The Nature of the Offense

Is selling fetal tissue malum in se or malum prohitibum?

25 comments

Does Joining the European Union Weed Out Corruption?

I’ve got to admit that I’m baffled by this post at RealClearWorld:

If ever there were a country that the European Union could benefit, that country is Macedonia. Bordering several troubled countries that arose from the bloodstained ashes of the former Yugoslavia, Macedonia, with a helping hand, could become the peaceful example that this patch of the Balkans sorely needs.

Stuck between Albania, Serbia, Kosovo, Bulgaria, and Greece, Macedonia is a land-locked country of slightly more than 2 million souls. It is also a country typical of the Balkans, with its troubled past and the potential for future violence. Macedonia is a European nation in trouble, and the European Union should help it. The question increasingly is whether Macedonia still wants that help – and all the strings that come attached to it.

I’m well aware of Macedonia’s problems with poverty, corruption, and lack of economic development. They’re problems all too common among the European former subjects of the Ottoman. All experienced several hundred years of oppression by the Turks followed by misrule by German princes and, in the case of Macedonia, a former Yugoslav republic, by Communist bosses.

I’m not sure the European Union and even less the euro would do much to produce the changes that Macedonia needs—foreign direct investment and development under conditions that would gradually build economic, political, and social institutions. What it is more likely to experience is a flood of German goods and the squelching of its domestic economy. Consider the example of Greece.

0 comments

Give Me $150 Billion in Small, Unmarked Bills

The gold guys at zerohedge have noticed something interesting—since the beginning of the year the Chinese government has sold off $150 billion of U. S. Treasuries, about 10% of their total holdings, and bought gold:

While the implications of this on the global FX scene are profound, they tie in to what we said last November when explaining the death of the petrodollar. For the most part, the country most and first impacted from this capital outflow will be China, something its stock market has already noticed in recent weeks.

But what is likely the take home message for non-Chinese readers from all of this, is that while there has been latent speculation over the years that China will dump US treasuries voluntarily because it wants to (as punishment or some other reason), suddenly China is forced to liquidate US Treasury paper even though it does not want to, merely to fund a capital outflow unlike anything it has seen in history. It still has a lot of 10 Year paper, aka FX reserves, left: about $1.3 trillion at last check, however this raises two critical questions: i) what happens to 10 Year rates when whoever has been absorbing China’s Treasury dump no longer bids the paper and ii) how much more paper can China sell before the entire world starts paying attention, besides just JPM and Goldman… and this website of course.

No one seems to know exactly why the Chinese are taking this course of action, as the linked post documents. zerohedge seems to think that, if the Chinese continue the sell-off, it will strongly encourage the Fed to buy up the slack. The explanation that occurs to me is that the Chinese are continuing what they’ve said they’d do, move from a dollar peg to a peg based on a market basket of currencies and they’re continuing their diversification out of dollars. Or the Chinese may be concerned about Fed policy, something they’ve indicated in the past.

Or, of course, we may be seeing the CCP’s end game. It’s a lot easier to disguise the provenance of gold than that of U. S. Treasuries.

1 comment

In Re: Friedman on the Iran Deal

This post isn’t intended so much as a fisking of Tom Friedman’s most recent column on the Obama Administration’s incipient deal with Iran as much as an interlinear commentary.

From the minute Iran detected that the U.S. was unwilling to use its overwhelming military force to curtail Tehran’s nuclear program — and that dates back to the George W. Bush administration, which would neither accept Iran’s right to a nuclear fuel cycle nor structure a military or diplomatic option to stop it — no perfect deal overwhelmingly favorable to America and its allies was ever going to emerge from negotiations with Iran. The balance of power became too equal.

