Trading Places

Here is the meat of Joseph Epstein’s WSJ review of Shelby Steele’s book, Shame:

“Liberalism in the twenty-first century,” Mr. Steele writes, “is, for the most part, a moral manipulation that exaggerates inequity and unfairness in American life in order to justify overreaching public policies and programs.” This liberalism, which is not your Aunt Bessie’s liberalism but the liberalism that came into play at the 1972 Democratic convention that nominated George McGovern, “is invested in an overstatement of America’s present sinfulness based on the nation’s past sins.” Mr. Steele argues that liberalism’s efforts to alleviate the past injustices done to blacks in America have amounted to another botched project of that famously failed political construction firm, the Good Intentions Paving Co. “Liberalism,” Mr. Steele writes, “expresses its inborn racism in the way it overlooks the full human complexity of blacks—the fact that they are more than mere victims—in order to distill and harden the idea of their victimization into a currency of liberal power.”

Liberals, Mr. Steele holds, deal in what he calls “poetic truth.” This is a kind of truth “conceived in reaction to the great shames of America’s past—racism, sexism, territorial conquest (manifest destiny), corporate greed, militarism, and so on.” In poetic truth, the world is reduced to victims and victimizers, with liberals alone innocent of evil and thus excluded, by self-dissociation, from the role of victimizers. Under the realm of poetic truth, Mr. Steele explains, the race riots of the late 1960s could find justification and the feminist slogan “woman as nigger” could be taken seriously, while “fifty years of real moral evolution in America” can be entirely ignored.

After the 1960s, in Mr. Steele’s reading, authority was undermined and “authenticity” put in its place. Authenticity, he writes, “meant the embrace of new idealisms and new identities that explicitly untethered you from America’s notorious hypocrisies.” Through rebellion, antiwar activity, dissent, civil and uncivil disobedience, and dropping out before selling out, authenticity rendered one innocent of all the old evils associated with American power, domestic and international; authenticity also gave one the right to view “traditional America as a fundamentally hypocritical society.”

Mr. Steele does not use the word, but authenticity also conferred virtue on those who chose it. Self-virtue is the ultimate consolation to be found in the poetic truth of the new politics that came into being in the 1960s, and millions of Americans, rich white liberals prominent among them—recall Leonard Bernstein’s famous party for the Black Panthers—gloried in it. These politics changed the nature of liberalism from a reform-minded, character-forming set of political ideas into “a broad, guilt-driven, moralistic liberalism in which at least a vague anti-Americanism was decency itself.” America, in this interpretation, is essentially evil, and those who oppose it from within are thereby good. Hence the claim to moral superiority of the protest groups—blacks, women, gays et al.—of our day. For black Americans, the claim to moral superiority took the form of grievance, boisterous, unrelenting and willfully blind to any evidence of progress.

The new liberalism, eager to bring about The Good (Mr. Steele’s capital letters), went in for social engineering to accomplish its missionary work. For Mr. Steele not The Good but true good “would include an incentive to minorities to in fact become equal with all others by talent and merit . . . [and] would ask minorities to assimilate into modernity even if that felt like self-betrayal. . . . And it would discourage them from building a group identity singularly focused on protest. . . . Instead, all would be focused on their becoming competitive.” Blacks, Mr. Steele argues, ran into serious discrimination in sports and music, and yet in these competitive fields “their excellence and merit ultimately prevailed over all else.”

As things now stand in American political life, the desire for equality has trumped freedom; self-virtue, honesty; and preferential programs, the development of character. The effect of these liberal victories has been to lessen the quality of American life. Consider the contemporary university, where the goal of diversity, enforced by the whiphand of political correctness, has brought in various minority studies, women’s and gay studies, and other intellectual vulgarities in the name of redressing old injustices and mollifying grievances. The humanities and the social sciences have become hopelessly tendentious, the ideal of truth besmirched and higher education itself turned sadly comic.

IMO the politics, particularly the party politics, of race relations in the United States is more complicated than that passage might lead you to believe. It is a matter of record that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was enacted into law by a bipartisan vote in which three-fifths of Democrats voted “Yea” while just about 70% of Republicans voted “Yea”. In other words its passage required the supermajority of Republican votes. However, my judgment is that many of the Democrats who voted “Nay” would become Republicans within a few years while the Republicans who voted “Yea” would be considered RINOs by today’s standards and would probably be independents.

