Returning to the Problem at Hand

There’s an interesting op-ed at The Wall Street Journal from Stephen Parente in which the author attempts to get his hands around the likely pattern of rate increases for healthcare insurance plans offered under the federal healthcare insurance marketplace, Healthcare.gov:

Using the latest health-insurance-exchange enrollment data and a microsimulation model funded in part by the Health and Human Services Department, I estimated the premium increases that could occur as a result of the expiration of risk corridors and reinsurance. My model also assumes that 2017’s big premium increases will be spread out over both 2016 and 2017 rates.

My research shows that the average 2016 family plan could experience premium increases of 11.2%, compared with 8% hikes for individual plans. The relatively cheap bronze plans, which cover 60% of a consumer’s health-care costs, could see the highest jumps—16.6% and 11.5%, respectively. Individual silver plans could see a relatively low increase—3.1%—but families won’t be so lucky, potentially paying 8.4% more.

That won’t stay the same in 2017, however, when individual silver-plan premiums could rise by an average of 12.1%, surpassing a 9.2% increase for families. Across every type of health-care plan—bronze, silver, gold, platinum and catastrophic—families could be looking at average increases of 7.3%, compared with 11% premium hikes for individual plan holders.

To put these numbers in context: For consumers with silver plans, which account for about two-thirds of the ACA market, the average individual could see annual premiums rise to $3,700 over the next year and a half from $3,200. A family could expect an increase to $15,400 from $13,000 over the same period.

After 2017, most ACA-compliant plans will likely fall into a pattern of annual premium increases of between 3%-6%, which will persist for the next decade and likely beyond. By 2023, I estimate that the average family plan could be 61% more expensive than it is in 2015, with individual plans only one or two percentage points behind. These increases are so high that direct taxpayer subsidies to consumers are unlikely to keep up. So the cost, both financially and politically, will become increasingly intolerable.

I would expect that the reaction of many consumers to these price increases will be to lower their metal tiers, i.e. people who elected gold plans will change to silver, those who elected silver plans will change to bronze. Because of the increased deductibles implied in that decision, that has serious implications for the non-healthcare components of the economy. Increasingly, people will just be spending more of their incomes on healthcare with the concomitant reduction in overall economic activity.

The free marketers may get what they want. People will start economizing on healthcare. I know of no study that suggests that when people economize on healthcare they distinguish between necessary healthcare and unnecessary healthcare, i.e. that they do so prudently. The conundrum remains how do you control the cost of healthcare while preserving a reasonable level of public health.

Perhaps after President Obama leaves office we can return to the pressing business of reforming our healthcare system. I see little prospect of it before then.

6 comments

The Mistake of American Politicians

James Taranto highlights remarks made by President Obama about his deal with Iran:

Obama: Let me answer the question that you asked. It does not give me pause that Mr. Assad or others in Tehran may be trying to spin the deal in a way that they think is favorable to what their constituencies want to hear. That’s what politicians do.

which Mr. Taranto correctly characterizes as an example of hasty generalization:

Of course it is true that politicians frequently “spin” and pander to their constituents. That’s part of democracy. But it’s bizarre and unsettling for Obama to wave away the triumphalist remarks of Bashar Assad or Ayatollah Ali Khameini as if they were democratic politicians trying to attract votes. Dictators don’t need votes.

He goes on to list other fallacies in the president’s comments: argumentum ad populum, appeal to authority, and his favorite device, the false dichotomy. In President Obama’s defense these are errors that are incredibly common among American politicians. And they’re among the reasons our foreign policy is so bad. We persist in thinking that every country is exactly like us, that everybody wants the same things we do, and that their leaders are motivated by the same things ours are.

I don’t think he’s being entirely fair to the president here:

The answer to the question “Why now?” seems obvious: With his presidency nearing an end, Obama was determined to strike a deal, any deal, to cement his legacy. “He’s like some old guy with a bucket list, checking off boxes and basking in the consternation that trails him,” writes Yahoo! News’s Matt Bai—who, incredibly, seems to view that at least somewhat approvingly…

The Iran deal is no item from a bucket list. Like the “Afghan surge” and healthcare reform, face to face negotiations with our enemies were components of Barack Obama’s earliest stump speeches in his first presidential campaign. A presidential “bucket list” doesn’t bother me so much as that the items lack any coherence or thematic unity. With Mr. Obama does not, apparently, do strategy. It is all tactics.

