The Rhetorical War Between Iran and Saudi Arabia

The Saud family’s position is dependent on two things: their control over the oil fields in the northeast of the country in an area in which a majority of the people are Shi’ites and their claim to be the protectors of the Muslim holy places. Adam Silverman explains how the Iranians are now attacking them on both of those fronts, rhetorically at least.

If this keeps up the Sauds are going to get the impression that the Iranians don’t like them.

6 comments

China Pursues Its Interests

Hugh White is worried that China has interests:

For a long time American (and Australian) thinking about China has been dominated by a broad consensus that, despite many signs of growing assertiveness, Beijing does not pose a fundamental challenge to US leadership in Asia. The argument goes that, whatever they might say, China’s leaders know that its economic future is too uncertain, its political system too fragile, its military too weak and its friends too few to allow it to contest American primacy. They also know that China’s own stability and prosperity depend on the regional order that only America can uphold.

Therefore, the consensus has concluded, America doesn’t have to do much in response except remind everyone that it intends to stick around. Hence the ‘pivot’, which has emphasised declaratory statements rather than substantive actions.

But that consensus may be unravelling, at least in America. Washington’s AIIB debacle seems to have sounded a wake-up call and now, in just the past week, two major reports from the heart of the US foreign policy establishment have chimed in too. Both reports argue that China’s challenge to US primacy in Asia is for real, and that America’s policy in Asia needs to shift radically to respond.

I think that our policy with respect to China has been bad for 40 years but, presumably, not in the way that Mr. White does. I think that Nixon erred in opening U. S. relations with China, Clinton erred in granting China “Most Favored Nation” status, and the world erred in admitting China to the World Trade Federation. Just to name a few among many missteps.

We needed to approach all of those things with the patience the Chinese authorities would have shown. Confucius once said that if your plan is a one year plan, plant rice; if your plan is a ten year plan, plant trees; if your plan is a hundred year plan, teach children. With characteristic American impatience we have been pursuing one year plans when we should have been pursuing a hundred year plan. China is simply too large for anything else and we’re seeing the results of that now.

Whether our economy is in a slow motion collapse as a result of our terrible policies with respect to China remains to be seen and I feel fortunate that I will probably not live to see it. Not that our policy with respect to China is our only problem. Our policies with respect to Mexico are just as bad and have even more serious implications.

3 comments

Strategic Failure

Anthony Cordesman issues a broadside against the Obama Administration’s foreign policy:

This administration does face an extraordinary mix of challenges, ones it cannot easily prioritize and certainly cannot afford to simplify, spin, and ignore. These challenges include the broad need for changes in the U.S. and allied force posture and strategy in Europe and Asia. They also include dealing with a broad series of actual conflicts in the Middle East, Africa, and South Asia, where the United States must rely on strategic partners to an extraordinary degree.

There often are no good options, no ways to shape even the near-term outcome with a high probability of success, and no ways to eliminate uncertainty and the need to react. At the same time, this overview of U.S. challenges shows again and again that the United States has relied far too much on concepts and rhetoric and failed to develop and implement credible strategic plans, provide the required resources, and create that kind of transparency that can win congressional and public support.

The short version of his post is that every foreign policy issue the Obama Administration has touched has turned to crud. In the lengthy post he outlines all of the present debacles in turn and explains the lack of strategic vision that lead to the problems at hand.

I find myself in the unusual position of being more optimistic than the author. I think that the U. S. policy of infantilization of its allies that has been our dominant strategy at least since the end of the Cold War has always been defective. The reality is that other countries have interests, too. They should be expected to follow them and we shouldn’t be expected to effectuate their interests for them. If they’re not willing to back up their interests, they’re not really interests.

I don’t view the reassertion of their interests by regional powers as a disaster but as an inevitability. Germany will always be powerful country in the middle of Europe. There is nothing we can do to stop Russia from being a regional superpower. Iran will be a major power in West Asia. China will want to pursue its interests in East Asia.

In addition there will be friction between Germany and Russia, Between Russia and Iran, between Russia and China, between China and India, and between China and Japan. We can’t stop that and we shouldn’t want to. Our interest should be in preventing these frictions from turning into war and, failing that, from turning into nuclear war.

We need to consider where our interests actually lie with a dispassionate eye. We can’t consider being the only power in the world as one of those interests. That’s just beyond our capabilities.

