Out of Space, Out of Time

In his post on gun control, Tyler Cowen divides American political thought, at least as it relates to firearms into four categories:

1. There are the anti-gun modern Democrats, who want Americans to own many fewer firearms, and who maybe favor slight cuts in defense spending, in order to spend more on redistribution. They don’t come to terms with the reality that their vision for America’s international state requires a fairly martial supporting culture at home, including strong attachments to gun ownership.
By the way, citations of the Australian gun control experience are a good indicator of this position and its partial naivete; Australian pacifism can to some extent free ride upon American martial interest. Another “warning sign” is if someone is incredulous that the San Bernardino attack is strengthening America’s attachment to a relatively martial internal culture, rather than leading to gun control. That person is out of touch, even if he or she is right about the substance of the issue.
2. There is the radical, anti-war, anti-military-industrial complex, semi-pacifist, anti-gun Left. Their positions on these issues are quite consistent, though this branch of the Left has disappeared almost entirely.
3. There are the libertarians, who hate martial culture on the international scene, but who wish to allow it or maybe even encourage it (personally, not through the government) at home, through the medium of guns. They are inconsistent, and they should consider being more pro-gun control than is currently the case. But I don’t expect them to budge: they will see this issue only through the lens of liberty, rather than through the lens of culture as well. They end up getting a lot of the gun liberties they wish to keep, but losing the broader cultural battle and somehow are perpetually surprised by this mix of outcomes.
I except non-American libertarians from these charges, and indeed many of them, albeit under the table, in fact support gun control as a libertarian and indeed pro-peace position.
4. There are the “right-wing conservatives.” They support a martial ethic, they support America’s active foreign policy abroad, and they are anti-gun control for the most part. And they find their greatest strength in the relatively martial American South. Like the old anti-war Left, their positions are consistent, and their positions are rooted in a cultural understanding of the issue. They see the gun control movement as a war on America’s greatness, America’s martial culture and the material embodiments of said culture. They don’t understand why “the world’s greatest nation” should give up its superpower role, and its supporting internal martial culture, all for the sake of limiting the number of suicides and maybe stopping a few shootings too. To them it’s not close to being worth it.

I don’t fit into any of them, except possibly “non-American libertarians”, ironic since I think I represent a strain of political thought that is distinctly American and older than any of the four he recognizes. It makes me sad.

11 comments

Is It a Floor Wax or a Dessert Topping?

Do we need greater income equality in the United States or faster growth? In a post at RealClearMarkets J. T. Young comes down solidly on the side of faster growth:

Liberals have contorted an effect of America’s slow economy into its cause. However misperceiving reality does not change it, but simply delays our ability to successfully confront it. Such is the case if we focus on income inequality instead of the slow overall growth that is exacerbating it.

There are ample reasons for America’s economic concerns. For almost nine years, real GDP growth has not matched 2006’s 2.7% increase. During this time annual growth has averaged 1.4%. Unemployment is currently 5%, but only because labor force participation is down too (62.4%). If participation equaled 2006’s level (66.2%), today’s unemployment rate would be twice as high.

Amidst the general concern over this stubbornly slow growth, liberals have a particular one: Income inequality. It is unsurprising that they seize on this as the economy’s prevailing problem. The left sees free market competition as inherently inefficient and unfair. For them, it as a zero-sum system; that it is one with fewer – but bigger – winners, and more – but bigger – losers, simply validates their original verdict.

Liberals are unlikely to be persuaded by the obvious observation: income inequality is rather simply, if also miserably, cured. This is what the late and unlamented communist regimes succeeded so mightily in – an equality of poverty for all but their ruling political class.

You can read the rest if you must.

For a tonic I turn to that bastion of progressive thought, the Wall Street Journal where Janet Adamy has handily provided a graph illustrating the problem:

Unless you think that our economy has been growing too slowly for the last 40 years, something I would dispute

  1. The rise in income inequality started a lot longer ago than the last 7 years
  2. Which means that slow growth cannot have caused the disparity.

I think that we need both faster growth and greater income equality and, fortunately, the two are interrelated. For the bulk of the 20th century there was a consensus that income growth in the middle class was the key to a healthy and robust economy. That consensus has broken down and, well, si monumentum requiris, circumspice (“if you seek a monument, look around you”). But what is to be done?

