Recap of Chicago’s Fiscal Woes

There’s a pretty fair briefer on Chicago’s fiscal problems at City Journal. The one thing in the post that I disagree with is their assessment of Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s posture. I think he thought that being Chicago mayor would be a sinecure, as being a U. S. Congressman was for him.

2 comments

In Good Company

Former New Hampshire governor and U. S. senator Judd Gregg draws a connection among Greece, Puerto Rico, and Illinois:

Greece, Puerto Rico, Illinois: they are starkly similar, fiscally dire political entities.

Since one is a nation, the second a commonwealth and the third a state, one would not think they would have the same problems when it comes to the management of their respective cultures and people. But they do.

The common thread is that for years voters in all three places have been electing people to govern them who have promised a great deal and borrowed to pay for those promises.

In each case, the root of the fiscal imbalance is that the governments are dedicated to the power of patronage. At their heart is the belief that you can retain power so long as you promise to fund gains for your supporters by taking from someone else.

Here’s how he sees Illinois’s central problem:

In Illinois, the state line is far too close. Whether it is Indiana or even Texas, departing the political disaster is relatively easy.

Those left behind will be those who cannot move. They will find that their school systems (especially their state college system) and their healthcare systems will be pitted against their public pensioners in dividing the diminishing revenue pie. The quality of all services will be hit.

His recommendation is that we stop electing demagogues.

Here in Illinois we’ve taken the first step or at least what we hope is the first step. We’ve elected a governor who isn’t a part of the political combine that created our problems, isn’t beholden to it, and, apparently, isn’t afraid of it.

I’m not sure that will be enough. There are a lot of livelihoods riding on things staying just the way they have been and lots of people who will fight to hold onto them.

1 comment

Incremental Change Has Run Out of Steam

I think that Lawrence Summers has a point—the problems that face the world can’t be solved with incremental change:

Greece’s relationship with the euro area has been a financial soap opera for months, and the drama is unlikely to end anytime soon. Concerns about German dominance of Europe are now more salient than they have been at any time in the past 70 years.

China’s stock market has been a roller-coaster in spite of — or perhaps because of — a remarkable (even for China) level of government involvement. And the ability of the Chinese government to deliver the rapid growth on which its legitimacy increasingly depends is very much open to question.

In the United States, while the fiscal picture at the federal level appears healthier than it has in a long time, thanks to a marked slowdown in health-care costs, Puerto Rico is on the brink of the largest municipal bond default in U.S. history. The debt of Chicago — America’s third largest city — has traded at spreads to U.S. treasuries of as much as 500 basis points, or 5 percentage points, even in the seventh year of an economic recovery.

The problems that are beyond the power of incremental change to ameliorate let alone solve are not limited to Greek debt, Puerto Rican debt, and the Chinese stock market. There’s a host of domestic problems that fall into the same category. I’ll just mention two.

The first is healthcare. There has been mention here lately of the “iron triangle” of healthcare: affordability, availability, and quality. The PPACA chose availability over affordability and, in all likelihood, quality. As I have been saying for well over a decade, lower costs will result in more people being able to afford healthcare coverage. Healthcare prices increasing faster than the non-healthcare economy grows will result in spiraling that, at the very least, will result in ever-increasing subsidies which in turn means that national priorities other than healthcare will suffer.

I don’t think our healthcare system can be reformed incrementally. Too many very smart people are dependent for their livelihoods on it for that to be practical.

Similarly, I don’t see any incremental solution to the problem posed by public pensions. Here in Illinois Republican Bruce Rauner wants to strip public employees’ unions of bargaining right in areas of pay, pensions, and overtime and freeze the pay of public employees for five years after which time they could choose between higher pay or their full pensions. I don’t think his plan will fly but there’s one thing you can see about it. He’s not proposing incremental change. If anybody knows of a plan of incremental change that will solve Illinois’s problems, I’m all ears.

