We Have Met the Enemy and He Is Us

Here’s the bullet point summary of Megan McArdle’s exegesis of the housing crisis of the Aughts:

  • Sub-prime loans only account for about half of defaults.
  • Ordinary prime loans account for the other half.
  • The crisis wasn’t caused by villains breaking or bending the laws. Not evil lenders. Not evil borrowers.

It was just ordinary people on both sides of the transaction pursuing the incentives they had. Here’s the problem: the incentives haven’t changed.

20 comments

What will the Fed Do?

The Federal Reserve governors are meeting today and tomorrow. There’s quite a bit of fretting over whether they’ll decide to raise interest rates or not. The editors of The Wall Street Journal remark:

The Fed has been able to skirt the scrutiny it deserves for the slowest recovery since World War II by maintaining near-zero rates and some bond-buying. The path of least political resistance now is to stand pat. There may be dissenters on the FOMC, but this decision will belong to Chair Janet Yellen, who studied at the James Tobin school whose Keynesian disciples have been writing that the Fed should wait.

But if not now, when?

They continue by citing the work of St. Louis Fed vice president Stephen Williamson that suggests, to no one’s surprise other than perhaps the Fed governors, that quantitative easing has done nothing either to goose inflation or to encourage investment:

Mr. Williamson examines the history of monetary policy following financial crises and argues that “there is no work, to my knowledge, that establishes a link from QE [bond-buying] to the ultimate goals of the Fed—inflation and real economic activity. Indeed, casual evidence suggests that QE has been ineffective in increasing inflation.”

He’s right, which is the opposite of what some monetarists predicted (including on these pages) when the Fed accelerated its bond-buying in 2010 after the recession had ended. This has surprised the Fed too. As former Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke explained the theory, buying bonds with long maturities would reduce interest rates, which would lift asset prices and ultimately economic growth and inflation. It hasn’t worked out that way, and FOMC members have consistently underestimated growth and inflation since the recovery began.

Mr. Williamson points out that “the Fed has undershot its inflation target of 2% since early 2012,” and that is the norm for central banks across the world. “Indeed, mainstream monetary theory and the experience of Japan for the last 20 years tells us that extended periods of ZIRP [zero-interest-rate policy] lead to low inflation, or even deflation.”

He says this can leave bankers “trapped in ZIRP” because “inflation is low, and the central banker reasons that maintaining ZIRP will eventually increase the inflation rate. But this never happens and, as long as the central banker adheres to a sufficiently aggressive Taylor rule [a monetary price rule], ZIRP will continue forever, and the central bank will fall short of its inflation target indefinitely. This idea seems to fit nicely with the recent observed behavior of the world’s central banks.”

Meanwhile Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul and economist Mark Spitznagel make a somewhat stronger argument:

The “doves” are right to point out that higher interest rates will lead to a repricing of many securities, aka a crash. But years of near-zero interest rates have made this inevitable. Continuing on the current course will only allow structural distortions caused by these interest rates to fester and an inevitable reckoning that will be much worse than seven years ago.

The master fallacy underlying so much economic commentary is to imagine that a handful of experts in Washington should be setting the price of borrowing money. Instead, the Fed should set markets free.

but it’s not one that I think that very many people would find appealing. It’s the problem that all minarchists and anarch-capitalists face. It might well be true that markets would do a better job (if, indeed, there are markets or markets could be created to “set free”, far from a done deal). But that’s not the situation we have now and the period of adjustment would be truly miserable. Millions would lose their jobs. That’s millions of voters.

It also fails to take globalization into account. Basically, we’ve been exporting inflation for the last 9 years.

That’s why I think the best course available right now is for the Fed to keep interest rates where they are, to end quantitative easing and keep it ended, and for the Congress to get off their collective spreading derriere and start taking the steps to mitigate the risks posed by long-term very low interest rates.

They might think about making the structural changes we need to get the economy back on track but that’s pie in the sky stuff. There’s already enough fantasy in this post as it is.

3 comments

How Do You Say “Underpants Gnome” in German?

Step 1: Issue open invitation to Syrian, Iraqi, Afghan, etc. migrants.
Step 2: ?
Step 3: Profit!

closely followed by (continuing with my comics/cartoon references) a Charlie Brown football move:

Step 4: Close the border.

Can anyone guess what Step 5 will be? The editors of the Wall Street Journal provide some helpful analysis:

It worked—too well. Berlin’s perceived openness is encouraging many others still in the Middle East to risk dangerous sea and land journeys to Europe. The German public’s initial wave of humanitarian enthusiasm has given way to the realization that they can’t cope indefinitely with an almost unlimited number of desperate migrants from the Middle East and Africa.

I think it’s actually worse than that. The Germans’ “perceived openness” has put who knows how many unfortunates into a pipeline of migrants. Many of the people stalled at the border probably set out for Germany a week or ten days ago—long before the Germans had second thoughts.

It’s yet another example of the Germans making what is already a bad situation worse with their machinations. Mass migration doesn’t just stop on a dime.

17 comments

What Inflation?

Over at Bloomberg Mark Waterhouse wonders, as I have, where the inflation that the Federal Reserve governors see might be hiding:

When Federal Reserve officials meet this week to discuss how much more stimulus the U.S. economy needs, they will have to parse various arguments about the threat of inflation. Those who want the Fed to raise interest rates, for example, sometimes assert that whatever the headline numbers show, price increases are already hitting some people hard.

The data don’t present much reason for concern.

The balance of the post concentrates on where prices have, indeed, risen and it’s the usual suspects: healthcare and education. His bottom line is that inflation isn’t biting much if at all.

There’s one group that inflation is in fact hitting: the rich. For example, the Forbes Index for Living Extremely Well increased more than 5% last year. The cost of investment, something that isn’t included in the CPI, has gone up as well. Meanwhile, the incomes of the rich went up by double digits.