I don’t agree with most progressives that the key to middle class income growth is unions. I think they’re confusing the deindustrialization of the United States that has taken place with the decline of unions, a case of reverse causality. Here are the things that I think need to be done in quick bullet form:

  • Reindustrialize the United States.
  • Counter the mercantilist policies of our trading partners that produced the situation.
  • Control immigration.
  • Stop subsidizing (or at least restrict the subsidies) of sectors that tend to concentrate wealth, e.g. finance and healthcare.
  • Change the incentives so that creating and making things returns more than owning intellectual property and retail sales.

I’m not foolish. I don’t think that my plan will be adopted but I also think that it’s what will work. In the absence of the reforms I advocate I think we’re likely to see slow growth and a society increasingly divided between the very well-to-do and the working poor.

20 comments

Do American Muslims Have a Duty to Their Country?

Suggesting a somewhat different tack than CAIR, in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal Khurram Dara says they do:

It isn’t enough to condemn radicalism—we must actively engage in counter-extremism messaging. We must build an intellectual and theological case against radicalism. Our religious leaders must educate and warn our youth about the dangers of searching for spiritual guidance on the Internet. And we have to be vigilant. When someone stops coming to mosque and disappears from a community, abruptly after marrying a Pakistani woman in Saudi Arabia whom he met online, it shouldn’t take two years and 35 Americans getting shot (including one from that very congregation) before we notice.

There is a war going on that extends beyond Syria, and American Muslims are under siege. Not by a fringe group of bigoted Americans, but by a fringe group of Muslims abroad who seek to tear our Western communities apart. They are trying to target the disaffected among us, hijack the mosque pulpit, and convince us that we’re unwelcome in our own country.

But in order to lead this fight with unified support, certain things will have to change. We can’t call out prejudice against our faith without also calling out the gender inequality and homophobia that we find in some of our communities. We can’t be champions of our own religious freedom without also championing the rights of all traditions across the globe that wish to peacefully practice, including other Muslim sects we may disagree with doctrinally. We have to change the way we think about Islamic law and vilify the medieval judicial practices that persist in the Middle East. And we must have uncomfortable but necessary conversations about where much of the funding for this cancerous supremacist ideology is coming from—Saudi Arabia.

We carry with us a responsibility to our country, our faith and our children. The majority of us are here because our parents or grandparents emigrated from oppressive and illiberal nations for the promise of a better life in America. But the way things are heading, our children may grow up with less opportunity and freedom than we did. I can think of no greater defeat and surrender to radicalism than that.

I think that’s right, it’s what President Obama has asked for, and, as a matter of practicality, it’s the best way for us to increase our security here at home. I hope Mr. Dara can convince his fellows. The money is pushing the other way.

1 comment

What Must Happen in Chicago

After a long and uncomfortable silence on the murder of Laquan McDonald and the subsequent demonstrations here in Chicago, the editors of the Chicago Tribune have remarked on Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s speech yesterday:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel stood before the Chicago City Council on Wednesday and said two little words many Chicagoans have been demanding to hear.

No, not I resign.

I’m sorry.

I know of no one who was waiting for those two words. I can only speculate that the Trib’s editors move in different circles than I do. They continue:

The truth is that the City Council has been signing off on multimillion-dollar legal settlements over police brutality for far longer than Emanuel has been mayor. Aldermen have never insisted on changes in the department’s policies on the use of deadly force, or in the byzantine disciplinary process that rarely holds officers accountable for misconduct.

Time and again, Chicago’s leaders have faced a crisis, promised reforms, then dropped the ball.

Emanuel vowed, this time, to follow through. He must.

He’ll have the U.S. Department of Justice looking over his shoulder, likely for many years. In the short term, he’s assigned a task force to figure out how to overhaul the police oversight system, to limit the use of lethal force, to improve transparency and community engagement. The group has already recommended naming a “senior officer for civil rights” within the Police Department.

I think that several things must happen in Chicago before a corner can be turned.

