The Smartest People Who Never Lived

Articles like this one at Big Think on the “Top 20+ Smartest People Who Ever Lived” always bug me. For one thing there’s little reason to believe that a half dozen of the people on the list ever lived at all.

And even if they did live how in the heck would you figure out what they would have scored on an IQ test? Based on works for which no originals survive and that have been edited and re-edited over the period of several millennia? IQ test by committee?

That’s even a problem for people we’re pretty sure existed, like William Shakespeare. Papers are still being written on the authoricity of the works attributed to Shakespeare and those were written just 400 years ago.

But there’s an even more serious problem. How valid is it to compare IQ test results in excess of three standard deviations above normal? Above four standard deviations? More? It seems to me that’s an instance of the false precision fallacy. Isn’t the margin of error higher than the actual variation?

Finally, IQ isn’t what it’s cracked up to be. For example, this should give us pause:

William Siddis (1898-1944) was an American child prodigy, whose IQ was reportedly between 250-300, perhaps the highest ever. He had outstanding abilities in math, entered Harvard at age 11, and claimed to know 40 languages. An MIT professor predicted the young Siddis would become the greatest mathematician of the 20th century. William crashed and burned as an adult, however, holding menial jobs and getting in trouble with the law, never finding an avenue to live up to the expectations.

High IQs aren’t particularly well correlated with success in life. Social and emotional development are.

7 comments

Democracy In Action

Although I agree with what I see as the spirit of Dani Rodrik’s New York Times op-ed:

We need to rescue globalization not just from populists, but also from its cheerleaders. Globalization evangelists have done great damage to their cause not just by underplaying the real fears and concerns on which the Trumps of this world thrive, but by overlooking the benefits of a more moderate form of globalization.

We must reassess the balance between national autonomy and economic globalization. Simply put, we have pushed economic globalization too far — toward an impractical version that we might call “hyperglobalization.”

The transition to hyperglobalization is associated with two events in particular: the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’s decision in 1989 to remove all restrictions on cross-border financial flows, and the establishment in 1995, after almost a decade of negotiations, of the World Trade Organization, with wide-ranging implications for domestic health and safety rules, subsidies and industrial policies.

The new model of globalization stood priorities on their head, effectively putting democracy to work for the global economy, instead of the other way around. The elimination of barriers to trade and finance became an end in itself, rather than a means toward more fundamental economic and social goals. Societies were asked to subject domestic economies to the whims of global financial markets; sign investment treaties that created special rights for foreign companies; and reduce corporate and top income taxes to attract footloose corporations.

[…]

The world’s trade regime is driven by a mercantilist logic: You lower your barriers in return for my lowering mine. But lack of openness is no longer the binding constraint on the world economy; lack of democratic legitimacy is.

It is time to embrace a different logic, emphasizing the value of policy autonomy. Poor and rich countries alike need greater space for pursuing their objectives. The former need to restructure their economies and promote new industries, and the latter must address domestic concerns over inequality and distributive justice.

I have some problems with his emphasis on democracy as opposed to other yardsticks like the rule of law or protection of civil liberties. As we have seen in Iraq, they don’t necessarily go together. I also have problems with his bifurcation of interests. Why is Dr. Rodrik concerned about “inequality and distributive justice” in the United States but not in China, where it’s much worse? Why so paternalistic?

I have a question. Dr. Rodrik cites Russia, Saudi Arabia, and China as examples of non-democratic countries. What would a democratic Russia, Saudi Arabia, or China do that the present countries aren’t doing? Quite to the contrary, IMO Russia is quite democratic. It just isn’t liberal or devoted to the rule of law. Those Russian opinion polls showing Putin with an 80%+ approval rating? Those aren’t fictions like opinion polls in the Soviet Union. The Russian people approve of what he’s doing.

I think we know what a democratic Saudi Arabia would be like. Think “Iraq”. Or maybe Al Qaeda.

What would a democratic China be like?

Rather than encouraging democracy, wouldn’t it be more prudent to encourage freedom secured by an independent judiciary and the rule of law? Why not harness our trade policies to our notional values?

1 comment

Can You Determine That Based on the Figures You’re Showing?

This must be my day to be baffled. I don’t see how Mark Perry reaches the conclusion that he does:

America’s middle-class is disappearing, but into higher, not lower, income categories

based on the data that he presents. He presents four graphs, all drawn from Census Bureau data. The first illustrates average household income, median household income, and average household size. The second illustrates average and median household income per member. The third illustrates median family income for married couples, both spouses working. The fourth illustrates percent income shares for high middle and local income groups.

What leaps out at you from the graphs is that incomes for the highest group have grown substantially, the others not so much.

