Reducing Income Inequality By Taxing the Rich

I agree Henry Aaron. We can reduce income inequality by taxing the rich and transferring the proceeds to the poor. Or, as he puts it:

Tax policy significantly reduces inequality. But transfer payments and other spending reduce it far more. In combination, taxes and public spending materially offset the inequality generated by market income.

However, as the late great Yogi Berra said it so memorably, in theory there’s no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is.

The question is not whether income inequality can theoretically be reduced by taxation. The question is whether the taxation that is likely to be enacted and the ways in which the proceeds are spent will have that effect and to do that both political parties would need to abandon the policies that have guided them for the last 30 years.

Republicans would have to stop opposing every tax increase and Democrats would have to stop spending money on services provided to the poor and actually give the proceeds to the poor. Neither will happen so we can’t reduce income inequality by taxing the rich.

5 comments

When the Journalists Are the News

I didn’t watch the Republican debate last night. I’m not particularly interested in candidates I’ll never have the opportunity to vote for (even if I wanted to) and I have little use for the joint press conference format of the “debates”. My observations are based on the accounts I’ve read.

There’s something that the entertainment industry can’t quite come to terms with and, let’s face it, whether in Hollywood, New York, or Washington, DC, cable newsreaders are in the entertainment industry. Although people take some interest in entertainers in somewhat the same way that they watch building on fire, they’re not really that interested in them. Ordinary people don’t have the all-absorbing interest in entertainers that entertainers have in themselves.

Journalists should report the news not be the news. When journalists are the news, there’s a serious problem. Jeff Jacoby’s remarks are just about right:

One of the CNBC moderators, Carl Quintanilla, asked Senator Ted Cruz whether his opposition to the just-announced congressional deal raising the federal debt limit demonstrates that he’s “not the kind of problem-solver American voters want.”

Cruz’s response was to turn the tables on the moderators, blasting them for the hostility toward the candidates that oozed from virtually every question they had asked so far.

Then, with devastating accuracy, he recited back the offensive questions:

“Donald Trump, are you a comic-book villain? Ben Carson, can you do math? John Kasich, will you insult two people over here? Marco Rubio, why don’t you resign? Jeb Bush, why have your numbers fallen?”

By this point, the audience was going wild with cheers.

But Cruz wasn’t finished. He contrasted the animus of the media panel toward the GOP field with the recent Democratic debate, “where every fawning question was: Which of you is more handsome, and why?” And then he underlined the message: “Nobody watching at home believes that any of the moderators has any intention of voting in a Republican primary.”

It was brutal takedown, and CNBC’s smarmy moderators had it coming.

Now I recognize that Ted Cruz is quick on his feet but I’d bet a shiny new dime that he had pre-prepared that diatribe. He was just waiting for CNBC’s immoderate moderators to fall into the trap.

I have no interest in Ted Cruz. I think he’s a demagogue. But CNBC can help him become a star if they want to. Just keep being the news.

4 comments

The Real China News

While most commenters remarked on China’s transmogrifying its One-Child Policy to a Two-Child Policy, I think that they may have missed the real China news. China is reducing its growth target to 6.5%:

Premier Li Keqiang highlighted a minimum growth estimate for China in the coming five years that could indicate the leadership’s readiness to accept the weakest period of expansion since the economy was opened up three decades ago.

The nation needs annual growth of at least 6.53 per cent in the next five years to meet the government’s goal of establishing a “moderately prosperous society”, Li said in an October 23 speech to Communist Party members, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be named as the remarks were not public.

Communist Party leaders today conclude a four-day gathering to discuss their 2016-20 five-year plan for the nation, the first since President Xi Jinping and Premier Li took office.

“It seems that Premier Li is sending a signal through his speech that China’s government is likely to lower their growth target to 6.5 per cent in the 13th five-year plan,” said Le Xia, a Hong Kong-based economist at Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria. “The 6.5 per cent target is still a little challenging. A target of 5 to 6 per cent seems a more feasible one.”

Private economists have predicted a lowering in the five-year growth target to 6.5 per cent, down from 7 per cent in the current plan, a reflection of the Communist leadership’s continuing attempts to move away from debt-fuelled expansion.

You’ve got to read between the lines of these announcements a bit. The CCP is acknowledging that they’ve made mistakes. That’s huge. Earth-shattering.

And cutting the growth targets (even as the actual growth is probably substantially less) means that they’re throwing in the towel on the strategy that has served them for the last three decades. Just about 100 million people in China are in desperate poverty—a number only exceeded by India. The announcement is confessing that China will always have a large number of desperately poor people.