My interpretation of that has been that his policy preferences are a grab-bag of progressive policies going back nearly a century. Back then they may have had coherence but, well, things have changed. More regulation made a good deal of sense in a rapidly growing country that had practically no regulation. That doesn’t describe the U. S. now. We now have good reason to believe that “jar jar is better than war war” neither may be better still, and that detente does not always work in our favor.

Back in those halcyon days of six or seven years ago I had hoped that President Obama had the capacity to learn from his experiences. I no longer believe that to be the case.

6 comments

The Reynolds Plan

The other day our old friend Michael Reynolds left a manifesto on immigration in a comment at OTB that I didn’t want to get lost so I’m excerpting it here. I liked it so much it could almost be my own.

1) We have a perfect right to decide who does and who does not enter this country.

2) I don’t doubt that the “anchor baby” phenomenon is real, but it’s so tiny a thing as to be irrelevant to much of anything.

3) We should tune our immigration policies with the goal of improving the lot of US citizens, with a secondary goal of humanitarian assistance.

4) We should recognize the reality which is that without Mexicans and Salvadorans this country would grind to a halt in five minutes.

5) It is likely true that illegals depress wages, but it’s also likely true that the wages thus depressed are their own and those of other recent immigrants.

6) We need to decide the issue rationally, without right-wing racism or left-wing sentimentality.

There is one specific that I don’t think that Michael understands properly and I want to address that. It’s #4.

First, “Salvadorans” is sleight of hand. When you look at immigration over the period of the last 30 years something between half and three-quarters of all immigrants over that period have been Mexican nationals and most of those have been illegal. I’m generally unconcerned about immigration but I’m concerned about the extremely large volume of Mexican immigration over the period of the last generation or so because I think it has had serious effects on both of our countries.

But I have a more serious objection. There is a feedback mechanism between the large number of low-skilled and non-skilled immigrants and “this country would grind to a halt in five minutes”. Rather than investing in equipment or skills training of their employees to increase productivity, they don’t worry about productivity but instead tailor the companies’ processes to be performed by low skill employees. They can always depend on more of them so they can be confident that their payroll costs will remain low.

I recognize that my explanation doesn’t apply to manufacturing. But it does apply to agriculture, banking, the insurance business, food service, retail, and many of the other service businesses that have been where the job growth has been for the last forty years.

25 comments

The Committee

I want to home in on a single aspect of the 159 page deal that President Obama’s team has negotiated with the Iranians: the process by which sanctions will be lifted. As I understand the deal, after the IAEA has certified that Iran is conforming to its side of the agreement, sanctions may be lifted by a majority vote of a committee consisting of the United States, Iran, Russia, China, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, and the European Union. Please correct me if I’ve misunderstood the terms.

What immediately struck me that in essence Germany gets two votes—one for itself and one in the form of the European Union. If there’s one thing that should be clear from the draconian arrangement imposed on Greece by the EU finance ministers last week, it’s that “the EU” means Germany. Germany was the only country holding out for the tough measures imposed on Greece. Other countries were predisposed to lighter measures. What was the outcome? Tougher sanctions were imposed.

That in turn means Iran, Russia, China, and Germany can basically remove the sanctions at will. I have no doubt that Germany is eager to have the sanctions removed. Iran wouldn’t have a nuclear development program, its own munitions industry, or an aerospace program without German companies all eager to sell it whatever it wants to buy. The overwhelming preponderance of all machinery and industrial equipment in Iran comes from Germany.

1 comment

Tertium Non Datur, Iran Deal Edition or The Fourth Alternative

The editors of the Wall Street Journal call the president on using his favorite fallacious argument, the false dilemma, in characterizing the Iran deal his team has negotiated with the Iranians:

The debate is raging over President Obama’s nuclear deal with Iran, and Mr. Obama held a rare press conference Wednesday to say that “99% of the world community” agrees with him. Then why bother with a press conference? Mr. Obama made other claims we’ll address in coming days, but for today it’s worth rebutting his assertion that “none” of his critics “have presented to me or the American people a better alternative.”

