The International Order and China As Threat

There’s an interesting article at Foreign Policy in Focus that challenges the notion that China poses a superpower military threat to the United States or will do so in the foreseeable future:

China has become the bête noire of U.S. security policy, the new universal enemy to replace the Soviet Union.

Its economic power and rapid military build-up, after all, make it a much more credible long-term threat than Putin’s Russia or the Islamic State. When policy pundits and military men want to spread alarm about the decline of America and beat the drum for increased defense spending, their scary enemy of choice is China.

Take James Jay Carafano, a retired military man and a policy pundit at the right-wing Heritage Foundation who raises the possibility of “a U.S.-China Nuclear War.” He argues at The National Interest that keeping the peace between China and the United States “requires significantly recapitalizing the U.S. armed forces.” This is necessary, he says, to assuage the doubts and insecurities of America’s allies. He argues that Washington “has to close any gap in military power that the Chinese might think could be exploited.”

Read the whole thing.

Back in the early days of the George W. Bush Administration there was a persistent attempt to cast China as a threat to U. S. security not that the Chinese didn’t give us cause for believing that. That was put on the backburner during the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq but I see that, clearly, it’s an idea of which some people never tire. It makes sense. If the kind of war you want to prepare to fight is great power high tech war (and there are still plenty of Pentagon folks who’ve based their careers around planning for great power high tech war), there are really only two candidates for opponents: China and Russia. Since the prevailing wisdom on those two countries is that Russia is the declining power and China the rising power, China it is.

I think that’s far-fetched not only for the reasons expressed in the article but for demographic reasons, social reasons, and economic reasons. The number of people of working age, coincidentally the same age as fighting age, has actually started to decline in China, just as I pointed out a decade ago. To send people to war China would need to use the young people it needs to work in its factories. These are the same singletons who, due to the One Child Policy, are the sole support of their aging parents. There would be significant resistance to numbers of young people fighting and dying. Keep in mind that China is still a Confucian society.

Finally, the United States is China’s largest trading partner and largest source of foreign exchange, something China desperately needs to purchase the raw materials for its factories and to keep its vehicles powered. The Chinese leaders aren’t crazy. They don’t want to go to war with the U. S. It would be terribly bad for business.

Is it impossible that we will go to war with China? No. I just think it’s very unlikely.

In considering why the idea that China is a major security threat to the United States is so resilient I think you need to go back to some models of the international order. One idea is that everything is guided by the United Nations and that without Security Council approval war is obsolete. In my view that model is fatuous. The permanent members of the Security Council, the ghosts of the World War II Allies, include the U. S., China, and Russia. Lack of Security Council approval has not been a barrier to any of their going to war in the past and I can’t believe it will be so in the future.

The second model, sadly one that is quite prevalent in the United States, could be thought of as the “Pax Americana model”. In that model there is room for only one power, not just one superpower, but one power and we’re it. No other country has interests or will be allowed to pursue them. I think that’s the context for the notion that China is a security threat to the United States. It’s only a threat if we view any interest by any country that is even tangential to our own as a threat.

The model that I prefer is an old one: spheres of influence. The idea goes back at least to 1885 when the Earl of Granville, the British Foreign Secretary, wrote a letter to his opposite number in Germany outlining how the two countries should divvy Africa up into “spheres of action”. During the Cold War the same concept was referred to as “spheres of influence”. Eastern Europe was the Soviet Union’s sphere of influence. Western Europe was ours.

China and Russia, just to pick two countries at random, have interests. Not only should we expect them to pursue those interests but interests can be ranked. Russia is more interested in Ukraine than we are; China is more interested in North Korea.

Japan is much more interested in pursuing its own interests and, possibly, remaining free of limitations that might be imposed on it by China, than we are. In my view we should expect China to act to secure its interests, Japan should act to secure its own, and we should not conflate Japanese interests with U. S. interests. They have points of intersection but they aren’t identical. Japan is quite capable of looking after themselves and we should not only recognize that we should welcome it.

Viewed in that light China is no threat to the United States. It is merely another country that has interests just as Japan is. Just as India is. Just as we are.

3 comments

Watcher’s Council Nominations

The members of the Watcher’s Council have nominated the following for consideration by the Council:

The Noisy Room – The Faustian Pact Between Obama And Iran

Terresa does not care for the agreement the Obama Administration is negotiating with Iran. I think it’s a waste of time and breath but I don’t have the passion about it that Terresa does.

Don Surber – Prime Minister: “Australians are sick of being lectured to by the United Nations”

Newcomer to the Watcher’s Council but certainly not to the blogosphere Don Surber writes in praise of the Australian prime minister, Tony Abbott.

The Right Planet – The Silencers

Brent pens an obituary for M. Stanton Evans.

GrEaT sAtAn”S gIrLfRiEnD – If War Is The Best Option

GsGf writes in praise of an op-ed I thought, frankly, was loony.

