What Sectors Have the Highest Earners?

As I made my rounds this morning I didn’t find a lot of blog-worthy material. You can’t make bricks without straw, you know. What I found was the regular bickering and sniping which I generally find pretty boring.

I did stumble across this study which I believe is from the Minneapolis Federal Reserve. Here’s the part I found interesting:

Third, regarding the characteristics of top earners, we find that the dominance of the finance and insurance industry is staggering, for both males and females: in 2012, finance and insurance accounted for around one-third of workers in the top 0.1 percent. However, this was not the case 30 years ago, when the health care industry accounted for the largest share of the top 0.1 percent. Since then, top earning health care workers have dropped to the second 0.9 percent where, along with workers in finance and insurance, they have replaced workers in manufacturing, whose share of this group has dropped by roughly half.

Finance, insurance, and healthcare are all highly regulated. If there’s a correlation between the degree of regulation of a sector of the economy and share of top .1% of income earners, it’s a positive one. In other words, if you’re concerned about income inequality, don’t expect the problem to get better by regulating the sectors of the economy with the most high earners more tightly.

10 comments

I Agree With Scott Sumner Here

I want to endorse several ideas put forward by Scott Sumner. First, that the Federal Reserve should be relieved of its regulation function and those should be given to some other (preferably purely governmental) agency.

Second, that among these actions:

In May 1984 the government bailed out all depositors at Continental Illinois, which at the time was the largest bank failure in US history. At smaller banks, depositors were only protected up to $100,000.

In 1994, Mexico’s creditors were saved by a large US loan to Mexico during the peso crisis.

In 1998, a rescue of LTCM by big banks was organized by the Fed.

In March 2008, Bear Stearns’ creditors were rescued.

the Fed should not have bailed out Continental Illinois, LTCM, or Bear Stearns.

For those of you who disagree with those assessments while believing that income inequality presents a serious problem for the United States, I’d like to ask you a question. If you always bail out large financial concerns, regardless of the legalities, what to do expect? Under those circumstances increasing financialization of the economy and greater income inequality are inevitable. Companies must be allowed to fail. Creditors must be allowed to lose money.

7 comments

Can the PPACA Be Reformed?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal, never great fans of the PPACA, take note of two metrics by which the healthcare reform law is not doing particularly well: new enrollments and loss ratio. New enrollments appear to be falling behind both HHS’s and CBO’s projections:

This month the Health and Human Services Department dramatically discounted its internal estimate of how many people will join the state insurance exchanges in 2016. There are about 9.1 million enrollees today, and the consensus estimate—by the Congressional Budget Office, the Medicare actuary and independent analysts like Rand Corp.—was that participation would surge to some 20 million. But HHS now expects enrollment to grow to between merely 9.4 million and 11.4 million.

Recruitment for 2015 is roughly 70% of the original projection, but ObamaCare will be running at less than half its goal in 2016. HHS believes some 19 million Americans earn too much for Medicaid but qualify for ObamaCare subsidies and haven’t signed up. Some 8.5 million of that 19 million purchase off-exchange private coverage with their own money, while the other 10.5 million are still uninsured. In other words, for every person who’s allowed to join and has, two people haven’t.

The PPACA limits the “loss ratio”, the proportion of premiums paid out for care, to a floor of not less than 85%. That does not appear to be something its authors need have worried about:

MLRs measure the share of premium revenue that flows to reimbursing medical claims. ObamaCare sets an MLR floor of 80% for patient care, with one-fifth left over for overhead like administration and profits, and the pre-ObamaCare 2010-13 historical trend for the individual market ranged from 79% to 86%.

The researchers found that in 2014—the first full year of claims experience in ObamaCare—average MLRs across all health plans sold on 16 state exchanges roamed from 90% to 99%. Average MLRs in 11 states climbed to 100% or more, reaching as high as 121% in Massachusetts. A business can’t stay solvent for long spending $1.21 for every $1 that comes in.

The 2014 MLRs are used to set rates for 2016 premiums, which are still under regulatory review. But the researchers estimate that to rebound to an MLR of 85%, premiums in the 11 money-losing states need to rise by 10% to 36% in the best estimate and 23% to 52% in the worst scenario. The familiar danger is that as rates rise, more people drop out, and thus rates must rise still higher, as the states that attempted ObamaCare-like regulatory schemes in the 1980s and 1990s discovered.

