Just How Bad Is Illinois’s Fiscal Situation?

This bad:

Illinois and California are the two worst states in the nation for fiscal shape, and Illinois and Louisiana are the two worst states for government corruption.

Illinois leads all states for the highest taxes paid per resident, at $7,700 per year. And Illinois has the second highest property taxes, behind only New Jersey.

To put that per capita tax figure into perspective, while Illinois has the highest taxes per resident it’s 16th in per capita income.

Chicago has the highest sales tax in the nation, doesn’t have the power to impose an income tax, and is nearing the end of its authority to increase property taxes. Illinois is at or near the bottom when it comes to the state’s share of education spending which means that our system is rigged against poor kids. Illinois also has the worst or near the worst return in federal spending to federal taxes paid.

There is something we do lead the nation in: the percentage of Illinoisans who leave every year for another state.

1 comment

Reparations

The other day on Richard Steele’s Barber Shop program on WBEZ I heard a discussion of Mayor Emanuel’s announced support for the victims of John Burge. If you’re not up on your Chicago atrocities, it is apparently the case that under John Burge Chicago police routinely tortured criminal suspects.

I couldn’t agree less with the participants in the discussion, all clearly adherents to the belief in the “roomful of money” hypothesis of government, that somewhere there’s a roomful of money that the city can just draw from whenever it cares to. The city would need to borrow to pay these reparations and at present interest rates that means the city would pay these reparations forever, many times the originally promised sum. Indeed, the city would be better off paying a modest stipend to each of the torture victims for life if it could do so from actual operating revenue than it would to promise lump sum payments it would be forced to borrow to pay.

My view of this is that such cases should not be heard by the courts under the doctrine of sovereign immunity, that the mayor should not have the power to make such promises, and the the mayor and the City Council together should not have the power to pay reparations. It is rife for abuse. Additionally, it punishes the innocent and allows the guilty to go scot free, the opposite of what you might wish. If the mayor wishes to pay reparations from his own pocket it would be magnanimous of him, otherwise no.

My view is that the city should not even defend city employees accused of breaking state law or city policy. That would at least provide some small incentive for city employees to do the right thing.

1 comment

That Old Style Religion

There’s a nice essay at City Journal on what we have lost or in peril of losing: true liberalism. There was a time in which liberalism meant “freedom” rather than protection from being offended.

1 comment

Illinois’s War on the Middle Class

ChangeinMiddleClass

The graph above is from the Pew Charitable Trust. You can click on the image to see an interactive version of it which shows the change in the middle class since 2000 by state. The darker the state, the greater the change. Here are their remarks:

The middle class has shrunk since 2000 in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, according to a Stateline analysis. In 22 states, middle-class households – defined as those making between two-thirds and twice the state’s median income – fell to less than half of the total households between 2000 and 2013.

In Illinois those who meet their definition of middle class have fallen from just below 50% of the state’s residents to just under 46%. Meanwhile, inflation-adjusted household median income has fallen from $64,201 to $56,210. That means that Illinois has a lower percentage of people in the middle class than any other state in Midwest other than Ohio and we’re very nearly the same as Ohio in that regard.

Although they haven’t fallen as fast as we have and incomes in them have not declined as much as here, Illinois still has a higher percentage of its people than either California, New York, or Texas and just a tiny bit fewer than Florida.

The decline in the middle class in Illinois is attributed to a number of factors but primarily housing costs of which property tax is a substantial component, see here.

7 comments

“What America Looks Like Now”

As I was out and about yesterday, doing my part to stimulate the economy, I caught a radio interview with the composer of the hiphop musical, Hamilton, that’s getting so much attention these days and he said something that caught my attention. He described the cast of the musical as being “what America looks like now”. I haven’t seen the musical or even read a review but based on his characterization I wonder if that’s true.

Let’s imagine a cast of 50. Using the figures from the Census Bureau as a basis, here’s what the breakdown of the cast by race would be if it truly looked like America. Thirty-two would be white and not Hispanic. Eight would be Hispanic. Six would be black (a proportion that has been remarkably durable over time). One would be Asian. One would be something else. I suspect that’s not what he had in mind.

And that’s if the cast is composed of men, women, and children. If the case is composed of adults, the cast would be even whiter.

I suspect that what he really meant is that the cast is what Brooklyn looks like now. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that and the casting choices undoubtedly convey their own distinctive reflection of truth. But statistically I suspect they’re not true.

BTW, the number of homosexuals or transgender individuals in that cast above would be one. I can almost guarantee you that’s not the case. As Nathan Lane once put it, it’s musical theater—you do the math.

1 comment

The End of the Dream

Sometimes the best way to deal with something painful is all at once, like pulling a bandage from a wound. That’s what Joel Kotkin does in this piece about California:

California has met the future, and it really doesn’t work. As the mounting panic surrounding the drought suggests, the Golden State, once renowned for meeting human and geographic challenges, is losing its ability to cope with crises. As a result, the great American land of opportunity is devolving into something that resembles feudalism, a society dominated by rich and poor, with little opportunity for upward mobility for the state’s middle- and working classes.

