Watcher’s Council Nominations

I haven’t done one of these in a while. Some changes in the Council’s membership are under way so this is as good a time as any to resume an old custom of mine. The members of the Watcher’s Council have nominated the following for consideration by the Council:

The Independent Sentinel – Shocker! What Barack Obama Doesn’t Know a Thing About

I have my disagreements with Sara about President Obama but I think she’s right about this. The Obama White House has expressed ignorance about an amazing number of things, the most recent being that while Secretary of State Hillary Clinton used a private email server for her correspondence in contravention of directives. There aren’t that many explanations for that. Either they’re lying, they’ve taken “plausible deniability” beyond plausibility, or they don’t know a lot of things they really should know about.

The Noisy Room – Russia, the Caliphate and the Shadow of World War III

We had best hope that Russia doesn’t present the threat that Terresa thinks it does. The only real threat of nuclear war is with Russia. While I don’t think that Russia is our friend, I don’t think that it’s our enemy, either. I think it has interests and we need to pay heed to them. I think that Germany is actually behind many of today’s challenges.

Joshuapundit–Disgracing ‘The Spirit Of Selma’

I learned a bit about the building of the White House in this post about the commemoration of the Selma march 50 years ago. And I agree with Joshuapundit that trying to conjoin blacks brought to this country against their wills as slaves with kids brought to this country illegally by their parents is quite a stretch. I also agree that turning the commemoration into a campaign event was unseemly but I guess I’m more fatalistic than Joshuapundit is. It’s what politicians do.

GrEaT sAtAn”S gIrLfRiEnD – Open Letter To Iranian Leadership

Gsg quotes the letter signed by 47 senators sent to the Iranian leadership. As I’ve said before, I think the senators erred. The letter certainly doesn’t bode well for whatever treaty the Obama Administration manages to negotiate with the Iranians being ratified. The letter does bring up an interesting question, though. How far does the Senate’s power to advise go?

The Razor –Listening Is Still A Virtue

Scott comments on the shortcomings of the evolution in gender roles over the last half century.

The Glittering Eye –Are American Kids Just Stupid and Lazy?

My remarks on a test administered to students from around the world. American kids didn’t do too well.

VA Right! – Justice Kennedy in King vs Burwell: Are State Exchanges really just Coercion?

Tom comments on King v. Burwell and makes the correct point that one place to look for how the justices will rule is their previous rulings on the PPACA.

Nice Deb – US Backed Islamist Reportedly Now Leads ISIS in Libya

Deb takes note of a report which illustrates just how fatuous the idea of supporting “moderate rebels” is.

Bookworm Room – Getting a Progressive to yes on conservative ideas

Bookworm recounts eleven points of agreement she found with a progressive friend. I suspect that many more could be found. IMO the way forward in American politics is through seeking areas of agreement. Demonizing your opponents, whether you’re a conservative or a progressive, may rally your side but it won’t do much to convince people.

Rhymes With Right – Jew-Hatred Lives At American Colleges And Universities

I really never thought I’d see the day when being a member of Hillel was thought to be disqualifying to be a member of a judicial review board at a major American university.

The Right Planet – A Strong Warning from Trevor Loudon on Illegal Amnesty

I think that Brent’s remarks on the Democratic Party are a bit hyperbolic but I agree that how we deal with illegal immigration is a major challenge and we’re not facing it particularly well. Too bad both parties support open borders.

Ask Marion – America’s Drug Story and the Rockefeller Empire

I would never have thought to draw a connection between Big Pharma and John D. Rockefeller but, apparently, there is one.

The announcement post, including the non-Council nominations, at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Subsidies to the Rich

No, most people don’t realize that the home mortgage deduction is a subsidy to the rich. But that’s what it is:

Since the Great Depression, US housing policies have aimed almost exclusively at encouraging Americans to become homeowners. Housing policies favor and heavily subsidize homeownership because it is said to help create strong communities and build family wealth. But it would be a mistake to continue with this approach now.

Homeowners receive tax benefits for their housing expenses, mostly because of the enormously expensive mortgage interest deductions, which disproportionately benefits higher-income taxpayers. But no such support is offered to lower-income renters.