  1. There must be more indictments of police officers. To date only one police officer, the one who actually pulled the trigger, has been indicted relative to the murder of Laquan McDonald. The officers who were on the scene and their immediate superiors on the force continue on active duty. They haven’t even been suspended. At the very least there should be more indictments for filing false reports and IMO conspiracy. The remainder should be worked out in the courts.
  2. As John Kass very correctly pointed out in a recent column, there’s an intergenerational struggle going on among the politicians in Chicago’s black community:

    Cops and protesters know how Chicago works, and though Rahm and his biscuit eaters take great umbrage at what I’ve been saying, I’ll say it again for visitors who don’t know our ways:

    Emanuel sat on that police dash-cam video of a white cop shooting a black teenager, Laquan McDonald, until after the mayor’s re-election was secure. The deal was cut before the votes were cast, and after his re-election, he settled the case for $5 million of taxpayer cash. Now his bill is past due.

    Now black politicians and clergy who supported Emanuel are running for cover, trying to run ahead of the angry protesters. And the hard political left, which never liked Rahm, is flexing.

    The protests in Chicago on Wednesday that were broadcast across the nation look like many other protests in other towns. But those who are wise in the Chicago Way can see a subtle but critical difference.

    It all signals a coming changing of the guard among Chicago’s black leadership.

    The Rev. Jesse “King of Beers” Jackson can still command a microphone, but he’s old and getting older. A younger, more vigorous group of black activists has been waiting a long time for him to vacate center stage.

    Jackson muscled the elders out when he was young. Now it’s his turn to be elbowed aside. And he’s holding on by his fingernails.

    There’s got to be at least a partial changing of the guard.

  3. The FOP must get on board. To date we have heard thinly veiled threats from police officers, e.g. “blue flu”, go slow, etc. There is no conspiracy against the police. What there has been is a police conspiracy against the people of Chicago. That’s not something that can be solved by circling the wagons.
  4. Chicago politicians must start preparing for the post-Rahm era. Even if he survives, it’s pretty clear that he’s no longer in control.

As I’ve said before, I strongly suspect that Mayor Emanuel will survive unless and until he become a liability for the president or Hillary Clinton at which point he’ll sink like a stone. The longer this story makes the national news, the closer that day comes.

3 comments

That Should Do It

On the morning news this morning I heard a representative of the Council on American-Islamic Relations complaining about the organization’s perennial topic: Islamophobia. The part that I didn’t understand is why we’re not just telling CAIR that Muslims are more likely to be struck by lightning than they are to killed or injured by an anti-Muslim hate crime—according to the FBI the number of hate crimes against Muslims every year is fewer than 200. Indeed, they’re more likely to be killed or injured by radical Islamists than they are by Islamophobes. That should make them feel better.

Keep in mind: a) CAIR is an off-shoot of the Muslim Brotherhood; b) they’re not good guys; c) they’re funded by foreign governments. Their constant whinging about Islamophobia tells the world that a practically non-existent problem is a lot more serious than it actually as. They’re part of the problem.

7 comments

Disgusted

Today there was a mob chanting outside my office building for the better part of the day. At one point it sounded for all the world like a riot.

I took another look at the video of the execution of Laquan McDonald, paying closer attention to the aftermath. There’s little doubt about what’s going on. The police officers on the scene are comparing notes, getting their story straight. Under the circumstances there are two words for that: criminal conspiracy. They all filed reports that corroborated the shooter, Van Dyke’s account of what happened. No reasonable observer watching the video can draw any conclusion other than that they’re all lying.

The mob was calling on Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel to resign. Where the heck are our two major newspapers? Neither of them is asking the obvious questions. Did you watch the video? When? I doubt any Chicagoan believes anything other than not only is he involved in the conspiracy, he’s up to his hips in it.

And what about the Department of Justice? Their investigation into the incident is more than a year old now. There is a point at which investigation becomes obstruction.

The mayor gave a speech today. He said he was sorry. Nobody believes it.

11 comments

It’s the Holes

David Ignatius, writing in the Washington Post, has noticed a major lacuna in President Obama’s strategy for dealing with DAESH:

But there was a mysterious black box in the middle of Obama’s speech. Here’s how he tried to explain it: “The strategy that we are using now — airstrikes, special forces and working with local forces who are fighting to regain control of their own country — that is how we’ll achieve a more sustainable victory.”

What “local forces” is Obama talking about? If he means Kurdish fighters in Iraq and Syria, yes, they’ve performed admirably. In Kurdish areas. They don’t want to clear and hold the Sunni heartland of the Islamic State, nor should they. If Obama is talking about the Shiite-led Iraqi military, its performance is still just barely adequate, even backed by U.S. air power, and it is disdained and mistrusted by the Sunnis of Ramadi, Fallujah and Mosul. If he’s talking about the Islamist brigades in Syria armed by Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar, it’s still not entirely clear whether they’re friend or foe.