Joshuapundit–The Chicken Or The Egg?

Joshuapundit writes on the quandary facing Muslims. I’m in not position to make sweeping generalizations about Islam but I certainly agree with his conclusion.

The Glittering Eye –The History of ‘Advice and Consent’

VA Right! – Is the Location of Hillary Clinton’s Email Server 75 Broad St New York, NY 10004?

Tom does a little detective work trying to find the physical location of Hillary Clinton’s private email server.

The Razor – The New Eco-Feminist Top Gear Unveiled

Scott writes about an Eco-Feminist alternative to the automotive program Top Gear.

Nice Deb – President Bystander Blames Bush For ISIS – Even Though He Funded Them and They Metastasized On His Watch

Deb notes that President Obama does seem to have a never-ending desire to blame President Bush. I do notice an amazing lack of self-awareness on the president’s part.

>Bookworm Room – Trevor Loudon tells enthralled Marin County audience that victory in 2016 requires uniting and inspiring conservative base

Bookworm writes on attending a lecture by former Council member Trevor Loudon.

The Independent Sentinel – Unbelievable: Iran Is Off the Terrorism List and Assisting Obama in Defeating Congress

Iran is on Sara’s mind this week, too.

Ask Marion – Beating The Odds

Marion writes about the experience of fighting and beating cancer.

Rhymes With Right – But The Obama Administration Assured Us These Folks Were Poor People Who Just Needed Jobs!

Greg notes that a sense of entitlement seems to be a better predictor of violent radical Islamism than poverty.

Well, I’ve decided which posts to vote for. Which posts would get your votes? The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

4 comments

The Upside of Power Outage

At 8:00am this morning I received a robocall from ComEd warning me that there would be a scheduled power outage in one hour to perform unspecified maintenance. I carefully powered our various computers down. Three hours later when no power outage had occurred, I powered up one of my computers. No sooner had it booted than power went down. It must be one of those things like washing your care.

Well, now I know for sure that my battery backup is working. I quickly powered the computer down. Ten minutes later the power was restored. I waited another twenty minutes (just in case) and then started powering things back up again.

I’m a bit paranoid on this subject. I have battery backups on all of my computers and on my broadband modem and network switches. I really prefer to power things off and bring them back up gracefully. That’s probably not as necessary as it used to be but it still reassures me to do it.

0 comments

Improving the Healthcare System

Here three prescriptions for improving the U. S. healthcare system that can be implemented by the states and don’t require massive federal bureaucracies to impose or enforce. If they look familiar to you, it might be because I’ve mentioned all of them at one time or another around here. The reforms proposed are:

  • Eliminate certificates of need
  • Reform scope-of-practice laws
  • Remove the regulatory barriers to telemedicine

About two-thirds of the states require one version or another of certificates of need, warrants that a new or expanded facility does not duplicate resources already available. These are obviously anti-competitive. While there is no ironclad proof that competition reduces costs or improves care, there is no credible proof that the absence of competition does, either. CONs mostly serve existing providers and, at the very least, the circumstances under which they must be obtained should be narrowed. How much sense does it really make for a physician to spend a quarter mil to obtain a CON to purchase another MRI machine?

Scope-of-practice laws limit what nurses, nurse practitioners, physicians’ assistants and other similar providers are allowed to do. I’m sympathetic with such regulations but they have problems, too. Here’s an example. Is a PA who finished his or her education and training five years ago really that much less prepared to provide primary care than a physician who was trained 50 years ago? The answer isn’t obvious. I’ve seen studies that suggest that MD degrees have a shelf life. I don’t think that all procedures should be open to nurse practitioners or PAs but I do think the issue needs to be revisited on a regular basis, something the regulatory system just isn’t all that good at.

If it isn’t already, telemedicine is going to be a fact of life, particularly in poorly-served rural areas. It’s already widely performed in some places in the world, e.g. Australia. I know of radiology labs and pathology labs that already send routine stuff to India which means that providers are reaping the economic surplus rather than consumers. If physicians’ and regulatory organizations don’t get out in front of the trend towards telemedicine, it will overwhelm them.

3 comments

Dallas Seavey Wins 2015 Iditarod

Dallas Seavey, the winner of last year’s Iditarod, has won the 2015 Iditarod:

NOME — Behind a strong team of nine champion Alaska huskies, 28-year-old Dallas Seavey from Willow rolled under the burled arch on Front Street in this fabled gold mining town in the wee hours of Wednesday to seal the deal on a victory in the 1,000-mile Iditarod Trail Sled Dog Race and put the Seavey stamp solidly on the current era of Alaska dog mushing.

[…]

Combined with his father’s win in 2013, Dallas’s win Wednesday gave the Seavey family title to victories in four straight Iditarods.