I also think that it’s true that the Democratic Party has not done right by its black constituents. For one coarse measurement about one in five Democrats is black. In the present Senate there’s only one black senator and he’s a Republican. It would be reasonable for ten of the Democrats to be black. Why are there no black Democratic senators?

There has been a robust dialogue in the black community over the last century or more over how that community should be advancing. A century ago the exemplars of two of the competing views were Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois. A half century ago the contrasting views were exemplified by Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Jr. Today I don’t think it’s completely out of line to point to Mr. Steele’s taking one side with most of the black intelligentsia arrayed against him.

Today we’re hearing calls for dialogue about race relations but it’s not clear to me what that means. “Dialogue” generally means a conversation in which both parties participate rather than a lecture, an airing of grievances, or a shouting match. I’m all for dialogue. Lectures or airing of grievances, not so much.

I wish I had some solutions. I don’t.

10 comments

What Is It Good For?

In reaction to Tom Friedman’s most recent column, arguing that DAESH could serve the useful function of opposing Iranian power, Pat Lang retorts:

While we are speaking of hard truths – Iran under its current form of government, Syria as ruled by Assad, Lebanon with Hezbollah and even Iraq being controlled by the Shia is at worst an inconvenience for the West and the US, but a thorn in the eyes of the Gulfies (for paranoia and religious reasons) and Israelis (for paranoia and in pursuit of local hegemony).

The idea the Gulfies and Izzies sell in DC is that the US must adopt their favourite enemies as their own, and that the US must help destroy them. Friedmann find no flaw in that. While he professes to despise ISIS as much as the next guy, he despises Iran more.

Where, if I may ask, is the US interest in aiding Israeli maximalist ambitions or in helping spread the Gulfie’s profoundly anti-Western religious chauvinism in Iraq and Syria?

Pat is much more anti-Israel than I but on this subject we’re in agreement. I think we’ve confused our interests with those of our allies and, worse, with those of our clients. Pat seems to think that’s a consequence of canny public relations. I think there must be more to it.

The notion that my enemy’s enemy is my friend goes back several millennia at least. I think the notion that my friend’s enemy is inherently my enemy, too, is problematic. The enemy of my frenemy is what? How would you even evaluate it?

1 comment

The Poisoned Pill

I am generally wary of John McCain’s advice. He holds a view of America’s proper role in the world that is quite remote from mine. In particular he seems to believe in much more use of force by the United States than I believe is prudent.

That said in the video above he says something that’s remarkably astute about the large number of Chinese students who have been studying in the United States to the effect that when they go home they’re not satisfied with what they see in China. I was reminded of G. K. Chesterton’s remark that the value of foreign travel is the ability to return to your native land and see it as though going to a foreign one.

The part that I’m referring to is at about 3:30.

0 comments

Singing Cowboys

I’ve never been a great fan of singing cowboys. By and large it never looks to me as they do either (singing or being a cowboy) particularly well. However, when I was a kid television, hungry for content, was just full of B-movies and movie serials from the 1930s and 40s and you could hardly escape singing cowboys so I’ve probably been more exposed to the genre than most of my readers have.

The first singing cowboy was Ken Maynard. His 1929 movie, The Wagon Master, is generally considered the first movie featuring a singing cowboy. I’ve never seen it. I honestly don’t know that I’ve ever seen a Ken Maynard picture. He’d been a trick rider with the Wild West Show so I expect his stunts are pretty good. The impression I’ve received is that his horse, Tarzan, was actually the star of his movies. To the best of my knowledge the second singing cowboy was, of all people, John Wayne in 1933’s Riders of Destiny which I have seen. It’s pretty much what you’d expect.

Bob Steele, one of the best B-movie cowboy stars and later in his career a great heavy (see his performance as Lash Canino in The Big Sleep), also did a stint as a singing cowboy.

Gene Autry was unquestionably the most successful of all singing cowboys and, due to his recordings of “Frosty the Snowman” and “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer”, people still recognize his voice today. IMO he has a pleasant screen affect and his pictures wear pretty well today. A lot of Gene Autry’s success was undoubtedly due to his business acumen. Here’s a tip: use the money you make starring as a singing cowboy to buy radio and TV stations in Southern California.

Tex Ritter, a prolific singing cowboy star (and the father of the late John Ritter), is probably most recognized today for singing the “Do Not Forsake Me, Oh My Darlin'” in High Noon.