If the Fed decides to raise interest rates, my tentative conclusion is that the Fed governors are hanging out with wrong people and that their wages are too high. I’d suggest a 50% cut as a start. And put serious controls over lunches, dinners, travel, and other gratuities they’re able to accept.

1 comment

Using the Back of a German Envelope

I think that the reason the Germans just closed the border is that somebody sat down with a pencil and an envelope and started writing down numbers. They estimate that they spend 12,500 euro per “refugee”. In round numbers then a million “refugees” will cost the German government $15 billion. That’s about ten times what they spent in 2013.

And then there’s the moral hazard. In 2013 they had 100,000 “refugees”. Let’s say they’ll have a million in 2015. Will they have ten million next year?

8 comments

Educational Indebtedness

For your grim reading of the day, you might take a look at this analysis in Inside Higher Ed of the Obama Administration’s recent release of the higher education data they’d assembled for their now-defunct college rating site. The bottom line is that more young people are in more debt than ever before without a great deal to show for it.

In some circles this is referred to as “being less materialistic”. In others it’s being a debt slave.

5 comments

House, Senate, and State House Elections, 2016

I want to commend an article at Politico from Larry Sabato on winning “down-ballot” elections in 2016. As I’ve said before, I think the 2016 election will be a turnout election. I’ll also predict that if Democratic primary votes are low, it will hurt the party’s chances of making up lost ground regardless of the outcome of the election in November.

0 comments

Deadweight Loss and the Decline of Nations

Writing in the Washington Post, Robert Samuelson makes a good point—one of the explanations for the slow rate of productivity growth in the U. S. is deadweight loss:

The causes of the productivity collapse are unclear. Some economists say that productivity isn’t measured properly — Internet benefits are allegedly undercounted. Other economists contend that U.S. technology and innovation are lagging. Still others argue that weak business investment after the Great Recession explains lackluster growth.

To this list should be added another plausible candidate: the dead weight losses created by special interest groups, as explained by the late Mancur Olson (1932-1998).

and he goes on to explain. Read the whole thing. What he doesn’t do is name names but I will. The sectors that are the largest recipients of subsidies and responsible for the largest amount of deadweight loss are:

  • Finance (particularly the banks)
  • the military sector
  • education
  • healthcare

He does make one error. Business investment didn’t slow following the recession—it had started slowing long before, at least by 2000.

As was pointed out thirty years ago however measured (other than in wages which is measuring inputs rather than outputs) outputs per input have been falling in all of those sectors for decades.

If we’re going to counter our present slump by reducing deadweight loss, we’re going to need to make some hard choices. Making hard choices is not something we’ve been good at.

5 comments

Borders

Hungary is redoubling its efforts to close its border with Serbia:

After weeks of chaos, Mr. Orban has warned in recent days that “the tolerance period is over” for migrants, most of whom are fleeing the war-torn Middle East and Afghanistan.

He announced the deployment of troops along Hungary’s southern border to enforce a battery of new measures, including prison sentences of up to three years for illegal border entry beginning Sept. 15. Mr. Orban also ousted his defense minister for taking too long to finish the fence, which will run alongside a smaller, existing barrier.

and Germany has announced it’s closing its borders, too:

BERLIN — Facing an unstaunchable flood of migrants and refugees, Germany on Sunday said it was reaching a breaking point and would implement emergency controls on its border with Austria, temporarily suspending train service along the main pipeline for thousands seeking sanctuary in western Europe.

The English are still refusing to accept the streams of migrants trying to enter Britain through Calais.

See also this story from the New York Times from two weeks ago: “Migrant Crisis Tests Core European Value: Open Borders”. Clearly there are values and then there are values.

7 comments

Not So Smart

While I’m sympathetic with Carl Cannon’s complaints about Donald Trump, this portion of his op-ed got my Irish up:

It’s not that John Kerry (Yale class of ’66, U.S. Navy Officer Candidate School, Boston College Law School,’76) or Barack Obama (Columbia ’83 and Harvard Law ’91) are immune from questions about their acumen.

He’s not pointing to anything that proves that either John Kerry or Barack Obama are particularly smart. Or dumb for that matter. He’s just repeating their resumes and assuming you can deduce something from those makes a long laundry list of assumptions. Let’s focus on John Kerry.

John Kerry’s SAT scores have been published. He got a combined score of 1190, slightly lower than George W. Bush. Let’s compare that with some really smart people. Bill Gates and Ben Bernanke both got a 1590 on their SATs and Steve Balmer got a 1600, a perfect score. That put him in the bottom 25% of Yale admissions at the time he was admitted. Obviously, both he and Bush were legacies.

“Legacy” is a term I’ve used before but perhaps I should explain it. In old college parlance a “legacy” was someone who was admitted to a particular college due to connections rather than accomplishments. Kerry’s dad was a Yale grad. His mom was a member of a prominent (and wealthy) family. I haven’t been able to uncover where his maternal grandfather attended college (I suspect Harvard) but his maternal grandmother’s male ancestors were Harvard grads going back three centuries.

His SAT scores were average for all college applicants in the year he took them. By all accounts (and his college transcripts) he was no intellectual, more interested in skiing than scholarship. Those SAT scores suggest that his IQ was just about average for Navy OCS at the time.

Boston College Law School is not a top 20 law school and his transcripts tell us he didn’t get top scores while he was there. The bottom line here is that John Kerry is far more likely to be of average intelligence or at best average intelligence for a member of the professional class than he is to be particularly smart.

After law school his jobs were strictly political jobs. I don’t think that points to any great intelligence, either, but YMMV.

Why is it that so many people long for their politicians to be smart? If they do they’re bound for disappointment.

7 comments