Over-Extended

There is a fascinating study at Pew Research on how income and expenditures have recovered since the Great Recession. The graph above illustrates both. As you can see real expenditures are just about where they were in 2007. Real income has not fared so well. Here are Pew’s remarks:

From 2004 to 2008, median household income grew by only 1.5 percent,3 while median expenditures increased by about 11 percent. During that period, the expenditure-to-income ratio (the percentage of a household’s budget used for spending) jumped by 9 percent. As the recovery began, median household expenditures returned to pre-crisis levels, but median household income continued to contract. By 2014, median income had fallen by 13 percent from 2004 levels, while expenditures had increased by nearly 14 percent. This change in the expenditure-to-income ratio in the years following the financial crisis is a clear indication of why and how households feel financially strained.

The different class of expenditures have not all increased at the same rate:

A number of things jump out from that graph. Two classes of expenditures, healthcare and housing, have grown substantially relative to income since 1996. And most of that growth has been since 2012. Spending on food as a share of income has essentially been flat since 1996 while spending on pets, toys, and entertainment has decreased a tiny bit as a share of income.

How can real expenditures have increased so much while real incomes barely increased at all? I think the most likely explanation is that prices in healthcare and housing have continued to rise and supply and demand has taken care of the rest.

How can expenditures be outstripping income? It’s possible that people are dipping into nonexistent savings but by far the more likely explanation is the substantial increase in credit card debt that has occurred over the period.

A couple of other things from the study. The lower third of income earners are actually worse off now than they were before the Great Recession. Rent now consumes half of their incomes, a shocking figure.

Do these results fit your idea of a robust and sustainable recovery? The business cycle has still not been repealed. What do you think is going to happen in the next inevitable recession?

My prescription, as it has been for some time, is that healthcare spending must be not merely controlled but actually brought down and we need to create a lot more jobs that pay more. Neither of these things look particularly likely without major changes in policy.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Chicago’s Teachers in One Day Strike

Chicago’s public school teachers have walked out in a one day strike. Some are picketing at their schools. Some are just staying home. There’s more than one way of looking at this action. Here’s the press release from the Chicago Teachers’ Union:

The strike is a call for increased revenue for Chicago Public Schools and its students, and a direct response to continued attacks and efforts toward union-busting from Gov. Bruce Rauner, Mayor Rahm Emanuel and the mayor’s handpicked CPS CEO, Forrest Claypool. For the past year, the district has stalled contract negotiations with the CTU, threatened and mandated furlough days, cuts and layoffs, and removed step and lane increases for educators—the latter of which is the legal basis for the April 1 strike. Gov. Rauner, while unable to pass a state budget and putting the welfare of thousands of his constituents at risk, is on record in his desire to break unions and is currently starving city and state schools—at elementary, high school and university levels—unless downstate legislators accept his “turnaround” agenda.

April 1 will highlight proposals from the CTU and its education and community partners for winning school funding and funding for other important services. The only solution that doesn’t involve a complete downgrade of the teaching profession and teachers’ standard of living, and that protects quality public education, requires new revenue sources in the form of progressive tax reform that would get the super wealthy (top 5 percent) to pay their fair share in state taxes. This could generate up to $6 billion in new revenue for education and other social needs. In addition to progressive tax reform, the Union continues its demands about toxic swaps and tax increment financing (TIF)—swap terminations cost the district $240 million this year alone, and the TIFs could put enough money into the schools to completely reverse this year’s cuts. The Union’s calls for increased revenue for the district are now an issue on the national stage, and there is legislation pending in Springfield that would take TIF control out of the mayor’s hands and force the release of these funds to our schools.

Here’s what Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel had to say as reported by the Associated Press:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel says he agrees with Chicago teachers that more money is needed for education.

But he says the Chicago Teachers Union should join with him and Chicago Public Schools to lobby state lawmakers, rather than go on strike.

Thousands of teachers are protesting cuts in school funding Friday. Their one-day strike shut down schools for nearly 400,000 students.