He gave full credit to the dogs.

“As long as you take care of the dog team and make good decisions, good things will happen,” he said. “We loved every second of it.”

Dallas’s coronation as the new king of the Iditarod had been clear since White Mountain, the penultimate checkpoint, on Monday. With only 75 miles left to the finish line and a lead of more than 4 hours over father Mitch, his nearest competitor, Dallas’s team could almost have walked to Nome and won.

But they trotted smartly over the Topkok Hills and along the famous beaches of golden sands to reach the finish line in an unofficial time of 8 days, 18 hours, 13 minutes and 6 seconds — about four hours off last year’s time on a course that ran mainly on the rivers of Alaska’s Interior. Seavey conceded it was flatter than the traditional route over the Alaska Range, but said it was every bit as challenging.

I haven’t covered the race as much this year as in previous years but that doesn’t mean we haven’t been following it here. We’ve been checking in on the race on a daily basis—the Internet coverage from Iditarod.com has been great. I may have more on this year’s race later. I just got a call that ComEd was turning the power off.

4 comments

St. Patrick’s Day, 2015

Somehow I feel compelled to mention this every St. Patrick’s Day. I’m at least a quarter Irish and possibly as much as half Irish. After fifty years of genealogical research that’s as specific as I can be. I have two parents, four grandparents, and eight great-grandparents, just like most people. Of my four maternal great-grandparents at least two were Irish and one may have been half Irish. My best guess if that the other great-grandparent was mostly French (it’s possible that half Irish great-grandparent was Irish and French, too).

My best high school buddy, among the most Irish Americans I know with four grandparents all born in Ireland, used to wear orange on St. Patrick’s Day in protest.

18 comments

What Law Did Hillary Break?

A question that has been asked (frequently truculently) by some supporters of Hillary Clinton about her decision to do all of her public business while Secretary of State on a completely private email address and server has been what law did she break in doing so? After three weeks of the story being in the media, we finally have an answer from Dan Metcalfe, former head of the Department of Justice’s Office of Information and Privacy. It’s the Federal Records Act:

To be sure, this cannot as a practical matter be absolute. When Obama administration officials came into office in 2009, the Federal Records Act certainly allowed room for the occasional use of a personal email account for official business where necessary—such as when a secretary of state understandably must deal with a crisis around the world in the middle of the night while an official email device might not be readily at hand. That just makes sense. But even then, in such an exceptional situation, the Federal Records Act’s documentation and preservation requirements still called upon that official (or a staff assistant) to forward any such email into the State Department’s official records system, where it would have been located otherwise.
This appears to be exactly what former Secretary of State Colin Powell did during his tenure, just as other high-level government officials may do (or are supposed to do) under such exceptional circumstances during their times in office. Notwithstanding Secretary Clinton’s sweeping claims to the contrary, there actually is no indication in any of the public discussions of this “scandal” that anyone other than she managed to do what she did (or didn’t) do as a federal official.

It’s a good, information, not politically-motivated article by a knowledgeable and authoritative individual and I recommend you read the whole thing.

Hat tip: memeorandum

Update

Here’s a bit of the relevant code, 18 U.S.C. 2071:

(a) Whoever willfully and unlawfully conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, or destroys, or attempts to do so, or, with intent to do so takes and carries away any record, proceeding, map, book, paper, document, or other thing, filed or deposited with any clerk or officer of any court of the United States, or in any public office, or with any judicial or public officer of the United States, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.
(b) Whoever, having the custody of any such record, proceeding, map, book, document, paper, or other thing, willfully and unlawfully conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, falsifies, or destroys the same, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both; and shall forfeit his office and be disqualified from holding any office under the United States. As used in this subsection, the term “office” does not include the office held by any person as a retired officer of the Armed Forces of the United States.

It’s going to be an interesting time.

Update 2

There’s more on a related issue from Ronald Rotunda:

The law says that no one has to use email, but it is a crime (18 U.S.C. section 1519) to destroy even one message to prevent it from being subpoenaed. Prosecutors charging someone with obstruction don’t even have to establish that any investigation was pending or under way when the deletion took place. As T. Markus Funk explained in a journal article for the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, the prosecutor “need only prove that the defendant shredded the documents, at least in part, to make life more difficult for future investigators, if and when they eventually appear.”

Legal commentators call this “anticipatory obstruction of justice,” and the law punishes it with up to 20 years imprisonment. The burden of proof is light. The Justice Department manual advises that section 1519 makes prosecution much easier because it covers “any matters” or “’in relation to or contemplation of’ any matters.” It adds, “No corrupt persuasion is required.”

In addition, rules governing the practice of law forbid attorneys from anticipatory obstruction of justice. These ethics rules are drafted by the American Bar Association, but they are also reflected in real law. Virtually every state court adopts them, and violation can lead to disbarment. Rule 3.4 (which has been around for many years) provides that an attorney shall not unlawfully “conceal a document or other material having potential evidentiary value.” Mrs. Clinton is a lawyer governed by these rules. So are any attorneys who advised her to delete her emails.

