The Two UN Speeches

You might not have realized it from reading the news coverage but there were actually two valedictory speeches given at the UN yesterday and they could hardly have been more different. President Obama’s address praised the “liberal international order” and appeared to be directed primarily at a domestic audience:

He painted a dark picture of the future awaiting Americans, and the world, if the forces of “aggressive nationalism” or “crude populism” win out. And he specifically inveighed against building a wall — a centerpiece of Trump’s proposal on border security.

“A nation ringed by walls would only imprison itself,” Obama declared to the assembled representatives of the UN’s member states.

Gone were Obama’s idealistic appeals to bring about a world free of nuclear weapons and an agenda focused on peace, as were his previous UN addresses. The “hope and change” of his argument as a presidential candidate himself was also replaced by exhortations against a future filled with chaos.

“Time and again human beings have believed they finally arrived at a period of enlightenment, only to repeat cycles of conflict and suffering. Perhaps that’s our fate,” Obama suggested.

“We have to remember the choices of individual human beings led to repeated world war,” Obama said. “Each of us as leaders, each nation can choose to reject those who appeal to our worst impulses and embrace those who appeal to our best. For we have shown that we can choose a better history.”

He pointed to growing divisions and discontent at home that challenge those decisions, and noted that the shortcomings of globalization had created “an uncertainty and unease and strife” that required acknowledgement, but not turning inward.

“I believe that at this moment we all face a choice,” Obama said. “We can choose to press forward with a better model of cooperation and integration or we can retreat into a world sharply divided and ultimately in conflict along age-old lines of nation and tribe and race and religion. I want to suggest to you today that we must go forward and not back.”

To my ear President Obama’s remarks were only tangentially related to reality. The United States is a multi-ethnic, multi-confessional state, astonishing in its diversity. At present roughly 14% of its population consists of immigrants. We already have among the most liberal trade policies in the world. The evidence that the problems of the world can be solved by the U. S. accepting more “refugees” or further liberalizing its trade is weak.

By comparison China is not multi-ethnic and is barely multi-confessional with religious minorities routinely persecuted. It is an illiberal oligarchy. It has highly restrictive trade policies. Unlike the U. S. for every incremental dollar of GDP it produces proportionally more greenhouse gases.

India remains for practical purposes a one-way autarky. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has a large population of foreign workers with almost no rights. Trade is controlled rigidly. The same may be said of many of the Arab countries of the Middle East and North Africa.

In other words, not only is President Obama preaching to the choir, he’s damning the choir for its misdeeds when by far the graver misdeeds are those of others.

By comparison UN Secretary Ban Ki Moon’s farewell address was more generally addressed and even less optimistic:

Ban stated that recent achievements in economic development and public health are vulnerable to “grave security threats.”

Armed conflicts have grown more protracted and complex. Governance failures have pushed societies past the brink. Radicalization has threatened social cohesion—precisely the response that violent extremists seek and welcome.

This is not where he then pivoted with a but! to things more hopeful. Instead, Ban went on to detail the consequences of these trends in Yemen, Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan, the Sahel region, Ukraine, South Sudan, and North Korea. Still, he saved most of his frustration for Syria, pointing to this week’s bombing of a U.N. aid convoy and saying “just when we think it cannot get any worse, the bar of depravity sinks lower.”

He noted:

Present in this hall today are representatives of governments that have ignored facilitated, funded, participated in or even planned and carried out atrocities inflicted by all sides of the Syria conflict against Syrian civilians.

He also shouted out both Israeli and Palestinian leaders, calling the current state of affairs “madness” and arguing that abandoning the two-state solution “would spell doom” for both peoples.

He doesn’t like Donald Trump, either.

4 comments

Debating the Great Recession

When I took economics (before the glaciers descended and dinosaurs ruled the earth), the Great Depression of the 1930s was still being debated and to a lesser extent it still is. We have probably just barely begun debating the Great Recession. There are several diverse explanations for why U. S. economic growth has been so slow in its aftermath:

  1. The fiscal stimulus wasn’t large enough.
  2. It wasn’t caused by a shortfall in aggregate demand but by too large a debt overhang, i.e. it was a “balance sheet recession” (which means that fiscal stimulus of whatever size would have been ineffective).
  3. We have a mature hybrid economy now that doesn’t respond to the old strategies.
  4. We are in a global economy now and moves by the U. S. are matched by counter-moves in other countries. Fiscal stimulus in the U. S. may result in economic growth in China rather than the U. S. Chinese inflation may result in U. S. deflation.

Note that the first two explanations are mutually exclusive.

The most recent salvo in the debate over the aftermath of the Great Recession comes from Robert Barro in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal:

Arguing that the recovery has been weak because the downturn was severe or coincided with a major financial crisis conflicts with the evidence, which shows that a larger decline predicts a stronger recovery. Moreover, many of the biggest downturns featured financial crises. For example, the U.S. per capita GDP growth rate from 1933-40 was 6.5% per year, the highest of any peacetime interval of several years, despite the 1937 recession. This strong recovery followed the cumulative decline in the level of per capita GDP by around 29% from 1929-33 during the Great Depression.