Emanuel says for many of those students, school is the only place they get two meals each day or other services. He says the “kids are paying a price that” he doesn’t “think is right.”

and here’s what Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner said, as reported by the Chicago Tribune:

Rauner issued a statement Friday in response to the strike, saying: “It’s shameful that Chicago’s children are the victims in this raw display of political power. Walking out on kids in the classroom, leaving parents in the lurch and thumbing their nose at taxpayers — it’s the height of arrogance from those we’ve entrusted with our children’s futures.”

Elsewhere the Trib is referring to the strike as “Tantrum Day”.

I’m of mixed minds on this. I think that something should be done to end the budget impasse in Springfield. I’d prefer it if both sides gave in a little. Waiting for the governor to cave isn’t much of a plan but it seems to be the only plan that the Democratic leadership of the state legislature has. Illinois needs a budget but it needs a lot more than a budget. It needs a plan to foster economic growth. Without that we’re just bickering over the dead bones.

However, I don’t see a straight line connection between the budget battle and more funding for the schools. So far what I’ve seen strongly suggests that the strike is unlawful and immoral (since it’s a secondary boycott).

18 comments

A Strange Mixture

I found Matthew Delmont’s piece in Atlantic, “When Black Americans Exited Left”, a strange mixture of solid analysis and fantasy. For one thing, I think there’s room for a companion piece: “When Republicans Accepted the Dixiecrats”.

I think he’s strongest when writing about history. For my money here’s the meat of the piece:

After the 1964 election, where Republican candidate Barry Goldwater described the Civil Rights Act as unconstitutional, black voters essentially found themselves in a one-party system for presidential elections. Republicans turned their attention to white voters in the South and suburbs and have made few serious attempts in subsequent campaigns to appeal to the African American electorate. Richard Nixon in 1960 is the last Republican candidate to earn more than 15 percent of black votes.

This is a problem for black voters, because the Democratic Party’s vision of racial justice is also extremely limited. Northern liberals pioneered what scholars now call “colorblind racism.” That’s when racially neutral language makes extreme racial inequalities appear to be the natural outcome of innocent private choices or free-market forces rather than intentional public policies like housing covenants, federal mortgage redlining, public housing segregation, and school zoning.

Democratic lawmakers drafted civil-rights legislation that would challenge Jim Crow laws in the South while leaving de facto segregation in the North intact. When NBC News asked the civil-rights organizer Bayard Rustin why many African American communities rioted the summer after the bill passed, he said, “People have to understand that although the civil-rights bill was good and something for which I worked arduously, there was nothing in it that had any effect whatsoever on the three major problems Negroes face in the North: housing, jobs, and integrated schools…the civil-rights bill, because of this failure, has caused an even deeper frustration in the North.” Today’s protest movements against second-class citizenship in Baltimore, Ferguson, Oakland, and elsewhere are in part a legacy of the unresolved failures of civil-rights legislation.

The Civil Right Act was enacted by a coalition of liberal Democrats and Northeastern Republicans. Many of the political descendants of both of those groups now consider themselves independents. Today’s progressive Democrats don’t resemble the liberal Democrats of a half century ago so much as they do Michael Harrington’s vision of a “Democratic Left” while today’s Republicans are increasingly looking a lot like the Southern Democrats of 50 years ago.

At least to my ear his conclusion is a fantasy:

Whoever wins the nomination will likely garner support from over 85 percent of black voters, but African Americans still lack a mechanism to hold Democrats accountable once they are elected. Consequently, the outlook for blacks in the United States regarding housing, jobs, education, and criminal justice is little better today than when Kennedy helped get King out of jail in 1960. During this election year, they will again weigh what they won and what they lost when they cast their lot with the Democratic Party.

If there are any signs of that process, I don’t see them. The Democratic Party’s position appears to be more like “take it or leave it” and “at least we’re better than the Republicans”, which after a half century is cold comfort.