To be sure the end of the One-Child Policy is interesting. China’s population is expected to peak at something like 1.6 billion people in 2040. After that it’s expected to fall to something like half of that. Like Russia and unlike the United Kingdom, France, or the United States, China isn’t likely to replace that demographic collapse with immigrants. It’s just too xenophobic.

That would make an interesting exercise for a demographer. When will the U. S. population and China’s population cross?

0 comments

Beliefs, Conclusions, and Policies

I’m not sure what moved me to write this post but right now I’m seeing an enormous disconnect among what people think, what they have reasonable grounds to think, and their policy preferences. When we say that “somebody believes something”, we mean that he or she is convinced of something whether or not she or he has evidence to that effect or even possibly despite evidence to the contrary. For example, I believe we should only engage in just wars. I think that’s not only an ethical position but also one that’s grounded in realpolitik but I probably couldn’t prove that to you.

When we say that “somebody has concluded something” we mean that he or she has looked at evidence and reached that conclusion. The evidence could be authoritative testimony, experience, or other kinds of evidence. It’s possible to draw different conclusions about things, even different conclusions from the same evidence. For example, I don’t think it’s technically impossible for the United States to have hyperinflation but I know that others do.

If you think that hyperiflation is technically impossible in the United States, the debate over the budget is meaningless noise to you and must be incredibly frustrating since, if hyperinflation is technically impossible, we shouldn’t have taxes at all (unless there’s some need to remove money from circulation). The federal government should simply issue credit to itself and spend the money.

One last observation on policies. When you choose among the available alternatives and you categorically and unfailingly reject policy X, we should conclude that you don’t support policy X other than rhetorically. For example, if you say you’re opposed to agricultural subsidies but always reject cuts in agricultural subsidies, you’re just kidding yourself.

Politicians lie all of the time. The truth frequently hurts and they know that hurting people doesn’t get you elected or re-elected. I don’t judge what politicians believe by what they say but by what they do.

8 comments

The Deal on the Budget

In their lugubrious reaction to the incipient deal on the federal budget, the editors of the Wall Street Journal present the deal as a measured and balanced one:

The Obama Presidency staged a last policy gasp Tuesday, as the White House and congressional leaders completed a budget deal that defers every serious choice to the next Administration. The mutual nonaggression pact is the product of a hyper-polarized Washington, and perhaps the only thing worse than passing it would be not passing it.

The agreement breaks the budget spending caps to add $50 billion to the budget in fiscal year 2016 and $30 billion in FY 2017, split evenly between domestic discretionary programs for Democrats and defense top-ups for GOP hawks (plus $31 billion more in “emergency” war funding outside the caps). This is nominally offset with cuts elsewhere and won’t add to the deficit on paper, but trading immediate spending for future savings that are partly illusory is vintage Beltway subterfuge.

Still, this means the discretionary budget—everything except entitlements—will be $56 billion and $70 billion less, in 2016 and 2017 respectively, than the first Paul Ryan budget that the House passed in 2011. Subsequent versions included deeper cuts. The GOP Congress has strayed from maximalist fiscal restraint, but it has preserved the lower arc of spending that is its most consequential achievement.

before turning their attention to the sop thrown to the budget hawks (if any still exist in Washington):

But Republicans did secure modest entitlement reforms. The deal repeals an ObamaCare mandate for businesses to automatically enroll workers in health benefits, regardless of the cost. It also equalizes the Medicare payment rates for hospital and outpatient care to mitigate losses from providers that game the formula to get paid more for the same services.

Most important, Social Security will get its first upgrade since the 1980s to fix disability insurance. A slack economy and policy expansions under George W. Bush and Mr. Obama have transformed disability from a safety net into a middle-age retirement program and the rolls have exploded. Benefits were scheduled to fall by 20% next year because the program’s “trust fund” is nearly bankrupt.

The reality is that the deal, such as it is, does almost nothing to “fix disability insurance”. Over the period of the last fifteen years outlays under the program have doubled. The reality is that SSDI has become the unemployment insurance of last resort. I don’t have a solid estimate but I believe that there are probably tens or hundreds of thousands of recipients who would prefer to be working over being on the dole and who would work through pain and illness.

The real problem with SSDI is that the number of jobs isn’t growing fast enough and the compensation for the jobs that are being created isn’t keeping up with the cost of living. Those are the problems that are desperately in need of “fixing”. Expect lots of pontificating but not a lot of action over the next year if not forever.

3 comments

The Structure of the Finance and Insurance Sectors

In the interest of producing more light with less heat in discussing the financialization of the economy and how compensation within the various subsectors of the finance and insurance sector of the economy has changed over the years, I plan a series of posts analyzing the structure of the industry, the number of concerns, assets, revenues, employment, and compensation of the various subsectors, and how they have changed over the years. It’s not a simple task and all contributions will be gratefully accepted.

