Handicapping the First Presidential Debate

The first debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump of the 2016 presidential election cycle will take place on Monday. In anticipation of the debate I’d like to place a couple of questions on the floor:

  1. Will the debate take place? Will all of the debates take place?
  2. What will the outcome of the debate be?
    1. Hillary Clinton will wipe the floor with Donald Trump.
    2. Donald Trump will wipe the floor with Hillary Clinton.
    3. It doesn’t matter; nobody will watch the debate and everybody’s voters have already made up their minds.
    4. Hillary Clinton will look tired, old, and dyspeptic and will further reduce her credibility.
    5. Donald Trump will look crazy, poorly informed, and erratic and will further reduce his credibility.
    6. Some combination of the above.
    7. Lester Holt will lose decisively.
    8. What debate?

I think that the odds are about 50-50 whether this debate or any of them will actually come off. Hillary Clinton has much more to lose than Donald Trump has either to win or to lose and she has a plausible reason to beg off, at least from this debate—health. That will add fuel to the fires of speculation but that won’t make any difference to her core voters.

Assuming the election comes off, I think that Hillary Clinton will win on the substance, Donald Trump won’t be as much of an idiot as the NeverTrumpers would like, and Lester Holt will be blamed regardless of what happens. Basically, a combination of A, C, D, and G. I also think that, if either candidate does really badly and her or his poll numbers drop sharply after the debate, it will be the only presidential debate.

5 comments

On Not Winning By 50 Points

I like the conclusion of Tom Bevan’s post at RealClearPolitics in response to Hillary Clinton’s complaint that she isn’t winning by 50 points:

Her task would be difficult for a great politician, let alone someone with Clinton’s baggage. To paraphrase then-Sen. Obama’s backhanded compliment of her during a debate in 2008: She’s likable enough. But just barely – and only because her opponent is even less likable in the eyes of so many voters. But she doesn’t need to win by 50 points, she only needs to win by one, and that X-factor — Donald Trump’s own baggage — is why she’s ahead at all.

Over at FiveThirtyEight Nate Silver makes a similar point with numbers:

Right now, Clinton is over the line by exactly one state. As of this writing, that state — what we also call the tipping-point state — is New Hampshire. But a group of states are closely lumped together, and Pennsylvania, Colorado and Wisconsin have all taken their turn as the tipping-point state in recent weeks.

If she wins all those states and everything toward the blue end of the snake, Clinton would finish with 272 electoral votes, even assuming she loses the 2nd Congressional District of Maine. (Maine and Nebraska split their electoral votes by congressional district.) That’s two more than she needs to win the election.

But in different ways, that both understates and overstates how precarious Clinton’s position is. It understates it because Clinton has no margin to spare. Clinton’s polling has been somewhere between middling and awful in most of the other swing states lately, and they all at least lean toward Trump at the moment, narrowly in some cases (such as Florida) and more clearly in others (such as Iowa). If Clinton loses any of the states on the blue side of the snake without picking anything up on the red side, she’ll be stuck on 269 electoral votes or fewer.

As I’ve said before the only poll that makes any difference is the one that takes place on the first Tuesday of November. Anybody who thinks this election is anything but too close to call is looking at something other than the emerging facts.

How in the heck did we get into this idiotic situation?

1 comment

What Should I Think?

This isn’t a news blog. It’s an analysis blog. I try to wait to post until the facts are in and reasonable conclusions may be drawn. What should I think about the recent killings of black men by police officers in Oklahoma and North Carolina?

I know what I think about the rioting. It may cause attention to be focused on the rioters’ notional cause but that is not likely to be the sort of attention that they’d like.

5 comments

Funny About That

The Wall Street Journal is reporting that Facebook has been significantly over-estimating the amount of time its users spend watching videos on the site:

Big ad buyers and marketers are upset with Facebook Inc. after learning the tech giant vastly overestimated average viewing time for video ads on its platform for two years, according to people familiar with the situation.

Several weeks ago, Facebook disclosed in a post on its “Advertiser Help Center” that its metric for the average time users spent watching videos was artificially inflated because it was only factoring in video views of more than three seconds. The company said it was introducing a new metric to fix the problem.