That is absolutely true, insightful, and I wonder if Mr. Friedman or, indeed, the president understands the larger implications of that on our entire deterrence posture. Successful deterrence depends on several components the most notable being a) you’ve got to have the ability to back up a threat and b) the other party must believe you’ll follow through on a threat. We have more than enough ability to back up any threat but both the Bush and Obama Administrations have done their darnedest to convince Iran in particular (but not limited to Iran) that we won’t use it which undermines the very idea of deterrence. Kiss deterrence, non-proliferation and any number of other perennials in our defense policy good bye. They have been inoperative for some time.

In both the cases of the Bush Administration and the Obama Administration that’s incredibly ironic. How could anyone doubt that George W. Bush was willing to use force? Or that Barack Obama wouldn’t (given Libya, the “Afghan surge”, the drone strike program, etc.)? And yet that’s what’s happened.

Some of that’s inevitable in the modern world when you have a country like the United States in which national deliberations on matters of state are carried on in the public media. President Obama’s bold talk without the will to follow through, cf. Syria, Russia, and Iran just to name a few, probably hasn’t helped.

But there are degrees of imperfect, and the diplomatic option structured by the Obama team — if properly implemented and augmented by muscular diplomacy — serves core American interests better than any options I hear coming from the deal’s critics: It prevents Iran from producing the fissile material to break out with a nuclear weapon for 15 years and creates a context that could empower the more pragmatic forces inside Iran over time — at the price of constraining, but not eliminating, Iran’s nuclear infrastructure and sanctions relief that will strengthen Tehran as a regional power.

As I’ve said before, it only ensures that Iran will not “break out with a nuclear weapon for 15 years” if you don’t believe they have a nuclear weapons development program. In other words, the deal is only worth having if it’s unnecessary.

Supporting this deal doesn’t make you Neville Chamberlain; opposing it doesn’t make you Dr. Strangelove. Both sides have legitimate arguments.

I agree with that, too. But try and convince the partisans of one side or another of it. As I’ve said for weeks, it’s neither the parousia nor a disaster. My main concern is the prospect of the sanctions lifting without our getting enough for it.

That would be a mistake that would isolate us, not Iran, and limit our choices to going to war or tolerating an Iran much closer to nuclear breakout, without any observers or curbs on the ground, and with crumbling sanctions.

People keep saying that the sanctions are crumbling but no one is producing any evidence of that. I have no doubt that China, Russia, and Germany are chafing at the restrictions the sanctions impose. And in the absence of any other activity on our part I agree that the sanctions will evaporate. But those aren’t the only alternatives. IMO we can maintain the sanctions regime as long as we care to. And that’s the crux of it.

“The nuclear agreement is a deal, not a grand bargain,” argued the Wilson Center’s Robert Litwak, author of “Iran’s Nuclear Chess.” “Obama and Iran’s supreme leader Khamenei are each making a tacit bet. Obama is defending the deal in transactional terms (that it addresses a discrete urgent challenge), but betting that it will empower Iran’s moderate faction and put the country on a more favorable societal trajectory. Khamenei is making the opposite bet — that the regime can benefit from the transactional nature of the agreement (sanctions relief) and forestall the deal’s potentially transformational implications to preserve Iran’s revolutionary deep state.”

We can, though, do things to increase the odds that the bet goes our way: 1. Don’t let this deal become the Obamacare of arms control, where all the energy goes into the negotiation but then the implementing tools — in this case the verification technologies — don’t work. President Obama should appoint a respected military figure to oversee every aspect of implementing this deal.

He must be talking about some other Obama Administration. Can you name any of its major accomplishments that hasn’t been subjected to benign neglect? Until the brink of disaster or beyond? I will not speculate on why the administration’s attention span is so short. It may just be the affliction of most administrations—the inability to walk and chew gum at the same time. But pick a subject. ARRA. PPACA. The multiple IRS transgressions. They were all allowed to go on auto-pilot.

2. Congress should pass a resolution authorizing this and future presidents to use force to prevent Iran from ever becoming a nuclear weapons state. Iran must know now that the U.S. president is authorized to destroy — without warning or negotiation — any attempt by Tehran to build a bomb.

That would almost certainly be viewed by China and Russia as a violation of our treaty obligations. I also feel compelled to note that such action would not meet the standard for a just war.

3. Focus on the Iranian people. The celebrations of this deal in Iran tell us that “the Iranian people want to be South Korea, not North Korea,” notes Karim Sadjadpour, Iran expert at the Carnegie Endowment. We should reach out to them in every way — visas, exchanges and scholarships — to strengthen their voices. Visiting Iran taught me that Iranians have had enough Islamic fundamentalism to know they want less of it and they’ve had enough democracy to know they want more of it. (Iran’s hard-line Revolutionary Guards know this well, which is why they are still trying to persuade Iran’s supreme leader to reject this deal and its opening to the world.)

I wonder if he means as we did following the 2009-2010 demonstrations in Iran? The sad reality is that the mullahs are willing to do whatever they need to do to hold on to power. The opinion of the people is irrelevant.

4. Avoid a black-and-white view of the Middle East. The idea that Iran is everywhere our enemy and the Sunni Arabs our allies is a mistake. Saudi Arabia’s leadership has been a steadfast U.S. ally in the Cold War; many Saudis are pro-American. But the Saudi leadership’s ruling bargain is toxic: It says to the Saudi people that the al-Saud tribe gets to rule and in return the Saudi Wahhabi religious establishment gets billions of dollars to transform the face of Sunni Islam from an open and modernizing faith to a puritanical, anti-women, anti-Shiite, anti-pluralistic one. The Saudis have lost control of this puritanical-Salafist transformation of Islam, and it has mutated into the ideology that inspired the 9/11 hijackers — 15 of 19 of whom were Saudis — and the Islamic State.

Do we really want to engage in a Kremlinology of the religious, tribal, ethnic, and political factions of the Middle East? I have a much simpler strategy in mind: he who sups with the devil should use a long spoon.

13 comments

Brave New World of Automotive Vulnerability

If you drive or plan to, I strongly recommend you read this article at Wired on the progress that a pair of hackers have made at hacking into automobiles. Wirelessly. While the vehicles are on the road.

Trigger warning: if you’ve ever experienced Sudden Unintended Acceleration you might not want to read the article.

Hat tip: memeorandum

9 comments

Magical Thinking, Government Style

Over at Bloomberg, Noah Smith makes a point that I think is too often forgotten:

But what we really lack is any idea of the quantitative impact of any given reform. A good idea might produce a 1 percentage point increase in growth for three years, or a 0.01 percentage point bump for three months. A lot of the belief that we can reform our way to sustained higher growth really boils down to faith and hope.

There are many cases where that faith and hope has turned out not to be justified. For example, there is the case of the ALEC rankings. ALEC is short for the American Legislative Exchange Council, a think tank comprised of state senators and representatives from a number of large corporations in industries such as energy and pharmaceuticals. They employ a number of economists, including Arthur Laffer, the famous proponent of supply-side economics.

Every year, ALEC produces a report called “Rich States, Poor States,” in which it ranks states according to how business-friendly their policies are. ALEC claims that the policies it advocates determine which states will grow and which won’t. From the report’s website:

Rich States, Poor States not only identifies these policies but also makes sound research-based conclusions about which states are poised to achieve greater economic prosperity and those that are stuck on the path to a lackluster economy.

Alec lists 15 factors that it claims boost state growth rates. These boil down to low taxes, low levels of government spending and light regulation. In other words, these policies are similar to the ideas John Cochrane describes, and that pro-free-market economists have been promising us will boost growth since time immemorial. It’s a simple prescription: shrink the state, cut taxes and the economy will grow.

