There’s an interesting op-ed at The Wall Street Journal from Stephen Parente in which the author attempts to get his hands around the likely pattern of rate increases for healthcare insurance plans offered under the federal healthcare insurance marketplace, Healthcare.gov:
Using the latest health-insurance-exchange enrollment data and a microsimulation model funded in part by the Health and Human Services Department, I estimated the premium increases that could occur as a result of the expiration of risk corridors and reinsurance. My model also assumes that 2017’s big premium increases will be spread out over both 2016 and 2017 rates.
My research shows that the average 2016 family plan could experience premium increases of 11.2%, compared with 8% hikes for individual plans. The relatively cheap bronze plans, which cover 60% of a consumer’s health-care costs, could see the highest jumps—16.6% and 11.5%, respectively. Individual silver plans could see a relatively low increase—3.1%—but families won’t be so lucky, potentially paying 8.4% more.
That won’t stay the same in 2017, however, when individual silver-plan premiums could rise by an average of 12.1%, surpassing a 9.2% increase for families. Across every type of health-care plan—bronze, silver, gold, platinum and catastrophic—families could be looking at average increases of 7.3%, compared with 11% premium hikes for individual plan holders.
To put these numbers in context: For consumers with silver plans, which account for about two-thirds of the ACA market, the average individual could see annual premiums rise to $3,700 over the next year and a half from $3,200. A family could expect an increase to $15,400 from $13,000 over the same period.
After 2017, most ACA-compliant plans will likely fall into a pattern of annual premium increases of between 3%-6%, which will persist for the next decade and likely beyond. By 2023, I estimate that the average family plan could be 61% more expensive than it is in 2015, with individual plans only one or two percentage points behind. These increases are so high that direct taxpayer subsidies to consumers are unlikely to keep up. So the cost, both financially and politically, will become increasingly intolerable.
I would expect that the reaction of many consumers to these price increases will be to lower their metal tiers, i.e. people who elected gold plans will change to silver, those who elected silver plans will change to bronze. Because of the increased deductibles implied in that decision, that has serious implications for the non-healthcare components of the economy. Increasingly, people will just be spending more of their incomes on healthcare with the concomitant reduction in overall economic activity.
The free marketers may get what they want. People will start economizing on healthcare. I know of no study that suggests that when people economize on healthcare they distinguish between necessary healthcare and unnecessary healthcare, i.e. that they do so prudently. The conundrum remains how do you control the cost of healthcare while preserving a reasonable level of public health.
Perhaps after President Obama leaves office we can return to the pressing business of reforming our healthcare system. I see little prospect of it before then.






