The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

They Won’t Be Young Forever

I want to excerpt a single quote from this post at Zerohedge:

Right now, young people cannot save enough on their own because they face stagnant incomes and heavy student-debt burdens.

to which I would add that the very low interest rates today probably aren’t helping, either. Zerohedge is quoting Blackstone President and COO Tony James from a CNBC interview.

Does any of that sound familiar? It’s what I said some years back about why we need a federal system of social insurance. And I think we also should remember that our economic growth is based mostly on personal consumption spending which would decline if young people were actually saving.

Unfortunately, too much of what as country we’re consuming are education and healthcare services, both of which have experienced declining productivity per dollar input for decades.

The young won’t be young forever and unless something changes they’ll be in even worse shape than we are when they inevitably become as old as I am. I do not envy them.

6 comments

Speaking of Denmark

As it works out the Danes are becoming more like us:

Income inequality is on the rise. The rich control more of the country’s wealth. Union membership is falling. The ranks of the poor are growing.

Sounds like the United States? Actually, it’s Denmark.

Read the whole thing.

4 comments

There Is No Easy Way

There is a lengthy, dense, and, honestly rather opaque piece at RealClearMarkets that goes a long way towards explaining the economic fix we’re in, at least from a macroeconomic standpoint. Here’s a sample:

This week it was revealed what I had long suspected, namely that the Chinese central bank had been forced into a form of deception that reveals the folly of “devaluation” rhetoric. Local Chinese banks had been “selling” spot “dollars” in August at the behest of the PBOC who were issuing forwards for the back end of that “trade.” This is almost classic response to a wholesale “dollar” run, as has been practiced time and again, most recently in Brazil.

The idea is simple enough even if it follows along far more complex tactical deployment. In general terms, private “dollar” markets were disrupted (the run) which then led the PBOC to three unappealing options of varying danger. First, the central bank could actively supply “dollars” itself in various forms, which is what the PBOC had clearly been doing for some time before the break (essentially pegging the CNY/USD to no variability for five months). Second, they could do nothing and allow rollover defaults in the local and offshore eurodollar markets. Or they could widen the trading band of renminbi/dollar exchange in order for the private, onshore “dollar” market in China to bid for liquidity at whatever cost. They chose the last option after being exhausted and beaten by the first, which proves the seriousness of the malady itself.

His prediction is actually rather bleak:

Japan is working on its third straight “lost decade” with the US and Europe closing in on completion of each their first. That is an enormous amount of unnecessary waste, especially when properly viewed under terms of compounding. Wholesale money may have been, and may remain, dauntingly complex and often counterintuitive but not so much as to have been impossibly excluded and ignored. The financial epidemic is of the wholesale strain. Health and recovery lie there, and no QE or interest rate control can reach it now as the clock continues to tick.

or, said another way, there’s a good chance that global economic doldrums will persist for the rest of my life. I agree with much of what he writes and his analysis will come as no surprise to some of the readers here.

I don’t think that macroeconomics explains all of our problems, however. While I agree that central banks’ policies have weakened our economy, they’re not alone. I think that microeconomics needs to be taken into account as well. We just import too much of what we consume to have a really robust economy and central banks’ policies are not only aggravating that but making it necessary. The policy solution is to do whatever is necessary to change that and, given those central banks’ policies, that may be pretty severe. It’s no wonder that the Powers-That-Be are resisting change with all their might. They like things as they’ve been.

One final word on China. As I’ve predicted all along, China has followed Russia’s lead. The economy of Stalin’s Russia was the envy of the world in the 1930s but it was a house built on sand. It prospered by moving relatively unproductive labor resources from agriculture to manufacturing, just as China has done. The difference between Stalin’s Russia and China of 1979-2005 is that China managed to accomplish that while increasing agricultural productivity. China’s agricultural productivity stopped increasing about a decade ago, a sure sign that they were nearing the end of the road for that particular strategy. And here we are.

