Winners and Losers in the FBI v. Apple

The Department of Justice has withdrawn its suit against Apple seeking to compel the company to assist it in breaking the encryption of one of an iPhone that had belonged to one of the San Bernardino terrorists. Here’s what ABC News had to say:

Federal officials announced Monday night they successfully cracked into an iPhone belonging to one of the San Bernardino shooters and no longer needed Apple’s help in unlocking the device.

In doing so, authorities succeeded in their goal of breaking into an iPhone used by Syed Farook but did not set any sort of legal precedent that could be used in a future case, making it a sort of lukewarm win for both Apple and federal authorities.

Superficially, that looks like a win-win solution. Both parties got what they said they wanted. The FBI has decrypted the phone. Apple wasn’t forced to help. However, I think this particular outcome is a significant loss for Apple and I’ll try to explain why.

While both parties accomplished their stated objectives they each had unstated objectives which might have been more important to them than the stated objectives. The FBI clearly wanted a test case for compelling a technology company to assist them in this way and it didn’t get it. But that wasn’t something they didn’t already have. Failing to achieve an unstated objective isn’t a loss. It’s just a missed opportunity and there will be other bites at the apple, so to speak, in the future.

But the phone has been decrypted. Now Apple does not know if that feat was accomplished by brute force, whether it employed some exploit in the particular model of that one iPhone, or if it exploited some more general flaw. If it employed an exploit in that particular model, it reveals that Apple was lying in its claim that assisting the FBI could put all smartphones at risk. If decrypting the iPhone exploited a more general flaw that Apple doesn’t know about, Apple’s worst fears will be realized, all smartphones are at risk, and Apple’s marketing strategy is in a shambles.

The company’s reputation has been injured. Either for probity or technical superiority or both. In other words Apple no longer has something it used to possess. It should have helped decrypt the iPhone.

8 comments

Thinking the Unthinkable

You might want to take a look at William McGurn’s column in the Wall Street Journal. In the column he muses over what some people think of as unthinkable: the prospect that Donald Trump might actually win the election. He opens with a characterization of Mr. Trump from of all people Al Sharpton that rehabilitates Mr. Sharpton somewhat in my eyes:

Leave it to Al Sharpton to come up with the most compelling analogy for Mr. Trump: another New York promoter.

“The best way I can describe Donald Trump to friends is to say if Don King had been born white he’d be Donald Trump,” Mr. Sharpton told Politico earlier this year.

If that’s not an example of praising with faint damns I don’t know what is.

Mr. McGurn addresses several of the arguments that people put forward for why Trump can’t possibly win one at a time. For example, here are some of his remarks on Mr. Trump’s high negatives in opinion polls. After noting that Sec. Clinton, too, has high negatives he says:

David Plouffe, who managed Barack Obama’s successful 2008 campaign, has been warning Democrats not to take a Clinton victory for granted in the event Mr. Trump is the Republican nominee.
He has also consistently reminded Democrats that the coalition that sent Mr. Obama to the White House—including women, minorities and young voters—is not one Mrs. Clinton can take for granted. She needs to earn their support, he says. Right now the Bernie Sanders wins are highlighting some of her soft spots, including with young women.

Verbum sat sapienti est

I think the better question is what states could Trump carry that were carried by President Obama in the 2012 general election? We don’t elect presidential candidates at large. Is Sec. Clinton likely to carry any states that President Obama did not while holding on to the states he did win?

3 comments

Curb Your Enthusiasm

The Gallup organization has published a poll that arrives at what is to me a somewhat counter-intuitive conclusion: that Hillary Clinton’s voters are more enthusiastic than Sanders voters. From Gallup’s commentary on the poll:

PRINCETON, N.J. — As the 2016 primaries continue, with neither party’s nominee yet decided, Gallup finds sharp differences in the enthusiasm expressed by supporters of the various candidates. Among Republicans and Republican leaners, voters who support Donald Trump are the most enthusiastic by far, with a combined 65% describing themselves as extremely or very enthusiastic. This is nearly twice the level of fervor expressed by Republicans backing Gov. John Kasich (33%), and well eclipses the enthusiasm from those backing Sen. Ted Cruz (39%).