They propose that the law be amended to deal with the problems:

ObamaCare will almost inevitably be reopened in 2017, whoever wins the election. The good news is the emerging consensus among Republican candidates about a credible, pragmatic and optimistic alternative. Jeb Bush was the latest to release a plan two weeks ago—and this is a debate that has always deserved to be litigated at the presidential level to create a mandate for reform.

The basic approach is to deregulate insurance and medical practice while replacing ObamaCare’s complex subsidy schedule with a refundable tax credit for individuals who lack job-based coverage. Unchained from benefit and redistribution mandates, insurance products and prices would come to reflect what consumers want. The credit would be sufficient to buy at least coverage for catastrophic expenses if people get sick, and the trade-offs of such skinnier plans might look better to voters priced out of ObamaCare.

I think that’s going to prove more easily said than done. As I pointed out with boring repetitiveness back in 2009, it’s the first piece of major social legislation passed on a straight party line basis (insert boilerplate about the recalcitrance of Republicans here). Said another way it’s been a political football since before it was enacted into law. The acrimony of the debate has only risen over time.

I predict that Democrats will resist any Republican attempt at reforming the law and Republicans will similarly resist Democratic attempts at reforming it. The words “gutting”, “stonewalling”, and “hate poor people” come to mind.

In an earlier comment I mentioned the many weak assumptions made in the framing of the PPACA. One of the weakest was that incremental reform of the law was a viable plan.

6 comments

How Many Contractors Are There in Afghanistan?

If this article in Foreign Policy is to be credited, there are nearly 40,000 civilian military contractors still in Afghanistan, mostly not American citizens. Unlike most Americans I have serious objections to the use of civilian military contractors on all sorts of grounds. I have even more serious objections to their employment being ignored.

Did you know that there is no reliable reckoning of how many civilian military contractors we employ?

7 comments

Maureen O’Hara, 1920-2015

I was a bit taken aback by the opening of The Telegraph’s obituary of Maureen O’Hara:

Maureen O’Hara, who has died aged 95, appeared in more bad films than she cared to remember but nevertheless emerged as a Hollywood star on the strength of her extraordinary flame-haired beauty and a successful screen partnership with John Wayne.

It’s a backhanded slap or, at best, damning with faint praise. I’m curious. What “bad films” do they have in mind? I’ll name one: Jamaica Inn. It was directed by Alfred Hitchcock, starred Charles Laughton, one of the finest movie actors of the day, and was based on a novel by one of the best-selling authors of the day, Daphne Du Maurier. It was her first starring role and they blame the weakness of the picture on her? Why not the director or the star or the story?

Let’s list some of the outstanding pictures she starred in (in chronological order):

The Hunchback of Notre Dame
How Green Was My Valley
The Black Swan
This Land Is Mine
The Spanish Main
Rio Grande
The Quiet Man
Our Man in Havana
The Parent Trap
Mr. Hobbs Takes a Vacation
Spencer’s Mountain
McClintock!
Big Jake

Any one of those pictures would have cemented her place in screen history. Did they not like them because they were entertaining? Sure, she made a few pictures that were below that standard. Everyone did under the studio system. That was the way it worked. For goodness sake, Bette Davis and Joan Crawford made many more worse pictures. Margot Grahame, Deborah Kerr, and Greer Garson all made worse pictures. I think you can put Maureen O’Hara’s record against any of her contemporaries.

I’m not a particular fan of Maureen O’Hara’s but fair is fair.

5 comments

Kevin Drum Is Wrong

It’s simply not true that President Obama wants to to give people cheap healthcare. He wants to subsidize their consumption of expensive healthcare. A better sales pitch might not be on how free it is but how expensive it would be without the subsidies. It might be true that people like free stuff but it’s also true that American consumers are pretty sophisticated and just might think that you get what you pay for.

One of the underlying points that needs to be emphasized: enrollment for insurance programs hasn’t been as slow as it has and awareness as weak as it is because of a lack of trying. Quite literally billions of dollars have been spent on outreach over the last couple of years. It’s just barely possible that those billions have been squandered.

My own view is that those doing the outreach were naive amateurs who didn’t really understand how to reach people. Or the nature of a marketing universe and that there are some people who just can’t be reached.

5 comments

Surprise: Members of the Political Parties Have Different Ideas About Foreign Policy

There’s an interesting article on the results of a survey on foreign affairs commissioned by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs. The results aren’t particularly surprising. Americans, regardless of party affiliation, tend to be interventionist in their views. Americans are concerned about the rise of Islamist fundamentalism, increasingly so. Republicans are more hawkish than Democrats. Democrats are pro-amnesty for illegal immigrants; Republicans favor expulsion but not as greatly as you might think. A majority of Democrats believe that climate change is a serious, immediate problem. A majority of Republicans do, too, although more Republicans think a measured solution is adequate than believe that immediate, strenuous action is called for.