58 comments

The Electoral College Will Go to Clinton

Updating his previous projections for the 2016 presidential election, Larry Sabato predicts that in the event of a Clinton-Trump match-up:

  1. All of the states he previously listed as toss-ups lean to Clinton.
  2. All of the states he previously listed as leaning towards Clinton are now likely to go to Clinton.
  3. The state that was leaning towards whoever the Republican candidate might have been is now leaning towards Clinton.

Then he looks farther into the future:

Every now and then, one of the major parties goes off the track and forfeits an election, as in 1964 and 1972. This time, it is possible that the Republicans are the new Whigs, headed for a crackup, an oft-made comparison that historian Michael Holt recently examined in the Crystal Ball.

However, it’s just as possible, maybe probable, that the party would repair itself by 2020. Four years after the Goldwater debacle, the Republicans elected a president. Four years after the McGovern disaster, the Democrats elected a president. Odds are, there will be no need for a bugler playing taps for the GOP this time either. Somehow, though, Republicans will have to find ways to heal the deep rifts in their party, while becoming more mainstream and accommodating to this century’s American electorate. It will take far more than another “autopsy report” like the one in 2013 to accomplish this.

His prediction is basically an elaboration on the prevailing wisdom. If the prevailing wisdom holds, Clinton is probably not defeatable, at least not by this Republican Party. But this has proven to be a surprising primary season, the prevailing wisdom might not hold, and nobody really has any idea of what will happen.

By which I don’t mean to say that Clinton cannot win. What I’m saying is that if there’s a real political seachange in the making, nobody knows what will happen.

15 comments

Fortunately, No One’s Paying Attention

In his Chicago Tribune column yesterday John Kass presented two characterization of Hillary Clinton. The first was as the “old lady whispering ‘Hush!'”. The second, even more apt, was as Frank Underwood in a pantsuit. Here’s that whole section of his column:

You know the room, that big green room with the red balloon. The picture of the cow jumping over the moon. And the comb and the brush and the bowlful of mush.

And the old lady whispering, “hush.”

So why would Hillary whisper “hush” to young people feeling the Bern?

Because she wants to be president of the United States and rule the world, and fulfill her destiny as queen of the new American political establishment.

And she doesn’t need Sanders supporters ruining things.

Which is why her campaign has been working so hard to get Sanders voters to simmer down.

Sanders is the candidate with the momentum on the Democratic side. His voters believe that he believes in something. And I think he does. I disagree with his views, but he does stand for something.

And Hillary Clinton? What does she stand for? What does she believe in?

Herself. Power. That’s about it.

She’s like Frank Underwood in pantsuits.

She’ll play the gender card, she’ll pander to race, she’ll force you to parse her sentences. These are tactics, not core principles.

I think that would be quite damaging if anyone were paying attention. Fortunately for Sec. Clinton no one is.

I do think that Mr. Kass has put his finger on something important. Unless something dramatic changes this presidential campaign will be entirely about tactics rather than principles because neither of the likely candidates has any core principles to speak of.

25 comments

Forum Question: Anti-Semitism

The Watcher’s Council forum question this week was on anti-semitism. I didn’t participate this week but if you’re interested in the remarks of my fellow Council members the forum is here.

My own thoughts on this subject are, well, complicated. I think that in the Western world anti-semitism is a complicated stew of force of habit, prejudice, and anti-Zionism.

Also, political orientations don’t travel well. Neither “conservative”, “liberal”, “right-wing”, nor “left-wing” mean the same thing everywhere but, particularly in the United States, partisans of one stripe or another incorrectly feel sense of solidarity based on the labels.

Over the period of the last couple of decades in Israel Likud, the “right-wing” party, has gained ascendancy over Labor, the “left-wing” party. Despite their having practically nothing in common American conservatives are siding with Likud.

I have the apparently benighted view that Israel’s problems are Israel’s to solve and as an American I should butt out of Israeli politics.