These problems all have something in common. They have arrived after years, decades even, of kicking the can down the road. That’s what happens when you fail to address a problem or, as me auld mither used to say “grasp the nettle”. Eventually you’re left without palatable solutions and the solutions that will actually solve are pretty darned radical.

4 comments

The Problem Is Clear. It’s the Cure That’s Elusive

While I agree with Michelle Chen at The Nation that our economic problem is not that we’re not smart enough, skilled enough, and that we don’t work hard enough, I think that her preferred solutions:

The divergence between productivity and workers’ gains is why labor groups and even labor officials have pushed various policies that focus on making work pay for workers, and making the workplace fairer. These include boosting minimum wages (including recent initiatives to raise wages for workers on federal contracts), and strengthening policies to promote stable hours and more flexible leave time, along with the recently proposed expansion of overtime pay to many previously exempt salaried workers.

will hardly make a dent. She doesn’t mention it but increasing the marginal income tax rate on the highest income earners probably won’t do much, either.

Our economy is exactly what you’d expect from 30 years of allowing a constant stream of low-skill and no-skill workers into the country. People build business models around it at the expense of jobs that pay better, have more flexibility, and are more personally rewarding.

0 comments

She Knows Which Way the Wind Is Blowing

I think that Stephen Moore is probably right about this at any rate:

Let’s see: she wants more infrastructure spending, higher taxes on the foreign earnings of U.S. Corporations and hedge fund managers, a higher minimum wage, new rules to make it easier to form unions (card check), more child care subsidies, expanded paid medical leave for workers, and renewable energy subsidies.

Sound familiar? It’s more taxes, more regulatory burdens on employers, the green agenda, more government spending paid for with debt. One looks at the list of leftist wish list priorities from yesteryear and wonders: Mrs. Clinton, is this thin gruel really all you have to offer?

There aren’t even hints of her husband’s New Democrat agenda that generated growth and reform of government. The free trade, welfare reform, balanced budget, middle class tax cuts, sound money New Democrat agenda has vanished. Poof. Disappeared.

Well, yes. Sec. Clinton knows which way the winds are blowing, at least in the caucus of Democratic primary voters, and she knows what she needs to do to get the nomination. The more pertinent question is how would she govern?

I think the evidence is that once elected president she’d abandon the left-populist rhetoric and move in a much more corporatist-Wall Street direction. After all, she’ll be raising money for her re-election campaign.

So, if you think that our economic problems are that wages are too high, we just don’t have enough workers with the skills needed to do the work that America needs to do, and that there’s nothing wrong with Wall Street that nationalizing the risks and privatizing the profits won’t cure, then vote for Clinton! Because that’s what we’re probably going to get and it may make no difference who’s elected.

0 comments

Building Nationwide Networks

There are times that John Tamny is right, times when he’s wrong, and times when he’s spectacularly wrong. He’s spectacularly wrong about highways and the Internet. In his most recent column he writes:

Rather than getting into the policy weeds as it were, it seems the majority of libertarians and conservatives have given up on the idea of privatizing roads, highways and freeways. Whatever the proper response, readers can rest assured that this is not a column about privatization of transportation.

Still, and before moving on, it’s worth pointing out that governments don’t exactly build roads as much as they extract resources from the private sector in order to pay private industry to construct them. Just as the federal government was only able to create a crude and unmarketable version of the internet with resources taken from the private sector first, so did the same booming private sector similarly make it possible for governments to construct the roads on which we travel. If this is doubted, as in if some truly think governments have a magical ability with concrete, they might try getting to know Peru, Haiti and Zimbabwe by car.

I think the problem is that he’s imagining we’ve never tried to have a private transportation network but we have. It’s what we lived with for most of the country’s history so we know exactly what it would be like. Some people living in some places were able to get to some other places with reasonable comfort and ease. It was a patchwork system and some places were extremely difficult to reach by anyone. The most profitable routes were served well; less profitable ones weren’t served at all.

Similarly with the Internet. Private networks had been created regularly over a period of thirty years. As it turns out a private network that only reaches a handful of sites just isn’t that useful so none of these network every reached the sort of mass market today’s Internet does. I could elaborate on the details but you get the idea.