Specifically, Mr. Obama resorted to his familiar default of the false political choice. “There really are only two alternatives here. Either the issue of Iran obtaining a nuclear weapon is resolved diplomatically through a negotiation or it’s resolved through force, through war. Those are—those are the options,” Mr. Obama said. He added that no better deal was or is possible than the one he has negotiated.

Their preference is what they call “coercive diplomacy”:

Take the sanctions regime, which finally started to get tough in December 2011. By 2013 Iran had an official inflation rate of some 35%, its currency was falling, and its dollar reserves were estimated to be down to $20 billion. Mr. Obama had resisted those sanctions, only to take credit for them when Congress insisted and they began to show results in Tehran.

Yet Mr. Obama still resisted calls to put maximum pressure on Iran. He gave waivers to countries like Japan to import Iranian oil. He was reluctant to impose sanctions on global financial institutions that did business with Iran (especially Chinese banks that offered Tehran access to foreign currency). The U.S. could have gone much further to blacklist parts of Iran’s economy run by the Revolutionary Guard Corps. A bipartisan majority in Congress was prepared to impose more sanctions this year, but Mr. Obama refused as he rushed for a second-term deal.

Mr. Obama now argues that the sanctions could not have been maintained, and that they are sure to collapse if Congress scuttles his deal. But there was no sign sanctions were collapsing as long as the U.S. continued to keep the pressure on. And to the extent support did weaken, one reason was the momentum of Mr. Obama’s negotiations. The more the U.S. gave the impression that it desperately wanted a deal, the more other countries and businesses began to maneuver for post-sanctions opportunities.

My preference is even simpler and doesn’t require the the brinksmanship that requires an attention span and appreciation of detail of which our present crop of politicians may be incapable: do nothing. Veto any attempt at lifting sanctions, excoriate unilateral sanction-breakers but otherwise do nothing.

For those who believe that the arrangement negotiated by Sec. Kerry and his team represents the best of all possible worlds, please explain what we get from the deal. I know what the Iranians get. I know what the Germans get. I know what the Russians and the Chinese get. I know what President Obama and Secretary Kerry get. It’s not nearly so clear as to why the deal is good for the United States.

10 comments

So Near and Yet So Far

In her most recent post Megan McArdle, steps right up to the edge of a Great Truth and then pulls back, unwilling to tumble over the edge. The title of the post is “Hillary and Jeb Agree, But Are Both Mostly Wrong” and here’s her conclusion:

If you like lower taxes and less regulation, vote for the Republican. If you want more paid family leave and child care, vote for the Democrat. But don’t expect miracles from either of them.

The reality is that there is a broad consensus among the members of the nomenklatura, the power structures, of both political parties and much of that consensus is wrong. There are so many areas of agreement between the two parties that they are too numerous to present a complete list. I’ll just mention three: immigration, trade, and banking.

Both parties believe that we need more low-skill and non-skilled workers and they should be brought in via immigration. You’ll occasionally run into examples of jobs that go wanting because employers can’t find workers to do them. You probably can’t find many native-born Americans who are willing to pull plows, drag large stones across the desert with ropes, or jump into volcanos. We just don’t do things that way any more and there are lots of things we presently do that require an unending supply of low-skill or no-skill workers because employers can depend on a continuing supply.

Both parties agree on the benefits of free trade. In theory that’s correct but in practice the U. S. hasn’t concluded a free trade agreement in my lifetime if ever. There is nothing in David Ricardo’s theory of trade which would lead anyone to conclude that managed trade, the sort that we do have, is of benefit other than to a very few.

Both parties agree that banks should be subsidized. I should hardly need to present substantiating evidence of that. That was the only message that could be drawn from the actions of both political parties in 2007-2009.

I can list others from agricultural subsidies to infrastructure to the size of government but you get the idea. The thing that the Powers-That-Be in both political parties agree on most of all is that the American people are dopes and that they, the Powers, are better suited to determine what’s good for them than they are.

4 comments

When Iran Sells Oil

I don’t have much to add to the volumes being written, pro and con, about President Obama’s incipient deal with Iran. I have noticed one thing that has gone unremarked upon so I’ll point it out. Most commentators seem to believe that as soon as sanctions are lifted Iran will begin selling oil. What hasn’t been pointed out is that the present price of oil (just over $50 per barrel) is significantly above, a multiple of Iran’s production cost (over $130 per barrel).