It’s one of the better pieces I’ve read on the challenges facing the Golden State. The key problem is that there’s no room for an economy that will support anybody but the rich and their servants in the grand plan that has dominated California politics for decades. That grand plan doesn’t resemble anything we would think of as America.

For any plan to “work”, as Mr. Kotkin puts it, it must include the jobs that will pay ordinary people what used to be thought of as an ordinary income, enough for them to live in what used to be thought of as an ordinary way.

The reality is that two-thirds of the people won’t be doctors, lawyers, financiers, engineers, architects, college professors, or any other job in what’s thought of as the “professional class”. When job growth is limited to hospitality, retail sales, and the lower echelons of the healthcare sector and we don’t limit the number of people who can compete for those jobs, simple supply and demand tells us there is no way those jobs will pay enough to support a middle class lifestyle.

We are a large, diverse country and we need a commensurately large, diverse economy. We need more than hospitality, retail sales, education, and healthcare. We need farming, mining, manufacturing, lumber, energy production, and the thousands of other “brown” jobs that are jobs that ordinary people can do. As Jared Bernstein pointed out recently (and as I’ve pointed out for years) that means ending the currency games that enables other countries to buy Treasury bonds with the dollars they receive in trade rather than buying goods made in the U. S. A.

Sadly, the trends Mr. Kotkin points to are not limited to one state. We have seen the future and it is California.

28 comments

More On Measuring Economic Growth

Over at Bloomberg Mark Gilbert sees the sales of SKF, world’s largest manufacturer of ball bearings, as a microcosm of the global economy:

Few components are as essential to the workings of industry as the humble ball bearing. So the bleak economic picture painted by today’s earning report from the world’s biggest bearings maker was worrisome enough. But combined with sales news indicating weak consumer demand for staples such as toiletries and food — goods that economists call inelastic, meaning people tend to keep buying margarine and soap no matter what their economy is doing — they suggest the global economy is far more fragile than most observers have acknowledged.

Sweden’s SKF is a proper industrial company. Its metal spheres are used in everything from wind turbines to Ducati motorbikes to fridge compressors. So the ongoing slump in its organic sales growth, which tells you how its underlying business is doing excluding things such as acquisitions or the gyrations of the currency market, suggests things aren’t going so well for its customers — all the makers of things with moving parts out of steel and other hard materials…

and follows with a graph illustrating the Swedish manufacturer’s flagging sales. Sales growth was down to 1% at the end of 2014. When I read the article my immediate reaction was to wonder whether SKF’s results were actually representative. I did a little research and it isn’t. According to SKF’s own estimates the worldwide ball bearings market grew by 4% last year. Other analysts project 7% annual growth over the period of the next 10 years.

What actually appears to be happening is that SKF is losing market share. They appear to have made a strategic error. China continues to be the largest market for ball bearings (for obvious reasons) and Chinese customers are increasingly bearing Chinese ball bearings. I think we should expect other emerging markets, e.g. India, Brazil to follow the same pattern. Emerging markets will neither continue to emerge nor be markets for European or American manufacturers forever.

I don’t honestly know whether the global ball bearings market is a microcosm of the world economy. However, I’m pretty confident that SKF’s experience is not representative and Mr. Gilbert should re-think his assumptions.

3 comments

Joe Biden’s Heresy

At Bloomberg Noah Smith outlines the student college loan mess in three charts illustrating the growth in student loans, the socialization of student loans, and the increasing role of debt service in student loans in total federal revenues. In other words, young people are behaving exactly as you expect when they’ve been told over the period of their entire lives that a college education is necessary if you want to be a full participant in our society.

The problems are obvious. What solutions are being proposed?

One way to bring that unlucky generation some relief would be to permit student debt to be expunged in bankruptcy. Democrats in the Senate are trying to allow that. But with Republicans in control of both chambers of Congress, this probably won’t happen.

Instead, what we’ve gotten is President Barack Obama’s “Student Aid Bill of Rights.” The list of “rights” emphasizes students’ right to go to college, to take out loans and to pay those loans back quickly and easily. In other words, it’s exactly what you’d expect from a government interested in maximizing the revenue it collects from indebted college graduates.

Vice President Joe Biden has proposed a more radical solution:

Vice President Biden on Saturday said free community college was vital for a healthy American economy.

“It’s simple, folks — two years of community college should become as free and universal as high school is today if we’re to make this economic resurgence permanent and well into the 21st Century,” he said in the White House’s weekly address.

Biden argued that Americans insisting on free high school had produced a competitive U.S. workforce in years past. With other countries catching up, he added, the time was ripe for reaching new heights on educational access.

That’s not merely radical but heretical. Whether he realizes it or not he’s proposing the socialization of higher education.