Given the lack of recovery in GDP, a surprising aspect of the post-2009 period is the strong employment growth. The growth rate of total nonfarm payrolls averaged 1.7% a year from February 2010 to July 2016, despite the drop in the labor-force participation rate. The post-2009 period is not a jobless recovery; it is a job-filled non-recovery. Similarly, the drop in the unemployment rate—from 10% in October 2009 to 4.9% in July 2016—has been impressive, though overstated because of the decrease in labor-force participation.

What accounts for the strong recovery in the labor market combined with the non-recovery in GDP? Mainly weak growth of labor productivity. The growth rate of GDP per worker from 2010-15 was 0.5% per year, compared with 1.5% from 1949 to 2009. The recent productivity slowdown is clear since 2011 but may have started as early as 2004.

Probably the most controversial claim in Dr. Barro’s op-ed is this:

The main U.S. policy used to counter the Great Recession was increased government transfer payments. Federal social benefits to persons as a ratio to GDP went from 8.7% in 2007 to 11.7% in 2010, then fell to 10.9% in 2015. The main increases applied to Medicaid, Medicare, Social Security (including disability) and food stamps, whereas unemployment insurance first rose then fell. Unfortunately, increased transfer payments do not promote productivity growth.

and he doesn’t much care for either the prescriptions of Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump.

My own view is that we’re in a global economy now, that debt overhang probably played some role but not the only role, that we import too much of what we consume, and that the fiscal stimulus of 2009 was probably too small, definitely too slow, and almost entirely politically motivated. The employment figures are a phantasm, created by obsolete adjustment factors.

1 comment

Our Stars or Ourselves?

There’s more evidence that gaining weight might not just be a result of bad behavior over at LiveScience:

Obese children have a different population of microorganisms living in their intestinal tracts, compared with lean children, researchers have found. These microorganisms appear to accelerate the conversion of carbohydrates into fat, which then accumulates throughout the body, the researchers said.

The study is the first to find a connection between the gut microbiota and fat distribution in children. The gut microorganisms in obese children are similar to those seen in previous studies of obese adults, providing evidence that bacteria play a role in excess weight gain starting at an an early age.

It might be that different diets might be conducive to different gut microbiota. That was suggested by studies conducted by the Chinese (in studies that could only have been conducted by the Chinese). Or it might be congenital. Or we might learn that obesity is a communicable disease.

0 comments

Is Our Dysfunctional Politics a Predictable Outcome of Our Political System?

As I read the remarks of Danish journalist Anders Agner Pedersen on the American election at RealClearPolitics, it occurred to me that the political system of the United States has endured longer than any European system other than those of the United Kingdom and Switzerland. I don’t know whether that suggests that our system is more durable than their systems or that ours is obsolete.

The UK is separated from the rest of Europe by water while Switzerland is practically a direct democracy and has a strong inclination to independence.

3 comments

Whose Middle East Policy Do You Favor?

At RealClearWorld they have an interview with Green Party candidate for president Jill Stein on U. S. policy with respect to the Middle East. I think I agree with her answers more than I agree with the answers of either of the major party candidates.

0 comments

The Miseducational System

The Council on Foreign Relations took a survey on what young people educated in America knew about geography, the environment, demographics, U. S. foreign policy, recent international events, and economics. Here were the results:

The average score on the survey’s knowledge questions was only 55 percent correct, and just 29 percent of respondents earned a minimal pass—66 percent correct or better.

If the sample questionnaire at the link is representative of the actual questions, they should all have gotten 100% correct. I did. The only question I hesitated on was about treaty obligations.

Maybe it’s true that we get the politicians we deserve. How do we get the educational system that we need?

15 comments

For the Want of a Horseshoe Nail

Is international relations scholar Mohammed Ayoob’s superficial analysis of the reason for the failure of Arab states presented in The National Interest typical of IR scholars, Middle Eastern thinking, Middle Eastern IR thinking or all three? There is a bit of wisdom that goes back at least a millennium in the West:

For want of a nail the shoe was lost.
For want of a shoe the horse was lost.
For want of a horse the rider was lost.
For want of a rider the message was lost.
For want of a message the battle was lost.
For want of a battle the kingdom was lost.
And all for the want of a horseshoe nail.

The implication of that little bit of doggerel is that events happen for reasons; things are connected even if the connection isn’t immediately apparent.