The linked author proposes rent subsidies. My preference would be ending the home mortgage deduction or, failing that, capping the home mortgage interest deduction at, say, $50,000 per year. Do I really need to explain how anybody paying more than $50,000 in home mortgage interest is probably not in the lower three income quintiles?

5 comments

Taking Nominations for “Study Most Likely To Be Challenged” Award

It’s a bit early in the year but I have a candidate for the study most likely to be challenged for 2015. Apparently, a Florida State criminologist has done a meta-analysis of the scholarship which finds that there’s no link between gun ownership and crime:

Acknowledging the limitations of current research on the link between gun ownership and crime, Florida State University criminologist Gary Kleck sorted through dozens of studies to first separate the best from the worst, and then determine what the strongest studies tell us. His efforts were recently published in the Journal of Criminal Justice.

“All research is flawed, and all bodies of research are incomplete,” Kleck noted, “but that does not mean we cannot distinguish the less flawed work from the more flawed, and draw tentative conclusions based on the best available research conducted so far.”

Kleck included 41 studies that examined the association between measured gun levels and crime rate in his analysis, then used three specific criteria to gauge the strength of the studies.

First, he looked for a validated measure of gun ownership. In-depth surveys and percent of suicides with guns were two of the few acceptable measures. Second, he checked to see if confounding variables were properly controlled for and how many were included. Third, he checked to see whether the researchers used procedures that would rule out reverse causality, i.e. whether crime rates actually caused gun ownership to increase. (Past studies have shown that when crime rises in an area, gun ownership often increases, likely for purposes of self-defense.)

In all, the 41 studies produced 90 findings on gun ownership and various crime rates. Of these, 64% found no statistically significant positive affect between gun ownership and crime. However, 52% did identify a link between gun ownership and homicide.

The better the study, the less likely it was to find a connection between the two.

As I’ve said before, I own two long guns. One hasn’t been fired in 150 years and the other not in nearly a century. They’re family heirlooms. I don’t feel the need to own a gun. I’m not a big booster of gun ownership. I don’t really have a dog in this hunt.

However, whenever you gore sacred cows you probably should expect some consequences and I won’t be surprised if Dr. Kleck’s study isn’t roundly criticized.

10 comments

Après Hillary, le déluge

The editors of Bloomberg, getting a little ahead of themselves, speculate on who the Democratic candidate for president will be if it isn’t Hillary Clinton?

At the moment, four Democrats are playing presidential footsie. Vice President Joe Biden has visited Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina this year and indicated that if he were to run, it would be as the “sticking with what works” candidate. Former Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley is positioning himself as a bit more liberal than Clinton without all the baggage, a fresh face from (slightly) outside of Washington.

Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders is an independent who calls himself a Democratic socialist, crusades against the influence of money in politics, and appeals to the party’s ideological Ben & Jerry’s-eating activists. Former Virginia Senator Jim Webb is a populist who is as critical of Wall Street as he is of foreign military intervention, and his attacks on affirmative action and defense of gun rights speak to white voters who have been deserting the party — or feeling deserted by it.

Others could yet emerge. Senator Elizabeth Warren might change her mind, and the Al Gore chatter has already begun.

The field should be diverse.

Democrats may need to decide between a weakened candidate and a weak candidate.

3 comments

Bevan’s Reasons

It isn’t just Hillary Clinton who’s in the opinion pages today. It’s Clintonistas, too. At RealClearPolitics Tom Bevan gives five signs that Rahm Emanuel may lose the run-off election. They are:

  1. His poll numbers haven’t budged.
  2. The ad (which I’ve mentioned before) in which he sorta kinda apologizes won’t do him any favors.
  3. Black pastors, among them Jesse Jackson, are endorsing Chuy Garcia.
  4. Everybody hates the red light cameras.
  5. The mayor hasn’t done enough to deal with the shooting occurring every weekend on the South Side.

Who wins the run-off will depend on who does the best job of getting their voters to show up. I wouldn’t be surprised if fewer than 25% of voters vote in the run-off. Anything, including Rahm Emanuel’s defeat, could happen.

The question might be as simple as in an election based on name recognition alone will more voters vote for or against Rahm Emanuel?