After Gene Autry the singing cowboy best-known today must be Roy Rogers who was given his start in movies by Gene Autry. A founding member of the Sons of the Pioneers, he had a couple of hits under his belt before he turned to being a singing cowboy on the screen. Despite that solid start, I’d say the reason that he’s remembered today is timing. His TV show which was syndicated for decades is still remembered by millions of Baby Boomers.

From a singing standpoint Dick Foran was probably the best of the singing cowboys. He wasn’t much as a cowboy or an actor though.

No post on singing cowboys would be complete without mentioning Herb Jeffries, the Bronze Buckaroo. He made four westerns targeted to the black audience in the late 1930s. He’s a good singer and the movies aren’t bad, considering their ultra-low budgets.

My understanding is that there was a robust tradition of singing cowboys during the Golden Age of Mexican cinema in 1930, 40s, and 50s but that’s outside my experience.

6 comments

The Scorecard

PolitiFact offers a scorecard of predictions about the Affordable Care Act:

Predictions about the health care law were a dime a dozen back in 2010. Supporters contended that virtually everyone around the country would soon have access to affordable insurance. Opponents said the law would cost a fortune by adding to the national debt and killing jobs.

Actually, none of those things have happened.

A lot more people remain uninsured than supporters of the PPACA were predicting when the law was enacted and nobody knows whether the lower cost has anything to do with the PPACA or not.

My opinion on evaluating the results of the PPACA remain what it has been for some time: it’s too early to tell. Most of the provisions of the law weren’t implemented until 2014. Some won’t be implemented until years from now. Others will never be implemented.

I think that when the federal government starts phasing out its subsidization of the expansion of Medicaid in 2017 it will be telling. I don’t know how the states will respond but I do know that lots of states including Illinois don’t have the money to pay the full freight for the expansion.

10 comments

Greatest Western Movies (Updated)

It occurred to me yesterday evening that, although I’d made lots of lists of the best (or, at least, my favorite) movies in a number of different genres, I’d never produced my list of the greatest westerns. When I began thinking about it I realized that I’d need to impose some caveats and restrictions on my list. You could come up with a list of ten great westerns that were all John Wayne pictures. In looking at various lists of great westerns it wasn’t hard to see that about a third of the lists were typically composed of John Wayne pictures. Or Clint Eastwood pictures.

So I decided to impose restrictions on my list. I don’t like “spaghetti westerns” so I’m limiting my list to American westerns. And I’m limiting my picks to one pick per lead actor. The list is in alphabetical order.

The Fastest Gun Alive (Updated)

I forgot to include this picture in my original list. An unlikely and unwilling hero played by Glenn Ford, a menacing, psychopathic villain played by Broderick Crawford, and an ending that’ll probably surprise you. IMO this movie is a neglected gem.

The Magnificent Seven

This re-working of Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai is outstanding for any number of reasons including its Oscar-winning score and its assembling of a group of fine character actors, some of whom gave their best performances in this movie.

Open Range

This movie proved several things. It’s still possible to make a great western. Kevin Costner is capable of making a great western. Robert Duvall can do no wrong.

The Ox-Bow Incident

My Darling Clementine makes a lot of people’s greatest western lists but I think if you’re going to pick just one Henry Fonda picture it should be this one. I think it’s head and shoulders above My Darling Clementine if only because it doesn’t have Victor Mature in it.

Ride the High Country

I like this movie, about the end of the Old West and starring Joel McCrea and Randolph Scott, the best of all Sam Peckinpah’s films. Two of Hollywood’s handsomest leading men and iconic western stars and possibly Randolph Scott’s best performance. Joel McCrea is a sadly unappreciated actor these days and I’m not sure why. He excelled in practically every genre.

The Searchers

What can I say about The Searchers that hasn’t already been said? This may well be the best western ever made. It’s certainly the best John Wayne western ever made.

Sergeant Rutledge

This John Ford western was bold in its day. And Woody Strode was clearly one of our best western movie actors. Check out the pictures he was in.

Shane

Alan Ladd is simply poetry in this picture. Great performances. Great cinematography. Great climax. Iconic ending. It really gives a new meaning to “riding off into the sunset”.

