The Modern Saboteurs

I’m not as concerned as James Pethokoukis is about the prospect of abandoning free trade. Perhaps I would be if what were being negotiated were free trade but it isn’t and I’m not. I wish he were as energetic in condemning managed trade agreements as intolerable affronts to freedom as he is in critiquing their opponents.

However, I fully endorse his conclusion:

Those lost manufacturing jobs aren’t coming back in large numbers, though technological advances may mean we can create new ones here. At the same time, we need to upgrade our national safety net for workers hurt by trade — including helping them move to where new jobs are –while also preparing them for new opportunities. As The Economist concludes: “If America is to go on reaping the gains from trade, it must ensure it compensates those who lose out. You can oppose protectionism, or you can oppose redistribution. It is getting harder to do both.”

I see few signs of that right now. Quite to the contrary, discontent is rising and we shouldn’t be surprised at the pushback that, for example, the Trans-Pacific Partnership is receiving.

19 comments

It Isn’t Just Here

When I say that there appears to be something in the air, I don’t mean just here. For example, it’s affecting the Germans, too, as Lucian Kim notes at Reuters:

“We have reached a tipping point,” the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development warned last year. Income inequality in the 34 member countries is at its highest level in the past half century, the OECD said in a report. The average income of the richest 10 percent of the population is nine times that of the poorest 10 percent across the OECD, up from seven times 25 years earlier.

There is a time-tested European tradition of sneering at the crassness of American capitalism and the blowhards it produces. But Germans in particular are discovering that their society is not as equitable as they once believed, nor immune to the blather of populists.

In the decades following World War Two, West Germany built up its fabled social welfare system in part to compete with communist East Germany and in part to form a bulwark against the type of extremism that had given rise to Adolf Hitler. Consensus became a byword for the German way of doing politics.

After the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe and German reunification in 1990, the assumption was that the successful West German model would simply be transferred to the eastern half of the country. But as Germany struggled in an increasingly global economy, Merkel’s predecessor, Gerhard Schroeder, slashed social benefits as part of a sweeping reform to make the country more competitive.

Unemployment dropped, and the working poor emerged. Large parts of the former East Germany failed to catch up with the West, and an angry underclass that felt cheated by the promises of democracy was created.

Research shows that Germany is far more similar to the United States in economic terms than most people might imagine. Germany’s so-called Gini coefficient, a measure of income disparity, is 76 — closer to the 80 in the United States than the 69 across the euro zone. In a Morgan Stanley ranking of 20 industrialized countries, Germany came in as the sixth most unequal, right after the United States, preceded by Spain, Greece, Italy and Portugal.

Marcel Fratzscher, head of the German Institute for Economic Research, isn’t only concerned about income inequality in Germany; he also worries about systemic barriers to social mobility. “I don’t have a problem with the top 10 percent,” Fratzscher told Die Zeit. “I have a problem that the bottom 40 percent are being left behind.”

Contrary to the prevailing wisdom I don’t believe that this is a natural and inescapable outcome. I think what has happened in the United States and in Germany is the result of policy and what can be caused by policy can be remediated or reversed by policy.

15 comments

What the Economic Models Say

The Hill reports that two of three economic models of the outcome of presidential elections, the Fair Model, the Abramowitz model, and Moody’s model, both predict that the Republican candidate is likely to prevail whoever that candidate may be:

Republicans are expected to win the White House under two economic models that have accurately forecast presidential elections for decades.

A third model run by Moody’s Analytics predicts Democrats will win the White House, in part because of President Obama’s rising approval rating.

The three models are being challenged like never before by the presence of GOP presidential front-runner Donald Trump, whose campaign has shaken up politics.
Trump’s fights with Ted Cruz and his other GOP rivals have electrified his supporters but have turned off other voters. A Washington Post-ABC poll last week found that 67 percent of registered voters held an unfavorable view of the outspoken billionaire. That has given hope to Democrats that even with a weakened Hillary Clinton as their nominee, their party could cruise to victory.

I’ve written about Ray Fair’s model before. His model has correctly predicted every presidential election since 1916 with the exception of 2012.

As I written before, I think that this election will be exceptional and appeals to reason or experience or even polling data may well not be relevant. There appears to be an angry electorate out there and I doubt that the outcome of the primaries will appease them.

1 comment

The Absent Americans

Something interesting has emerged about the Panamanian Papers (as they’re being called). There are no Americans in them. The conspiracy theories are flying!

Why do you think that the Panamanian Papers don’t contain any Americans?

  1. Americans are models of probity and honesty.
  2. Americans don’t go through Panama for their shady deals.
  3. The law firm that was hacked to obtain the papers doesn’t like Americans.
  4. Americans don’t like that law firm.
  5. The document dump was produced by the Americans (that’s the Russians’ theory).
  6. There is a special providence that looks over fools, drunkards, and the United States of America.
12 comments

The “Coming Apart” Election

There are some comments by Joel Gehrke at the Washington Examiner that conform more to my sense, such as it is, of what’s going on in this election cycle more than most of what I’ve read lately:

But 2016 is hardly normal, as is clear both from Trump’s successes and socialist Bernie Sanders’ durability in the Democratic presidential primaries.

“It’s a ‘Coming Apart’ election,” Republican political consultant Brad Todd said in a reference to political scientist Charles Murray’s study of the class-based divisions among white Americans.

Murray analyzed “the state of white America [from] 1960-2010” and found a new upper class had formed in that time — a cognitive elite whose smart kids go score high on the ACT or the SAT, go to top-flight universities, marry their college classmates and use their high combined incomes to buy houses in “Belmont,” raising their kids in only the most desirable neighborhoods.