2 comments

No Satisfaction (Multiple Updates)

Following up on my last post, the editors of the Wall Street Journal aren’t satisifed by the statement Sec. Clinton made yesterday, either:

The more likely truth is that she and her husband wanted to control how much of her communications at State would eventually become public—in case, say, she ran for President some day. And sure enough Mrs. Clinton violated State Department policy at the time by not turning over the emails in that private account to the government for its archives. She gave some of them to State only after Congress had requested them as part of the Benghazi probe, and State had none in its possession.

Asked on Tuesday why she didn’t turn over the emails from the start, Mrs. Clinton ducked the question and claimed “I’d be happy to have somebody talk to you about the rules.” She then added a new entry for the Clinton Ethics Pantheon: “I fully complied with every rule that I was governed by.” Just not the policy she was supposed to abide by.

I have a recurring nightmare. And this is it. It’s going to be a long ten years.

Update

Frank Bruni:

She made a choice when she stepped into the secretary of state’s job that was bound to be second-guessed if it ever came to light, as everything eventually does. And when it did, she was silent about it for a week, letting suspicions fester.

She was on the spit Tuesday because she placed herself there.

Josh Marshall:

But Hillary Clinton seems to have taken it a bit further than all the others combined – or perhaps combined together all the things that others individually had done. In any case, at the end of the day – like with every other Clinton scandal – I doubt very much that there’s any there there. Did they actually do anything wrong or terribly embarrassing that they’re covering up? I doubt it. And I say this because I’ve been to this rodeo before. Many times. I’ve seen how it eventually plays out.

And yet here we are again – with an almost infinite, process-driven scandal that can easily continue on into a Clinton presidency, if there is one. Consider it. Clinton and her lawyers have separated her work emails from personal ones and then sent the work ones to the State Department. But Republicans will never believe that the filtering was on the level. And by apparently destroying the personal ones, that means that Republican questions and press questions will meet a permanent question mark. Presumably even if she wanted to let a third party review all the emails now she can’t. So the deleted emails will remain the permanent fantastical repository for the decision not to prevent a rescue of Chris Stevens, give orders to erase warnings about safety at the Benghazi consulate and more.

So why do you delete personal emails? I think because you’re very focused on your personal privacy and want to avoid scrutiny and you want to permanently foreclose the possibility. Lawyers and businesses frequently do this. Clinton for these purposes is not a lawyer or a business.

Sean Trende:

To be clear, I don’t think the scandals matter much, in and of themselves. In this respect, I agree with George Washington University political scientist John Sides, who sees almost zero chance that anyone’s mind will be changed by this directly.

To see how I think it might matter, it’s worth thinking back to 2008, and why Hillary Clinton lost the Democratic nomination to a relatively inexperienced challenger. Barack Obama running a pitch-perfect campaign mattered a lot, as did Hillary Clinton’s vote for the Iraq War.

Her problems, however, went deeper. To start, she’s not a natural politician. Remember, the wheels started to come off the campaign bus for her in 2008 after her answer to this question on driver’s licenses for undocumented immigrants. It’s still hard to watch the exchange without cringing. Her speeches tended to be wooden and forced. She didn’t exude warmth.

Even more importantly — if you read any of the three synoptic gospels of the 2008 election – “Renegade,” “Game Change,” or “The Battle for America” – they all agree that her campaign was beset by infighting, poor judgment, and hubris. Clinton campaign strategists supposedly didn’t realize that the delegates were proportionally allocated. No one took Obama seriously (except for Bill). Her campaign overspent and then struggled for cash once the race became competitive. She had a bad relationship with the press. Crucially, the campaign failed to organize the caucus states, where Obama swept delegates in races where only a few hundred votes were cast. Yet in the fall of 2007, she was drawing up lists of vice presidential candidates.

Surely, many thought to themselves, this time will be different. There were signals that she was putting together the sort of larger-than-life, untouchable campaign that Obama put together in 2008 (and, to a lesser extent, 2012). Her Twitter account was set up deftly, she played coy with the press and her base regarding her campaign, and some tweets, such as the “grandmother knows best” one tweaking Republicans on vaccinations, seemed to suggest a very competent, sharp campaign. I had begun to muse privately whether she might not be able to re-create the Clinton coalition, which would lead to a truly astonishing win.