The Sooner

The very first American movie was a western and the number of great silent westerns is huge. The Sooner is my favorite silent western. It stars William S. Hart who, as it worked out, had been both a cowboy and a Shakespearean actor. That’s a combination you don’t run into much anymore.

The Westerner

I don’t care for High Noon. No list of great westerns would be complete without a Gary Cooper movie and as it works out The Westerner is a better picture than High Noon anyway.

Unforgiven

I read an amusing anecdote about Unforgiven. As the story goes Clint Eastwood purchased the rights to this story back in the 70s and then waited until he got old enough to play the part to make the movie. One of only three westerns to win an Academy Award as Best Picture.

Winchester ’73

This picture was the first collaboration and between Jimmy Stewart and Anthony Mann. Theirs was one of the great partnerships in cinema, right up there with John Wayne and John Ford. And Shelley Winters’s pretty trashiness was a real asset in this picture. This picture might have more great heavies than any other western ever made. And check out Will Geer’s performance as Wyatt Earp. You may not recognize him as Grandpa Walton.

Which westerns do you think are the best? I’m sure your list is different from mine.

27 comments

Value-Added Taxes

If it’s a tax, you can expect the editors of the Wall Street Journal to be against it. In their recent editorial the target of their ire is the value-added tax or VAT:

The VAT is a sort of turbo-charged national sales tax on goods and services that is applied at each stage of production, not merely on retail transactions. Politicians love it because it is the most efficient revenue-raiser known to man, and its rates can be raised gradually to finance new entitlements or fill budget holes. The VAT is typically introduced with a low rate but then moves up over time until it swallows huge chunks of national economies.

The reasons stated for opposing a VAT include a) their rates inevitably increase and b) politicians can’t resist awarding lower rates to sectors they want to favor. Both of those are true of all taxes not just VAT.

If you believe that government expenditures must be kept more or less in line with government revenues and you can find no way to place a limit on the things you want the government to do, you will always want higher taxes. It’s as simple as that and it pertains to defense spending as much as it does to spending on healthcare.

I’ll just point out that the economically optimal tax in the United States today would be to eliminate all income taxes and payroll taxes in favor of a progressive consumption tax. The basic principle is that if you tax something, there will be less of it. Do we really need less income and fewer jobs?

6 comments

Brave New World

In his most recent column George Will writes on “assortative mating”:

Those favored by genetics and by family acculturation of the acquired social capital (the habits and dispositions necessary for taking advantage of opportunities) tend to go to school and then to work together. And they marry one another, concentrating advantages in their children.

Hence today’s interest in what is called privilege theory, which takes a dark view of the old couplet “All men are by nature equal/ but differ greatly in the sequel.” The theory leaps from the obvious to the dubious. Obviously some people are born with, and into, advantages, congenital and social. What is dubious is the conclusion that government has the capacity and duty to calibrate, redistribute and equalize advantages.

Consistent with the president’s recent musing over the solution to low voter participation, isn’t there a simple solution to the problems of inequality abetted by assortative mating? Just have the government determine who should have whose children. And take the societally vital task of child rearing away from parents so that children might be reared to promote greater social equality? Maybe Huxley was on to something.

I think that the key phrase in Mr. Will’s column might be “suitable partners”. Is it possible that it’s a lot easier to change the economy and the society than it it to change what men and women consider to be “suitable partners”?

4 comments

Who’d a Thunk It?

The editors of the Washington Post are appalled at the Senate Democratic minority’s lack of willingness to compromise:

There are legitimate concerns about whether the Hyde Amendment’s provisions — it allows abortions only in the cases of rape, incest and danger to the mother’s life — are broad enough to cover young women forced into sexual exploitation. But the question of whether and how congressional appropriations can be used for abortions has long been settled, for better or worse. There is, as we wrote earlier this week, a reasonable way for the two sides to compromise on the trafficking bill, but both sides need to be reasonable. Sadly, that was not the case for Senate Democrats this week.

I’m beginning to lose track. Is a hardline stance by a Congressional minority obstruction of progress, childish stubbornness, and the next thing to treason? Or it is high-minded principle and a refusal to surrender the good of the people to the heartless majority?

Maybe it’s exactly what you’d expect in today’s political climate in which through gerrymandering (and increasingly sophisticated get-out-the-vote strategies) legislators pick their constituencies rather than the other way around and the political views of the legislators are more extreme than those of the communities they notionally serve?

1 comment

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments