Is There a Great American Novel?

There’s an interesting post at RealClearBooks musing over candidates for the title “the Great American Novel”. One of the first candidates to be nominated (back in 1868) for that eminence was Uncle Tom’s Cabin. That’s almost certainly the most influential American novel, not just here but worldwide. Huckleberry Finn, certainly a perennial candidate, was also hailed almost from the time of its publication. Here are other candidates:

That said, the list of books bestowed the unofficial G.A.N. title over the centuries include “Moby Dick,” written a decade before the Civil War, “The Virginian,” “My Antonia,” “Ethan Frome,” “The Great Gatsby,” “The Sun Also Rises,” “Grapes of Wrath,” “To Kill a Mockingbird,” “Citizen Kane,” “All the King’s Men,” “Lonesome Dove,” “Beloved,” and many more.

I note that the only genre fiction nominees on that list are westerns, which to me suggests the prejudice of the author who goes on to mention other novels with western settings he’d put forward:

I’d personally lobby for inclusion on the list two books set in the American West, though they are not westerns, precisely. These contenders are Wallace Stegner’s 1972 “Angle of Repose,” and the more recent “Snow Falling on Cedars” by David Guterson. A few years ago Time magazine put a contemporary writer, Jonathan Franzen, on its cover with the headline, “Great American Novelist.”

and goes on to mention some sports novels.

Our British cousins, apparently, do not believe that any American novels are genuinely great:

Academics and writers have reacted angrily to plans to drop classic American novels including To Kill a Mockingbird and Of Mice and Men from the GCSE curriculum as a result of the insistence by the education secretary, Michael Gove, on students studying more British literature.

The new English literature GCSE syllabus to be published this week by OCR, one of the biggest UK exam boards, will leave out Harper Lee’s Pulitzer-prizewinning 1960 novel of racism in the American south. John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men, and Arthur Miller’s play The Crucible – in which the Salem witch-hunts serve as a metaphor for McCarthyite anti-communist zealotry – will also disappear from the list, according to the Sunday Times. Another exam board, Edexcel, is expected to follow suit.

In the course of my formal education I read not only American novels but English, French, German, Spanish, and Russian novels. To the best of my ability to determine no American novels are a formal component of French, German, or Russian primary or secondary education.

Is there a singular “Great American Novel”? Are there other candidates for GAN? Are there genre novels which belong in the canon? IMO The Big Sleep is better than most of the novels on the list above and certainly a better novel than Uncle Tom’s Cabin (albeit not more influential). And it’s better than My Antonia or The Virginian. For goodness sake, Kiss Me Deadly is as good a novel as The Virginian.

35 comments

No Moore’s Law for Batteries

All is proceeding as I have foreseen. 50 years ago one of the founders of Intel, Gordon Moore, predicted that the number of transistors per square inch on integrated circuits would double every year for the foreseeable future. After 1975 he pulled back on that prediction to every two years. He’s been right. Along with its many, many fortunate consequences that has had two unfortunate consequences. People think it will go on forever which is likely not to be the case. And people think it pertains to all technology. That is eminently and obviously not the case.

There is no Moore’s Law for batteries and that has serious implications for electric cars:

A couple of years ago BMW, which is leading the way with battery-only i3 and i8 plug-in hybrid vehicles, said within four to five years electric cars will have twice the current power and double the range. BMW board member Ian Robertson added then, that in the next three to four years there will be more progress in battery development than in the previous 100 years.

Not much sign of that and time is running out.

It may be that there is some great breakthrough in batteries just around the corner and that will allow brilliant new things in electric cars. Or we may have already reached the acme of electric car technology.

8 comments

Has the Gold Turned to Rust?

I guess I should take some solace in the fact that Illinois isn’t the only state with problems. California has plenty of problems, too:

California remains the Golden State for most of us, a place of opportunity and fantastic weather. But for an increasing number of our residents, it is a place of perpetual economic struggle.

The difficulties are detailed in a new study by United Ways of California, “Struggling to Get By: The Real Cost Measure in California 2015.” The RCM is a new formula that takes into account California’s high cost of living.

It found that 31 percent of Californians were living in poverty in 2012-13. That’s higher than the 23.4 percent poverty rate, the worst in the nation, found in an October 2014 study by the U.S. Census Bureau.

A big cause, obviously, is the high cost of housing. According to a March analysis by the California Legislative Analyst, “Today, an average California home costs $440,000, about two–and-a-half times the average national home price ($180,000).”

Another big factor is the ongoing exodus from the state of decent-paying jobs for workers with few skills, Bill Watkins told us; he’s the executive director of the Center for Economic Research and Forecasting at California Lutheran University. “California used to manufacture Firebirds and Camaros,” he said, until General Motors’ Van Nuys assembly plant closed in 1992. Aerospace also has been hit hard by consolidation and moves to other states.

California’s population continues to grow. People with skills are leaving; they’re being replace by semi-skilled and non-skilled immigrants. Nearly 2/3s of California’s immigrant population are on some form of public assistance. It’s the cat and rat farm again. There’s a sucker born every minute.

10 comments

The Master-Minds

You would think that the editors of the Chicago Tribune would have learned by now. Our mayor and City Council are arrogant dopes. They thought that the courts would carry their water for them:

But it’s clearer with each ruling — two Supreme Court cases and this one in Cook County — that governments throughout Illinois are running out of options. State and local officials have to figure out how they’ll function while meeting these obligations under this constitution.

When the city’s law passed, Emanuel said it was constitutional, would protect pensions going forward and would be a model for other pension funds. Without the changes, he said, Chicago’s funds would face insolvency: “Without this reform, these two funds will run out of money in just a matter of years, which is why we must defend this law to protect the future of our workers, retirees and taxpayers.”

But now that the law has been struck down, and an appeal may fall on deaf ears, Illinois governments have to figure out what to do next. And it can’t be more borrowing.

That’s been the city’s crutch so far, both for City Hall and Chicago Public Schools. Just borrow into oblivion, as servicing that debt consumes ever more dollars that taxpayers want spent on services.

Nor can higher taxes be everyone’s sole go-to. Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle already pushed through a half-billion-dollar sales tax increase, in part to deal with pension costs.

Borrowing the money has always been the fall-back plan. IMO that amounts to political malpractice. It has always been obvious that their pension reform plans would not pass constitutional muster. I said it at the time. I cited the black letter law.

If the plan was always that they would borrow the money, they should have done so before the city’s credit rating was graded down rather than afterwards. What they’ve done will cost Chicagoans billion upon billions of dollars.

I generally stick with the view that stupidity and incompetence are better explanations than brilliance and malice, as Goethe pointed out more than two hundred years ago. Either the mayor was trying to give more money to bankers than was necessary or he was too arrogant and pig-headed to realize what would take place. When Karen Lewis handed Emanuel his head in 2012 that should have been obvious. And yet people voted to re-elect him.

3 comments

The South Rising Again. And Again. And Again.

I am genuinely astonished at Southerners’ ability to hold views that simply aren’t so. The most recent example I’ve found was in the blog of a blogger whom I respect, roughly my contemporary, a Southerner born and bred with a lineage going back to the 17th century in the South. He made the claim that over time the states of the Confederacy would have themselves abolished slavery, one at a time.

When I quoted for him the passage in the Confederacy’s constitution that would have rendered such a process illegal, he resorted to a fallacious appeal to authority. He couldn’t handle the truth.

BTW, in the Confederacy’s constitution “negro slavery” is mentioned a half dozen times. “State sovereignty” is mentioned airily in the preamble but much of the Confederate constitution, just as is the case with the U. S. constitution, is a statement of the ways in which the power of the states is limited. So much for the idea that the American Civil War was not about slavery but about states’ rights.