6 comments

The Cup Half Full

I am frequently baffled by the onesidedness of Paul Krugman’s New York Times columns and today’s column is no exception. In this column Dr. Krugman takes the Europeans to task for rejecting Keynesian approaches to the economic turndown in the last recession:

Why has Europe done so badly? In the past few weeks, I’ve seen a number of speeches and articles suggesting that the problem lies in the inadequacy of our economic models — that we need to rethink macroeconomic theory, which has failed to offer useful policy guidance in the crisis. But is this really the story?

No, it isn’t. It’s true that few economists predicted the crisis. The clean little secret of economics since then, however, is that basic textbook models, reflecting an approach to recessions and recoveries that would have seemed familiar to students half a century ago, have performed very well. The trouble is that policy makers in Europe decided to reject those basic models in favor of alternative approaches that were innovative, exciting and completely wrong.

I’m one of those students of a half century ago and, yes, Keynesian pump-priming if familiar to me. As I’ve said before, back in the olden days when I took economics Keynes was king. There was no competing view.

My problem isn’t with the passage quoted above. I think it’s correct as far as it goes. I question the opening of his column:

BRUSSELS — America has yet to achieve a full recovery from the effects of the 2008 financial crisis. Still, it seems fair to say that we’ve made up much, though by no means all, of the lost ground.

The problem I have with that passage is that it only tells part of the story. Keynesian stimulus is a short term strategy not a long term one and after eight years it’s undoubtedly fair to think that the short term is behind us. If I remember those models of 50 years ago correctly, by this point whatever stimulus was provided from 2007 to 2011 would have been absorbed into a return to trend.

It’s not as though Keynesian stimulus hasn’t been tried over the last generation. It has been deployed first in Japan, then here, and then in China and I think we’ve learned something from the experiment. First, we’ve learned that the empirical evidence for the effectiveness of Keynesian stimulus remains weak. Second, we can be pretty confident that Western politicians don’t have the courage to follow through with what the models predict in dealing with a severe recession. Third, and in this we can be even more confident, their economic advisors will unfailingly abet the politicians in their cowardice.

The question I would ask Dr. Krugman is how could anything else have happened in Europe? The Germans are the dog not the tail there and they are absolutely convinced that German prosperity is based on German industry and thrift while Portuguese, Greek, etc. woe is a result of their being lazy spendthrifts. And dishonest. Those shifty, layabout, dishonest Southern Europeans.

We are not the only ones who have a history of economic theory. The German have a full century of truly horrific theories that have resulted in depressions, revolutions, and wars beyond anything we’ve experienced. They can be expected to hold onto them until it is politically impossible for them to continue which means for the foreseeable future.

1 comment

Sale’s Retort

As you may recall, when I see a fine specimen of the polemic literary form, I take notice. They’re rare. Read Richard Sale’s take on the recent piece in Elle on Chelsea Clinton.

6 comments

Marvel’s Daredevil on NetFlix

NetFlix’s latest foray into series television which dropped last week, Marvel’s Daredevil, is not your typical comic book adaptation. Not only is it head and shoulders above most television comic book adaptations, it is better than average television, owing more to The Wire or Breaking Bad than Marvel’s Agents of Shield or Agent Carter (although I liked Agent Carter, too).

The show consists of 13 episodes, roughly 12 hours in all. It is not episodic but a single continuous storyline or arc continuing for all 13 episodes. The acting is solid and the direction is tight—a cut above typical TV fare. In particular, it doesn’t have all of the mugging and voguing usually associated with young casts.

In all likelihood the only cast members you’ll recognize are Vincent D’Onofrio (from Law and Order: Criminal Intent), Rosario Dawson, Scott Glenn, and Vondie Curtis-Hall. With the exception of D’Onofrio, who plays the tremendously menacing but oddly sympathetic Wilson Fisk, they are all supporting characters.

It is an international cast with American, Canadian, Australian, English, Israeli, and Chinese actors. It is multi-lingual, with substantial passages in English, Russian, Spanish, and Chinese, all spoken (or dubbed) by native speakers. Matt Murdock (Daredevil) is played by young English actor Charlie Cox in an understated, measured performance. As played by Mr. Cox, Matt Murdock is more like Ethan in The Searcher, little better than the criminals he’s fighting.

It is grim, gritty, and dark. What glamor it has is provided by accomplished Israeli actress Ayalet Zurer in a wonderfully nuanced portrayal. When was the last time you saw a comic book adaptation in which the villain’s romance received significantly more attention than the hero’s?

