The First Presidential Debate of 2016

Somewhat to my surprise I ended up watching the first presidential debate last night between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. To my eye in essence it met my expectations. I found it troubling and difficult to watch.

If there was a winner, it was probably Hillary Clinton. I thought her strongest moment was when she explained why Trump’s birtherism was problematic. I don’t know that Trump had a strong moment. He probably did, however, accomplish what he needed to. He didn’t sound like a lunatic.

I thought that Trump rambled and frequently stepped on his own points. Clinton, well, was Clinton. I was surprised at Cokie Roberts’s observation that Trump was rude to Sec. Clinton. If anything, I thought it was the other way around.

Watch the debate, at least for a few minutes, with the sound off. In effect that’s the way most non-political junkies saw the debate.

The debate’s moderator, Lester Holt, acquitted himself well, rather better than I expected. Good for him.

Pundits’ assertions to the contrary notwithstanding neither Sec. Clinton nor Donald Trump is a particularly good debater. The measure of a good debater is the ability to convince someone who comes into the debate disagreeing with your position that you’re right. I doubt there was much of that going on.

9 comments

The Game

I don’t recall whether I’ve ever mentioned this before. My wife and I have a sort of IQ test for dogs. We call it “the game”. Here’s how it works.

My wife kisses me. Then she kisses one of the dogs. I kiss my wife. Then I kiss one of the dogs. Smart dogs react by kissing each of us back in turn.

1 comment

Question

Taking into account the genocide that he perpetrated, should we have invaded Cambodia to remove Pol Pot in the 1970s?

3 comments

The Grey Lady vs. Donald Trump

Lest anybody be uncertain about it, I agree with a good deal of what’s in the New York Times’s editors’ diatribe against Donald Trump. I agree most with this passage:

But voters should be asking themselves if Mr. Trump will deliver the kind of change they want. Starting a series of trade wars is a recipe for recession, not for new American jobs. Blowing a hole in the deficit by cutting taxes for the wealthy will not secure Americans’ financial future, and alienating our allies won’t protect our security.

And I agree with their conclusion: Donald Trump shouldn’t be president.

5 comments

The End of an Era

There are two notable stories, each of which marks the end of an era. Together they’re even more dramatic.

When I was a kid, the voice of the St. Louis Cardinal baseball team was Harry Caray. His voice was the sound of summertime. And Vin Scully was the voice of the Dodgers. After 67 years Vin Scully has retired:

LOS ANGELES — After 67 years, Los Angeles wasn’t ready to say goodbye to Vin Scully.

With the Colorado Rockies holding a 3-2 lead with two outs in the bottom of the ninth inning, Corey Seager, the Los Angeles Dodgers’ 22-year-old shortstop, hit a home run to right field to tie the game and extend the final home game for the 88-year-old announcer one more inning.

Sunday was the final game Scully will broadcast from Dodger Stadium as he nears the end of a 67-year career that began in 1950, when the Dodgers were in Brooklyn, and spanned nearly seven decades.

“And wouldn’t you know we’d go extra innings,” Scully said after Seager’s home run. “Of course, you didn’t have anything better to do, anyway.”

With two outs in the bottom of the 10th inning, Charlie Culberson homered on a fly ball to left field to give the Dodgers a 4-3 victory and their fourth straight National League West title, a franchise first, in Scully’s final game behind the microphone at Dodger Stadium.

“The Dodgers have clinched the division,” Scully said on the call. “And will celebrate on schedule.”

It was a storybook moment in a storybook career for Scully, who was given a standing ovation after the game from the crowd and the players, who took off their championship hats and waved them at a smiling Scully up in the broadcast booth.

Angelenos were suitably emotional about the farewell. Most of them don’t remember a time when Vin Scully wasn’t the voice of the Dodgers.

And the great golfer Arnold Palmer has died:

Golfing legend Arnold Palmer died Sunday afternoon in Pittsburgh, his longtime spokesman and friend Doc Giffin told ESPN. Palmer was 87.

“I’m just so heartbroken about it,” Giffin said. “As much as Arnold Palmer meant to the world, he meant that much and more to me.”

According to his longtime agent, Alastair Johnston, Palmer died of complications from heart problems. Johnston said Palmer was admitted to the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center Presbyterian on Thursday for some cardiovascular work and weakened over the past few days.

Palmer, who was nicknamed “The King,” won seven major championships during his professional career, which spanned more than five decades. He won the Masters four times, The Open twice and the U.S. Open once.

It’s hard to overestimate Mr. Palmer’s importance to the game of golf and his influence over it. He was really the first golfing superstar, dominating the game for a decade. Not only did he popularize and democratize the game of golf, he changed the business of golf in his involvement in sports marketing.

1 comment

Geography Lesson

The pin in the map above is stuck in the Russian city of Krasnodar, a major city with roughly the population of Seattle. It’s a day’s drive from Ukraine and about 800 miles from Damascus which is about the same as the distance between Los Angeles and Portland, Oregon.

This morning I heard George Stephanpoulos ask the newly-appointed British foreign minister, Boris Johnson, about Russia’s interventions “all over the world”, pointing to Syria and Ukraine. Syria and Ukraine aren’t “all over the world” for Russia. They’re the Russians’ near abroad. We’re intervening all over the world. The Russians are worried about their own neighborhood.

It’s reasonable to disapprove or even oppose what the Russians are doing. But know what the heck you’re talking about.

23 comments

Managing Globalization

I found a lot to agree with in Jared Bernstein and Lori Wallach’s article at American Prospect on globalization. Particularly this:

Today’s FTAs, of which the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) is Exhibit A, are not mainly about cutting tariffs to expand trade nor are they about jobs, growth, and incomes here in the United States. Rather, they’re about setting expansive “rules of the road” that determine who wins and who loses.