Americans regardless of party overwhelmingly believe in maintaining U. S. military dominance, international treaties, strengthening the United Nations, and “free trade” agreements.

Would you have believed that 53% of Republicans and 44% of Democrats (44% of Americans overall) support sending troops into Iran if Iran violates the deal that the Obama Administration has negotiated? I find it distressing that so many Americans believe in preventive war (it’s self defense if you go to war because another country attacks you; it’s “preemptive war” if you go to war because another country is about to attack you; it’s “preventive war” if you go to war because another country could go to war against you).

I recommend you dig into the more detailed report on results. It’s actually more revealing than the executive summary. For example, see this graphic illustrating how Americans “prefer the United States fight terrorism”:

How American Prefer to Fight Terrorism

Pretty bellicose, no?

The real surprises in these results might be how much consensus there is among Americans on issues that haven’t been as highly publicized and how the leaders of the political parties struggle to reconcile their own actions with what their voters believe about foreign policy.

19 comments

Chicago, Neighborhood by Neighborhood: Mayfair

A house in Mayfair

Let’s take a little stroll down a street in Mayfair, a Chicago neighborhood just south of Forest Glen, the last Chicago neighborhood I wrote about.

More houses in Mayfair

Bungalows like this are pretty typical for Mayfair although not far from this street I saw a whole row of Luxembourg farmhouses. Continuing down the street you reach the North Branch of the Chicago River.

The North Branch of the Chicago River in Mayfair

There’s an oddly riparian lifestyle here. Not at all something you’d expect in the heart of Chicago. I’ve actually seen houses in this neighborhood with docks and boats tied up at them. Lots of wildlife. Ducks, as you can see if you click on the image above for a larger version, but also geese stopping on their migration from Canada, otters, raccoons, deer, and coyotes. Rats, too, I suppose. And damp basements. I wouldn’t eat a fish caught out of the Chicago River if you paid me but I’ll bet there are people who do.

Glancing upstream the North Branch of the Chicago River in Mayfair

Here’s a glance upstream. Mayfair is quite diverse. Within three blocks of this street are a Catholic church, a Romanian Evangelical church, a Buddhist temple, and a mosque.

Mayfair is a small neighborhood in the community area of Albany Park, on the northwest side of Chicago about 8 miles north of the Loop. It got its start after the Civil War and was annexed to Chicago in 1889. It wasn’t until the turn of the century that Albany Park became urbanized—prior to that it was farmland.

For the last century Albany Park has been home to many immigrant families, Germans and Swedes initially, then Jews from Eastern Europe. Nowadays Albany Park is very heavily Korean although it has substantial Hispanic and West Asian populations as well.

2 comments

The Doormat of the National League

I don’t want to let the Cubs loss to the Mets go unremarked upon. The Mets didn’t just defeat the Cubs they clobbered them, winning four games in a row in their best of seven series. The Cubs’ problem was very clearly pitching—their bench just wasn’t as deep as the Mets’.

For those of you who aren’t Chicagoans, the Cubs haven’t won the World Series in living memory—109 years. The oldest living identified Cubs fan, a 101 year old woman, has never seen the Cubs win the World Series and once again loyal Chicago fans have been disappointed.

I can’t remember who said it but being a Cubs fan continues to be the purest form of fandom in sports, untainted by hope of victory.

Wait ’til next year. Or the year after that or the year after that…

With a hat tip to the late, great, much lamented Stevie Goodman:

7 comments

Tell Me Something I Don’t Know

The appearance of Sec. Clinton before the House’s committee on the attack on the U. S. embassy in Benghazi, Libya confirmed several things:

  • Sec. Clinton is a highly experienced political operative. For the most part she was poised and controlled in her responses, most of which had clearly been prepared and rehearsed.
  • Sec. Clinton is a liar. She has lied about public business for decades; if elected president she’ll continue to lie. This has already been discounted both by her supporters and her detractors.
  • Politicians do things for political reasons. Both the Republicans on the committee and the Democrats on the committee have political motivations. I’d rate the Republicans slightly worse: the Democrats on the committee are only defending Sec. Clinton because the Republicans are attacking her. But only slightly.

IMO it’s time to move on from this whole sorry incident. There’s nothing to be gained from perseveration on it.

10 comments