Higher education is presently a public-private hybrid. Like every other public-private hybrid it is foundering on the rocky shoals of human nature. Given the prevailing neoliberal orthodoxy, proposing that be changed, however logical, is not just a major change but preaching a heresy.

This isn’t the first time that Joe Biden has preached heresy. A decade ago he proposed that Iraq be divided into three countries: Kurdistan, a Sunni country, and a Shi’ite country. It was widely criticized then. With the exception of the Kurds, Iraqi public opinion favored a unified Iraq and dividing Iraq would have been the act of a conqueror. The orthodoxy at the time was that we had removed Iraq’s government but had not conquered the country and our actions after removing Saddam attempted to further that impossible goal.

Those were the grounds on which I, for example, opposed dividing Iraq. To do so we would have needed to conquer Iraq, that wasn’t our objective, and there was insufficient popular support in the United States to take the steps that would have been necessary for Iraq’s subjugation.

Back in August of 2007 Joe Biden suggested that the way that our healthcare system should be reform was through a system of catastrophic care insurance for adults and insuring all kids, more heresy.

When did Joe Biden become the Democratic Party’s “crazy uncle”? I don’t recall his always filling that role. It does serve the useful function of being able to dismiss what he says however logical it may be as the maunderings of a nutty old man.

9 comments

Bad Presidents

At The National Interest Robert Merry presents his list of our worst wartime presidents. They are, for various different reasons:

  • Wilson
  • Truman
  • Johnson
  • George W. Bush
  • Obama

I’m pretty sure there are some who will balk at President Obama’s presence in the list. Here’s what Mr. Merry says about that:

In one sense, it may seem unfair to place Obama in company with these other wartime presidents. For one thing, he didn’t initiate these wars but rather inherited them from George W. Bush. For another, the situation he inherited didn’t deteriorate into the kinds of messes characterized by these other tales of presidential failure. Third, it probably says something about America’s wartime history that an effort to list the five most hapless wartime presidents pulls into the mix a man such as Obama, whose wartime record only slightly places him in the category of failure.
On the other hand, presidents don’t get to make excuses based on what they inherit in taking office, nor do they get to trim on defining their success in relation to the performance of their predecessors. Obama inherited a mess; his job was to clean it up; on balance the situation got worse on his watch—not only in Iraq and Afghanistan but also in the surrounding region.

to which I would add that his “Afghan surge” can only be painted as a blunder. As a consequence of that decision several thousand young Americans died and who knows how many seriously injured to absolutely no end. The primary differences between the situation in Afghanistan now and in 2008 and are that seven years have passed, thousands of people have died, and billions of dollars has been spent.

Wilson was obviously an egregiously bad wartime president for the reasons listed by Mr. Merry. I think that Johnson’s offense was a different one from those listed by Mr. Merry. Johnson attempted to prosecute a war without placing the United States on a wartime footing. George W. Bush and Barack Obama made the same mistake and for that reason if for no other they aren’t out of place on a list of bad wartime presidents.

I also have a different problem with his list: it is prejudiced in favor of the present and recent past. How about James K. Polk who lead the country into what was obviously an unjust war of aggression? How about McKinley, ditto? We’re still living with the consequences of those wars, we merely accept them under the category “Things As They Are”. In a century the same will be true of Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan.

10 comments

How Fast (or Slow) Is Economic Activity Growing?

Although you wouldn’t gather it from reading the writings of most economists or the popular media, gross domestic product is not a real thing. It’s not measured by adding up everything going on in the country. It’s estimated. There are probably as many ways of estimating GDP as there are people trying to estimate GDP.

One of my favorite ways of gauging whether there’s more or less economic activity than there was last year is from what the states say they’ve collected in taxes. That’s no estimate. Believe me, the states keep very close track of what they receive.

The Census Bureau is reporting the 2014 survey of what the states have received in revenues and here are the highlights:

State government tax revenue increased 2.2 percent, from $847.1 billion in fiscal year 2013 to $865.8 billion in 2014, the fourth consecutive increase, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2014 Annual Survey of State Government Tax Collections.

General sales and gross receipts taxes drove most of the revenue growth, increasing from $258.9 billion to $271.3 billion, or 4.8 percent. Severance taxes increased 6.0 percent, from $16.8 billion to $17.8 billion, and motor fuel taxes increased 3.4 percent, from $40.1 billion to $41.5 billion.

That’s complicated even farther because the states change rates from year to year, sometimes increasing rates, sometimes decreasing, sometimes (like Ohio) increasing some and decreasing others, cf. here and here.

My back of the envelope calculation suggests that 2.2% growth for 2014 is probably a ceiling rather than a floor, that is, I doubt that there was more than 2.2% year-on-year growth and there may well have been less. What does that mean? To me it means that when inflation is taken into account if the economy is growing at all it’s growing very slowly, maybe so slowly that it’s not fast enough for us to measure.

We’ve got to do better than this. The recovery such as it has been won’t last forever. They tell us we’ve been in recovery now for 70 months. It sure doesn’t feel like it.

19 comments