Snowpiercer

I watched the movie Snowpiercer this weekend, streaming on NetFlix of course, and I’ve been consumed with the need to talk about it. It is a dystopian science fiction story (aren’t they all these days?) and I found it engaging, dark, and creative. It isn’t entirely without precedents in science fiction. Robert Heinlein’s novella, “Universe”, comes to mind but it’s a class conflict story and I suspect that as such it owes more to Metropolis or even Aelita (which influenced Metropolis) than to a 60 year old science fiction story its creators have never read. It also reminded me of The Air Trust but who other than me has read The Air Trust nowadays?

Imagine that some time in the near future the world becomes cold. Very cold. 100° below zero Fahrenheit or colder. Too cold for human life. All of humankind is riding on a gigantic never-stopping train that circles the globe once a year. The poor, starving proles are at the back of the train, the well-to-do effete rules at the front. The train is a huge, self-contained, self-sustaining ecosystem.

It’s apparently a Korean movie based on a French graphic novel and if that isn’t an intriguing enough pedigree for you its hero is played by Chris Evans in a very un-Captain America-like role and its villain is played by the British actress Tilda Swinton. I hadn’t realized what a chameleon the woman is. I suspect she was thinking of 1984 or Pink Floyd’s The Wall. Her characterization certainly brought those to mind for me.

I think that Chris Evans has the potential to portray a new type of American hero. He reminds me more of Henry Fonda or Jimmy Stewart than of John Wayne or Gary Cooper and he’s certainly very different from Clint Eastwood. His characters are definitely good, decent, strong, and brave but they have a past. They’re conflicted. They carry a burden. I think that the late Paul Walker had a similar quality. Brandon Routh is of something of the same mold but he’s a little too good-looking.

They actually give me some hope for the Millennials. We’ll just have to see what materializes.

At any rate if you’ve got a couple of hours to kill, watch Snowpiercer, and come back and give me your impressions.

5 comments

Deterrence

There’s a good post on deterrence at RealClearDefense which takes a largely historical perspective:

Deterrence has most frequently been explored through the lens of the Cold War, when the promise of massive nuclear retaliation kept the world from plunging into global thermonuclear warfare. Yet the concept of deterrence encompasses a much broader range of human behaviors, and existed long before the advent of nuclear weapons or the countries that wield them.

In fact, the logic underlying deterrence has been around for centuries. During the Peloponnesian Wars in ancient Greece, for example, Sparta threatened to launch an invasion of Attica if Athens carried out an attack against Potidaea. The long peace between Rome and its rival Persia in the fifth century AD was not due to a lack of potential for conflict, but rather because certain strategic and economic conditions made successful deterrence possible.

Efforts to deter undesirable actions by others take place at all levels of government, in business, education, and our interactions with others. One can find examples in virtually every aspect of human interactions. For instance, drivers often see signs that read “Fines Doubled” near construction zones. If it were the desire of the highway patrol to collect the most fines possible, they would not warn drivers of the situation. By visibly raising the consequences of speeding in a dangerous area the authorities are deterring drivers from behaving in undesirable ways.

Yet as history has shown, deterrence often fails; adversaries attack and drivers run red lights. So what separates deterrence successes from these failures? The key is to establish the credibility of deterrent threats. That is to say, one must be able to instill a sincere belief in adversaries that the promise of counteraction will be carried out if they fail to comply with the threat.

Over the years I’ve written pretty extensively about deterrence here at The Glittering Eye. It has two components: they physical and the psychological. You’ve got to be strong enough that your threats meet the laugh test and you’ve got to be convincing enough that your opponents take the threats seriously. IMO we’ve overachieved in the first component and underachieved in the second. Our present military is the strongest the world has ever known and it’s quite capable of opposing any foreseeable enemy. I don’t believe it’s crumbling, on the verge of collapse, or suffering some other malady as alarmists would have you believe. It’s also battle-tested (unlike the militaries of our prospective foes), a factor that should not be under-estimated.

I have no doubt that President Obama would defend the United States if we were attacked. However, he’s reneged on enough threats that, at the very least, he’s sending a mixed message and in terms of deterrence ambiguity is not a strength.