I found the company’s statement beautifully coy:

“We recently discovered an error in the way we calculate one of our video metrics,” Facebook said in a statement. “This error has been fixed, it did not impact billing, and we have notified our partners both through our product dashboards and via sales and publisher outreach. We also renamed the metric to make it clearer what we measure. This metric is one of many our partners use to assess their video campaigns.”

The error may not have “impacted” billing but it did have an effect on the value of the service. The WSJ noticed that, too:

Due to the miscalculated data, marketers may have misjudged the performance of video advertising they have purchased from Facebook over the past two years. It also may have impacted their decisions about how much to spend on Facebook video versus other video ad sellers such as Google’s YouTube, Twitter, and even TV networks.

Media companies and publishers are affected, too, since they’ve been given inaccurate data about the consumption of their video content across the social network. Many use that information to help determine the types of content they post.

I doubt there was anything particularly nefarious about it. I just think the numbers they produced using their algorithm fit their expectations and/or business model so they didn’t examine them closely enough. If the numbers the algorithm had produced were 60% below expectations, they’d’ve been on it like a hawk.

I noticed that the WSJ mentioned ad buyers and marketers, media companies and publishers but not investors. In post-close trading Facebook’s stock was down sharply and that seems to be continuing. Any bets on how much money Mark Zuckerberg will lose today?

1 comment

Living to a Ripe Old Age

We just finished watching Seven Brides for Seven Brothers for the umpteenth time. I remember seeing it when it first came out and that was 62 years ago. Time flies. In my opinion it’s the finest movie musical ever made. Although Singing in the Rain, The Band Wagon, and West Side Story are all good candidates, too.

I noticed something interesting. Of the male principal cast three are still alive (Russ Tamblyn, Tommy Rall, and Jacques d’Amboise) and of the female principle cast five are still alive (Jane Powell, Julie Newmar, Nancy Kilgas, Ruta Lee, and Norma Doggett). Those of the principal dancing cast who are deceased lived to quite advanced ages. Marc Platt was in his mid 40s when the picture was made for goodness’ sake.

The moral of the story is that two keys to living to a ripe old age are dancing and discipline.

0 comments

When You Look At It That Way…

In reaction to the several terrorist attacks last weekend, the editors of the Wall Street Journal make a list:

The Federal Bureau of Investigation opened an “assessment,” which is a risk review short of a full criminal probe that includes interviews and cross-checks of federal terrorism and criminal databases. Mr. Rahami was cleared, though he travelled to Pakistan and Afghanistan several times over the last decade, including a year in the Taliban hothouse of Quetta.

Family and friends now say Mr. Rahami returned from these sojourns religiously and politically radicalized, and he began wearing traditional Islamic dress. He ordered his IED components online. Missing these red flags was especially notable given New York City’s antiterror focus since 9/11.

Was Mr. Rahami’s spree preventable? More details will emerge, but he is merely the latest domestic terrorist who had encounters with law enforcement or otherwise displayed suspicious patterns before acts of mass violence.

In 2013 the FBI assessed Omar Mateen, the Orlando nightclub killer. He was removed from the terror watch list the next year, despite trips to Saudi Arabia and his acquaintance with Moner Mohammad Abu-salha, a Floridian who became a suicide bomber in Syria in 2014.

The 2015 San Bernardino killers, Syed Rizwan Farook and Tashfeen Malik, weren’t in the terror database. But they spent a year planning and maintained an extensive digital correspondence about jihad and martyrdom. Malik was born in Pakistan and spent time in Saudi Arabia before marrying Farook.

The FBI also kept a file on the Tsarnaev brothers, the Boston Marathon bombers, after receiving a tip in 2011 that Tamerlan Tsarnaev was a dangerous Islamic radical. The G-men missed his trip to a Muslim region in Russia near Chechnya. The voyage registered on a Homeland Security travel monitoring system when he left, but the listing somehow lapsed by the time he came back and no one was alerted. Similar failures have also been documented after the separate attacks on two Tennessee military bases and in Garland, Texas in 2015.

When you look at it that way we don’t appear to have been doing a particularly good job of risk assessment, have we? Please don’t respond with any assertions of the effectiveness of tiger repellent.

