How Do You Tell Overreaction from Underreaction?

There’s a question that’s been bothering me for the last 12 years. Did we overreact or underreact to 9/11? My standards for such things are so skewed that at this point I have no idea.

If, for example, we had nuked the 20 largest Arab capitals plus Mecca and Medina, I would have considered that an overreaction. If we had just nuked Kabul and Tora Bora, there would have been some tut-tutting but it probably wouldn’t have been considered an overreaction.

What we actually did was in reality an enormous underreaction.

Please keep in mind that I opposed not only the invasion of Iraq but the invasion of Afghanistan, too. That’s to head off the charge that I’m some sort of warmonger.

5 comments

Discussion Points

  • The United States does not recognize a generalized right to immigration. Indeed, no country in the world does and no international accord to which the United States is a party recognizes such a right.
  • The talking points about the robust nature of our vetting of those requesting visas and the moral imperative of accepting Syrian women and children refugees died with the victims in San Bernardino.
  • What does the president have in mind in terms of gun control that would have reduced the likelihood of the killings in San Bernardino? Does he actually have anything in mind?
  • What is the likelihood of any Democrat being inaugurated president in 2017 in the presence of a presidential firearms confiscation order?
  • Do we really require no photo IDs from applicants for visas?
  • Present law requires U. S. immigration and naturalization authorities to take information about the religions, races, and ethnicities of applicants into account in granting refugee status. Aren’t those decrying taking religion and ethnicity into account in such cases actually attacking their own position? How can you define “refugee” without recourse to such distinctions? Take the applicants’ word for it?
  • Why do we continue to allow CAIR to violate the Foreign Agent Registration Act?
  • Same question with respect to foreign-born imams (85% of the total) who receive much of their funding from unaudited overseas sources?
  • One reasonably talented programmer could develop a spider that would monitor social networking sites for things like, oh, declaring allegiance to DAESH or its leader. Given the untold billions we’ve spent on monitoring, why has this not, apparently, been done? Or at least not exploited? Maybe we need a detailed auditing of our intelligence-related IT.
  • Why do we accept immigrants from Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Chechnya, Syria, Yemen, or Libya (you can probably name other countries) other than our translators and their immediate families?
  • If Assad and his regime are ousted from Syria, who will run the country? Please be specific.
  • What do you think will happen if a U. S. pilot operating in Syria or Iraq is shot down and captured by DAESH? How do you think Americans will react to that?
  • (For Ted Cruz fans only) How would carpet bombing DAESH (presumably Raqqah) contribute to domestic U. S. security?

If you have other, similar discussion points, please feel free to add your own in comments.

13 comments

These Are the Times That Try Men’s Souls

Maybe I’m a seeing a full-on assault against enlightenment values where there is none. And, as the Tom Paine quote that forms the title of this post suggests, crisis brings out both the best and the worst in people. First, there were the college demands for “safe zones”, i.e. non-free speech zones. Following the killings in San Bernardino the New York Times devoted a rare front page editorial to a call for gun control in the United States that was so filled with logical fallacies and errors of fact that it should alarm supporters and opponents of gun control alike. The only way the Times editors’ argument holds water is if you take a strictly instrumental view of law. What is the limit on such arguments? That presidents who don’t like articles that the Times runs about them are empowered to shut the paper down?

Then I read Linda Stasi’s column in the New York Daily News which draws an express equivalence between one of the victims of the couple in San Bernardino and the terrorist couple:

Make no mistake, as disgusting and deservedly dead as the hate-filled fanatical Muslim killers were, Thalasinos was also a hate-filled bigot. Death can’t change that. But in the U.S., we don’t die for speaking our minds. Or we’re not supposed to anyway.

Thalasinos was an anti-government, anti-Islam, pro-NRA, rabidly anti-Planned Parenthood kinda guy, who posted that it would be “Freaking Awesome” if hateful Ann Coulter was named head of Homeland Security. He asked, “IS 1. EVERY POLITICIAN IS BOUGHT AND PAID FOR? 2. EVERY POLITICIAN IS A MORON? 3. EVERY POLITICIAN IS RACIST AGAINST JEWS?” He also posted screeds like, “You can stick your Muslim Million Man march up your asses,” and how “Hashem” should blow up Iran.

all of those utterances are protected speech (particularly opposition to governments and politicians). You may not like it but it’s protected. There are no “buts” here. There is no equivalence between Thalasinos on the one hand and Syed Farook and his wife on the other. Seeing one is a rejection of Enlightenment values.

This morning on one of the talking heads programs I just heard Jeb Bush articulating an argument in support of abridging the rights of some people in the United States depending on their political views.

A week or so ago I posted on polling results that found that a majority of Americans feel like strangers in their own country. Is it any wonder?

23 comments

The Next Shoe

I have a feeling we haven’t seen the last criminal indictment arising from the killing of Laquan McDonald. From WGN television:

CHICAGO — There are new discrepancies in the Laquan McDonald case.