The disturbing fact is that a strong, reliable, indigenous Sunni ground force doesn’t exist yet in Iraq or Syria. The United States has been trying to fix this problem since the fall of Mosul in June 2014, with very little success. We’re like the joke about the starving economist who needs to open a can of beans on a desert island and posits: “Assume we had a can opener!”

That’s long been a fundamental problem with the president’s strategy. If fighting DAESH is in the U. S. interest, why hold the strategy hostage to the political and social vagaries of other countries? It makes little sense. If it’s not in the U. S. interest, our actions are immoral.

Unfortunately, that’s not the only weak assumption in the strategy the president outlined on Sunday evening. One of the issues he mentioned was the vital importance of cooperation from American Muslims. The problem—American Muslims don’t wanna:

President Obama’s request that Muslim Americans help “root out” and confront extremist ideology in their communities is getting mixed reactions. Muslim leaders say they want to help, but some are not happy that they are being singled out.

“We would never ask any other faith community to stand up and condemn acts of violence committed by people within their groups,” said Palestinian-American activist Linda Sarsour, who has worked extensively with the Black Lives Matter movement and other minority groups. “The fact that this is only directed at the Muslim community is something that I personally can’t accept.”

During World War II the response of Japanese Americans to the questioning of their loyalty was to prove their detractors wrong. Of the 280,000 some-odd Japanese Americans in the United States at the outbreak of the war, roughly 10,000 served in the U. S. military—a number far greater than their numbers would suggest—and they served with distinction. The 442nd Infantry Regiment, the “Nisei regiment”, composed almost entirely of Japanese-Americans, was the most highly decorated unit in American military history.

The response of Muslims following 9/11 has been very different. Roughly .45% of those serving in the U. S. military are Muslims, compared with the 3-4% that Muslims comprise of the U. S. population. My impression is that American Muslims have religious scruples against fighting their fellow Muslims. The same scruples may apply to cooperation with the civil authorities. There is plenty of anecdotal evidence that’s the case.

I’m not suggesting that American Muslims are under some obligation to serve in the military. They are under no such obligation. I’m just pointing out that President Obama may be expecting more than American Muslims are willing to give. It would be nice if they did more than whinge about practically non-existent hate crime. According to the FBI about 200 hate crimes against Muslims take place every year in a country of 310 million people. By comparison 1,000 hate crimes against Jews are committed every year even though Muslims outnumber Jews three to one (at least).

9 comments

Crafting Sensible Policy

I think that Mark Krikorian has this about right:

Under current trends, the United States will admit about 1 million new Muslim-origin immigrants over the next decade, plus hundreds of thousands of Muslim guest workers and foreign students. In addition, something like 50,000 young people from Muslim immigrant families turn 18 in the United States each year. Many of these individuals are productive citizens who pose no threat to our republic. Iman the supermodel, television’s Dr. Oz, Fareed Zakaria, Coke CEO Muhtar Kent — whatever their merits or lack thereof, their Muslim origins pose no threat to us. Some are even politically conservative American patriots, such as our own Reihan Salam.

But large Muslim populations, continually refreshed by ongoing mass immigration, are a problem. Polling suggests between a quarter and a third are not attached to the principles of the Constitution, supporting things such as sharia law over U.S. law and the use of violence against those who insult Islam. Nor is this merely hypothetical; Muslims account for only about 1 percent of the U.S. population but account for about half of terrorist attacks since 9/11. That means Muslims in the United States are about 5,000 percent more likely to commit terrorist attacks than non-Muslims.

He proposes ideological screening:

The narrowest solution would be to restore the principle of “ideological exclusion” to U.S. immigration law. With the end of the Cold War — which too many imagined to be the End of History — we eliminated the legal bar to enemies of America who were not actual members of terrorist organizations or card-carrying members of totalitarian political parties. Specifically, the law says the State Department is prohibited from keeping a foreigner out “because of the alien’s past, current, or expected beliefs, statements, or associations, if such beliefs, statements, or associations would be lawful within the United States.” In other words, since 1990 we have applied the First Amendment to all foreigners abroad seeking admission to our country. The only exception is if the secretary of state “personally determines that the alien’s admission would compromise a compelling United States foreign policy interest” — note this exception is only for a “compelling . . . foreign policy interest,” not a domestic-policy one, like limiting the number of residents who support killing apostates. Even President Obama has paid (grudging) lip service to the ideological — as opposed to the violent — threat. In his Oval Office speech Sunday night he said “Muslim leaders here and around the globe have to . . . speak out against not just acts of violence, but also those interpretations of Islam that are incompatible with the values of religious tolerance, mutual respect, and human dignity.” So why aren’t we keeping out people who adhere to such interpretations?