There have been any number of explanations offered on why we’re having problems with risk assessment. And every explanation points to its solution. There are certain factors that every one of the cases cited by the WSJ editors have in common. When you start with the most specific (rather than the most general) it narrows the field pretty quickly.

You can’t do a reasonable risk assessment on the basis of fairness. The world just doesn’t work that way.

7 comments

What We’re Learning from the Campaigns

For the last year or so I’ve frequently noted how difficult it is for me to make heads or tails over what’s been going on with the political campaigns, I’ve thought a lot about it, and I think I may have some insights as to why that might be. Over the period of the next month or so I’m going to be writing a number of posts analyzing what we might be learning about how our politics is changing from the Clinton and Trump campaigns.

As part of my analyses I plan to produce evidence supporting my observations and outcomes that would test some of them one way or another. Stay tuned.

8 comments

The Absolute Choices Are Very, Very Few

There is a bit of wisdom in this post on risk analysis of environmental stressors by James Broughel and Dima Yazji Shamoun at RealClearPolicy that you might want to reflect on:

The first is that there are no absolute choices; there are only tradeoffs. Regulations that address risk induce behavioral responses among the regulated. These responses carry risks of their own. For example, if a chemical is banned by a regulator, companies usually substitute another chemical in place of the banned one. Both the banned chemical and the substitute carry risks, but if risks are exaggerated by an unknown amount, then we remain ignorant of the safer option. And because LNT detects — by design — low-dose health risks in any substance where there is evidence of toxicity at high doses, businesses are led to use newer, not-yet-assessed chemicals.

Economic costs borne from complying with regulations also produce “risk tradeoffs.” Since compliance costs are ultimately passed on to individuals, lost income from regulations means less money to spend addressing risks privately. When their incomes fall, people forgo buying things such as home security systems, gym memberships, healthier food, new smoke detectors, or safer vehicles. And when regulators inflate publicly addressed risks but leave private risks unanalyzed, it becomes impossible to weigh the pros and cons of public versus private risk mitigation.

There is good reason to believe that deadweight loss is among the most important factors in modern economic growth. That means that getting regulations right and administering them consistently are vitally important. Just throwing new regulations against the wall to see which ones stick is a bad risk.

0 comments

The Whole Is Greater Than a Single Part

I disagree rather strongly with Michael Barone’s analysis of the Democratic Party:

But what if Hillary Clinton loses? The political map in that case will look quite different, with Democratic states confined to the Northeast, West Coast and a few splotches in between. The presidential Democratic Party, like the congressional Democratic Party, will be concentrated in heavily Democratic central cities, some sympathetic suburbs and scattered university towns.

The shock for Democrats will likely to be more severe than for Republicans if Trump loses. “Imagine the best candidate in your party losing to the weakest candidate in the other party,” speculates Dan McLaughlin at nationalreview.com, “after years of telling yourself that your party had unlocked the demographic code to a permanent majority.”

Here’s the reason that I disagree: the Clintons are not the sum total of the Democratic Party. For the last thirty years they’ve made a fine art of sucking all of the air out of the room and, importantly, attracting a lot of money. Given the commitment of the present national Democratic Party to the professionalization of politics, that’s vital.

It takes a huge amount of money to run a national or statewide campaign these days and it’s a finite resource. If all of the money floats your way it naturally discourages potential competitors. And that’s what’s happened with the Democratic Party.

There are tens of thousands of elected officials who are Democrats and who knows how many of those candidates would be much better known nationally if it weren’t for the Clintons? Of major U. S. cities only a relative handful—Albuquerque, Colorado Springs, Fresno, Jacksonville (Florida), Mesa, Miami, Oklahoma City, Omaha, San Diego, Tulsa, Virginia Beach, and Wichita—have Republican mayors. Even in solidly Red Texas no major city has a Republican mayor.

So don’t worry about the Democratic Party if Hillary Clinton loses. It’ll be fine. It might well free the party.

4 comments

Those Were the Days

Take a look at this post at The Citizens Audit on the complicated flow of money, donations, and commissions among non-profits, PACs, 527s, etc. operated by David Brock.

It used to be that newspapers did this sort of investigation and analysis. Those were the days!

3 comments