My first quibble is that I think his definition of “middle income” is peculiar. How does he arrive at the distribution he does? A “drunkard’s search”? It would seem to me that reasonable definitions would be median plus or minus one standard deviation (middle would be two-thirds, a sixth “high”) or median plus or minus standard deviations (95% middle, 2.5% high). Under his definition “high income” is about a twelfth, either too high or too low to be intuitive.

But my biggest gripe is that I just don’t see how the conclusion can be reached from the data. Wouldn’t the large proportion of middle and higher income jobs, particularly in the $80,000 to $120,000 range, that have gone to immigrants provide an alternative explanation? If that’s the case it’s not so much a “middle income disappearing into upper income” story as one of importing a new upper middle income group to replace the previous one.

4 comments

Kwitcherbellyakin


As a resident of Chicago for more than a half century and of the city itself for the last 30 some-odd, I’m drawn to stories about Chicago, regardless of where they appear. Dennis Byrnes’s piece in Weekly Standard on Chicago’s murder rate was no exception:

What have 85 years of uninterrupted Democratic rule and unremitting pro-gres-sive dogma gotten Chicago? Murderous gang wars with no armistice in sight.

This is a Chicago specialty: The city has had more homicides this year than New York and Los Angeles combined. As crime rates declined elsewhere, August was Chicago’s most violent month in 20 years. The more than 500 murders this year already exceed the 2015 tally. Over the July 4 weekend, someone was shot every 2.8 hours. The Labor Day weekend total was at least 13 people killed and 52 wounded.

That first sentence is a common trope among Republicans and conservatives, generally. What baffles me about it is that no, repeat no Republican has run for mayor of Chicago since 1995. In that campaign Raymond Wardingley, a candidate of whom nobody had ever heard and who ran without notable support from the Illinois or national Republican Party, received 2.8% of the vote.

What is it that Republicans expect to happen? That frustrated Chicagoans will demand a Republican mayor and seize some hapless Republican soul, forcing him or her to become mayor by acclamation?

To be elected you’ve got to run. You’ve got to have name recognition. And you’ve got to have money. If you can’t raise it locally, you’ve got to get it from downstate Republicans or out-of-state Republicans. Don’t tell me about the hypothetical solutions to Chicago’s problems proposed by some theoretical candidate. Run a credible campaign, already.

The second problem with that opening sentence is that anyone who thinks that Democrats in Chicago are progressives like those in San Francisco or New York is operating under a serious misconception. Chicago’s Democratic leadership are machine politicians full stop. The only principle they embrace is remaining in office.

Chicago has lots of problems and that Chicago Democratic politicians are in bed with the gangs that are responsible for Chicago’s murder rate is just one of them.

Gimme some solutions. Run a credible campaign. Don’t sit on your duffs telling me how wonderful you are. That’s infantile.

4 comments

The Things You Find

The bronze medal above was among the many odds and ends we found in my mom’s possessions after her death. You might notice the captions “1 August”, “1° agosto”, and “1er août” and, very faintly, “Huguerin” (if you look closely enough). One of my sharp-witted siblings figured out what it was.

August 1 is Swiss National Day, by tradition the day on which the Swiss Federal Charter were adopted. It’s Switzerland’s founding holiday, their Fourth of July. Huguerin is an old Swiss watchcase and medal-making company, still in operation. We figure that the medallion, rigged up as a badge with a pin on the back, was a commemorative badge of some sort.

We have no idea what its provenance is or the story behind it if any. I do know that my Swiss great-grandfather, Joe Schuler, as well as his sister Agatha were still alive in 1926 and that Agatha visited Switzerland around that time. I have a photo of the two of them together, taken around that time. My guess is that it was a present from Agatha to Joseph but I have no way of verifying that.

0 comments

The First Thing

The first thing you need to understand is that Americans are crazy. At least we’re crazier than people in other countries. Immigrants aren’t as crazy as the native-born; the children of immigrants are crazier than their parents.

Any number of studies, not just the ones I’ve cited, have found that. There are all sorts of possible explanations for it including the possibility that Americans just seek care and are diagnosed at higher rates than people in other countries but the studies have repeatedly found that the reported incidence of mental illness among Americans is higher than that of people in just about any other country. Higher than Mexico, New Zealand, Israel, or China.

Another possibility is encapsulated in the old proverb “money can’t buy happiness”. Depression may be a luxury and the wealth of Americans may enable them to afford mental disorders that people in other countries can only dream of.

It also might be that people from different countries react differently to mental health problems. Irishmen may go to the pub and drink; Poles may sit at home and drink; Americans may seek out care.

How do people for whom alcohol is forbidden deal with their mental health problems? Maybe they drink anyway which adds self-loathing to their other problems. Maybe they act out violently. There have been studies that have claimed that people with mental health problems in Muslim communities around the world are seriously stigmatized.