Meanwhile, back in “Fishtown,” Murray’s name for working-class communities, those who struggled as high school students go on to struggle as adults. They are less likely than the upper class to marry, and more likely to divorce and to have children out-of-wedlock. They’re not religious. They are poor, either unemployed or working in low-skilled jobs at wages that have been falling since the 1970s.

They believe politicians are corrupt, but they’re not motivated by rigorous ideological narratives. They don’t have the elite education to do so.

As noted in the linked post, these people are natural Democrats who’ve been ignored by the elites of both political parties.

6 comments

The Kleptocracy Continues in Ukraine

One thing I didn’t mention in my earlier post on the Panamanian document drop is one of the figures who seems to be implicated: the present President of Ukraine, Petro Poroshenko. As fifth president he’s just another in a long line of crooks in that country.

The Russians claim that the present Ukrainian government are fascists. Fascist crooks. And we’re supporting them.

13 comments

Why the Rise in Violent Crime in Chicago?

The Christian Science Monitor muses over why murders have spiked in Chicago:

As of March 30, there were 135 homicides in Chicago during the first quarter of the year – a 71 percent increase from the same period last year when 79 homicides were reported, according to Chicago police data. The homicide totals are the highest they have been since 1999. A Tribune analysis showed shootings citywide were also up from last year 73 percent, totally 727 reported.

[…]

Chicago has been on the precipice of an education crisis. Roughly 27,000 city teachers have worked since July without a contract, The Christian Science Monitor reported on Friday. Chicago public schools, the nation’s third largest school district, faces a $1.1 billion budget deficit and an even larger multi-billion dollar debt from pensions.

Financial struggles at the state and city level could also be influencing crime rates. Illinois has gone nearly a year without a state budget. And Chicago residents have been battling an unemployment rate slowly ticking upward, reaching 7.2 percent unemployment in February, according to the Chicago Business Journal.

But Mayor Emanuel has mainly attributed the rising 2016 crime rate to a newly paralyzed police force, which is where the new interim superintendent Eddie Johnson comes into the picture.

I think that all of those explanations are fatuous. Do they seriously believe that a new teachers’ contract or a state budget would reduce the homicide rate? Chicago’s general unemployment rate can’t be blamed either.

More to the point, Chicago’s black youth unemployment rate is around 50%.

Malaise in the police force isn’t much of an explanation, either. We’ve had bad policing in Chicago for decades. Do the police officers genuinely think that less scrutiny is what the force needs to do a more effective job?

Basically, Chicago’s problem and Illinois’s greatest problem is bad government. Everything else is a symptom.

6 comments

How the Other .01% Lives

The big story of the day, of course, is the story of the gigantic release of secret correspondence between a Panamanian law firm and its ultra-wealthy clients. If you haven’t been following it here’s the opening of the ICIJ’s article on the release:

A massive leak of documents exposes the offshore holdings of 12 current and former world leaders and reveals how associates of Russian President Vladimir Putin secretly shuffled as much as $2 billion through banks and shadow companies.

The leak also provides details of the hidden financial dealings of 128 more politicians and public officials around the world.

The cache of 11.5 million records shows how a global industry of law firms and big banks sells financial secrecy to politicians, fraudsters and drug traffickers as well as billionaires, celebrities and sports stars.

These are among the findings of a yearlong investigation by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists, German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung and more than 100 other news organizations.

We don’t know right now what impact this release will have. I suspect it will be years before we know the whole story if ever. Eleven and half million records is a lot of documents.

At its most superficial the story should just confirm what any observant person should at least suspect: that the ultra-wealthy remain ultra-wealthy by engaging in practices which are either illegal, unethical, immoral or give the appearance of one or more of those.

One gauge of who’s the most at risk from the disclosures is who’s doing the most damage control. Never believe anything until it’s been officially denied. At this point that appears to be Putin’s inner circle and the Swiss banks. Putin is taking the position that it’s all disinformation. One of the hazards of being a liar is that you come to believe that everybody else is a liar, too. The Russians are probably the world’s heavyweight champions at disinformation so it’s not particularly surprising that they’d claim that any bad news is disinformation.

The Swiss banks are responding with a Clintonian “it’s old news”, they’ve made all the reforms necessary already, etc. We’ll see how well that flies.

I was amused by François Hollande’s response. His take was that the leak was tremendously good news for France because the French government would be in for a lot of additional revenue which sounds a lot like he’s making lemonade to me.

At this point there don’t seem to be any present American politicans on the Scheisse list but that could change at any time. Stay tuned.

8 comments

The Benefits of Trade

The St. Louis Federal Reserve has developed a measure of a country’s openness to trade. As should not be terribly surprising the United States, along with Britain and the Netherlands, is among the world’s countries most open to trade. None of our major trading partners (Canada, Mexico, China, Japan, South Korea, Germany) is.

If China had been bombing our factories over the period of the last twenty years, I’m pretty sure we would have responded. The economic war that China has been waging on us over the period has had much the same effect and here we sit, fat, dumb, and happy.

The tragedy of the situation is that according to David Ricardo’s theory of comparative advantage China would have been better off if the country were more open to trade.

11 comments

The CBO Analyzes the President’s Budget

The Congressional Budget Office has analyzed President Obama’s budget for fiscal year 2017. Here are some of their findings:

Under the President’s proposals, the federal budget deficit would decline in 2017 and 2018. After that, however, outlays would rise more quickly than revenues, so deficits would grow. As a result, federal debt held by the public would grow as well. By 2026—the end of the period covered by the President’s budget—such debt would be higher than it is now, measured as a percentage of the nation’s economic output, and it would be rising.

The debt’s continuing to grow doesn’t particularly bother me. The prospect of its continuing to grow substantially faster than aggregate product does. Basically, we’ve got to produce more of what we consume. If the federal government is going to spend at this rate, we need substantially faster growth.

1 comment