But do the policies work? Empirical evidence suggests that they don’t deliver. Menzie Chinn, an economist at the University of Wisconsin, applied his formidable statistics skills to investigating the impact of ALEC’s rankings on actual state growth levels. What he found was startling — the ALEC rankings didn’t predict a state’s growth within one year, three years or six years. In other words, if having ALEC-endorsed policies makes a state grow faster, either it must take a very long time, or the effect is too small to measure.

In fact, when Chinn controls for a number of other variables, such as urbanization rates, weather and access to waterways, he finds that there may even be a negative relationship between the ALEC rankings and growth — in other words, states that ALEC claims have more business-friendly policies might actually grow more slowly!

Chinn isn’t the only one who has analyzed the ALEC rankings. The Iowa Policy Project, a smaller rival think tank, conducted its own analysis and reached the same conclusion as Chinn. They investigated ALEC’s factors individually, and found that none of them had much of a relationship to growth.

What about other measurements of business-friendly policy? These fare slightly better. In 2013, economists Jed Kolko, David Neumark and Marisol Mejia analyzed 10 different indexes of state business climate, and found that two factors did predict higher growth. These are 1) simpler corporate tax codes and 2) less spending on welfare and other transfer payments. But the effect of these policies on growth was very small.

which is that you can make grand claims about the effectiveness of your proposals but the reality may be quite different. This problem is not confined to one party or the other. We’re not going to grow our way out of the hole we’ve dug for ourselves by cutting taxes and shrinking government any more than we are by increasing the minimum wage or expanding Social Security.

Unfortunately, the reality is a lot harder than that. No incremental change will help much. No cluster of incremental changes will help much. We need serious structural change to get anywhere and nobody can really quantify what the impact of any given structural change might be. I may think that relying on fundamentals is the only way to go but it’s darned hard for me to prove that let alone tell you how much difference that might make. And there’s somebody else who believes just as fervently that he or she can manage his or her way to prosperity who’s in the same fix.

We could rely on consensus but nowadays there is precious little consensus. But over-heated differences of opinion we have a-plenty.

2 comments

One Size Does Not Fit All (Minimum Wage Edition)

Over at the Washington Post Catherine Rampell points out some of the complications in increasing the minimum wage as your leading piece of economic development strategy:

Raising the federal minimum wage to $10.10 — a policy change that most Americans support — would likely boost the earnings of about 16.5 million workers while reducing total employment by about 500,000, according to the Congressional Budget Office. This is a trade-off that many allies of low-wage workers are willing to accept — particularly those of us who worry that anti-poverty spending programs may allow employers to further depress worker pay.

But none of this suggests that there aren’t limits. Even the most diehard of labor advocates probably wouldn’t endorse a $50-an-hour minimum, because they know such a wage floor would price pretty much all low-skilled laborers out of a job.

So if a $10.10 minimum probably would help more low-wage workers than it would hurt, and a $50 minimum would almost certainly hurt more than it would help, what about $15?

In some parts of the country, where the cost of living is relatively steep, a $15 minimum wage might put more money into the pockets of workers while eliminating relatively few jobs. Think of cities such as New York, San Francisco, Chicago, Los Angeles, Seattle and the District, all of which have either proposed or already adopted a $15 minimum.

Even in these expensive cities, though, don’t be surprised if you see fewer busboys, grocery baggers and other low-level jobs. The higher wage floor will make at least some such positions cost-prohibitive.

In other, lower-cost parts of the country, however, a $15 minimum — which, remember, is more than double the current federal level — would likely throw many, many more people out of work.

The unintended effects might not show up all at once and they might not be limited to just fewer minimum wage jobs. Minimum wage plus contracts might result in losses of jobs above the minimum wage level. It might increase the size of the black market for labor.

Here in Chicago the Mayor and the City Council have already decided to increase the city’s minimum wage to $13 per hour in stepwise increments taking place on July 1 of each year, presumably on the principle of the “frog in a pot of water”. It may work or it may not. I suspect that prospective business owners are able to read calendars and calculate increases in payroll costs. They’ll need to decide whether opening up shop or adding a new employee makes sense under the conditions the city is establishing.