In my opinion the extreme diversity of the United States and the extreme isolation of life in the United States suggest that we may actually be crazier than people in other countries. Those two factors work synergistically to increase stress and reduce the availability of support systems.

The second thing you should understand is that personal empowerment and, particularly, the ability of individuals to inflict violence on others has reached levels unprecedented in human history. Today ordinary men and women can readily inflict a level of violence only available to a lord or a general in years gone by.

Which brings us to the news of the day. Last night there were two terrible incidents. One occurred in a shopping mall in St. Cloud, Minnesota. Eight people were stabbed and the perpetrator was killed. There are reports that the perpetrator was Muslim. In the other 29 people were injured by the detonation of a pipe bomb in the Chelsea neighborhood of Manhattan. At this point although the detonation appears to have been deliberate the perpetrator is unknown and, obviously, the motives are unknown.

We are unlikely to be able to stuff the jinn of personal empowerment back into his bottle. As the number of Americans rises as well as personal empowerment and given the high prevalence of mental illness here, we’re going to see more perpetration of mass violence against strangers. Some of the perpetrators will be Muslims; maybe most of them will be. It’s certainly true that the perpetrators of the Boston marathon bombing, the Fort Hood massacre, the killings in San Bernardino, and the recent massacre in Orlando were all the children of Muslims immigrants. I don’t know the specific pathologies that led them to do what they did.

I’ve also suggested a strategy for addressing the problem in advance: early intervention. I recognize that cuts deeply against the grain for many Americans but insisting on the “drunkard’s search” rather than applying resources where they’re needed is its own form of mental disorder.

2 comments

Silver on the Polls

As the campaign season moves into the fall and pollsters turn from Americans to registered voters to likely voters, the opinion polls become increasingly meaningful. At 538 Nate Silver comments on the recent polls:

Hillary Clinton’s lead in the polls has been declining for several weeks, and now we’re at the point where it’s not much of a lead at all. National polls show Clinton only 1 or 2 percentage points ahead of Donald Trump, on average. And the state polling situation isn’t really any better for her. On Thursday alone, polls were released showing Clinton behind in Ohio, Iowa and Colorado — and with narrow, 3-point leads in Michigan and Virginia, two states once thought to be relatively safe for her.

It’s also become clearer that Clinton’s “bad weekend” — which included describing half of Trump supporters as a “basket of deplorables” on Friday, and a health scare (followed by news that she had been diagnosed with pneumonia) on Sunday — has affected the polls. Prior to the weekend, Clinton’s decline had appeared to be leveling off, with the race settling into a Clinton lead of 3 or 4 percentage points. But over the past seven days, Clinton’s win probability has declined from 70 percent to 60 percent in our polls-only forecast and by a similar amount, from 68 percent to 59 percent, in our polls-plus forecast.

Read the whole thing.

The transition I mentioned above (from polling Americans to polling registered voters to polling likely voters) brings with it an illusion of movement. The greater likelihood is that the transition just makes the polls more similar to the eventual outcome.

I continue to believe that, barring some catastrophe, Hillary Clinton will be elected president. What the polls should signal to us is that the landslide, even an electoral landslide, that some had hoped for and others feared is unlikely to materialize. That in turn makes the “downballot effects”, the effect of the presidential election on Senate, House, governor’s, and local races is unlikely to be pronounced.

7 comments

The Birther Story That Wouldn’t Die

Who is going to be most embarrassed by the resurgence of the “birther” story, the canard that President Obama isn’t a U. S. citizen by birth?

  1. Donald Trump
  2. Barack Obama
  3. Hillary Clinton
  4. The news media
  5. Other
11 comments

Cast Members Still Alive

Yesterday I watched the 1967 movie The Dirty Dozen, oddly enough for the very first time. Although I’m something of a movie buff, the 1960s are something of a lacuna for me. I watched a lot fewer movies in the 1960s than before or after. I was too busy and, frankly, I didn’t think the movies were that great, either.

I found it a reasonably entertaining picture. Not bad, not great. Here’s what struck me. Of the major cast members only Jim Brown, Trini Lopez, and Donald Sutherland are still alive. Trini Lopez has been immortalized not only by his hit songs but by the episode in Sleepless in Seattle referring to him and The Dirty Dozen.

Turning to the reboot of The Magnificent Seven soon to be released (I have premonitions of another debacle), am I mistaken or is Robert Vaughn the only surviving major cast member?

14 comments

Speechless

We’ve watched the pilot to the new ABC family sitcom/dramedy Speechless on Hulu. It’s about a family consisting of a fairly nebbishy father, a very driven mother (played by Minnie Driver), and their children, one with special needs. We loved the pilot and have great hopes for the series.

That’s about all I’ll say about it. I wouldn’t want to give away the fun. It premieres on Wednesday on ABC.

3 comments