A good place to start would be with this link which describes the financial sector as having the following subsectors:

  • Banking
  • Asset management
  • Insurance
  • Venture capital

Unfortunately, the article doesn’t treat assets, revenues, etc. consistently from subsector to subsector so I’ll need to dig that information up. My next post in this series will discuss the number of companies in each subsector and how that has changed over the years. Onwards.

Once I’ve finished this exercise with the finance and insurance sector of the economy I plan to give the same treatment the healthcare sector. These are the sectors in which compensation is highest.

2 comments

How Bad Is Bacon?

Other than to say that I think that the news reporting on this story has been terrible, I really don’t know how to react to the report that the World Health Organization has deemed processed meats like bacon, sausage, and ham as carcinogenic:

Eating processed meats like hot dogs, sausages and bacon can cause colorectal cancer in humans, and red meat is also a likely cause of the disease, World Health Organization (WHO) experts said.

The review by WHO’s International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), released on Monday, said additionally that there was some link between the consumption of red meat and pancreatic cancer and prostate cancer.

IARC classified processed meat as “carcinogenic to humans” on its group one list along with tobacco and asbestos, for which there is “sufficient evidence” of cancer links.

Each 50-gram (1.8-ounce) portion of processed meat eaten daily increases the risk of colorectal cancer by 18 percent, the agency estimated.

Personally, I’m unconcerned. For one thing the risk still isn’t that high and for another I don’t eat that much processed meat. My ration is more like 10 grams a week than it is like 50 grams a day. 50 grams a day is a lot. I tend to use those things as seasoning rather than as entrees.

The report is completely unsurprising. It’s a meta-study. Findings along these lines have been coming out for decades.

I’m pretty out of touch with the American diet. How much processed meat do Americans eat on a daily basis? My impression is that the Germans eat a lot more wurst than Americans do.

9 comments

Is There a Problem With the Earth’s Gravitational Pull?

There’s that word again. Only in this case the word is “unexpectedly”. Bloomberg is reporting that durable goods order fell unexpectedly in September:

Orders for business equipment unexpectedly declined in September as tepid global markets gave American companies little reason to expand.
Bookings for non-military capital goods excluding aircraft dropped 0.3 percent after a 1.6 percent August decrease that was twice as large as previously estimated, according to a Commerce Department report on Tuesday. Demand for all durable goods — items meant to last at least three years — fell 1.2 percent.
Corporate investment may be slow to pick up until inventories are worked off and a pickup in foreign economies revives demand for commodities and U.S.-made goods. While weaker overseas sales have taken a toll on industrial companies from Caterpillar Inc. to 3M Co., stronger motor vehicle purchases have been supporting manufacturing.

That’s two consecutive months of decreased orders. I’ve been complaining the business investment was too weak to sustain growth for years. This at least gives me some basis.

6 comments

A Pictorial Timeline

You might want to check out this pictorial timeline and summary of how we got to where we are in the Middle East over at Pat Lang’s place. Here’s a snippet of the summary commentary:

If all of this doesn’t makes sense, that’s because it can’t, and there is a reason for that:

US clients pursue interests that are diametrically opposed with US goals and the US doesn’t have a coherent policy, with the neocon/neoliberal/R2P wings infighting with the residual realists. In continuity with the Bushmen before them, they also fancy the idea of global benevolent hegemony and the American civilising mission to remake the world in its own image. Also, they are limited in their freedom of movement, which the conduct of three key US allies illustrates…

As I see it there are two fundamental problems:

  • Bad assumptions
  • A basic inability to establish priorities and stick by them
1 comment

What Sectors Have the Highest Earners?

As I made my rounds this morning I didn’t find a lot of blog-worthy material. You can’t make bricks without straw, you know. What I found was the regular bickering and sniping which I generally find pretty boring.

I did stumble across this study which I believe is from the Minneapolis Federal Reserve. Here’s the part I found interesting:

Third, regarding the characteristics of top earners, we find that the dominance of the finance and insurance industry is staggering, for both males and females: in 2012, finance and insurance accounted for around one-third of workers in the top 0.1 percent. However, this was not the case 30 years ago, when the health care industry accounted for the largest share of the top 0.1 percent. Since then, top earning health care workers have dropped to the second 0.9 percent where, along with workers in finance and insurance, they have replaced workers in manufacturing, whose share of this group has dropped by roughly half.

Finance, insurance, and healthcare are all highly regulated. If there’s a correlation between the degree of regulation of a sector of the economy and share of top .1% of income earners, it’s a positive one. In other words, if you’re concerned about income inequality, don’t expect the problem to get better by regulating the sectors of the economy with the most high earners more tightly.

10 comments