Here’s an example of what I mean:

The process of state failure in the Arab world, in its most recent phase, has its roots neither in the Quranic verses flaunted by the jihadis to justify violence nor in the 1,400-year-old history of the divide between the Sunni and Shia, which sectarian entrepreneurs use to justify antagonism toward the “other.” It owes its origins to the American invasion of Iraq in 2003, which was accompanied by a deliberate program aimed at destroying both military and civilian organs of the state, a project euphemistically called de-Baathification. The American invasion by decimating the Iraqi state also let loose forces of radicalism, extremism, jihadism—all interchangeable terms in the current political vocabulary, which are now blamed for the chaos and mayhem in the Middle East. It did so by creating a huge political vacuum into which extremist forces, some of them on the run from Afghanistan, moved in. Thus was created Al Qaeda in Iraq, led by Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, which after his death mutated into ISIS.

I thought and continue to think that our multiple interventions in the Middle East and North Africa have been bone-headed and futile. But that doesn’t mean that all of the problems of Arab states are a consequence of those bone-headed and futile interventions. We invaded Afghanistan and Iraq because we had been attacked. We were attacked because we had troops stationed in Saudi Arabia. We had troops stationed in Saudi Arabia because Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait. Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait because he was a dictator and he could.

Let’s ask the obvious question: why were there no Arab democracies prior to our invasion of Iraq in 2003? And there are just barely a couple now. That Arab states required dictators isn’t a sign of the strength of the state but a sign of their weakness.

For the last millennium Arabs have either been governed by strongman governments or by foreigners. The U. S. invasion of Iraq didn’t cause that. I submit that has been true because of some pathology in Arab society and that pathology has resulted in weak Arab states.

Dr. Ayoob is confusing causes with effects.

14 comments

Michael Pettis On China

As China’s growth rate slows and its debt-to-income ratio grows (it’s presently a multiple of what ours was just before the collapse of the housing bubble), international bankers and investors seem to be becoming increasingly nervous. I strongly recommend that you read Michael Pettis’s comments on China’s present conundrum over the John Mauldin’s blog. Here’s his summation:

Beijing must find a way of generating domestic demand without causing China’s debt burden to surge, which basically means it must rebalance the economy with much faster household income growth than it has managed in the recent past, and it must begin aggressively writing down overvalued assets and bad debt to the tune of as much as 25-50% of GDP without causing financial distress costs to soar. Everything else is just froth.

I think the question that should be asked is why have the Chinese authorities been reluctant to let household incomes grow faster? Maybe they just want to maintain China’s position as the lowest price labor market but I don’t that’s the whole of it. I think they’re worried that increasing household incomes will result in demands for more political and economic freedom which would loosen their hold on the country.

2 comments

If This Goes On…

I don’t follow polls closely but I do follow trends. Consider the graph above of the head-to-head contest between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. When viewed over the last year, there is no trend. Lots of noise but neither candidate is distinctly improving or deteriorating in her/his standing. That lack of a trend explains a good deal of why I think as I do that ultimately Sec. Clinton will be elected president.

Sec. Clinton has a floor of support at around 43%. Donald Trump has a ceiling of support at around 45%. The next couple of weeks will be telling. If Clinton’s floor erodes or Trump breaks through his ceiling things will look a lot different.

Don’t expect Sec. Clinton to get a majority of the popular vote. Only one winning Democratic candidate have done that in the last half century—Barack Obama. The opposite has tended to be true for winning Republican candidates, i.e. they need popular majorities to win the Presidency. Sec. Clinton can win without a popular majority based on electoral vote count.

Despite all the sound and fury the election is likely to turn on a handful of Pennsylvania, Ohio, Virginia, Florida, Colorado. As of this writing Trump has established a lead in Ohio and Florida; Clinton holds her lead in Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Colorado.

And as I’ve been saying for the last year, this year will be a turnout election. Regardless of what the polls say going in to election day, the candidate who gets his or her voters to turn out and vote is going to win.

5 comments

Heightened Alert, DHS-Style

It seems to me that this Associated Press story speaks for itself:

WASHINGTON (AP) — The U.S. government has mistakenly granted citizenship to at least 858 immigrants from countries of concern to national security or with high rates of immigration fraud who had pending deportation orders, according to an internal Homeland Security audit released Monday.

The Homeland Security Department’s inspector general found that the immigrants used different names or birthdates to apply for citizenship with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services and such discrepancies weren’t caught because their fingerprints were missing from government databases.

The report does not identify any of the immigrants by name, but Inspector General John Roth’s auditors said they were all from “special interest countries” — those that present a national security concern for the United States — or neighboring countries with high rates of immigration fraud. The report did not identify those countries.

The story goes on to quote DHS personnel as blaming old-fashioned paper-based recordkeeping systems. I think I’d look more towards don’t-give-a-damnitude. One of the great things about paper-based systems is that it’s a lot easier to implement compensating controls than it might be with a computer-based system that could take years to develop, modify, and qualify.

Note that the DHS employees who implement these systems are unquestionably civil service employees, have the protections of civil service employees, and are darned hard to fire no matter how badly they screw up. And they know that.

5 comments