On the Democratic side, Hillary Clinton’s supporters are more enthusiastic than Sen. Bernie Sanders’ supporters, 54% vs. 44%.

I’m not surprised that Donald Trump’s supporters are more enthusiastic although that’s probably not the word I would use. Mr. Trump’s campaign is founded on cultivating enthusiasm among voters who share certain characteristics. Without enthusiasm what does Trump have? Certainly not thoughtful consideration.

“Enthusiasm” comes from the Greek words meaning, more or less, “filled by a god”. They’re filled with something, that’s for sure although maybe not a god.

But Hillary Clinton? That her supporters are enthusiastic certainly flies in the face of my own face-to-face encounters with her supporters which have shown something closer to the resignation of death row inmates than anything like what I’d call “enthusiasm”. Maybe the flip side of inevitability. Flip side. There’s an expression cast onto the ash heap of history. Like “ash heap”.

I guess the real proof will be in November. If Hillary Clinton’s supporters come out in numbers greater than or equal to those who supported Mr. Obama in 2008, I’ll concede their enthusiasm. Otherwise maybe not.

11 comments

Next Step—Junk

Fitch has cut Chicago’s credit rating two steps to the lowest investment grade. From the Tribune:

Chicago had its credit rating cut to the lowest investment grade by Fitch Ratings after the Illinois Supreme Court tossed out Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s plan for dealing with the mounting debt to its workers’ pension plans.

The two-step downgrade on Monday to BBB-, one rank above junk, affected $9.8 billion of general-obligation bonds and $486 million of debt backed by sales taxes. The company said the outlook is negative, indicating that the rating could be lowered further.

It can’t go much lower. The consequence of this downgrade is that the city is going to pay more to borrow going forward. Let’s see. Declining population, increasing costs, higher cost of borrowing, not much left in the way of strategies for cutting costs.

Chicago is paying the price for years, decades worth of bad decisions.

4 comments

Who Do You Think You Are?

I think there’s something basic missing from Noah Smith’s post at Bloomberg on the shrinking middle class:

Why do fewer Americans identify as middle class? One obvious possibility is that the middle class has been spreading out, separating into a well-to-do upper-middle and an expanding working class. The evidence shows that something like this has been happening for decades now.

and that’s immigration. Let’s say, just hypothetically, that you import 25% of the American population in the form of immigrants and their children and most of these immigrants identify as lower class or working class. Of course the percentage of people who identify as middle class will decline. That’s not economics or sociology—it’s mathematics.

It also suggests a policy solution: import a greater percentage of immigrants who self-identify as middle class. To do that you’ll need to control who comes here and who doesn’t which for some reason appears to be anathema.

0 comments

The Protected and the Unprotected

I found it hard to sample just one of the intriguing charts in the post by Jonathan Rothwell at Brookings questioning the prevailing wisdom on why the 1% earn so much more than the rest of us. I settled on this one. In the post the author rejects the usual explanations—capital vs. labor share, skills, and technology:

As economist Dean Baker points out, politicians and intellectuals often champion market competition—but what they mean by that is competition among low-paid service workers, production workers, or computer programmers who face competition from trade and immigration, while elite professionals sit behind a protectionist wall. Workers in occupations with no higher educational requirements see their wages held down by millions of other Americans denied a high-quality education and competing for relatively precious vacancies.

For lawyers, doctors, and dentists— three of the most over-represented occupations in the top 1 percent—state-level lobbying from professional associations has blocked efforts to expand the supply of qualified workers who could do many of the “professional” job tasks for less pay.

Don’t bother appealing to market forces. There is no effective market in any of the sectors in which most of the top earners work. Various forms of market restriction preclude it.

IMO that’s explanation for what has happened over the last 35 years. Wages have risen in jobs that have been protected; they haven’t (or even declined) when they haven’t.

If you’re at all concerned about income inequality, that suggests several possible strategies for remediation:

  • Tax or otherwise constrain wage growth in the protected jobs.
  • Stop protecting the protected jobs.
  • Protect all of the jobs.

Which of those strategies do you think will generate the least push-back? Or do you have a different solution to propose?