Daredevil‘s world is a completely corrupt one, reminiscent of Sin City. Everyone with even a scintilla of power is on the take, conniving, in it for themselves, criminal, and disturbed. Most of those without power are beaten down. This may ring a chord with you. Or not, depending on your outlook.

I recommend this show highly.

4 comments

So, You Want to Be a Populist?

There are times when I don’t know whether to laugh or to cry and reading Dana Milbank’s most recent column entitled “The Populists Capture the Democratic Party” was one of them:

It was another one of those rallies on Capitol Hill where lawmakers line up to take shots at the Obama administration. But this time the lawmakers were all Democrats.

A quartet of senators and a dozen members of the House took the stage in a park across from the Capitol midday Wednesday to join hundreds of steelworkers, union faithful and environmentalists in denouncing President Obama’s bid for fast-track approval of the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade deal.

First, not a single major Democratic Party figure was quoted in the piece. It was a group of second (or third) tier senators and Congressmen and a couple of union leaders.

If they aren’t the 1% they’re within spitting distance of it. Every single one of the people quoted in the piece has an annual income plus benefits package north of $200K a year. These are hardly Eugene Debses let alone Tom Joads.

Second, this is not the 1960s. Union members are just over 10% of the American people and activist environmentalists are even fewer than that. These are the elite, the vanguard of the proletariat, not the people.

In my opinion each and every one of those quoted would be horrified at a truly populist agenda in the United States. I agree that it would be opposed to the free trade position that has dominated both political parties for most of the last forty years. Here are some of the things that I think a truly populist platform would include:

  • Reduce foreign trade. Impose tariffs.
  • Cut foreign aid.
  • Bring the boys (and now the girls) home.
  • Cut the number of work visas, both H1-B and other.
  • Make English the national language. No languages other than English in public schools (other than in foreign language classes) and proficiency in English required to gain citizenship. I have no idea of where most Americans stand on birthright citizenship but I suspect they don’t think much of “anchor babies”.
  • Control the borders.
  • Medicare for all!
  • A higher minimum wage (how high?)
  • Don’t bail out big banks—break ’em up.

As I have said repeatedly here I continue to believe that the default position for many if not most Americans is isolationism which explains a lot of that list. Free trade is popular among economists and Congressmen but I don’t think it’s a popular view. Neither is mass immigration.

Despite the horror that many Americans express about “socialized medicine”, Medicare remains popular. A lot has to do with marketing. If you ask people whether everybody should be covered by a program like Medicare, they say “Yes”. If you ask whether they support a single-payer system, they say “No”. If you ask whether they approve of the VA hospital system, they’ll probably say “Yes”. If you ask whether they would approve of a national health system like Britain’s, they’d say “No”.

The number of people who would support a guaranteed job policy seems to be growing, too. I suspect that’s a question that also depends on just how you phrase it.

What would be in a truly populist political platform? Put your suggestions in comments. Your proposals don’t need to be things you’d support. Goodness knows I don’t support everything in the list I wrote above (maybe not anything). I’m just looking for ideas that are popular.

14 comments

Everybody Talks About It But Nobody Does Anything About It

Writing at Mother Jones Edwin Rios covers a lot of the same territory that I did yesterday about our lousy tax system. The main difference between the two posts being that unlike me Mr. Rios never tells us what he’s in favor of. By inference we can conclude he opposes income and American companies doing business overseas.

4 comments

How Much Should I Care?

On the other hand I’m really not sure how much I should care about Congress’s being on the brink of repealing the “Sustainable Growth Rates”, Congress’s 15 year old attempt to contain Medicare costs which, since the Congress doesn’t have the guts to stick by its guns, has resulted in the annual (or thereabouts) farce known as the “doc fix” where they absolve themselves from controlling the growth of Medicare costs.

The move will allegedly add a couple of hundred billion to the deficit but that’s kabuki, too, since the estimate is predicated on “existing law” which means the SGR which nobody really believes they’ll allow to take effect.

As best as I can tell the only reason this is in the news is the surprising spectacle of the Senate actually passing something, a rara avis during the Reid Senate. It’s pretty pathetic when a Senate move to reduce the workload of future Senates is a big news story.

0 comments

Is It Wrong of Me?

Is it wrong of me that I don’t care what Hillary Clinton ate for lunch or where she stopped for a cup of coffee or to use the restroom? There’s a long list of other things that I don’t care about and the major media outlets have hit just about all of them.

9 comments