It is still extremely early, and Clinton isn’t even an announced candidate yet. For now, I actually view that as the overall “rule,” if you will, of how to evaluate the campaign. The problem is that these scandals introduce a caveat to that rule that wasn’t present before: That this scandal occurred, that it was handled the way it has been, and that the press is reacting how it has been reacting should concern Democrats.

It’s not “Republicans” and it’s not Fox News.

Another Update

The best commentary on the whole affair that I’ve read to date comes from political science professor Charles Lipson at RealClearPolitics:

If the former secretary of state actually wanted to come clean without disclosing truly private, personal documents, she has a simple solution – just hand over everything to the chief of the US National Archives. Their specialists are trained to deal with these records. They have independent IT specialists who can examine the drives, restore deleted documents, and then return to Hillary all of her personal emails—and only those. That’s all she is entitled to. The rest belong by law to the U.S. public. Is there any reason to resist this simple, obvious solution? There must be a very good one since she’s clearly not taking it.

In any event, Hillary’s resistance will fail—politically and probably legally. Federal judges will become involved since FOIA requests have been made. Second, the House committee investigating the Benghazi debacle that occurred under Clinton’s tenure at State has issued subpoenas for all these documents, and they will not accept Mrs. Clinton’s personal assurance that she has complied.

He goes on to explain why the strategy of painting the story as a political witch-hunt mounted by Sec. Clinton’s enemies isn’t going to work and how the story undercuts her campaign’s primary political strategy. Read the whole thing.

Yet Another Update

The editors of USA Today:

But over the years, including recently, her résumé has been hard to square with some mystifying decision-making. At times, she has appeared obsessed with secrecy, dating to the health care task force she led during Bill Clinton’s first term in the White House and the mysterious discovery of missing law firm records. And, along with her husband, she has shown a habit of playing by her own rules and surrounding herself with some aides of questionable judgment.

7 comments

Ms. Clinton Regrets

Yesterday, after a week of the story of her maintaining her own email server for her public business as Secretary of State fermenting, Secretary Clinton made public statements about it. The editors of the Washington Post aren’t satisfied:

HILLARY RODHAM Clinton offered a soupcon of regret at a news conference Tuesday for having used private e-mail exclusively during her nearly four years as secretary of state. “Looking back, it would’ve been better” if she had not used a private e-mail account for official business, she conceded. Ms. Clinton said she decided to do so for “convenience” because “I thought it would be easier to carry just one device for my work and for my personal e-mails instead of two.”

Ms. Clinton noted that it is a “government employee’s responsibility to determine what’s personal and what’s work-related.” In general, this has been true; if a State Department official writes a personal note to a family member from a work e-mail address, that official can decide to withhold it from government archives. Each official has a responsibility to preserve federal records — messages and documents about policies and decisions. The methods of preservation have differed over time and among agencies; some still use paper printouts, and others have software options for preserving a record or e-mail. Government agencies are required to move to electronic preservation of e-mail records by the end of 2016.

What Ms. Clinton did not mention was that the Obama administration had clearly directed officials to use government e-mail networks for official business. She departed from this for “convenience.” Did she know about the policy? Did others know of her exclusive use of private e-mail? Did anyone raise an objection?

The target audience for her statement was not her political opponents but mainstream media journalists. Judging by the WaPo editors’ response it wasn’t successful. I thought it was remarkably maladroit for major party presidential candidate frontrunner, especially in a statement you’ve had a week to prepare. The part I had particular difficulty with was her assertion that the Secret Service had secured the server. That raises a host of questions on its own. Perhaps we’re learning that the Secret Service has security capabilities that go well beyond physical security. Or perhaps we’re learning that Sec. Clinton isn’t aware of best practice in securing servers of which physical security is only one part.

It does appear as though physical security for the server was provided using public money. Was the server itself, its infrastructure, and its connectivity paid for with public money? Was this email server public or private?

I certainly hope we’re not in for a decade more of this.

Predictions, please. Has Sec. Clinton successfully dealt with this particular story? Does it have legs?

29 comments

You’ve Got to Change the Policies

Kevin Drum asks who David Brooks is arguing against in his most recent column:

I don’t quite get who Brooks is arguing against here. Larry Summers is the obvious target, but Summers has been clear that he thinks education is important, both individually and for the economy as a whole. He just doesn’t think that improved education is likely to have much impact on growing income inequality, which is driven by other factors.