BTW, lest we feel too complacent, in the United States and based on the FBI’s statistics the number of hate crimes perpetrated against Jews outnumber hate crimes perpetrated against Muslims by 10 to 1, despite the number of Jews and Muslims in the U. S. being roughly comparable. Somehow this is interpreted as Islamophobia being a major problem while anti-semitism is barely a thing at all. IMO it’s almost exactly the opposite.

8 comments

The View From Across the Pond

I think it’s helpful to get the takes of European commenters on the attacks in Brussels. You might find Dutch writer Leon de Winter’s remarks at Politico interesting. Here’s his peroration and conclusion:

While about one in five natives can be considered as Islamophobic, the level of phobia against the West among Muslims — for which oddly enough there is no word; one might call it ‘Occidentophobia’ — is much higher still, with 54 percent believing that the West is out to destroy Islam.” Recorded rates of Christian hate toward Muslims hover around 10 percent.

“Occidentophobia” is an interesting term. It expresses a refusal to accept the essential concepts of life in the West. Young men like the perpetrators of the Brussels attacks have refused to embrace the social codes of Belgian life. They were raised on the idea that their religious ethics trump the ethics of the infidels (close to non-existent, in their eyes, in any case). Their second-rate socioeconomic status was therefore a humiliating affront, an indignity to be destroyed.

Muslim integration into Europe societies is successful when Muslims are willing to give up the mental confinement of their home countries — countries, let’s not forget, which they left in search of a better life. For as long as they refuse to adapt to a European state of mind, they will perpetuate resentment and a culture of violence.

What did “we” do to “them”? We opened up our cities, our houses, our wallets. And in our secular temples of progress — our metro stations and airports and theaters — their sons are killing themselves, and taking our sons and daughters with them. There is nothing for which we need to apologize. “Occidentophobia” originated in the Muslim community. We need to demand they abandon it.

which seems to me to come out quite clearly on the side of ejection.

My own opinion is that there’s no inherent conflict between Islam and the West but there is an inherent conflict between traditional ways of life and modernity and, to the extent that Muslims from, for example, the Middle East or North Africa, conflate Islam with traditional ways of life there is an insuperable barrier not merely to assimilation but even to peaceful coexistence.

The effect of modern transportation and communication is to make the world smaller. That’s a truism. The implication is that the Middle East and North Africa are in Europe’s neighborhood right now and the safe neighborhood to which they’ve become accustomed has gotten a lot tougher.

5 comments

Visualizing DAESH

I’ve been hoping that somebody would do something like the video I’ve embedded above and, finally, Atlantic has done it. Thanks.

I have one quibble with it and that’s at the very end. By the logic by which they compare the total number of deaths due to terrorism with the deaths due to other forms of homicide, we should never have declared war against Japan after the attack at Pearl Harbor. Only 2,400 people or so were killed. That’s a tiny fraction of the U. S. population. That’s simply not the way that you measure threat.

15 comments

The Worse, the Better

I wonder how Sanders supporters feel the same way as Susan Sarandon at least as expressed in this interview cited at The Daily Beast:

“I think Bernie would probably encourage people, because he doesn’t have any ego in this thing,” Sarandon told him. “But I think a lot of people are, ‘Sorry, I just can’t bring myself to [vote for Clinton].’”

“How about you personally?” Hayes asked.

“I don’t know. I’m going to see what happens,” Sarandon said.

That bit of honesty prompted Hayes to stop in his tracks. “Really?” he asked incredulously.

“Really,” Sarandon said, adding that “some people feel that Donald Trump will bring the revolution immediately if he gets in, things will really explode.” Asked if she thinks that’s “dangerous,” she replied, “It’s dangerous to think that we can continue the way we are with the militarized police force, with privatized prisons, with the death penalty, with the low minimum wage, threats to women’s rights and think you can’t do something huge to turn that around.”

BTW, the title phrase, frequently attributed to Lenin, is actually almost a century earlier than Lenin. It was first written by Nikolay Chernyshevsky.

16 comments