IMO the best possible policy outcome for the United States is successful deterrence while the worst possible outcome is unsuccessful deterrence. Bolstering a system is a process of strengthening the weak points not the strong points. Verbum sapienti satis est.

2 comments

No, Francis Is Not a Marxist

For those of you who think that Pope Francis’s recent remarks reveal that he is a crypto-Marxist, this post by Robert Barron should place Francis’s comments in some context for you:

Fr. Robert Sirico, Michael Novak, Arthur Brooks, and many others are therefore right in suggesting that Catholic Social Teaching does not represent a tertium quid beyond capitalism and socialism; rather, it clearly aligns itself against socialistic arrangements and clearly for the market economy. John Paul II appreciated the free-market as the economic concomitant of a democratic polity, since both rest upon the dignity of the individual and his right to self-determination.

But this valorization of the market by no means implies that the Church advocates an unfettered capitalism. The modern popes have consistently taught that the market functions properly only when it is circumscribed both politically and morally — and it is precisely in this context that Pope Francis’s remarks should be understood.

Read the whole thing if you’re interested in the question. The pope is not trying to put his thumb on the scales on the side of communism in a horserace between communists and capitalists and, even less, between Democrats and Republicans.

To place this question in some personal context every week without fail I read one thing or another claiming that Democrats are Marxists, something I find absurd on its face. The only thing I would find more absurd is the claim that Republicans are capitalists.

The leadership of both parties are crony capitalists, as anyone who’s been paying attention should know by now.

1 comment

What the IAEA Will Actually Do

There’s an article at Al-Monitor that asks an interesting question: is the IAEA capable of monitoring Iran’s nuclear program? I think the answer to that is pretty obvious. At its present staff levels and budget and given the way bureaucracies operate, I think the answer to that is obvious: no. The article remains interesting and I commend it to your attention.

What I think is likely to happen is that the IAEA will do its best. In all likelihood it will be tackling the biggest job it has ever tackled and I have little doubt that it will produce some sort of report in the tight timeframe is is allowed. The committee I referred to yesterday will vote to lift sanctions and whatever will be will be.

7 comments

What Is the Required Level of Surveillance?

In their editorial on the murder of four Marines in Chattanooga yesterday, the editors of the Wall Street Journal immediately leap to a number hasty conclusions:

  • That it was a terrorist attack. Although given the facts as we know them now it seems likely it still seems premature to me to draw that conclusion. Let’s let the investigation take its course.
  • That the attack was jihadist. This is something we simply don’t know at this time and it seems irresponsible to me to make that claim at this point.
  • That it was inspired by DAESH. Is there actual evidence of that?
  • That allowing or even requiring soldiers to carry sidearms on domestic military bases would do more good than harm. I have a vague recollection of a popular film of last year on the murder of some soldiers by another soldier using a sidearm. Which is more likely? That soldiers will be able to defend themselves successfully using their sidearms in the case of a terrorist attack at a military base on U. S. soil or that stressed, depressed, or psychotic soldiers will kill their fellows with one? That’s a question not an assertion. I’d like to see the evidence.
  • That there is some level of surveillance that would have prevented the attack. What surveillance measures not presently in place would have prevented this particular atrocity? Since we know so little about it, I can’t imagine they would have any idea. Of whom? Let me propose an alternative conjecture: that at the present level of personal empowerment in a country with as many people as the United States there is little that can be done to prevent occasional spree killings.

Allow me to point out a few facts. Some are quite uncomfortable.

  • By far the largest number of murders inspired by terrorism in the United States have been perpetrated by jihadis.
  • In 100% of the murders in the United States perpetrated by jihadis the perpetrators were Sunni Muslims.
  • In both of the terrorist attacks on U. S. military bases one or both of the perpetrators’ parents were Palestinians.
  • The greatest number of murders in terrorist attacks in the U. S. were not perpetrated using firearms.
  • Firearms are easy to come by in the United States and will remain so for the foreseeable future. Trying to eliminate terrorist attacks by going after the sale of firearms is, to put it coarsely, like trying to piss up a rope.
  • 80% of imams in the United States are foreign-born.
  • The Internet is everywhere and the cost of restricting access to it will unquestionably be greater than the cost of allowing access to it.