The question that should keep the heads of Western governments and companies up at night is just what will China do now? The Chinese people might just put up with rising unemployment and slower improvements in their standards of living. Or they might push back. In twenty years China might be much as it is now or it might be a cluster of warring provinces. The only things we can do here are watch and try to mitigate our risks.

2 comments

Comparing Us to the Wrong Countries

Whether you’re talking about income, hours worked, crime, child welfare, happiness, or security, I think you err if, as Robert Samuelson does limit your comparison of the United States to relatively small, prosperous, homogeneous European countries:

Americans have long been fascinated with global rankings. Where do we stand? How do we compare with other nations? We like to imagine ourselves as No. 1: the national equivalent of the racing halfback who raises his forefinger as he crosses the goal line. Common sense says otherwise. We excel in some things and not in others. The latest evidence of this comes from a massive report that collected indicators on a wide range of well-being — from incomes to leisure time — for most advanced countries.

On some indicators, the United States does rank No. 1. Average after-tax household income (including both cash and non-cash government transfers) totals about $40,000; Norway is next highest at nearly $35,000. Among 29 countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the average is $27,630. But the United States is also near the top in income inequality; this means that middle-class Americans don’t do quite as well as the average suggests.

It’s like trying to get some understanding of Michigan’s problems by comparing Detroit and Mackinac Island.

To arrive at some reasonable understanding of the United States, it’s better to think of us as two countries occupying the same territory—one large country that’s fairly prosperous and mostly of European descent and another much poorer country that mostly isn’t. I wish that weren’t the case but, sadly, it’s the reality. Think Mexico not Finland.

7 comments

No. Next Question?

The editors of the Washington Post wonder whether China is serious about ending its cyber-attacks against U. S. businesses and governments:

PRESIDENT XI Jinping of China has been assertive since coming to power in 2013. Although China is governed in opaque ways, and he faces entrenched and competing interests, Mr. Xi has attempted to appear as a leader who is decisive and setting China’s direction. It is fair to assume that when Mr. Xi wants to get something done in the realm of the Chinese state and party, he can get results.

Mr. Xi promised in his Sept. 25 news conference with President Obama at the White House not to wage cyberwar on the United States for valuable commercial secrets and intellectual property. He declared : “Cybertheft of commercial secrets and hacking attacks against government networks are both illegal; such acts are criminal offenses and should be punished.”

Mr. Obama quite rightly asked whether words would be followed by actions. So far, it appears not.

The answer, very obviously, is that the Chinese cannot be trusted as long as they gain a competitive advantage for their actions and pay no price for their actions. As I’ve suggested before I think we should shut China’s Internet connections down for a day (it’s well within our power) to give them the general idea.

If that’s too crude and direct for you we might try issuing letters of marque and offering bounties for shutting down Chinese networks. There’s nothing like a financial incentive to gain Americans’ interest.

3 comments

Decision 2016

I wonder if, somewhere in the vast pile of opinionating about Joe Biden’s decision not to seek his party’s nomination for the presidency, it’s been suggested that a major step has been taken in deciding who will be elected president? Maybe the decisive step. It’s all but a foregone conclusion that Hillary Clinton will be the Democratic nominee and, for good or ill, nearly ever voter in the United States has already made up his or her mind about Sec. Clinton.

IMO if the Republicans can harness their worst impulses just long enough to nominate an electable candidate, whoever that candidate is will take the White House. The torrent of negative advertising we’re bound to be deluged with this cycle will do what it always does: depress turnout. And depressing turnout will not work to Sec. Clinton’s advantage.

17 comments

So Much for Détente

This probably should have been included in my If only… post. I honestly don’t see how anyone could have taken the Obama Administration’s claims about the nuclear weapons agreement with Iran being the beginning of some sort of détente seriously. The Iranians got what they wanted out of the agreement and that’s that. As I’ve said all along, they’re shrewd bargainers.

