that family care physicians aren’t paid as highly as many other specialties, med students, understandably, are edging away from family practice towards better-paid specialties, and the medical schools and hospitals are allowing that.
There’s a simple solution to the problem: recognize that healthcare is a command economy and command. Amend the Medicare law to increase the number of paid residencies for the family care specialties (a more bizarre formulation than “family care specialties” can hardly be imagined), reducing the number of paid residencies for other specialties as needed. Or, alternatively, the federal government could just deny accreditation to medical schools that fail to meet their quota of family care physicians.
This morning I ate fresh blackberries on my oatmeal. When I was a kid fresh blackberries in March would have been an incredible luxury—prohibitively expensive—but today they’re a commonplace. Has anyone else noticed that in the last few years we’ve seen inexpensive year-round blackberries? Why? I know that most of the out-of-season blackberries are imported from Mexico but that’s not really the question.
Is there a new cultivar? Improved packaging and/or processing? A different way of transporting them than existed just a couple of years ago?
Somewhat to my surprise in his most recent column Harold Meyerson lurches uncontrollably onto the point I’ve been making at this blog since the very beginning. If you want to know why economic growth and, importantly, wage growth are phlegmatic, look to business investment:
Over the past decade, more than 90 percent of Fortune 500 corporations’ net earnings have been funneled to investors. The great shareholder shift has affected more than employees’ incomes. As Luke A. Stewart and Robert D. Atkinson noted in a 2013 report for the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, business investment in equipment, software and buildings increased by just 0.5 percent per year between 2000 and 2011 — “less than a fifth that of the 1980s and less than one-tenth that of the 1990s.â€
Mr. Meyerson blames that on “the power of major shareholders to appropriate corporate revenue” but engages in only a superficial consideration of that power and doesn’t have much in the way of a prescription for changing that or mitigating its effects. He does take a nostalgic glance at private sector unions but that’s confusing causes with effects.
In my view the place to look is the rise of institutional investors, i.e. mutual funds, pension funds, and the like. These are the “major shareholders” for most large companies these days and their objectives are very different from those of the shareholders of the past as exemplified by the much shorter durations stocks are held than was the case in the past:
In 1960, the average length of time an investor held a stock was eight years; today, it’s four months, and when computerized high-frequency trading is factored in, it’s 22 seconds.
They’re looking for short term movements in stock valuations rather than long term growth in markets and capitalization—the stuff that makes a company great. Their weight makes attracts boards to managers who’ll lay off employees beyond the level at which it adversely affects the company’s ability to function or who engage in other manipulations to boost stock value rather than the difficult work of improving and expanding companies. Giving managers stock in the company is a contributing factor as well.
The reason that I opposed the “Bush tax cuts” was that they were obviously at the very best a quick fix, ordinary Keynesian pump-priming. Their intent was to give a quick boost to consumer spending (which hadn’t fallen dramatically) rather than encouraging business investment (which had).
It is simply untrue that businesses only invest when sales are expanding. That’s only true of companies that are managed poorly. Businesses invest in order to expand sales, especially future sales. When the only future you’re interested in is the next 22 seconds, investment flags.
We need to be incentivizing a different kind of management but politicians have staunchly resisted any moves that might cause that to happen, e.g. abolishing the corporate income tax. I’m open to other suggestions but until we see a change in corporate governance and management we’ll just get more of the same.