I continue to be impressed with the truth Faulkner’s sad wisecrack that the past is not dead; it isn’t even past.

1 comment

Is Corruption Our Most Important Problem?

One sentence in Bill Curry’s Salon article on the obstacles facing Hillary Clinton in her march to the White House caught my attention: “Corruption, not the chimera we call partisan gridlock, is what makes our government so inefficient and ineffectual and our politics so empty and vicious.”

I guess, depending on how you define “corruption”, that’s true. If you define something broadly enough anything can mean anything. I think we’d all agree that when a Congressman or other elected official takes a bribe it’s corruption. When an individual or organization gives a contribution to a politician whose policies the individual or organization agrees with, is that corruption, too? If you think that, isn’t any system in which each candidate isn’t allowed to spend precisely the same amount inherently corrupt? Such a system would give an enormous advantage to incumbents. Isn’t that inherently corrupt as well?

When everything is corrupt, nothing is.

If I had to single out our most important problem, I think it would be a toss-up between the collapse of the rule of law and that there’s a consensus on most issues in Washington, the consensus position is unpopular, and nine times out of ten it’s empirically wrong.

Is corruption really our most important problem? Or is what Mr. Curry characterizing as “corruption” actually just human nature and inevitable?

2 comments

In Re: Sandra Bland

A week and a half ago Sandra Bland was pulled over in a routine traffic stop in Waller County Texas, arrested, and put in jail there. A few days later she was dead. Some think that she was murdered by the police while in custody. Others think she killed herself.

Here’s my question. Is this a big story or a little one? I think it’s a sad story; I don’t have any question about that but is it a big, important story?

My take: better work on the part of the arresting officer could have defused the situation before it reached the point of his arresting the woman. Did it make a difference that Sandra Bland was black? That the arresting police officer wasn’t black? There’s a lot of poor police work out there and always will be.

4 comments

Different Income Inequalities

As Barry Ritholz points out people mean different things when they talk about “income inequality”. Some people mean the fact that Warren Buffet earns more in a month than you do in a lifetime. But other means that even Americans below the poverty level are upper middle income by world standards:

It is noteworthy that while $10 is the lower threshold for middle-income status, it is about the median daily per capita income of U.S. households living in poverty. Pew reports that “a large share of poor people in the U.S. would also fail to meet the global middle-income standard.”

So, when the issue of income inequality or a wealth tax comes up in international circles, they don’t mean taxing Warren Buffet and giving the money to you. They mean taxing you and giving the money to Chinese and Indian farmers.

And somehow along the way a little of that money will be siphoned off into the pockets of the politicians and bureaucrats who will administer it. It’s said that hardly a drop of the Colorado River empties into the ocean these days as each state and municipality along the ways takes a little of the mighty flow for its own use.

2 comments

Why How You Made a Profit Makes a Difference

I was pretty surprised at the response to my observation on how Amazon had turned in its a rare quarterly profit:

Amazon made a $92 million profit last quarter, or about 19 cents per share. That’s peanuts compared to other tech giants like Google, which netted $3.93 billion last quarter, or eBay, which made $682 million. But analysts expected Amazon to lose 14 cents per share. In fact, it’s unusual that Amazon, a 21-year-old company, actually turns a profit at all. Last year the company lost 27 cents a share in the second quarter. So investors are feeling pretty good about Amazon right now: shares are up 15 percent in after-hours trading.

My observation was that Amazon had made money on cloud services and the reaction was does it matter? The answer is, yes, it matters.

First, a little background. For those of you who aren’t particularly tech-y, Amazon got into the cloud services business back in, I believe, 2002. It began selling the technology it had developed for its own use. It began to sell what has become known as cloud services. The 25 words or less description of that is that you can put your computing infrastructure, your processing power, storage, and so on, in “the cloud”, i.e. the Internet. Instead of having whole buildings full of servers, environmental control, backup power and so on, you just pay a fee to have someone else do it for you. For the purposes of this post I’m not going to go into the technical differences between what’s called “colocation” and true cloud services.