The Chicago Tribune obtained hundreds of pages of police reports that differ dramatically with dash cam video of the shooting.

Officer Jason Van Dyke told investigators that McDonald lunged at him before he shot McDonald 16 times last October.

Van Dyke said he thought McDonald was trying to kill him.

In the report, Van Dyke said he continued to fire because it appeared McDonald was trying to get back up.

Van Dyke defended his actions, telling investigators that he was aware of spring-loaded knives.

He also said the department had recently issued a bulletin, warning officers that there are knives that can shoot bullets.

At least five other officers also said McDonald moved toward them in a threatening way, but no one else fired their guns.

Van Dyke is now charged with murder in McDonald’s death.

It depends on the standard that is used to judge the officers’ actions. If the standard is “was you there, Charlie?”, it will be one thing. Police officers are generally given the benefit of the doubt. If a reasonable person standard is adopted, the outcome may be quite different. And then there are the possible conspiracy charges. How close are the various officers’ reports of the incident?

4 comments

Reasonable Inferences Are Not Facts

I just want to remind people that we still don’t know what happened in San Bernardino. At this point that Syed Farook’s Pakistani wife, newly imported from Saudi Arabia, was an Islamist terrorist and that they had much more devastating attacks in mind are reasonable inferences but they’re not facts. We may never know what happened.

18 comments

Unprecedented Obfuscation

The editors of the Wall Street Journal quote from the IAEA’s report on Iran’s nuclear program:

The IAEA is the U.N. outfit that is supposed to monitor Iran’s compliance with the agreement, which requires Tehran to answer the agency’s questions on its past nuclear work in order to obtain sanctions relief. On Wednesday the agency produced its “final assessment”—the finality here having mostly to do with the U.N. nuclear watchdog giving up hope of ever getting straight answers.

Hence we learn that “Iran did not provide any clarification” regarding experiments the agency believes it conducted on testing components of nuclear components at its military facility at Parchin. “The information available to the Agency, including the results of the sampling analysis and the satellite imagery, does not support Iran’s statements on the purpose of the building,” says the report. “The Agency assesses that the extensive activities undertaken by Iran since February 2012 at the particular location of interest to the Agency seriously undermined the Agency’s ability to conduct effective verification.”

For those of you who support the agreement the Obama Administration negotiated with the leaders of Iran, does this influence your judgment of the deal and if not why not? Has Iran lived up to its obligations under the agreement? Does this suggest that it is more or less likely that Iran’s compliance with any monitoring regime will be adequate to ensure its veracity?

2 comments

I Demand a Recount!

In an outcome I find impossible to fathom, 24/7 Wall Street ranks Illinois as the 49th worst-run state in its annual ranking:

Illinois collects more than $3,000 per capita in state and local taxes each year, one of the highest per capita tax revenues. Yet, the state’s fiscal management system does not appear to be operating optimally, which is the main reason it ranks as the second worst-run state. For example, Illinois has one of the smallest rainy day funds compared to other states, at 1% of its general annual budget — an indication the state may not be able to satisfy its short-term obligations. Illinois’ debt is equal to more than three-fourths of its annual revenue, also one of the highest shares in the nation. Similarly, the state’s pension fund is not financially healthy. The state only has assets on hand to meet 39% of its pension obligations, the lowest ratio of any state. Perhaps as a result of the state’s finances, Illinois has the worst credit rating and outlook from S&P and Moody’s of any state.

The housing market in Illinois is also struggling. One in every 73 housing units is in some state of the foreclosure process, nearly the highest foreclosure rate in the country. As is often the case in states with particularly high foreclosure rates, home prices in Illinois have dropped by more than 10% from 2010 through last year. This decline was the worst in the country during that time.

Only New Mexico is ranked lower. This is an obvious miscarriage of justice. Illinois should have been ranked dead last. Consider. In addition to the factors listed by 24/7 Wall Street Illinois

  • Has the lowest state contribution to education of any state.
  • Has the 2nd highest rate of outmigration of any state (only New York is higher).
  • Has a state legislature that has refused to enact a budget.
  • Is rated C- on its infrastructure by the civil engineers’ professional association.
  • Is the only Midwestern state to be ranked in the bottom third of states.
  • Is the most corrupt state in the Union (only Louisiana provides any real competition).

If Illinois were a company it would be placed in receivership and the entire management team replaced. Illinois’s voters replaced the Democratic governor with a Republican last year. Illinois’s legislatures, each with Democratic supermajorities, have completely refused to work with the new governor.

Illinois has political sclerosis. It needs to discharge its debts in bankruptcy, renegotiate its contracts with its public employees, something for which there are both legal and political barriers, and it needs to restructure its way of doing business completely. The only strategy our present leaders can imagine is raising taxes which is the reason Illinois has the 2nd highest rate of outmigration.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Threats

As I read this Atlantic interview of Chris Christie by Jeffrey Goldberg, it made me start thinking about threats. My thought process must be very different from that of most Americans. There’s a long list of countries and organizations I just don’t think are meaningful threats to us.