One of the things that’s frequently missed is that it doesn’t have to be that way. Pigouvian taxes could be levied on winners and the proceeds used to aid the losers. That doesn’t happen which makes one wonder if picking the winner were not the objective of the agreement in the first place.

Measures that the authors advocate for changing the “rules of the road” on globalization include:

  • Enforceable currency disciplines
  • Enforceable and substantive labor and environmental rights and standards
  • Rewarding those who play by the rules
  • Selecting appropriate trade partners

With respect to the last the authors remark:

Bad actors that violate worker and/or human rights or have long records of currency cheating will not become good actors if we simply invite them to trade more with us. Sadly, there is considerable empirical evidence from past U.S. trade initiatives with China, Vietnam, Russia, and other nations that supports this view.

I think the problem is actually somewhat worse than that. In the case of intellectual property China has laws that protect the intellectual property of foreigners. They just aren’t enforced and China does not have a robust system of civil law so there’s no practical way to secure redress when your intellectual property is not enforced. Consequently, the laws are meaningless.

0 comments

Patterns

Searching for patterns is part of the “hard-wiring” of human beings, part of the original factory equipment so to speak. It’s among our earliest instincts. Even newborns look for patterns. Searching for patterns underpins learning language or learning to walk as well as more mature activities including dancing a waltz, discovering that the earth revolves around the sun rather than the other way around, painting the Mona Lisa, worshipping a god, or playing a sonata on the piano. Absent the search for patterns life would be extremely difficult and probably terrifying.

If someone tells you they believe that everything is random, they’re either lying, exaggerating, insane, confused, or just plain wrong. Other than at the quantum level, real randomness is quite rare; it’s hard to produce. True randomness would mean that when I stepped out of my house here in Chicago it would be just as likely that I would be mauled by a bear, attacked by a shark, or explode into pure energy as it would that I would reach the sidewalk.

Because seeking patterns is so natural to us, we sometimes see them where they don’t exist. I think that the widely-reported phenomenon of seeing ghosts is caused by just such pattern-seeking.

There are whole branches of learning focused on distinguishing between patterns that don’t exist and those that do. Understanding logical fallacies is one way of doing that.

Depending on their abilities and experiences different people will see different patterns in the same things. As one friend of mine put it many years ago, you and I can do the same things but have different experiences.

In a country of 320 million people all sorts of things that would appear to be highly unlikely are practically certain to happen. Distinguishing between the things that actually constitute a pattern and those that don’t can be difficult. The pattern may be in what’s being reported and how it’s being reported rather than in what’s happening.

This all may sound like a lot of irrelevant rambling but it’s highly relevant since I strongly suspect that the evidence supports the hypothesis that both black men being shot and killed by police officers and the rioting that has followed black men being shot and killed by police officers are responses to seeing patterns. Are the patterns real or not?

Here are several true statements (some from this source):

  • In the city of Chicago an ordinary Chicagoan is more likely to be shot and killed than a Chicago police officer.
  • Twice as many whites are shot and killed by police officers every year as blacks.
  • As a proportion of homicides, more whites and Hispanics are killed by police than blacks.
  • Black and Hispanic police officers are more likely to discharge their guns at black men than white police officers.
  • Politics deals with perceptions not realities.
  • Politically-motivated policies are not likely to alter the underlying facts and may not alter the perceptions.

I think it’s a reasonable inference that what moves police officers to shoot and kill black men is fear. Is that fear based on reason?

22 comments

My Question

I have a question. Why would the president use a pseudonym when communicating with his Secretary of State?

Also among the newly disclosed details, according to the FBI: The name of the sender on an e-mail to Clinton in 2012 was “believed to be a pseudonym” for President Barack Obama. When the FBI told that to a top Clinton aide, Huma Abedin, during its investigation, she responded, “How is this not classified?” The documents don’t say whether the message went to Clinton’s private e-mail.

According to the FBI summary of its interview with Abedin, who is now vice chairwoman of Clinton’s presidential campaign, Obama’s e-mail system allowed him to receive messages only from approved senders. The White House had to be notified when Clinton changed her private e-mail address so that her messages could get through, Abedin told the FBI.

The message that the FBI said may have come from Obama under a pseudonym had the simple subject line: “Re: Congratulations.”

Other than as a joke I can’t think of any good reasons.

6 comments

The Third Most Powerful Drive

I disagree with this claim in John Tamny’s most recent post at RealClearMarkets on the gender pay gap:

In the real world, no truly talented person would seek coerced higher pay; instead, the skilled would reveal in the marketplace just why their pay isn’t high enough through performance proving just that. In short, if women really feel they’re underpaid relative to their male peers, they should express this truth in the free market.

Barring some deployment of the “no true Scotsman” fallacy, that’s simply and demonstrably untrue. Here’s one of tens of thousands of examples. Is Bill Gates “truly talented”? I think that most people would say so. And yet he has repeatedly resorted to the courts and to the legislature, two of the arms of the coercive state, to secure more revenue for Microsoft. Most large businesses do the same. Small businesses don’t but only because they don’t have the leverage.

It’s called “rent-seeking” and I would argue that the drive to leverage social or political systems to obtain more than you could get on the basis of your own unaided efforts is one of the most powerful ones in the world. Probably right after survival and reproduction.

I don’t blame activists for promoting exaggerations, myths, or flat-out lies to get the government on their side. I blame politicians for knuckling under and people who know better for not opposing them.

1 comment