It’s actually quite cheap. Right now you could browse on over to Amazon Web Services and they’d give you the cloud services equivalent of a small server of your own for free for a year. After that it would be just a few bucks a month. It’s no wonder that all of the Fortune 500 companies are using cloud services at some level and some have completely put their information infrastructure “in the cloud”.

Amazon didn’t make its profit in retail sales. That continues to lose money. It makes it in cloud services.

A shrewd manager will devote more resources, particularly management attention, always a scarce commodity, to where he’s making money and, at the very least, try to control his losses in other business segments. She’ll either do less of it or find out why it’s losing money and deal with it.

Amazon has been trying, unsuccessfully, to make money in retail sales for more than 20 years. Amazon’s weird business model moved Matt Yglesias to waggishly characterize the company as a “not for profit operated for the benefit of consumers”.

So I wouldn’t be at all surprise if Amazon gradually de-emphasized its online sales effort in favor of cloud services. But there’s more to the story. Amazon may have been the first mover in cloud services but it’s no longer alone. Amazon has about 29% of the cloud services market and it’s growing fast but Microsoft, IBM, and Google have carved out substantial chunks of that market and are growing even faster. Have you wondered why Microsoft’s software offering have been so lackluster? Maybe it’s because that market segment is languishing while cloud services is growing fast.

At any rate Amazon is actually making money in cloud services and it’s facing increasingly stiff competition. It will want to maintain its position in cloud services but whether it will be able to in the face of increasingly stiff competition is another question.

Meanwhile it’s good news for consumers. Your next PC may be “in the cloud”.

2 comments

Mud Wrestling

It isn’t often that a story comes along that ends up discrediting Hillary Clinton, The New York Times, and the Associated Press but before it’s done I suspect that the story of the IG wanting to launch a criminal investigation of Hillary Clinton about her email setup will end up throwing mud on the White House, the Department of Justice, and the IG. Noah Rothman gives a pretty fair summary at Commentary:

Hillary Clinton’s campaign team was surely reveling in the national media’s distracted focus on the messy Republican presidential primary late Thursday night when they got the news. Immediately, her campaign team sprang into action and began the familiar process of muddying the waters and misdirecting reporters with a magician’s mastery. The New York Times had revealed that two independent inspectors general requested that the Justice Department open a criminal investigation into Hillary Clinton for possibly jeopardizing national security by handling classified information on her personal “homebrew” email server. By morning, however, the Times story had been edited several times. Struck from the account was the contention that Clinton had “mishandled sensitive government information” and in its place was the claim that “information was mishandled” by… someone. The lead reporter on that story confessed that the alterations were made at the Clinton campaign’s “reasonable” request. The Associated Press dutifully followed the Times lead and noted that the IG’s referrals do not suggest wrongdoing by Clinton personally – merely her subordinates at the State Department.

Several hours later, the Justice Department indicated that the referrals they received were not criminal, leading to pushback from New York Times reporters who claimed that their sources were solid. Meanwhile, a spokeswoman for the Inspector General’s office is standing by the contention that classified information that was classified as such was sent to Clinton’s private email address. Something bizarre is happening.

What I suspect will come out of this is that the White House will finally and noisily insert itself into the story, revealing naked political interests, and the IG’s office will be slapped down. The ultimate outcome may well be the Hillary Clinton will be elected president.

I’ve made no secret of my distaste for Sec. Clinton. What I think should happen is that she should be compelled to pay a whopping civil penalty (she’s already confessed to regulatory infractions), should be tried for obstruction of justice, and, if found guilty, should do jail time. But I’m under no illusions any of that is likely to take place. There’s one law for the Clintons and another for you and me.

The whole story reminds me of the old joke about why you shouldn’t mud-wrestle with a pig.

4 comments