DAESH. Iran. Russia. China. Yes, even in the light of the San Bernardino murders I don’t think that DAESH is a meaningful threat to us.

That’s not to say that I think there are no meaningful threats but they’re not global ones, not institutional ones. They’re individuals and you can’t even get into a meaningful discussion of the subject without making people squirm, many to the point where they object.

Let’s look at risk factors. I don’t see how you can look at the San Bernardino or Fort Hood cases and not come to the conclusion that Muslims are risks. To me that’s not the question. The question is how great a risk and whether the risks can be mitigated.

More risk factors. Travel in certain high risk countries (Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, etc.)

Mental illness. Anomie. There’s a strong streak of what for lack of a better word we might call “anomic violence” that subsumes the murders at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church, the Aurora shooting, the Colorado Springs shooting, maybe the San Bernardino murders, too. Some of these risk factors stack up.

Sure, the availability of firearms is a risk factor. I don’t see a meaningful way of mitigating the risk. It’s a great way of signalling virtue, though.

What are some other risk factors?

I also think of that old MAD Magazine joke.

The Lone Ranger and Tonto are surrounded by hostile Indians.

Lone Ranger: Well, Tonto, it looks we’re not going to get out of this one.

Tonto: What you mean “we”, white man?

Not every threat to Israel or Germany is a threat to the United States. Or not a threat that presents the same level of risk.

15 comments

The Force

If Bakari Sellers’s reaction to Rahm Emanuel’s present posture is at all typical of black politicians around the country it illustrates precisely the forces that could drive Rahm Emanuel out of office:

(CNN)Whether we admit it or not, loyalty is the coin of the realm in American politics and was even before Ronald Reagan’s 11th Commandment, “Thou shalt not speak ill of any Republican,” became the standard for Republicans and Democrats alike.

I mention this because I am a loyal Obama Democrat committed not just to those principles that have defined the man and his presidency, but to those who, like myself, have committed themselves to realizing this vision and making it a reality: men and women who helped usher in his presidency, like Obama’s Senior Adviser Valerie Jarrett, the chief strategist for both his presidential campaigns (and now CNN Senior Political Commentator) David Axelrod, Obama’s 2008 deputy national campaign director Steve Hildebrand.

And Rahm Emanuel, Obama’s former White House chief of staff, now the mayor of Chicago.

But this kind of loyalty can only go so far; it can only excuse so much. Democrats Hillary Clinton, who has called for an independent federal inquiry into the Chicago Police Department over the death of African-American teenager Laquan McDonald, and Illinois Rep. Luis Gutiérrez, who withdrew his support for Cook County State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez in the upcoming primary, have offered profiles in courage by challenging the status quo.

But nothing short of Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s resignation will restore faith and trust in an already-fractured system that he further perverted, apparently for his own gain.

Hillary Clinton can’t win the presidency if black voters don’t turn out for her. Simple as that. Will black voters turn out for Hillary while Clintonista Emanuel endures a death of a thousand cuts over the police execution of a young black man? Tom Bevan speaks out:

Emanuel has casually brushed off the small but growing chorus of calls for his own resignation, and the city’s Democratic Party machine has a track record of protecting its leader.

But Rahm Emanuel is not only Chicago’s mayor. He is a former top aide to the Clintons, a onetime prominent member of the congressional House leadership, and a confidant of Barack Obama, whom he served as White House chief of staff. His actions, in other words, reflect on the Democratic Party—and this is the season of presidential politics.

Even his most staunch political allies are keeping their distance. The White House refused to come to Emanuel’s defense Wednesday, as the president’s spokesman punted on a reporter’s question of whether Obama thought the mayor should step down. “That’s a decision for Mayor Emanuel and the voters of Chicago to make,” said White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest.

and information relevant to those voters’ decision was withheld from them. Few doubt that the video of the execution was held back for any but political reasons.

What a difference a day makes! Yesterday Mayor Emanuel was castigating the idea of a Justice Department investigation (an investigation different than the one begun more than a year ago?) as “misguided”. Today he’s “open” to it:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel on Thursday reversed his opposition to a possible U.S. Justice Department review of the Chicago Police Department’s practices, the type of investigation that has led to federal court oversight and sweeping reforms in other troubled, big-city police departments throughout the country.

The about-face, coming a day after he called such an idea “misguided,” allowed Emanuel to try to save face politically, as his new position put him in line with Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan and Democratic presidential front-runner Hillary Clinton, both of whom already had called for the Justice Department to act. Illinois’ senior U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin and Cook County State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez quickly followed suit Thursday, and the White House and Justice Department declined to comment on the prospects of a probe.

Clearly, the pressure is mounting.

0 comments