And employers can also avoid the higher wage by stepping across the city line.

12 comments

The Case for Hillary

Can someone articulate the affirmative case for electing Hillary Clinton president for me? Not the negative case, the affirmative one. Other than electability, I mean. As the late Mayor Daley once said, regardless of how it looks now someone will be elected. In other words definitionally when two unelectable candidates face off, one of them will indeed be elected which means that he or she wasn’t that unelectable after all.

21 comments

The Reason Pension Funds Assume Larger Risks

After why San Diego County fired its outside pension fund manager Barry Ritholz concludes:

A city, county or municipality that fails to appropriately fund its pension plan isn’t honoring its fiduciary obligation to its employees and retirees. Not saving enough to meet its retirement obligations shouldn’t be an excuse for risky behavior or using additional leverage.

There is no free lunch. Instead, pension funds should keep it simple, manage a basic global allocation of assets, and watch costs. There simply is no reason to try to reinvent investing when there is a perfectly viable and preferable option.

But there is a reason. Undercapitalized pension funds assume higher risks chasing higher yields. When a pension fund has been constructed assuming an 8% yield, as many have, and instead they’re realizing 4% or even 2% yields, as many are, they’ve got to do something and assuming higher risks is what many public pension fund managers have decided to do.

The question is who assumes what risks. Increasing the amount of money paid from the public purse to the voters is the path of least resistance for politicians. It’s certainly less risky for them than increasing taxes to pay for the benefits they’ve already promised. It’s the taxpayers who are assuming the risks and as the roster of taxpayers dwindles relative to the number of benefit recipients there aren’t enough taxpayers squawking to make a difference. As Shaw said, when you rob Peter to pay Paul you can always depend on the support of Paul.

1 comment

Movies, Faith, and Hollywood

I stumbled across this op-ed from, of all people, Kevin Sorbo and although I think he’s got a good handle on the effects I don’t think he’s got his hands around the causes. If you know his name at all you’ll probably remember Kevin Sorbo as Hercules on the New Zealand-based television series from the 1990s. For the last decade or so other than the occasional appearance on television he’s been starring in what might be described as “Christian movies”. They’re a little bit hard to describe. The closest I think I can come in 25 words or less is that they’re pictures without a lot of sex or bloodshed but with a strong moral core.

Here’s the kernel of his argument:

The mainstream media just doesn’t get faith-based entertainment because they don’t have faith. And they don’t understand people of faith.

Unfortunately for them, the box office belongs to audiences, not elitist critics writing from their ivory Manhattan towers. It belongs to working mothers who want to raise their children with a strong sense of values and devoted fathers who are coaching softball games after a long day on the job. It belongs to regular people in small towns and flyover states and middle-class suburban neighborhoods who are struggling with how to live meaningful lives in an ever-changing society.

If critics want to meet these Americans, they can walk into a church on any given Sunday and listen to their stories. Their tales of faith and redemption sound something like this: “Amazing grace, how sweet the sound that saved a wretch like me. I once was lost but now I’m found, was blind but now I see.”

Until critics understand these types of stories, they’ll continue to misunderstand faith-based entertainment.

I think I’d phrase the question a little differently. Big, bloody blockbusters with lots of overt sexuality aren’t the only movies that make money. Why is Hollywood so fixated on sex and violence? And why have simple values fallen so far out of favor? I’ll give one simple example. The movie Elf has earned a tremendous amount of money. It only cost something like $30 million to make and it’s earned on the order to ten times that. It didn’t inspire a whole platoon of imitations. Why?

My speculation is that there are several reasons: international audiences, that those aren’t the movies that producers and directors want to make, and that Hollywood is tremendously solipsistic and inbred, largely dominated by secularized Jews and fallen-away Catholics who disdain simple stories and simple values and are possibly even frightened of traditional values.

6 comments