Or, in other words, Iran’s profit-maximizing strategy requires the price of oil to go up or, failing that, for Iran to leave its oil in the ground until it is able to produce oil at a lower cost.

That in turn leads to two observations. First, if Iran sells oil at all it means that it’s absolutely desperate for foreign exchange. And, more disquietingly, expect Iran to foment instability in the Middle East. Stability is bad for business.

16 comments

Congratulations, Illinoisans!

By the reckoning of the Mercatus Center we’re in the worst fiscal shape of any state. I found its conclusion most interesting:

So you think it’s beyond politics?

I think a lot of it is. Certainly politics figures into the whole thing – how legislatures and governors make decisions over time, how do they prioritize. Politicians tend to focus on the short-term, and I think that’s the story here. But it’s a 30-year story that we’ve got these pension benefits we can promise them, we can issue debt, we don’t have to think about that until tomorrow. Tomorrow is now in these states. And you see that in cities, too – Chicago, or you see that in Puerto Rico. That’s the past coming to you today, past decisions coming to you now.

That’s my take, too.

However, take a gander at the map that accompanies the post linked above. I find two things interesting. First, the richer the state, the worse fiscal shape its in. Or maybe it’s that having one extremely large city is a critical factor in making a state fiscally irresponsible. And Illinois is in much worse financial shape than any other Midwestern state while California is in much worse financial shape than any other Western state. That means that stepping across the state line is a perfectly workable strategy for getting out of the line of fire and the out-migration statistics for both states support that.

2 comments

The President Has His Deal With Iran

Today it is anticipated that President Obama and the Iranian leadership will announce a deal on Iran’s nuclear program:

VIENNA — An historic agreement Tuesday to limit Iran’s nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief will ensure Iran has no possibility to achieve rapid nuclear weapons “breakout” capabilities for at least the next decade, diplomats said.

“We have stopped the spread of nuclear weapons in this region,” said President Obama, noting some of the pillars of the deal including international inspections, reductions in Iran’s centrifuges used to make nuclear fuel and a sharp cut in Iran’s stockpile of nuclear material.

“We put sanctions in place to get a diplomatic solution, and that is what we have done . . . This deal offers an opportunity to move in a new direction. We should seize it,” said Obama, noting the review ahead in Congress.

and

A senior Iranian official, speaking to Western reporters on condition of anonymity, said the agreement would be submitted to the U.N. Security Council within a week to 10 days, and then be incorporated into a new Council resolution that eventually will lift sanctions that have crippled Iran’s economy.

Leslie Gelb observes:

The worrisome provisions pertain to the lifting of sanctions. Counter to Tehran’s wishes, they won’t be lifted all at once or all soon. A big chunk will be removed soon after the agreement is formally approved, but then, the bulk of the sanctions by the U.S. and others will come off over the course of years. Some might not be lifted by the U.S. Congress for many, many years.

A legitimate worry is that Iran will cheat or otherwise not live up to the agreement’s obligations, and that the sanctioning parties will let them get away with it. Indeed, China and Russia could look the other way and probably will. It’s also probable that the other signatories — Britain, France, Germany, and the European Union—won’t be tough in their responses to violations.

These concerns give real weight to the argument that this agreement in its execution could allow Tehran to have its nuclear capacity and a much stronger economy as well.

That an agreement will be reached should surprise exactly no one. Each side was clearly desperate for a deal, each for its own reasons. My own view has been and continues to be that the deal is irrelevant or, at least, enormously overblown. It all depends on whether you think that Iran has an active nuclear weapons development program.

If you don’t think that the Iranians have an active nuclear weapons development program, that means that they are as good as their word and we have nothing to worry about and haven’t for well over a decade. If you think that the Iranians have an active nuclear weapons development program, it means they’ve been lying all along and can’t be trusted including on this new deal. In either event this latest deal is, at the very least, greatly exaggerated in its importance. We’ll know in the fullness of time.

Meanwhile, kudos to the president. He’s got his deal with Iran. I genuinely hope it’s a deal worth having.

11 comments

Hillary Clinton’s Speech on the Economy

2 comments