11 comments

The Syrian Army Can Fight

Assisted by the Russians the Syrian military has recaptured the city of Palmyra from DAESH. From the New York Times:

BEIRUT, Lebanon — The Syrian Army said Sunday that it had fully captured Palmyra, routing Islamic State fighters who had occupied the city with its ancient ruins for almost a year, and handing President Bashar al-Assad a strategic prize. It also gave Mr. Assad something more rare: a measure of international praise.

The head of Unesco, the United Nations agency that had designated Palmyra’s ruins a World Heritage site, hailed the “liberation” of the city from the militants in a statement issued last week as Syrian troops were advancing. On Sunday, Ban Ki-moon, the United Nations secretary-general, called the retaking of the ancient city “fortunate” and said the Syrian government could now protect and restore the sites, wire services reported.

[…]

After a three-week push by the Syrian Army and its allies, including Russia, the majority of the Islamic State contingent in Palmyra had withdrawn or been driven out, with hundreds of its fighters killed, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, which tracks the conflict. The withering defeat underscores the Islamic State’s broader struggle to retain territory it has seized in Syria and Iraq.

The Russians are now assisting the Syrians in removing the IEDs and mines DAESH left behind them.

This is an important accomplishment. For one thing it demonstrates that the Syrian Army can fight. Whether the rebel forces supported by the United States can is an open question not to mention whether they’re fighting the Syrian government, DAESH, or each other. War on the Rocks has an interesting piece questioning whether our aid to rebels in Syria and Iraq is really accomplishing anything:

The Kurdish-dominated Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) are not a monolithic force. Like nearly every other faction in Syria, they’re spread across an archipelago of enclaves nationwide. The SDF units clashing with Syrian rebels reportedly supported by the CIA are not supported by the Pentagon —they’re from a different enclave. The U.S. military is exclusively supporting the SDF in northeastern Syria on the other side of the Euphrates River. The Pentagon-backed SDF east of the Euphrates is fighting the self-proclaimed Islamic State, not rebels with or without U.S. backing.

[…]

In reality, the Kurdish SDF actually pushed east from Afrin in the northwest, where they had been all along. SDF presence east of the Euphrates largely remains static, although they have established a beachhead west of the Tishrin Dam that spans the river.

All this is relevant because the Pentagon has only supported the SDF east of the Euphrates in its battles with the Islamic State. The Afrin SDF is not Pentagon-backed — this sounds sort of ridiculous, but it’s true.

Read the whole thing.

Russian support has obviously been critical in the Syrian government making the advances it has. As the campaign to re-take the Iraqi city of Mosul progresses, we’ll have a better indication of whether U. S. support is as effective. As the WoTR article suggests, it might be the case that U. S. support is inversely correlated with the willingness to fight. We’re suckers for a good sales pitch but, unfortunately, a good sales pitch doesn’t necessarily mean you’re ready or willing to fight.

3 comments

The Issues That Face Black People

As I was driving back and forth from a quick errand this morning I caught a brief portion of an interview in which a young man presented a somewhat different take on the (black) reparations issue. What he was saying is that treating the reparations issue as about transferring cash is a blind alley and that the issue should be more about making communities whole rather than handing out cash.

I agree with that in principle but the alternative version of reparations he gave—giving blacks preferential access to higher education, something I argued in favor of when I was the interviewee’s age—struck me as reflecting ignorance of the real problems facing black people.

Now, as an old white man I’m absolutely the wrong person to give an authoritative opinion on the problems black folk face but here are what I think the most significant problems are:

  1. Not enough jobs for people with or without college educations. Higher education as a vehicle for a fuller life experience is a luxury for rich people. For poor people and even middle income people regardless of color higher education is mostly a way to get a better job. If there are no better jobs available, what the heck good is it?
  2. Bad schools. Preferential access to education is no blessing if you’re not prepared for college. The grade schools and high schools attended by black kids aren’t doing that. When did the public schools become a jobs program or vehicle for political organization? When did they become about adults rather than kids?
  3. Higher education is too expensive. That’s not just a problem for black kids and black families. It’s a problem for everyone.
  4. Social dysfunction in the black community. For whatever reason (I have my own opinions) men are still treated as expendable in too many black families. Sixty years ago most black kids grew up in families with two parents who were married to each other. Now that’s a minority. Have you ever noticed that the most successful black actors, musicians, and sports figures all grew up in intact families? It’s not a coincidence.
  5. Gangs have become the alternative to the family for economic and social support for too many young black men. That’s a path to drug and alcohol abuse, prison, and premature death.
  6. Bad policing. There’s both too much crime in black neighborhoods and, at least here in Chicago, too many police officers are shooting first and asking questions later. Both have got to stop.
  7. The political system has failed black people. Despite all of their lip service, what have the Democrats done for black folks lately? Republicans aren’t even giving lip service. That’s what I call a failure of the political system.