But Brooks never even pretends to address this. I don’t think there are any prominent Democrats arguing that education isn’t important. Pretty much all of them are on board with good early-childhood education and better community colleges, among other things. That will help individuals and make the American economy stronger.

But will it rein in growing income inequality? As long as inequality is driven primarily by the gains of the top 1 percent—which it is—then it won’t. To address that particular problem, we have to look elsewhere.

I think the answer is “everybody”. Neither Republicans nor Democrats have much of an economic policy beyond education. It’s been our substitute for an industrial policy for the last three administrations.

As to Kevin’s assertion that the reason that income inequality is increasing is that the incomes of the top 1% of income earners are growing faster than those of the rest of us, that’s true but only in a mathematical sense. The incomes of the top 1% are growing because of policies that Republicans and Democrats, including Kevin, have supported for the last forty years or more. Those include trade, immigration, monetary, fiscal, healthcare, and on and on.

If you don’t like the inequality, you’ve got to change the policies.

13 comments

Watch the Behavior

Dovetailing nicely with the point I made yesterday about the discrepancy between the official numbers and how people are behaving, this post at Zerohedge from Charles Hugh Smith is interesting. Basically, purchasing managers are not behaving as though the country is on the verge of a boom which is the impression you might receive if you got absolutely all of your information from the The New York Times and the Washington Post.

Also, real wages are 4% lower than they were fifteen years ago:

In nominal terms, median household income is up a third from 2000–a strong showing indeed. But adjusted for official inflation (which understates inflation in key sectors such as healthcare and higher education), income has risen off the bottom (9.6% beneath 2000 levels) and is now only 3.9% below 2000 levels, but this is dismayingly at odds with the happy story of nominal gains.

This broad measure of household income doesn’t tell us how much of the gains have been captured by the top 10%; the top layer may have gained much more than the 90% below.

This also doesn’t reflect other potentially negative factors such as higher healthcare deductibles that lower actual take-home pay.

While “recovery” cheerleaders are busy predicting strong growth in wages going forward, they conveniently ignore that it will take another 4% of real gains just to get back to the levels of 15 years ago.

It doesn’t feel like a booming economy here in Chicago. Maybe my perspective is skewed. Maybe the official numbers are skewed.

4 comments

The Most Trusted Name in News

In the UK newspapers are clearly and openly associated with political parties. The Telegraph supports the Conservative Party to the extent that it’s wagginshly called “the Torygraph”. The Daily Mirror supports Labour.

Something of the same sort has happened here with television news. Fox News is thought of, at least by Democrats, as being a Republican news channel. MSNBC is widely thought of as Democratic news.

In a finding that I’m sure will be bitterly disputed by Democrats opinion polling has recently found Fox News, true to its catchphrase, to be the most trusted name in news. Tom Bevan remarks:

How many times have we heard someone say that Fox News and MSNBC are simply mirror images of each other? The numbers from the Quinnipiac poll show that comparison is wrong. One of the reasons Fox News keeps winning is that it has managed to build a solid reputation for its news coverage, one that extends beyond right-leaning viewers. And one of the reasons MSNBC keeps losing is that its programming – even during the daytime – has become so opinion driven that not even its fellow ideological travelers view it as a trustworthy source of news any more.

This is not a new finding. Nearly ten years ago I reported here on multiple impartial sources which found that Fox’s news coverage was the least biased. That has continued. Here’s a reference to a Pew study a few years ago. Here’s one to an earlier Pew study. Note that this is referring to the news coverage not the opinion coverage.

What leaps out to me in Tom’s post is how untrusted the broadcast news has become.

By and large I don’t follow the television news at all anymore. It must have been a half dozen years or more since I’ve even glanced at Fox News and I’ve never watched MSNBC. I’ve found it unwatchable. I get almost all of my news online and, shall we say, cast a wide net. I read the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, the BBC, and Al Jazeera, which I have found to have remarkably good news coverage. For sub-Saharan African news I generally check in with the French language media which I have found to have much more coverage and I check in frequently on the Russian language media which always has a drastically different point-of-view than anything you’ll see in the States.

16 comments