I think that Lawrence Summers has a point—the problems that face the world can’t be solved with incremental change:
Greece’s relationship with the euro area has been a financial soap opera for months, and the drama is unlikely to end anytime soon. Concerns about German dominance of Europe are now more salient than they have been at any time in the past 70 years.
China’s stock market has been a roller-coaster in spite of — or perhaps because of — a remarkable (even for China) level of government involvement. And the ability of the Chinese government to deliver the rapid growth on which its legitimacy increasingly depends is very much open to question.
In the United States, while the fiscal picture at the federal level appears healthier than it has in a long time, thanks to a marked slowdown in health-care costs, Puerto Rico is on the brink of the largest municipal bond default in U.S. history. The debt of Chicago — America’s third largest city — has traded at spreads to U.S. treasuries of as much as 500 basis points, or 5 percentage points, even in the seventh year of an economic recovery.
The problems that are beyond the power of incremental change to ameliorate let alone solve are not limited to Greek debt, Puerto Rican debt, and the Chinese stock market. There’s a host of domestic problems that fall into the same category. I’ll just mention two.
The first is healthcare. There has been mention here lately of the “iron triangle” of healthcare: affordability, availability, and quality. The PPACA chose availability over affordability and, in all likelihood, quality. As I have been saying for well over a decade, lower costs will result in more people being able to afford healthcare coverage. Healthcare prices increasing faster than the non-healthcare economy grows will result in spiraling that, at the very least, will result in ever-increasing subsidies which in turn means that national priorities other than healthcare will suffer.
I don’t think our healthcare system can be reformed incrementally. Too many very smart people are dependent for their livelihoods on it for that to be practical.
Similarly, I don’t see any incremental solution to the problem posed by public pensions. Here in Illinois Republican Bruce Rauner wants to strip public employees’ unions of bargaining right in areas of pay, pensions, and overtime and freeze the pay of public employees for five years after which time they could choose between higher pay or their full pensions. I don’t think his plan will fly but there’s one thing you can see about it. He’s not proposing incremental change. If anybody knows of a plan of incremental change that will solve Illinois’s problems, I’m all ears.
These problems all have something in common. They have arrived after years, decades even, of kicking the can down the road. That’s what happens when you fail to address a problem or, as me auld mither used to say “grasp the nettle”. Eventually you’re left without palatable solutions and the solutions that will actually solve are pretty darned radical.