The Supreme Court has already ruled on this; ideological screening is permissible. It all depends on what the Congress approves or disapproves.

This is something too frequently ignored:

But large-scale immigration of non-violent Islamic supremacists also facilitates violence, by forming and sustaining neighborhoods that serve as cover and incubators for jihad attacks, however unintentionally. Muslim immigrant neighborhoods, and their mosques and other institutions, fit Mao’s observation regarding the peasantry’s role in China’s war against the Japanese: “The people are like water and the army is like fish.” DHS’s chief intelligence officer told the House Select Committee on Intelligence in 2007, “As previous attacks indicate, overseas extremists do not operate in a vacuum and are often linked with criminal and smuggling networks — usually connected with resident populations [in the U.S.] from their countries of origin (emphasis added).”

There’s another reason for ideological screening, by which I mean interviewing people under oath. Should individuals have lied and later statements and action support that conclusion, the testimony can be used at later hearings to prove that a future naturalization was fraudulent.

2 comments

Burying the Lede: It Ain’t Just Republicans

I’ve got to hand it to the kids at Vox.com. They have a real genius for burying the lede. The title on their post is “Donald Trump has a base: 76% of Republicans think Islam is un-American”. When you dig into the same poll as they’re citing in their post (I’ve cited it here before), you come up with the following:

  • A majority of Americans (56%) believe that Islam is inconsistent with American values and the American way of life.
  • A majority of black Protestants (55%) believe that Islam is inconsistent with American values and the American way of life.
  • A majority of independents (57%) believe that Islam is inconsistent with American values and the American way of life.
  • 43% of Democrats (possibly a plurality) believe that Islam is inconsistent with American values and the American way of life.

I would love to know how Hispanics responded but the data aren’t broken out sufficiently for me to determine that. I would bet a shiny new dime that a majority of Hispanics think that Islam is inconsistent with American values and the American way of life.

How would you interpret those results? I don’t think it would be “Republicans are out-of-step with how most Americans think on this subject”.

Just for the record I don’t think that Islam is any less consistent with American values and the American way of life than Catholicism is. I do think that Islamism (political Islam) is inconsistent with American values and the American way of life just as Soviet communism was and for the same reason. Just as Soviet communism was a stalking horse for Russian imperialism I think that Islamism is a stalking horse for Arab nationalism and a whole laundry list of beliefs and practices that most Americans including many American Muslims find offensive and objectionable.

57 comments

Another Call for Emanuel’s Resignation

Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel columnist James E. Causey has added his voice to those calling for Chicago Mayor Emanuel’s resignation:

Rahm Emanuel has to go. The Chicago mayor must resign immediately to restore trust in a city still reeling from the public execution of a teenager by a police officer more than a year ago.

Emanuel demanded the resignation of Chicago Police Superintended Garry McCarthy because he said police officers are only effective when they have the trust of those they serve.

But what about Emanuel? Who can trust him? Was he silent because this incident occurred during an election cycle? He should do the next right thing. He should resign.

I continue to think that Mayor Emanuel will hold out until he begins to become too much of a liability to Hillary Clinton or the Democratic Party more generally.

The latest shoe to drop in this story is that the Department of Justice has announced that it is opening an investigation into the Chicago Police Department. Presumably, a wider-reaching investigation than the one opened into the killing of Laquan McDonald, which began more than a year ago, is intended. Something will depend on whether the DOJ investigation is thought of as part of the ongoing cover-up, an attempt at kicking the entire issue safely past the 2016 general election.

I genuinely think that Democrats are underestimating the potential impact of what’s going on in Chicago not just on Chicago but on what remains of the New Deal Coalition. Democrats don’t rack up electoral victories based on the support of the Harvard faculty directory. The reality is that without black voters Democrats are Nowheresville. That the Democratic leadership is so old and so white given the demographics of the base is an outrage.

5 comments