As I’ve written before, just because they’re lawyers doesn’t mean they’re good lawyers.

24 comments

Iraq Status

At this point the campaign against DAESH in Iraq appears to be stalled or, at the very least, inhaling. Here’s how things stand at this point.

The campaign to unseat DAESH in Tikrit in Anbar province is paused:

Operations by Iraqi forces to capture Tikrit from Islamic State militants have been temporarily halted to allow civilians to leave the city, the country’s interior minister said.

Mohammed Salem al-Ghabban said the offensive, which started early this month, has achieved 90% of its objectives and squeezed the militants into a small part of the city center.

Speaking Monday, al-Ghabban said that extremists from the Islamic State, also known as ISIS and ISIL, had booby-trapped buildings in the center of the city and that Iraqi forces, backed by Shiite militias and Iranian advisers, had slowed their push to reduce their casualties, protect the infrastructure and allow residents to leave.

That’s the benign interpretation of what’s happening. There are others, for example it might be that the leaders of the pro-government forces just don’t know what to do at this point and are trying to make up their minds.

in Ramadi DAESH is intensifying its efforts:

(Bloomberg) — Islamic State militants have increased their attacks to capture Ramadi since Iraq began a military operation to retake the city of Tikrit in Salahuddin province, said Faleh al-Issawi, deputy chief of the Anbar provincial council.

The group has hit Ramadi, the capital of Anbar province, with 150 mortar shells and attacked security forces with 23 car bombings since Wednesday, al-Issawi said in a telephone interview Saturday.

Ramadi is an hour and a half by truck from Baghdad.

The pro-government forces’ campaign to re-take Mosul has not yet begun. There are reports that Muslawi are attempting to flee the city but that’s been true for some time.

1 comment

No Legs

Barring some new revelation it looks to me as though the Hillary Clinton email story is dying down. There’ll be a Congressional investigation, of course, and I would predict that, unless the Republicans are most careful than we’ve seen lately, they’ll fare worse from them than Sec. Clinton will.

As I have said before, I believe that just about everybody has made up their minds one way or another about Sec. Clinton and aren’t likely to change them at this point. That implies that, should she actually run for president as just about everybody assumes she will, whether she is elected will depend more on convincing voters that support her to turn out and vote than it does on convincing people that she’d make a good president.

I would like to ask Clinton supporters a question. Do you believe that the email story will induce more of Sec. Clinton’s supporters to turn out and vote, will induce more of Sec. Clinton’s opponents to turn out and vote, or will have no effect?

Said another way, at this point what difference does it make?

18 comments

Engagement for Engagement’s Sake

The editors of the Washington Post have examined the Obama Administration’s policy on Burma and found it wanting:

During his last visit to the country, in November, Mr. Obama set five tests for measuring whether the transition from authoritarianism “has been fully realized.” The regime is failing all of them. It has not, as the president urged, moved to remove the constitutional ban on Ms. Suu Kyi. Instead of negotiating a cease-fire with ethnic rebel groups, it has escalated military operations against them. Mr. Obama urged fair treatment of religious minorities, but the regime is preparing new discriminatory laws. It is proceeding with a vicious campaign to deny rights, including voting rights, to the Muslim Rohingya minority.

Another of Mr. Obama’s tests was “basic issues of freedom and personal security,” such as the treatment of journalists and protesters. The result can be found in a Feb. 25 statement by the United Nations’ human rights high representative, Zeid Raad al-Hussein, who cited the jailing of 10 journalists and numerous peaceful protesters before concluding that the regime “seems intent on creating a new generation” of political prisoners. An ongoing crackdown on students only strengthens that judgment.

The generals are planning to stage an election this year, but it will not be the “fair, free, transparent election” Mr. Obama called for. Because the military is allocated 25 percent of the seats in parliament, the ruling party can retain power by winning only 34 percent of the elected seats. Ms. Suu Kyi is weighing whether to boycott the vote. If she does, the political process could collapse, but the alternative is legitimizing a facade of democracy over continued military rule.

Having rushed to lift sanctions as part of his engagement strategy, Mr. Obama now lacks leverage. The administration watches passively as the regime does the opposite of what the president called for. It’s a humiliating spectacle — and one that should give pause to those who believe that Mr. Obama’s variety of “engagement” will get results with other dictatorships.

I would welcome being given a half billion dollars without anything being expected in return and I suspect the military junta running Burma is no different. Neither engagement nor negotiations are good of themselves but only good to the degree that they result in good outcomes. Sometimes our best options in dealing wicked regimes is just not having anything to do with them and encouraging others to do the same.

8 comments