Oh, yeah. There’s also racism. It’s still present in hiring, access to credit, housing, you name it. Is it as bad as it was 60 years ago? Of course not. Is it as bad as it was 30 years ago? In many ways I think it’s worse.

What do you think are the most significant problems facing black people and what, if anything, do you think should be done about them?

30 comments

Healthcare Reform Is Overdue

The graph above illustrates the increase in real U. S. per capita healthcare spending. Lest we lose track of it, the PPACA had multiple objectives. One of the objectives was to increase the number of Americans who had healthcare insurance. It’s been mildly successful at that. Other objectives includes “bending the cost curve down” and reducing the deficit.

In accomplishing those it has been a flop. To quote Medicare trustee Charles Blahous:

Given how the ACA’s advocates touted the law as “bending the health care cost curve [down], and reducing the deficit” while occasionally in the same sentence crediting it with expanding coverage to “more than 94 percent of Americans,” many Americans could be forgiven for not understanding those two goals were in conflict.

Supporters of the PPACA will retort that our excessive healthcare spending is due to the increase percentage of old people in our population. Consider:

Do you see that dot that’s the far outlier indicating much higher per capita spending but lower life expectancy? That’s the United States. It’s the prices, stupid, as Uwe Reinhardt put it. We’re not receiving value for our money.

Back in the halcyon days of 2009 when the PPACA was a hot topic, I maintained a consistent position:

  1. Insuring more people was a fine objective but increasing the number of people insured would not of itself reduce spending.
  2. Reducing the cost of healthcare would of itself increase the number of people insured by the processes of supply and demand.
  3. Unless healthcare spending were curtailed, it would crowd out other spending priorities.
  4. Consequently, the more pressing problem was reducing healthcare costs.

and that’s still the case. As I also pointed out to those who claimed that the PPACA was merely the start, the first step in a a series of grand reforms in how healthcare would be delivered and paid for, the history of healthcare reform in the United States pointed in the other direction. The debates are always so bitter politicians have little appetite for tackling the problem for years after a major healthcare reform debate.

The problems haven’t gone away. Healthcare reform is overdue.

20 comments

Ways and Means

I think that Justin Yifu Lin is missing something crucial in his very optimistic Project Syndicate op-ed on China’s growth potential:

The question for China, after 36 years of catching up, is how much longer it can continue to benefit from this process. Some scholars believe it has reached its limits. Using historical data compiled by the economic historian Angus Maddison, they show how other East Asian countries experienced a deceleration of economic growth after their per capita GDP reached about $11,000 in purchasing-power-parity terms relative to constant 1990 US dollar prices, or $17,000 in constant 2005 US dollar prices.
For example, in the five years after Japan reached that level, its economy grew at an average annual rate of 3.6%. In South Korea, growth fell to 4.8%. In Hong Kong, it slowed to 5.8%. Given that China is projected to cross the same threshold sometime this year, many believe its average annual growth over the next five years will fall well below 7%.
I disagree. What this analysis fails to take into account is the fact that advanced countries are not sitting by idly; they are growing and making technological breakthroughs. And that creates opportunities for developing countries to continue to learn.

The question is not whether it’s theoretically or mathematically possible. Obviously, it is. The question is how?

It won’t be by using the strategies used over the last decade. China is already over-extended on credit and has too many bridges to nowhere, cities without populations, and airports with no arriving or departing flights. Building more won’t help.

It won’t be by building more productive capacity. In industry after industry China already has enough productive capacity to supply the whole world’s demand let alone China’s for years to come.

For the Chinese to consume more, the authorities must allow wages to rise, something they’ve been very reluctant to do. A lot of state-owned companies must be allowed to fail. And the Chinese people must be granted more freedom to choose.

1 comment