Somewhere in all of that mish-mosh I think there are mitigating strategies but they sure aren’t the ones I’m seeing being proposed.

13 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Iran’s Shopping List

There’s another interesting post at The Diplomat on some of the items likely to be on Iran’s shopping list when the embargo on military equipment and supplies is lifted, as will all but certainly be the case sooner rather than later. The list includes modern ground combat vehicles, small naval vessels, new technology aircraft, and cruise missiles.

4 comments

Corn Irony

I was pretty sure I would find an irony in Illinois’s naming sweet corn as its state vegetable:

Gov. Bruce Rauner signed legislation Thursday, making the designation official. State Sen. Sam McCann of Plainview introduced the legisilation after fourth-graders at Chatham Elementary School asked him about giving corn the honor. It had unanimous support.

Sweet corn now joins the list of other state symbols. That list includes popcorn as the official state snack food, violet as the official flower, cardinal as the official bird and square dancing as of the official state dance.

Rauner signed the measure before he was scheduled to visit the Chatham Sweet Corn Festival. The governor has yet to act on legislation that designates pumpkin pie as the official state pie.

Here’s the irony. Illinois doesn’t produce much sweet corn. It isn’t even among the top ten producers of sweet corn. The biggest producers of fresh sweet corn are Florida, California, and Georgia. Doesn’t seem to be mentioned in any of the stories. Illinois produces a lot of corn but it’s field corn—used for animal feed, in ethanol production, and making corn syrup.

3 comments

How to Lie With Statistics, Illinois Unemployment Rate Edition

The other day a news item stating that Illinois’s unemployment rate had dropped to 5.9% came across my desk. I didn’t comment on it because I suspected there was more to the story. There was:

The Illinois Department of Employment Security released last month’s jobs numbers Thursday. The statewide unemployment rate dropped from 6.9 percent in June 2014 to 5.9 percent last month.

The good news, however, is tempered by data showing that since January 2015 the state’s labor force has decreased by 33,600 workers, and the number of Illinois residents employed has dropped by 17,600. Based on the labor force constriction data, IDES analysts estimate that the number of jobs in Illinois won’t reach prerecession levels until at least September 2016.

Illinois shed 7,500 nonfarm payroll jobs in June, and the state’s jobless rate is still higher than the national rate, which came in at 5.3 percent last month.

IDES said a shrinking workforce must be considered when looking at jobless numbers.

“The drop in the number of unemployed Illinois residents since the beginning of this year is not entirely attributable to people finding jobs, rather to people leaving Illinois’ workforce altogether,” IDES Director Jeff Mays said.

or, in other words, our diligent political leaders in Illinois won’t rest until the last job is wrung out of the Illinois economy.

The unanswered questions are a) what is the state’s labor force participation rate?, b) what would Illinois’s unemployment rate be if the LFPR had remained the same?, and c) what is Illinois’s present population?

As it turns out, the answer to the first question is available:

The state’s workforce has decreased by 33,600 since the start of the year, with 8,300 disappearing from the workforce in June alone, which pushed the labor force participation rate to a new low of 64.4 percent–the lowest it has been since February of 1978.

Also, see the graph at the linked post. It’s been 37 years since the LFPR has been this low in Illinois. If you cast your mind back, Baby Boomers had just started entering the workforce and women were still getting into the workforce in numbers. And it’s still going down.

I don’t think that our political leaders have come to terms with the realities of our situation. You can’t support the same size (or larger) government as we did eight years ago. Trying to maintain the government at the same (or larger) size with less economic activity just pushes economic activity lower.

It genuinely concerns me that every solution to our economic problems proposed by our political leaders whether at the state, county, or local level will reduce economic activity. That doesn’t sound like the right direction to me.

0 comments

Disrupting the Disruptor

There’s an interesting article at Forbes suggesting that Amazon may itself be disrupted by an innovative new invention: brick and mortar stores.

1 comment