The editors of the Washington Post apparently did:

AS THEY concluded the nuclear deal with Iran in July, President Obama and Secretary of State John F. Kerry repeatedly suggested that it could open the way to cooperation with Tehran in resolving regional conflicts, beginning with the civil war in Syria. They also promised the United States would push back if Iran instead stepped up its aggression. Just three months later, Iran’s most notorious general is overseeing a new offensive by thousands of Iranian, Iraqi and Lebanese fighters aimed at recapturing the Syrian city of Aleppo from rebel forces, including some backed by the United States. Mr. Obama shows no sign of responding.

going on to catalogue what’s happened since the agreement was signed:

The attack is one of several provocative steps Tehran has taken as the nuclear deal has begun to come into effect. The same day the accord was debated by its parliament this month, the regime test-fired a nuclear-capable missile, violating a U.N. Security Council resolution. The White House acknowledged the infraction but pointed out that it was outside the bounds of the nuclear agreement.

Also that day, Iranian television reported that The Post’s Jason Rezaian had been convicted on espionage charges after a closed trial. The administration condemned the verdict.

They shouldn’t anticipate any “response” by the Administration. President Obama got what he wanted out of the agreement, too. His poll numbers are up. Surely we can all take satisfaction from that.

12 comments

How to Go About Gun Confiscation

There has been some kerfuffle in the Right Blogosphere about Sec. Clinton’s remarks to the effect that she’d consider an Australian-style gun confiscation program here in the United States. If I were they, I wouldn’t be overly concerned. Sec. Clinton will say anything she thinks might help her get elected. Otherwise you can’t believe anything she says. If elected she’ll be devoting her full attention to re-election and firearms confiscation will probably be very far down on her list. If you want to read a different explication of her views try James Taranto’s column.

The subject of this post is somewhat different. Assume arguendo that the next president is serious about a gun confiscation program. How would he or she go about it in a way that might actually meet constitutional muster? I think that the first step would be making the acceptance of searches of their homes, storage facilities, etc. for personal firearms and confiscation thereof (with suitable compensation, of course) a condition of employment for federal, state, and local government workers. The courts have upheld the abridgement of certain First Amendment rights for government workers. Why not Second Amendment rights?

I don’t think that I know a police officer or firefighter who doesn’t own a personal handgun.

Then retain police officers’ service sidearms at the stations, to be issued at the start of shift and restocked at the end of shift.

If the program succeed, reducing the number of gun homicides, it will move the Overton Window, producing more public acceptance for wider gun confiscation.

How that’s for a modest proposal?

8 comments

If Only…

Lately I’ve been seeing a lot of things in the op-ed pages and in our political discourse that can be summed up in just two words.

If only…

…we were a country of fewer than 10 million people, 90% of whom were ethnic Danes and Lutherans. Whether he realizes it or not that’s the underlying message of Paul Krugman’s recent New York Times column. Small nation-states in which the overwhelming preponderance of the people share a common ethnic, religious, and historic heritage have levels of social cohesion, preference, and agreement that make all sort of things possible that just aren’t acceptable and plain won’t work in large, diverse countries. How do I know that social cohesion makes a difference? Most of the welfare fraud in Denmark as well as an enormous proportion of the violent crime are being perpetrated by Denmark’s recent immigrants and their children who just don’t feel the attachment and sense of common purpose the Danes feel with each other.

If only…

…we could increase the effective tax rate solely on the rich high enough that we could afford a lavish welfare state even with all of the waste, fraud, and abuse that’s typical in America and so much rarer in Europe. We can’t. We don’t know how to do it. Bernie Sanders has based most of his campaign on that premise. Unfortunately, “the rich” (defined as the highest 1% of income earners) don’t have enough money even if taxed at 100% to satisfy the promises he’s been making. You’d need to start taxing the top 10% of income earners, possibly the top 20%. Details are in pretty short supply.

If only…

…there were “moderate rebels” in Syria we could support. If only there were a political solution there. If only there were a choice other than between Assad and DAESH.

If only…

…the policies that Democrats are running on at the national level would get them elected at state level.

If only…

…Republican misbehavior excused Democratic misbehavior.

If only…

…Illinois politicians were more concerned about prudent stewardship of the people’s money than they were in looking out for #1.

The list is practically endless.

19 comments