Markets simply don’t operate the way he imagines they do.

I think the situation is similar in healthcare. We had a purely private system for quite a long time and we know how such a system would operate very well. A handful of people in a handful of places would receive the best care that medical science could provide, some people would receive routine care. Lots of the care that people, even wealthy people, would receive was worse than no care at all and would kill them. The problems with our present system aren’t simply the government’s interference. They are that government interference has subsidized and allowed the market to self-regulate the supply end while reducing the cost of healthcare for a substantial segment of the market and letting the demand end otherwise on its own. The results are exactly what you’d expect.

8 comments

Black Lives Matter*

Meanwhile, here in Chicago, we have as many murders on the South Side many weekends as Charleston saw on that dreadful day that has caused a national uproar. The Confederate Battle Flag does not fly over City Hall. We have as stringent gun control laws as the Constitution will allow. More stringent, actually.

*Unless being taken by other black folks, in which case never mind.

2 comments

Something for Everyone

As I read the comments at this post at OTB on the revelation that the sale of the gun used to murder nine members of the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina, was only allowed by a goof on the part of the FBI, it occurred to me that the terrible occurrence really has something for everyone.

If you think the murders were the result of an environment of hate fomented by the Confederate Battle Flag, you’ll want to ban the Confederate Battle Flag. If you think that the murders were the result of guns, you’ll want more stringent laws against guns. If you think that the murders were the the actions of a crazed, drugged-out kid, you might want stricter controls on schedule drugs. If you think that the murders were a result of an FBI run amok, you might think that the FBI needs to be reined in. I’ve even seen claims that the murders would never have occurred if the victims had been armed themselves.

As I said, there’s something for everyone.

2 comments

The Strauss-Howe Generational Theory

I have just learned about something called the “Strauss-Howe Generational Theory”. It’s described here. I am mistrustful of grand, sweeping theories of this sort but it’s certainly intriguing. It’s a theory of history.

Basically, it posits a four generation cycle with the colorful names “Prophet” (idealist), “Nomad” (reactive), “Hero” (civic), and “Artist” (adaptive). Each generation experiences four different “turning” during its collective lifespand: high, awakening, unravelling, and crisis. These four turnings make up one “saeculum”. Right now we’re in a “crisis” turning.

The theory fit pretty well with American history over the period of the last several hundred years but I wonder if it’s just too Anglo-centric. Other than that I have two observations.

First, it doesn’t really fit my family’s experience over the years. Of course, my family are pretty much outcasts so we’re probably pretty atypical. Second, if the millennials are a “hero” generation, i.e. “come of age as team-oriented young optimists during a Crisis, emerge as energetic, overly-confident midlifers, and age into politically powerful elders attacked by another Awakening”, either they’re going to start changing a lot or we’re in a world of hurt.

2 comments

The Eva Tanguay of Presidents

Jonathan Bernstein, no particular foe of President Obama lays out the case for something I’ve been saying for some time—that Barack Obama doesn’t particularly care for the job of president:

President Barack Obama’s grade as top manager of the executive branch continues to sink. At this point, a C- would be generous.

Cases of mismanagement at the agency level include:

  • The Office of Personnel Management computer hack;
  • The Snowden theft from the National Security Agency;
  • The Department of Veterans Affairs scheduling fiasco;
  • The healthcare.gov rollout;
  • Unending problems at the Secret Service.

I think I disagree with him that the IRS’s acknowledged malfeasance is a “marginal case”. I think it’s a perfect exemplar of an agency running amok. And I’d add the security failure at the IRS to his list.

The key point is that none of these is just a Republican talking point. They’re all unforced errors.

It’s inevitable that any organization as large and bureaucratic as the federal government will develop a sort of resistance to efficiency or even simple competence. That doesn’t mean that presidents should be excused for the various management failures but that the job of president gets harder and harder all of the time.

1 comment